-
Universality of noise-induced transitions in nonlinear voter models
Authors:
Jaume Llabrés,
Maxi San Miguel,
Raúl Toral
Abstract:
We analyze the universality classes of phase transitions in a variety of nonlinear voter models. By mapping several models with symmetric absorbing states onto a canonical model introduced in previous studies, we confirm that they exhibit a Generalized Voter (GV) transition. We then propose a canonical mean-field model that extends the original formulation by incorporating a noise term that elimin…
▽ More
We analyze the universality classes of phase transitions in a variety of nonlinear voter models. By mapping several models with symmetric absorbing states onto a canonical model introduced in previous studies, we confirm that they exhibit a Generalized Voter (GV) transition. We then propose a canonical mean-field model that extends the original formulation by incorporating a noise term that eliminates the absorbing states. This generalization gives rise to a phase diagram featuring two distinct types of phase transitions: a continuous Ising transition and a discontinuous transition we call Modified Generalized Voter (MGV). These two transition lines converge at a tricritical point. We map diverse noisy nonlinear voter models onto this extended canonical form. Using finite-size scaling techniques above and below the upper critical dimension, we show that the continuous transition of these models belongs to the Ising universality class in their respective dimensionality. We also find universal behavior at the tricitical point. Our results provide a unifying framework for classifying phase transitions in stochastic models of opinion dynamics with both nonlinearity and noise.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Complete aging in the noisy voter model enhances consensus formation
Authors:
Jaume Llabrés,
Sara Oliver-Bonafoux,
Celia Anteneodo,
Raúl Toral
Abstract:
We investigate the effects of aging in the noisy voter model considering that the probability to change states decays algebraically with age $τ$, defined as the time elapsed since adopting the current state. We study the complete aging scenario, which incorporates aging to both mechanisms of interaction: herding and idiosyncratic behavior, and compare it with the partial aging case, where aging af…
▽ More
We investigate the effects of aging in the noisy voter model considering that the probability to change states decays algebraically with age $τ$, defined as the time elapsed since adopting the current state. We study the complete aging scenario, which incorporates aging to both mechanisms of interaction: herding and idiosyncratic behavior, and compare it with the partial aging case, where aging affects only the herding mechanism. Analytical mean-field equations are derived, finding excellent agreement with agent-based simulations on a complete graph. We observe that complete aging enhances consensus formation, shifting the critical point to higher values compared to the partial aging case. However, when the aging probability decays asymptotically to zero for large $τ$, a steady state is not always attained for complete aging.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Aging in some opinion formation models: a comparative study
Authors:
Jaume Llabres,
Sara Oliver-Bonafoux,
Celia Anteneodo,
Raul Toral
Abstract:
Changes of mind can become less likely the longer an agent has adopted a given opinion state. This resilience or inertia to change has been called ``aging''. We perform a comparative study of the effects of aging on the critical behavior of two standard opinion models with pairwise interactions. One of them is the voter model, which is a two-state model with a dynamic that proceeds by simple socia…
▽ More
Changes of mind can become less likely the longer an agent has adopted a given opinion state. This resilience or inertia to change has been called ``aging''. We perform a comparative study of the effects of aging on the critical behavior of two standard opinion models with pairwise interactions. One of them is the voter model, which is a two-state model with a dynamic that proceeds by simple social contagion, another is the so-called kinetic exchange model, which allows a third (neutral) state and the formed opinion depends on the previous opinions of both interacting agents. Furthermore, in the noisy version of both models, random opinion changes are also allowed, regardless of the interactions. Due to aging, the probability of change diminishes with the age, and to take this into account we consider algebraic and exponential kernels. We investigate the situation where aging acts only on pairwise interactions. Analytical predictions for the critical curves of the order parameters are obtained for the opinion dynamics on a complete graph, in good agreement with agent-based simulations. For both models considered, consensus is optimized by an intermediate value of the parameter that rules the rate of decrease of the aging factor.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Noisy kinetic-exchange opinion model with aging
Authors:
Allan R. Vieira,
Jaume Llabrés,
Raúl Toral,
Celia Anteneodo
Abstract:
We study the critical behavior of a noisy kinetic opinion model subject to resilience to change depending on aging, defined as the time spent on the current opinion state. In this model, the opinion of each agent can take the three discrete values, the extreme ones $\pm 1$, and also the intermediate value 0, and it can evolve through kinetic exchange when interacting with another agent, or indepen…
▽ More
We study the critical behavior of a noisy kinetic opinion model subject to resilience to change depending on aging, defined as the time spent on the current opinion state. In this model, the opinion of each agent can take the three discrete values, the extreme ones $\pm 1$, and also the intermediate value 0, and it can evolve through kinetic exchange when interacting with another agent, or independently, by stochastic choice (noise). The probability of change by pairwise interactions depends on the age that the agent has remained in the same state, according to a given kernel. We particularly develop the cases where the probability decays either algebraically or exponentially with the age, and we also consider the anti-aging scenario where the probability increases with the age, meaning that it is more likely to change mind the longer the persistence in the current state. For the opinion dynamics in a complete graph, we obtain analytical predictions for the critical curves of the order parameters, in perfect agreement with agent-based simulations. We observe that sufficiently weak aging (slow change of the kernel with the age) favors partial consensus with respect to the aging-insensitive scenario, while for sufficiently strong aging, as well as for anti-aging, the opposite trend is observed.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Partisan Voter Model: Stochastic description and noise-induced transitions
Authors:
Jaume Llabres,
Maxi San Miguel,
Raul Toral
Abstract:
We give a comprehensive mean-field analysis of the Partisan Voter Model (PVM) and report analytical results for exit probabilities, fixation times, and the quasi-stationary distribution. In addition, and similarly to the noisy voter model, we introduce a noisy version of the PVM, named as the Noisy Partisan Voter Model (NPVM) which accounts for the preferences of each agent for the two possible st…
▽ More
We give a comprehensive mean-field analysis of the Partisan Voter Model (PVM) and report analytical results for exit probabilities, fixation times, and the quasi-stationary distribution. In addition, and similarly to the noisy voter model, we introduce a noisy version of the PVM, named as the Noisy Partisan Voter Model (NPVM) which accounts for the preferences of each agent for the two possible states, as well as for idiosyncratic spontaneous changes of state. We find that the finite-size noise-induced transition of the noisy voter model is modified in the NPVM leading to the emergence of new intermediate phases and both continuous and discontinuous transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2023; v1 submitted 23 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
