-
Available energy of plasmas with small fluctuations
Authors:
P. Helander,
R. J. J. Mackenbach
Abstract:
The available energy of a plasma is defined as the maximum amount by which the plasma energy can be lowered by volume-preserving rearrangements in phase space, a so-called Gardner re-stacking. A general expression is derived for the available energy of a nearly homogeneous plasma and is shown to be closely related to the Helmholtz free energy, which it can never exceed. A number of explicit exampl…
▽ More
The available energy of a plasma is defined as the maximum amount by which the plasma energy can be lowered by volume-preserving rearrangements in phase space, a so-called Gardner re-stacking. A general expression is derived for the available energy of a nearly homogeneous plasma and is shown to be closely related to the Helmholtz free energy, which it can never exceed. A number of explicit examples are given.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
On the effect of flux-surface shaping on trapped-electron modes in quasi-helically symmetric stellarators
Authors:
M. J. Gerard,
M. J. Pueschel,
B. Geiger,
R. J. J. Mackenbach,
J. M. Duff,
B. J. Faber,
C. C. Hegna,
P. W. Terry
Abstract:
Using a novel optimization procedure it has been shown that the Helically Symmetric eXperiment (HSX) stellarator can be optimized for reduced trapped-electron-mode (TEM) instability [M.J.~Gerard et al., \textit{Nucl.~Fusion} \textbf{63} (2023) 056004]. Presently, with a set of 563 experimental candidate configurations, gyrokinetic simulations are performed to investigate the efficacy of available…
▽ More
Using a novel optimization procedure it has been shown that the Helically Symmetric eXperiment (HSX) stellarator can be optimized for reduced trapped-electron-mode (TEM) instability [M.J.~Gerard et al., \textit{Nucl.~Fusion} \textbf{63} (2023) 056004]. Presently, with a set of 563 experimental candidate configurations, gyrokinetic simulations are performed to investigate the efficacy of available energy $E_\mathrm{A}$, quasi-helical symmetry, and flux-surface shaping parameters as metrics for TEM stabilization. It is found that lower values of $E_\mathrm{A}$ correlate with reduced growth rates, but only when separate flux-surface shaping regimes are considered. Moreover, configurations with improved quasi-helical symmetry demonstrate a similar reduction in growth rates and less scatter compared to $E_\mathrm{A}$. Regarding flux-surface shaping, a set of helical shaping parameters is introduced that show increased elongation is strongly correlated with reduced TEM growth rates, however, only when the quasi-helical symmetry is preserved. Using a newly derived velocity-space-averaged TEM resonance operator, these trends are analyzed to provide insights into the physical mechanism of the observed stabilization. For elongation, stabilization is attributed to geometric effects that reduce the destabilizing particle drifts across the magnetic field. Regarding quasi-helical symmetry, the TEM resonance in the maximally resonant trapping well is shown to increase as the quasi-helical symmetry is broken, and breaking quasi-helical symmetry increases the prevalence of highly resonant trapping wells. While these results demonstrate the limitations of using any single metric as a linear TEM proxy, it is shown that quasi-helical symmetry and plasma elongation are highly effective metrics for reducing TEM growth rates in helical equilibria.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Trapped-particle precession and modes in quasi-symmetric stellarators and tokamaks: a near-axis perspective
Authors:
E. Rodriguez,
R. J. J. Mackenbach
Abstract:
This paper presents the calculation of the bounce-averaged drift of trapped particles in a near-axis framework for axisymmetric and quasisymmetric magnetic fields that possess up-down and stellarator symmetry respectively. This analytic consideration provides important insight on the dependence of the bounce-averaged drift on the geometry and stability properties of the field. In particular, we sh…
▽ More
This paper presents the calculation of the bounce-averaged drift of trapped particles in a near-axis framework for axisymmetric and quasisymmetric magnetic fields that possess up-down and stellarator symmetry respectively. This analytic consideration provides important insight on the dependence of the bounce-averaged drift on the geometry and stability properties of the field. In particular, we show that, although the maximum-$\mathcal{J}$ property is unattainable in quasisymmetric stellarators, one may approach it through increased plasma $β$ and triangular shaping, albeit going through a reduced precession scenario with potentially higher particle losses. The description of trapped particles allows us to calculate the available energy of trapped electrons analytically in two asymptotic regimes, providing insight into the behaviour of this measure of turbulence. It is shown that the available energy is intimately related to MHD-stability, providing a potential synergy between this measure of gyrokinetic turbulence and MHD-stability.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2023; v1 submitted 2 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Available energy of trapped electrons in Miller tokamak equilibria
Authors:
R. J. J. Mackenbach,
J. H. E. Proll,
G. Snoep,
P. Helander
Abstract:
Available energy (Æ), which quantifies the maximum amount of thermal energy that may be liberated and converted into instabilities and turbulence, has shown to be a useful metric for predicting saturated energy fluxes in trapped-electron-mode-driven turbulence. Here, we calculate and investigate the Æ in the analytical tokamak equilibria introduced by \citet{Miller1998NoncircularModel}. The Æ of t…
▽ More
Available energy (Æ), which quantifies the maximum amount of thermal energy that may be liberated and converted into instabilities and turbulence, has shown to be a useful metric for predicting saturated energy fluxes in trapped-electron-mode-driven turbulence. Here, we calculate and investigate the Æ in the analytical tokamak equilibria introduced by \citet{Miller1998NoncircularModel}. The Æ of trapped electrons reproduces various trends also observed in experiments; negative shear, increasing Shafranov shift, vertical elongation, and negative triangularity can all be stabilising, as indicated by a reduction in Æ, although it is strongly dependent on the chosen equilibrium. Comparing Æ with saturated energy flux estimates from the \textsc{tglf} model, we find fairly good correspondence, showcasing that Æ can be useful to predict trends. We go on to investigate Æ and find that negative triangularity is especially beneficial in vertically elongated configurations with positive shear or low gradients. We furthermore extract a gradient threshold-like quantity from Æ and find that it behaves similarly to gyrokinetic gradient thresholds: it tends to increase linearly with magnetic shear, and negative triangularity leads to an especially high threshold. We next optimise the device geometry for minimal Æ and find that the optimum is strongly dependent on equilibrium parameters, e.g. magnetic shear or pressure gradient. Investigating the competing effects of increasing the density gradient, the pressure gradient, and decreasing the shear, we find regimes that have steep gradients yet low Æ, and that such a regime is inaccessible in negative-triangularity tokamaks.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2023; v1 submitted 5 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Bounce-averaged drifts: Equivalent definitions, numerical implementations, and example cases
Authors:
R. J. J. Mackenbach,
J. M. Duff,
M. J. Gerard,
J. H. E. Proll,
P. Helander,
C. C. Hegna
Abstract:
In this article we provide various analytical and numerical methods for calculating the average drift of magnetically trapped particles across field lines in complex geometries, and we compare these methods against each other. To evaluate bounce-integrals, we introduce a generalisation of the trapezoidal rule which is able to circumvent integrable singularities. We contrast this method with more s…
▽ More
In this article we provide various analytical and numerical methods for calculating the average drift of magnetically trapped particles across field lines in complex geometries, and we compare these methods against each other. To evaluate bounce-integrals, we introduce a generalisation of the trapezoidal rule which is able to circumvent integrable singularities. We contrast this method with more standard quadrature methods in a parabolic magnetic well and find that the computational cost is significantly lower for the trapezoidal method, though at the cost of accuracy. With numerical routines in place, we next investigate conditions on particles which cross the computational boundary, and we find that important differences arise for particles affected by this boundary, which can depend on the specific implementation of the calculation. Finally, we investigate the bounce-averaged drifts in the optimized stellarator NCSX. From investigating the drifts, one can readily deduce important properties, such as what subset of particles can drive trapped-particle modes, and in what regions radial drifts are most deleterious to the stability of such modes.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Constructing precisely quasi-isodynamic magnetic fields
Authors:
Alan Goodman,
Katia Camacho Mata,
Sophia A Henneberg,
Rogerio Jorge,
Matt Landreman,
Gabriel Plunk,
Hakan Smith,
Ralf Mackenbach,
Per Helander
Abstract:
We present a novel method for numerically finding quasi-isodynamic stellarator magnetic fields with excellent fast-particle confinement and extremely small neoclassical transport. The method works particularly well in configurations with only one field period. We examine the properties of these newfound quasi-isodynamic configurations, including their bootstrap currents, particle confinement, and…
▽ More
We present a novel method for numerically finding quasi-isodynamic stellarator magnetic fields with excellent fast-particle confinement and extremely small neoclassical transport. The method works particularly well in configurations with only one field period. We examine the properties of these newfound quasi-isodynamic configurations, including their bootstrap currents, particle confinement, and available energy for trapped-electron driven turbulence, as well as the degree to which they change when a finite pressure profile is added. We finally discuss the differences between the magnetic axes of the optimized solutions and their respective initial conditions, and conclude with the prospects for future quasi-isodynamic optimization.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
The available energy of trapped electrons and its relation to turbulent transport
Authors:
R. J. J. Mackenbach,
J. H. E. Proll,
P. Helander
Abstract:
A collisionless plasma possesses a certain amount of "available energy", which is that part of the thermal energy that can be converted into field energy. Here, a calculation is presented of the available energy carried by trapped electrons in a slender non-omnigenous flux tube of plasma. This quantity is compared with gyrokinetic simulations of the nonlinear saturated radial energy flux resulting…
▽ More
A collisionless plasma possesses a certain amount of "available energy", which is that part of the thermal energy that can be converted into field energy. Here, a calculation is presented of the available energy carried by trapped electrons in a slender non-omnigenous flux tube of plasma. This quantity is compared with gyrokinetic simulations of the nonlinear saturated radial energy flux resulting from turbulence driven by collisionless trapped-electron modes in various stellarator and a tokamak. The numerical calculation of available energy is extremely fast and shows a strong correlation with the turbulent energy fluxes found in the gyrokinetic simulations. Indeed, the energy flux is found to be proportional to the available energy to the power of approximately 3/2, as one would expect from a simple phenomenological model.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2022; v1 submitted 2 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
