-
Modeling Pedestrian Crossing Behavior: A Reinforcement Learning Approach with Sensory Motor Constraints
Authors:
Yueyang Wang,
Aravinda Ramakrishnan Srinivasan,
Yee Mun Lee,
Gustav Markkula
Abstract:
Understanding pedestrian behavior is crucial for the safe deployment of Autonomous Vehicles (AVs) in urban environments. Traditional pedestrian behavior models often fall into two categories: mechanistic models, which do not generalize well to complex environments, and machine-learned models, which generally overlook sensory-motor constraints influencing human behavior and thus prone to fail in un…
▽ More
Understanding pedestrian behavior is crucial for the safe deployment of Autonomous Vehicles (AVs) in urban environments. Traditional pedestrian behavior models often fall into two categories: mechanistic models, which do not generalize well to complex environments, and machine-learned models, which generally overlook sensory-motor constraints influencing human behavior and thus prone to fail in untrained scenarios. We hypothesize that sensory-motor constraints, fundamental to how humans perceive and interact with their surroundings, are essential for realistic simulations. Thus, we introduce a constrained reinforcement learning (RL) model that simulates the crossing decision and locomotion of pedestrians. It was constrained to emulate human sensory mechanisms with noisy visual perception and looming aversion. Additionally, human motor constraint was incorporated through a bio-mechanical model of walking. We gathered data from a human-in-the-loop experiment to understand pedestrian behavior. The findings reveal several phenomena not addressed by existing pedestrian models, regarding how pedestrians adapt their walking speed to the kinematics and behavior of the approaching vehicle. Our model successfully captures these human-like walking speed patterns, enabling us to understand these patterns as a trade-off between time pressure and walking effort. Importantly, the model retains the ability to reproduce various phenomena previously captured by a simpler version of the model. Additionally, phenomena related to external human-machine interfaces and light conditions were also included. Overall, our results not only demonstrate the potential of constrained RL in modeling pedestrian behaviors but also highlight the importance of sensory-motor mechanisms in modeling pedestrian-vehicle interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Deconstructing Pedestrian Crossing Decision-making in Interactions with Continuous Traffic: an Anthropomorphic Model
Authors:
Kai Tian,
Gustav Markkula,
Chongfeng Wei,
Yee Mun Lee,
Ruth Madigan,
Toshiya Hirose,
Natasha Merat,
Richard Romano
Abstract:
As safe and comfortable interactions with pedestrians could contribute to automated vehicles' (AVs) social acceptance and scale, increasing attention has been drawn to computational pedestrian behavior models. However, very limited studies characterize pedestrian crossing behavior based on specific behavioral mechanisms, as those mechanisms underpinning pedestrian road behavior are not yet clear.…
▽ More
As safe and comfortable interactions with pedestrians could contribute to automated vehicles' (AVs) social acceptance and scale, increasing attention has been drawn to computational pedestrian behavior models. However, very limited studies characterize pedestrian crossing behavior based on specific behavioral mechanisms, as those mechanisms underpinning pedestrian road behavior are not yet clear. Here, we reinterpret pedestrian crossing behavior based on a deconstructed crossing decision process at uncontrolled intersections with continuous traffic. Notably, we explain and model pedestrian crossing behavior as they wait for crossing opportunities, optimizing crossing decisions by comparing the visual collision risk of approaching vehicles around them. A collision risk-based crossing initiation model is proposed to characterize the time-dynamic nature of pedestrian crossing decisions. A simulation tool is established to reproduce pedestrian behavior by employing the proposed model and a social force model. Two datasets collected in a CAVE-based immersive pedestrian simulator are applied to calibrate and validate the model. The model predicts pedestrian crossing decisions across all traffic scenarios well. In particular, by considering the decision strategy that pedestrians compare the collision risk of surrounding traffic gaps, model performance is significantly improved. Moreover, the collision risk-based crossing initiation model accurately captures the timing of pedestrian crossing initiations within each gap. This work concisely demonstrates how pedestrians dynamically adapt their crossings in continuous traffic based on perceived collision risk, potentially providing insights into modeling coupled human-AV interactions or serving as a tool to realize human-like pedestrian road behavior in virtual AVs test platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Distributed Online Non-convex Optimization with Composite Regret
Authors:
Zhanhong Jiang,
Aditya Balu,
Xian Yeow Lee,
Young M. Lee,
Chinmay Hegde,
Soumik Sarkar
Abstract:
Regret has been widely adopted as the metric of choice for evaluating the performance of online optimization algorithms for distributed, multi-agent systems. However, data/model variations associated with agents can significantly impact decisions and requires consensus among agents. Moreover, most existing works have focused on developing approaches for (either strongly or non-strongly) convex los…
▽ More
Regret has been widely adopted as the metric of choice for evaluating the performance of online optimization algorithms for distributed, multi-agent systems. However, data/model variations associated with agents can significantly impact decisions and requires consensus among agents. Moreover, most existing works have focused on developing approaches for (either strongly or non-strongly) convex losses, and very few results have been obtained regarding regret bounds in distributed online optimization for general non-convex losses. To address these two issues, we propose a novel composite regret with a new network regret-based metric to evaluate distributed online optimization algorithms. We concretely define static and dynamic forms of the composite regret. By leveraging the dynamic form of our composite regret, we develop a consensus-based online normalized gradient (CONGD) approach for pseudo-convex losses, and it provably shows a sublinear behavior relating to a regularity term for the path variation of the optimizer. For general non-convex losses, we first shed light on the regret for the setting of distributed online non-convex learning based on recent advances such that no deterministic algorithm can achieve the sublinear regret. We then develop the distributed online non-convex optimization with composite regret (DINOCO) without access to the gradients, depending on an offline optimization oracle. DINOCO is shown to achieve sublinear regret; to our knowledge, this is the first regret bound for general distributed online non-convex learning.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Asynchronous Training Schemes in Distributed Learning with Time Delay
Authors:
Haoxiang Wang,
Zhanhong Jiang,
Chao Liu,
Soumik Sarkar,
Dongxiang Jiang,
Young M. Lee
Abstract:
In the context of distributed deep learning, the issue of stale weights or gradients could result in poor algorithmic performance. This issue is usually tackled by delay tolerant algorithms with some mild assumptions on the objective functions and step sizes. In this paper, we propose a different approach to develop a new algorithm, called $\textbf{P}$redicting $\textbf{C}$lipping $\textbf{A}$sync…
▽ More
In the context of distributed deep learning, the issue of stale weights or gradients could result in poor algorithmic performance. This issue is usually tackled by delay tolerant algorithms with some mild assumptions on the objective functions and step sizes. In this paper, we propose a different approach to develop a new algorithm, called $\textbf{P}$redicting $\textbf{C}$lipping $\textbf{A}$synchronous $\textbf{S}$tochastic $\textbf{G}$radient $\textbf{D}$escent (aka, PC-ASGD). Specifically, PC-ASGD has two steps - the $\textit{predicting step}$ leverages the gradient prediction using Taylor expansion to reduce the staleness of the outdated weights while the $\textit{clipping step}$ selectively drops the outdated weights to alleviate their negative effects. A tradeoff parameter is introduced to balance the effects between these two steps. Theoretically, we present the convergence rate considering the effects of delay of the proposed algorithm with constant step size when the smooth objective functions are weakly strongly-convex and nonconvex. One practical variant of PC-ASGD is also proposed by adopting a condition to help with the determination of the tradeoff parameter. For empirical validation, we demonstrate the performance of the algorithm with two deep neural network architectures on two benchmark datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
MDPGT: Momentum-based Decentralized Policy Gradient Tracking
Authors:
Zhanhong Jiang,
Xian Yeow Lee,
Sin Yong Tan,
Kai Liang Tan,
Aditya Balu,
Young M. Lee,
Chinmay Hegde,
Soumik Sarkar
Abstract:
We propose a novel policy gradient method for multi-agent reinforcement learning, which leverages two different variance-reduction techniques and does not require large batches over iterations. Specifically, we propose a momentum-based decentralized policy gradient tracking (MDPGT) where a new momentum-based variance reduction technique is used to approximate the local policy gradient surrogate wi…
▽ More
We propose a novel policy gradient method for multi-agent reinforcement learning, which leverages two different variance-reduction techniques and does not require large batches over iterations. Specifically, we propose a momentum-based decentralized policy gradient tracking (MDPGT) where a new momentum-based variance reduction technique is used to approximate the local policy gradient surrogate with importance sampling, and an intermediate parameter is adopted to track two consecutive policy gradient surrogates. Moreover, MDPGT provably achieves the best available sample complexity of $\mathcal{O}(N^{-1}ε^{-3})$ for converging to an $ε$-stationary point of the global average of $N$ local performance functions (possibly nonconcave). This outperforms the state-of-the-art sample complexity in decentralized model-free reinforcement learning, and when initialized with a single trajectory, the sample complexity matches those obtained by the existing decentralized policy gradient methods. We further validate the theoretical claim for the Gaussian policy function. When the required error tolerance $ε$ is small enough, MDPGT leads to a linear speed up, which has been previously established in decentralized stochastic optimization, but not for reinforcement learning. Lastly, we provide empirical results on a multi-agent reinforcement learning benchmark environment to support our theoretical findings.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Decentralized Deep Learning using Momentum-Accelerated Consensus
Authors:
Aditya Balu,
Zhanhong Jiang,
Sin Yong Tan,
Chinmay Hedge,
Young M Lee,
Soumik Sarkar
Abstract:
We consider the problem of decentralized deep learning where multiple agents collaborate to learn from a distributed dataset. While there exist several decentralized deep learning approaches, the majority consider a central parameter-server topology for aggregating the model parameters from the agents. However, such a topology may be inapplicable in networked systems such as ad-hoc mobile networks…
▽ More
We consider the problem of decentralized deep learning where multiple agents collaborate to learn from a distributed dataset. While there exist several decentralized deep learning approaches, the majority consider a central parameter-server topology for aggregating the model parameters from the agents. However, such a topology may be inapplicable in networked systems such as ad-hoc mobile networks, field robotics, and power network systems where direct communication with the central parameter server may be inefficient. In this context, we propose and analyze a novel decentralized deep learning algorithm where the agents interact over a fixed communication topology (without a central server). Our algorithm is based on the heavy-ball acceleration method used in gradient-based optimization. We propose a novel consensus protocol where each agent shares with its neighbors its model parameters as well as gradient-momentum values during the optimization process. We consider both strongly convex and non-convex objective functions and theoretically analyze our algorithm's performance. We present several empirical comparisons with competing decentralized learning methods to demonstrate the efficacy of our approach under different communication topologies.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2020; v1 submitted 21 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Deep Transfer Learning for Thermal Dynamics Modeling in Smart Buildings
Authors:
Zhanhong Jiang,
Young M. Lee
Abstract:
Thermal dynamics modeling has been a critical issue in building heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) systems, which can significantly affect the control and maintenance strategies. Due to the uniqueness of each specific building, traditional thermal dynamics modeling approaches heavily depending on physics knowledge cannot generalize well. This study proposes a deep supervised domain…
▽ More
Thermal dynamics modeling has been a critical issue in building heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) systems, which can significantly affect the control and maintenance strategies. Due to the uniqueness of each specific building, traditional thermal dynamics modeling approaches heavily depending on physics knowledge cannot generalize well. This study proposes a deep supervised domain adaptation (DSDA) method for thermal dynamics modeling of building indoor temperature evolution and energy consumption. A long short term memory network based Sequence to Sequence scheme is pre-trained based on a large amount of data collected from a building and then adapted to another building which has a limited amount of data by applying the model fine-tuning. We use four publicly available datasets: SML and AHU for temperature evolution, long-term datasets from two different commercial buildings, termed as Building 1 and Building 2 for energy consumption. We show that the deep supervised domain adaptation is effective to adapt the pre-trained model from one building to another building and has better predictive performance than learning from scratch with only a limited amount of data.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
On Higher-order Moments in Adam
Authors:
Zhanhong Jiang,
Aditya Balu,
Sin Yong Tan,
Young M Lee,
Chinmay Hegde,
Soumik Sarkar
Abstract:
In this paper, we investigate the popular deep learning optimization routine, Adam, from the perspective of statistical moments. While Adam is an adaptive lower-order moment based (of the stochastic gradient) method, we propose an extension namely, HAdam, which uses higher order moments of the stochastic gradient. Our analysis and experiments reveal that certain higher-order moments of the stochas…
▽ More
In this paper, we investigate the popular deep learning optimization routine, Adam, from the perspective of statistical moments. While Adam is an adaptive lower-order moment based (of the stochastic gradient) method, we propose an extension namely, HAdam, which uses higher order moments of the stochastic gradient. Our analysis and experiments reveal that certain higher-order moments of the stochastic gradient are able to achieve better performance compared to the vanilla Adam algorithm. We also provide some analysis of HAdam related to odd and even moments to explain some intriguing and seemingly non-intuitive empirical results.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Current-induced magnetization switching in MgO barrier magnetic tunnel junctions with CoFeB based synthetic ferrimagnetic free layers
Authors:
Jun Hayakawa,
Shoji Ikeda,
Katsuya Miura,
Michihiko Yamanouchi,
Young Min Lee,
Ryutaro Sasaki,
Masahiko Ichimura,
Kenchi Ito,
Takayuki Kawahara,
Riichiro Takemura,
Toshiyasu Meguro,
Fumihiro Matsukura,
Hiromasa Takahashi,
Hideyuki Matsuoka,
Hideo Ohno
Abstract:
We investigated the effect of using a synthetic ferrimagnetic (SyF) free layer in MgO-based magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) on current-induced magnetization switching (CIMS), particularly for application to spin-transfer torque random access memory (SPRAM). The employed SyF free layer had a Co40Fe40B20/ Ru/ Co40Fe40B20 and Co20Fe60B20/Ru/Co20Fe60B20 structures, and the MTJs(100x(150-300) nm^2)…
▽ More
We investigated the effect of using a synthetic ferrimagnetic (SyF) free layer in MgO-based magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) on current-induced magnetization switching (CIMS), particularly for application to spin-transfer torque random access memory (SPRAM). The employed SyF free layer had a Co40Fe40B20/ Ru/ Co40Fe40B20 and Co20Fe60B20/Ru/Co20Fe60B20 structures, and the MTJs(100x(150-300) nm^2) were annealed at 300oC. The use of SyF free layer resulted in low intrinsic critical current density (Jc0) without degrading the thermal-stability factor (E/kBT, where E, kB, and T are the energy potential, the Boltzmann constant, and temperature,respectively). When the two CoFeB layers of a strongly antiferromagnetically coupled SyF free layer had the same thickness, Jc0 was reduced to 2-4x10^6 A/cm^2. This low Jc0 may be due to the decreased effective volume under the large spin accumulation at the CoFeB/Ru. The E/kBT was over 60, resulting in a retention time of over ten years and suppression of the write current dispersion for SPRAM. The use of the SyF free layer also resulted in a bistable (parallel/antiparallel) magnetization configuration at zero field, enabling the realization of CIMS without the need to apply external fields to compensate for the offset field.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Effect of high annealing temperature on giant tunnel magnetoresistance ratio of CoFeB/MgO/CoFeB magnetic tunnel junctions
Authors:
Jun Hayakawa,
Shoji Ikeda,
Young Min Lee,
Fumihiro Matsukura,
Hideo Ohno
Abstract:
We report tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratios as high as 472% at room temperature and 804% at 5 K in pseudo-spin valve (SV) CoFeB/MgO/CoFeB magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) annealed at 450oC, which is approaching the theoretically predicted value. By contrast, the TMR ratios for exchange-biased (EB) SV MTJs with a MnIr antiferromagnetic layer are found to drop when they are annealed at 450oC.…
▽ More
We report tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratios as high as 472% at room temperature and 804% at 5 K in pseudo-spin valve (SV) CoFeB/MgO/CoFeB magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) annealed at 450oC, which is approaching the theoretically predicted value. By contrast, the TMR ratios for exchange-biased (EB) SV MTJs with a MnIr antiferromagnetic layer are found to drop when they are annealed at 450oC. Energy dispersive X-ray analysis shows that annealing at 450oC induces interdiffusion of Mn and Ru atoms into the MgO barrier and ferromagnetic layers in EB-SV MTJs. Mechanisms behind the different annealing behavior are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2006;
originally announced October 2006.
-
Current-induced magnetization switching in MgO barrier based magnetic tunnel junctions with CoFeB/Ru/CoFeB synthetic ferrimagnetic free layer
Authors:
Jun Hayakawa,
Shoji Ikeda,
Young Min Lee,
Ryutaro Sasaki,
Toshiyasu Meguro,
Fumihiro Matsukura,
Hiromasa Takahashi,
Hideo Ohno
Abstract:
We report the intrinsic critical current density (Jc0) in current-induced magnetization switching and the thermal stability factor (E/kBT, where E, kB, and T are the energy potential, the Boltzmann constant, and temperature, respectively) in MgO based magnetic tunnel junctions with a Co40Fe40B20(2nm)/Ru(0.7-2.4nm)/Co40Fe40B20(2nm) synthetic ferrimagnetic (SyF) free layer. We show that Jc0 and E/…
▽ More
We report the intrinsic critical current density (Jc0) in current-induced magnetization switching and the thermal stability factor (E/kBT, where E, kB, and T are the energy potential, the Boltzmann constant, and temperature, respectively) in MgO based magnetic tunnel junctions with a Co40Fe40B20(2nm)/Ru(0.7-2.4nm)/Co40Fe40B20(2nm) synthetic ferrimagnetic (SyF) free layer. We show that Jc0 and E/kBT can be determined by analyzing the average critical current density as a function of coercivity using the Slonczewski's model taking into account thermal fluctuation. We find that high antiferromagnetic coupling between the two CoFeB layers in a SyF free layer results in reduced Jc0 without reducing high E/kBT.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2006; v1 submitted 13 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
Dependence of tunnel magnetoresistance on ferromagnetic electrode materials in MgO-barrier magnetic tunnel junctions
Authors:
Shoji Ikeda,
Jun Hayakawa,
Young Min Lee,
Fumihiro Matsukura,
Hideo Ohno
Abstract:
We investigated the relationship between the tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratio and the electrode structure in MgO-barrier magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs). The TMR ratio in a MTJ with Co40Fe40B20 reference and free layers reached 355% at the post-deposition annealing temperature of Ta=400 degree C. When Co50Fe50 or Co90Fe10 is used for the reference layer material, no high TMR ratio was obser…
▽ More
We investigated the relationship between the tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratio and the electrode structure in MgO-barrier magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs). The TMR ratio in a MTJ with Co40Fe40B20 reference and free layers reached 355% at the post-deposition annealing temperature of Ta=400 degree C. When Co50Fe50 or Co90Fe10 is used for the reference layer material, no high TMR ratio was observed. The key to have high TMR ratio is to have highly oriented (001) MgO barrier/CoFeB crystalline electrodes. The highest TMR ratio obtained so far is 450% at Ta = 450 degree C in a pseudo spin-valve MTJ.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.
-
Giant tunnel magnetoresistance and high annealing stability in CoFeB/MgO/CoFeB magnetic tunnel junctions with synthetic pinned layer
Authors:
Young Min Lee,
Jun Hayakawa,
Shoji Ikeda,
Fumihiro Matsukura,
Hideo Ohno
Abstract:
We investigated the relationship between tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratio and the crystallization of CoFeB layers through annealing in magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) with MgO barriers that had CoFe/Ru/CoFeB synthetic ferrimagnet pinned layers with varying Ru spacer thickness (tRu). The TMR ratio increased with increasing annealing temperature (Ta) and tRu, reaching 361% at Ta = 425C, where…
▽ More
We investigated the relationship between tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratio and the crystallization of CoFeB layers through annealing in magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) with MgO barriers that had CoFe/Ru/CoFeB synthetic ferrimagnet pinned layers with varying Ru spacer thickness (tRu). The TMR ratio increased with increasing annealing temperature (Ta) and tRu, reaching 361% at Ta = 425C, whereas the TMR ratio of the MTJs with pinned layers without Ru spacers decreased at Ta over 325C. Ruthenium spacers play an important role in forming an (001)-oriented bcc CoFeB pinned layer, resulting in a high TMR ratio through annealing at high temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2006;
originally announced June 2006.
-
Current-driven magnetization switching in CoFeB/MgO/CoFeB magnetic tunnel junctions
Authors:
Jun Hayakawa,
Shoji Ikeda,
Young Min Lee,
Ryutaro Sasaki,
Toshiyasu Meguro,
Fumihiro Matsukura,
Hiromasa Takahashi,
Hideo Ohno
Abstract:
Current-driven magnetization switching in low-resistance Co40Fe40B20/MgO/Co40Fe40B20 magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) is reported. The critical-current densities Jc required for current-driven switching in samples annealed at 270C and 300C are found to be as low as 7.8 x 10^5 A/cm^2 and 8.8 x 10^5 A/cm^2 with accompanying tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratios of 49% and 73 %, respectively. Furth…
▽ More
Current-driven magnetization switching in low-resistance Co40Fe40B20/MgO/Co40Fe40B20 magnetic tunnel junctions (MTJs) is reported. The critical-current densities Jc required for current-driven switching in samples annealed at 270C and 300C are found to be as low as 7.8 x 10^5 A/cm^2 and 8.8 x 10^5 A/cm^2 with accompanying tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratios of 49% and 73 %, respectively. Further annealing of the samples at 350C increases TMR ratio to 160 %, while accompanying Jc increases to 2.5 x 10^6 A/cm^2. We attribute the low Jc to the high spin-polarization of tunnel current and small MsV product of the CoFeB single free layer, where Ms is the saturation magnetization and V the volume of the free layer.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.
-
Dependence of tunnel magnetoresistance in MgO based magnetic tunnel junctions on Ar pressure during MgO sputtering
Authors:
Shoji Ikeda,
Jun Hayakawa,
Young Min Lee,
Ryutaro Sasaki,
Toshiyasu Meguro,
Fumihiro Matsukura,
Hideo Ohno
Abstract:
We investigated dependence of tunnel magnetoresistance effect in CoFeB/MgO/CoFeB magnetic tunnel junctions on Ar pressure during MgO-barrier sputtering. Sputter deposition of MgO-barrier at high Ar pressure of 10 mTorr resulted in smooth surface and highly (001) oriented MgO. Using this MgO as a tunnel barrier, tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratio as high as 355% at room temperature (578% at 5K)…
▽ More
We investigated dependence of tunnel magnetoresistance effect in CoFeB/MgO/CoFeB magnetic tunnel junctions on Ar pressure during MgO-barrier sputtering. Sputter deposition of MgO-barrier at high Ar pressure of 10 mTorr resulted in smooth surface and highly (001) oriented MgO. Using this MgO as a tunnel barrier, tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) ratio as high as 355% at room temperature (578% at 5K) was realized after annealing at 325 C or higher, which appears to be related to a highly (001) oriented CoFeB texture promoted by the smooth and highly oriented MgO. Electron-beam lithography defined deep-submicron MTJs having a low-resistivity Au underlayer with the high-pressure deposited MgO showed high TMR ratio at low resistance-area product (RA) below 10 ohm-um^2 as 27% at RA = 0.8 ohm-um^2, 77% at RA = 1.1 ohm-um^2, 130% at RA = 1.7 ohm-um^2, and 165% at RA = 2.9 ohm-um^2.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2005;
originally announced October 2005.