-
Zonal flow suppression of microturbulent transport in the optimized stellarators W7-X and QSTK
Authors:
Abhishek Tiwari,
Joydeep Das,
Jaya Kumar Alageshan,
Gareth Roberg-Clark,
Gabriel Plunk,
Pavlos Xanthopoulos,
Sarveshwar Sharma,
Zhihong Lin,
Animesh Kuley
Abstract:
We present a comparative study of turbulence transport in two optimized stellarator configurations: Wendelstein 7-X (W7-X) and a recent design called Quasi-Symmetric Turbulence Konzept (QSTK). Using global gyrokinetic simulations with the Gyrokinetic Toroidal Code (GTC), we explore the role of zonal flows (ZFs) in suppressing electrostatic Ion Temperature Gradient (ITG) driven turbulence in both c…
▽ More
We present a comparative study of turbulence transport in two optimized stellarator configurations: Wendelstein 7-X (W7-X) and a recent design called Quasi-Symmetric Turbulence Konzept (QSTK). Using global gyrokinetic simulations with the Gyrokinetic Toroidal Code (GTC), we explore the role of zonal flows (ZFs) in suppressing electrostatic Ion Temperature Gradient (ITG) driven turbulence in both configurations. The simulations reveal that ZFs significantly reduce ion heat transport in both W7-X and QSTK, with a more pronounced impact on the latter configuration, as suggested by the apparently higher linear threshold ("critical") gradients for ITG modes. The study also highlights that, while both stellarators exhibit similar mode structures, the reduced ITG growth rates in QSTK contribute to the better performance regarding turbulence suppression, particularly at larger temperature gradients. The results support the notion that linear stability measures, in combination with nonlinear stabilization by zonal flows, can play an important role in the suppression of nonlinear heat fluxes.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Stabilization of sawteeth instability by short gas pulse injection in ADITYA-U tokamak
Authors:
Suman Dolui,
Kaushlender Singh,
Bharat Hegde,
T. Macwan,
SK Injamul Hoque,
Umesh Nagora,
Jaya Kumar A.,
S. Purohit,
A. N. Adhiya,
K. A. Jadeja,
Harshita Raj,
Ankit Kumar,
Ashok K. Kumawat,
Suman Aich,
Rohit Kumar,
K. M. Patel,
P. Gautam,
Sharvil Patel,
N. Yadava,
N. Ramaiya,
M. K. Gupta,
S. K. Pathak,
M. B. Chowdhuri,
S. Sharma,
A. Kuley
, et al. (6 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Experiments on ADITYA-U tokamak show a marked enhancement in the sawtooth period by application of short gas puffs of fuel that cause a modification of the radial density profile. A consequent suppression of the trapped electron modes (TEMs) then leads to an increase in the core electron temperature. This slows down the heat propagation following a sawtooth crash, causing a delay in achieving the…
▽ More
Experiments on ADITYA-U tokamak show a marked enhancement in the sawtooth period by application of short gas puffs of fuel that cause a modification of the radial density profile. A consequent suppression of the trapped electron modes (TEMs) then leads to an increase in the core electron temperature. This slows down the heat propagation following a sawtooth crash, causing a delay in achieving the critical temperature gradient inside the q = 1 surface required for the next sawtooth crash to happen. The overall scenario has strong similarities with the behavior of sawtooth under electron cyclotron resonance heating (ECRH). Our findings suggest an alternate, simpler technique for sawtooth control that may be usefully employed in small/medium-sized tokamaks that do not have an ECRH or any other auxiliary heating facility.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Neural network assisted electrostatic global gyrokinetic toroidal code using cylindrical coordinates
Authors:
Jaya Kumar Alageshan,
Joydeep Das,
Tajinder Singh,
Sarveshwar Sharma,
Animesh Kuley
Abstract:
Gyrokinetic simulation codes are used to understand the microturbulence in the linear and nonlinear regimes of the tokamak and stellarator core. The codes that use flux coordinates to reduce computational complexities introduced by the anisotropy due to the presence of confinement magnetic fields encounter a mathematical singularity of the metric on the magnetic separatrix surface. To overcome thi…
▽ More
Gyrokinetic simulation codes are used to understand the microturbulence in the linear and nonlinear regimes of the tokamak and stellarator core. The codes that use flux coordinates to reduce computational complexities introduced by the anisotropy due to the presence of confinement magnetic fields encounter a mathematical singularity of the metric on the magnetic separatrix surface. To overcome this constraint, we develop a neural network-assisted Global Gyrokinetic Code using Cylindrical Coordinates (G2C3) to study the electrostatic microturbulence in realistic tokamak geometries. In particular, G2C3 uses a cylindrical coordinate system for particle dynamics, which allows particle motion in arbitrarily shaped flux surfaces, including the magnetic separatrix of the tokamak. We use an efficient particle locating hybrid scheme, which uses a neural network and iterative local search algorithm, for the charge deposition and field interpolation. G2C3 uses the field lines estimated by numerical integration to train the neural network in universal function approximator mode to speed up the subroutines related to gathering and scattering operations of gyrokinetic simulation. Finally, as verification of the capability of the new code, we present results from self-consistent simulations of linear ion temperature gradient modes in the core region of the DIII-D tokamak.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
A systematic investigation of electric field nonlinearity and field reversal in low pressure capacitive discharges driven by sawtooth-like waveforms
Authors:
Sarveshwar Sharma,
Nishant Sirse,
Miles M Turner,
Animesh Kuley
Abstract:
Understanding electron and ion heating phenomenon in capacitively coupled radio-frequency plasma discharges is vital for many plasma processing applications. In this article, using particle-in-cell simulation technique we investigate the collisionless argon discharge excited by temporally asymmetric sawtooth-like waveform. In particular, a systematic study of the electric field nonlinearity and fi…
▽ More
Understanding electron and ion heating phenomenon in capacitively coupled radio-frequency plasma discharges is vital for many plasma processing applications. In this article, using particle-in-cell simulation technique we investigate the collisionless argon discharge excited by temporally asymmetric sawtooth-like waveform. In particular, a systematic study of the electric field nonlinearity and field reversal phenomenon by varying the number of harmonics and its effect on electron and ion heating is performed. The simulation results predict higher harmonics generation and multiple field reversal regions formation with an increasing number of harmonics along with the local charge separation and significant displacement current outside sheath region. The field reversal strength is greater during the expanding phase of the sheath edge in comparison to its collapsing phase causing significant ion cooling. The observed behavior is associated with the electron fluid compression/rarefaction and electron inertia during expanding and collapsing phase respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2023; v1 submitted 15 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Plasma asymmetry, electron and ion energy distribution function in capacitive discharges excited by tailored waveforms
Authors:
Sarveshwar Sharma,
Nishant Sirse,
Animesh Kuley,
Miles M Turner
Abstract:
Using particle-in-cell simulation technique, we investigate the plasma and ionization asymmetry, electron and ion energy distribution function in capacitive discharges excited by tailored waveforms. At a base frequency of 13.56 MHz, three different waveforms namely, sinusoidal, saw-tooth, and square are applied for a constant current density of 50 A/m2 and 5 mTorr argon gas pressure. The simulatio…
▽ More
Using particle-in-cell simulation technique, we investigate the plasma and ionization asymmetry, electron and ion energy distribution function in capacitive discharges excited by tailored waveforms. At a base frequency of 13.56 MHz, three different waveforms namely, sinusoidal, saw-tooth, and square are applied for a constant current density of 50 A/m2 and 5 mTorr argon gas pressure. The simulation results show that the square waveform produces the highest plasma density in the discharge, whereas maximum asymmetry is observed for plasma excited by sawtooth like waveform. Both square and sawtooth waveforms generate multiple beams of high-energy electrons from near to the expanding phase of the sheath edge followed by the high-frequency modulations up to 100 MHz on the instantaneous sheath position. The electron energy distribution function depicts 3 electron temperature and highly elevated tail-end electrons for the square waveform in comparison to the sinusoidal and sawtooth waveform. The ion energy distribution function is bimodal at both powered and grounded electrodes with a large asymmetry and narrow type distribution in the case of sawtooth like waveform. These results suggest that the choice of the waveform is highly critical for achieving maximum asymmetry and plasma density simultaneously in the discharge.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Ion energy distribution function in very high frequency capacitive discharges excited by sawtooth waveform
Authors:
Sarveshwar Sharma,
Nishant Sirse,
Animesh Kuley,
Miles M Turner
Abstract:
Tailoring ion energy distribution function (IEDF) is vital for advanced plasma processing applications. Capacitively coupled plasma (CCP) discharges excited using non-sinusoidal waveform have shown its capability to control IEDF through generation of DC self-bias. In this paper, we performed a particle-in-cell simulation study to investigate the IEDF in a symmetric capacitive discharge excited by…
▽ More
Tailoring ion energy distribution function (IEDF) is vital for advanced plasma processing applications. Capacitively coupled plasma (CCP) discharges excited using non-sinusoidal waveform have shown its capability to control IEDF through generation of DC self-bias. In this paper, we performed a particle-in-cell simulation study to investigate the IEDF in a symmetric capacitive discharge excited by saw-tooth like current waveform at a very high frequency (VHF). At a constant driving frequency of 27.12 MHz, the simulation results predict that the ion energy symmetry scales with the discharge current amplitude and the IEDF turn into a bi-modal distribution at higher current density amplitude. Further studies at a constant current density and varying the fundamental excitation frequency, shows that the ion energy asymmetry is greatly reduced with a reduction in the driving frequency. Increase in the plasma asymmetry and significant DC self-bias at lower driving frequency is observed to be one of the principal factors responsible for the observed asymmetry in the ion energy peaks. An investigation of DC self-bias and plasma potential confirm that the powered electrode energy peak corresponds to the DC self-bias with respect to the plasma potential, and the grounded electrode peak corresponds to the plasma potential. These results suggest that although lower frequency is good for generating the asymmetry and DC self-bias in the discharge, but a narrow low energy IEDF is only possible in very high frequency driven CCP systems.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Dynamic Mode Decomposition of inertial particle caustics in Taylor-Green flow
Authors:
Omstavan Samant,
Jaya Kumar Alageshan,
Sarveshwar Sharma,
Animesh Kuley
Abstract:
Inertial particles advected by a background flow can show complex structures. We consider inertial particles in a 2D Taylor-Green (TG) flow and characterize particle dynamics as a function of the particle's Stokes number using dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) method from particle image velocimetry (PIV) like-data. We observe the formation of caustic structures and analyze them using DMD to (a) det…
▽ More
Inertial particles advected by a background flow can show complex structures. We consider inertial particles in a 2D Taylor-Green (TG) flow and characterize particle dynamics as a function of the particle's Stokes number using dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) method from particle image velocimetry (PIV) like-data. We observe the formation of caustic structures and analyze them using DMD to (a) determine the Stokes number of the particles, and (b) estimate the particle Stokes number composition. Our analysis in this idealized flow will provide useful insight to analyze inertial particles in more complex or turbulent flows. We propose that the DMD technique can be used to perform a similar analysis on an experimental system.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Driving frequency effect on discharge parameters and higher harmonic generation in capacitive discharges at constant power densities
Authors:
Sarveshwar Sharma,
Nishant Sirse,
Animesh Kuley,
Abhijit Sen,
Miles M Turner
Abstract:
Very high frequency (VHF) driven capacitive discharges are now being increasingly adopted for plasma-based materials processing due to their high processing rates and lower substrate damage. Past studies related to complex plasma dynamics and higher harmonics generation in such systems were limited to constant voltage/current conditions, whereas, industrial systems are mostly driven by constant po…
▽ More
Very high frequency (VHF) driven capacitive discharges are now being increasingly adopted for plasma-based materials processing due to their high processing rates and lower substrate damage. Past studies related to complex plasma dynamics and higher harmonics generation in such systems were limited to constant voltage/current conditions, whereas, industrial systems are mostly driven by constant power density sources. In the present study, using particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation, we explore the dynamics of collisionless symmetric capacitive discharges that is operated at constant power densities. Our focus is on the effect of the driving frequency on the discharge parameters like the electron density/temperature, the electron energy distribution function (EEDF), the ion energy distribution function (IEDF), and the generation of higher harmonics in the device. The simulations are performed for a driving frequency from 27.12-100 MHz in argon plasma at a gas pressure of 1 Pa and for two values of the power density, namely, 2 kW/m3 and 20 kW/m3. It is observed that the required discharge voltage for maintaining constant power density decreases and discharge current increases with an increase in the driving frequency. A transition frequency is observed at both power densities. The density decreases (electron temperature increases) before the transition frequency and the trend is reversed after crossing the transition frequency. The EEDF shows an enhancement in the population of the mid-energy range of electrons as the driving frequency increases up to the transition frequency thereby changing the shape of EEDF from bi-Maxwellian to nearly Maxwellian, and then transforms into a nearly bi-Maxwellian at higher driving frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Electric field non-linearity in very high frequency capacitive discharges at constant electron plasma frequency
Authors:
Sarveshwar Sharma,
Nishant Sirse,
Animesh Kuley,
Miles M Turner
Abstract:
A self-consistent particle-in-cell simulation study is performed to investigate the effect of driving frequency on the electric field non-linearity, electron heating mechanism and electron energy distribution function (EEDF) in a low pressure symmetric capacitively coupled plasma (CCP) discharge at a constant electron plasma frequency. The driving frequency is varied from 27.12 MHz to 100 MHz for…
▽ More
A self-consistent particle-in-cell simulation study is performed to investigate the effect of driving frequency on the electric field non-linearity, electron heating mechanism and electron energy distribution function (EEDF) in a low pressure symmetric capacitively coupled plasma (CCP) discharge at a constant electron plasma frequency. The driving frequency is varied from 27.12 MHz to 100 MHz for a discharge gap of 3.2 cm in argon at a gas pressure of 1 Pa. The simulation results provide insight of higher harmonic generations in a CCP system for a constant electron response time. The spatio-temporal evolution and spatial time averaged electron heating is presented for different driving frequencies. The simulation results predict that the electric field non-linearity increases with a rise in driving frequency along with a concurrent increase in higher harmonic contents. In addition to the electron heating and cooling near to the sheath edge a positive <J.E> is observed in to the bulk plasma at higher driving frequencies. The EEDF illustrate enhancement in the population of mid-energy range electrons as driving frequency increases thereby changing the shape of EEDF from bi-Maxwellian to nearly Maxwellian. For the constant ion flux on the electrode surface, a decrease in the ion energy by more than half is observed with an increase in driving frequency.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Lower hybrid destabilization of trapped electron modes in tokamak and its consequences for anomalous diffusion
Authors:
A. Kuley,
C. S. Liu,
V. K. Tripathi
Abstract:
Parametric coupling of lower hybrid pump wave with low frequency collisionless/weakly collisional trapped electron drift wave, with frequency lower than the electron bounce frequency is studied. The coupling produces two lower hybrid sidebands. The sidebands beat with the pump to exert a low frequency ponderomotive force on electrons that causes a frequency shift in the drift wave, leading to the…
▽ More
Parametric coupling of lower hybrid pump wave with low frequency collisionless/weakly collisional trapped electron drift wave, with frequency lower than the electron bounce frequency is studied. The coupling produces two lower hybrid sidebands. The sidebands beat with the pump to exert a low frequency ponderomotive force on electrons that causes a frequency shift in the drift wave, leading to the growth of the latter. The short wavelength modes are destabilized and they enhance the anomalous diffusion coefficient.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Parametric upconversion of lower hybrid wave by runaway electrons in tokamak
Authors:
A. Kuley,
V. K. Tripathi
Abstract:
A kinetic formalism of parametric decay of a large amplitude lower hybrid pump wave into runaway electron mode and a uppersideband mode is investigated. The pump and the sideband exert a ponderomotive force on runaway electrons, driving the runaway mode. The density perturbation associated with the latter beats with the oscillatory velocity due to the pump to produce the sideband. The finite paral…
▽ More
A kinetic formalism of parametric decay of a large amplitude lower hybrid pump wave into runaway electron mode and a uppersideband mode is investigated. The pump and the sideband exert a ponderomotive force on runaway electrons, driving the runaway mode. The density perturbation associated with the latter beats with the oscillatory velocity due to the pump to produce the sideband. The finite parallel velocity spread of the runaway electrons turns the parametric instability into a stimulated compton scattering process where growth rate scales as the square of the pump amplitude. The large phase velocity waves thus generated can potentially generate relativistic electrons.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Verification of particle simulation of radio frequency waves in fusion plasmas
Authors:
A. Kuley,
Z. X. Wang,
Z. Lin,
F. Wessel
Abstract:
Radio frequency (RF) waves can provide heating, current and flow drive, as well as instability control for steady state operations of fusion experiments. A particle simulation model has been developed in this work to provide a first-principles tool for studying the RF nonlinear interactions with plasmas. In this model, ions are considered as fully kinetic particles using the Vlasov equation and el…
▽ More
Radio frequency (RF) waves can provide heating, current and flow drive, as well as instability control for steady state operations of fusion experiments. A particle simulation model has been developed in this work to provide a first-principles tool for studying the RF nonlinear interactions with plasmas. In this model, ions are considered as fully kinetic particles using the Vlasov equation and electrons are treated as guiding centers using the drift kinetic equation. This model has been implemented in a global gyrokinetic toroidal code (GTC) using real electron-to-ion mass ratio. To verify the model, linear simulations of ion plasma oscillation, ion Bernstein wave, and lower hybrid wave are carried out in cylindrical geometry and found to agree well with analytic predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Verification of nonlinear particle simulation of radio frequency waves in tokamak
Authors:
A. Kuley,
Z. Lin,
J. Bao,
X. S. Wei,
Y. Xiao,
W. Zhang,
G. Y. Sun,
N. J. Fisch
Abstract:
Nonlinear simulation model for radio frequency (RF) waves in fusion plasmas has been developed and verified using fully kinetic ion and drift kinetic electron. Ion cyclotron motion in the toroidal geometry is implemented using Boris push in the Boozer coordinates. Linear dispersion relation and nonlinear particle trapping are verified for the lower hybrid (LH) wave and ion Bernstein wave (IBW). Pa…
▽ More
Nonlinear simulation model for radio frequency (RF) waves in fusion plasmas has been developed and verified using fully kinetic ion and drift kinetic electron. Ion cyclotron motion in the toroidal geometry is implemented using Boris push in the Boozer coordinates. Linear dispersion relation and nonlinear particle trapping are verified for the lower hybrid (LH) wave and ion Bernstein wave (IBW). Parametric decay instability is observed where a large amplitude pump wave decays into an IBW sideband and an ion cyclotron quasimode (ICQM). The ICQM induces an ion perpendicular heating with a heating rate proportional to the pump wave intensity.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Kinetic particle simulations in a global toroidal geometry
Authors:
S. De,
T. Singh,
A. Kuley,
J. Bao,
Z. Lin,
G. Y. Sun,
S. Sharma,
A. Sen
Abstract:
The gyrokinetic toroidal code (GTC) has been upgraded for global simulations by coupling the core and scrape-off layer (SOL) regions across the separatrix with field-aligned particle-grid interpolations. A fully kinetic particle pusher for high frequency waves (ion cyclotron frequency and beyond) and a guiding center pusher for low frequency waves have been implemented using cylindrical coordinate…
▽ More
The gyrokinetic toroidal code (GTC) has been upgraded for global simulations by coupling the core and scrape-off layer (SOL) regions across the separatrix with field-aligned particle-grid interpolations. A fully kinetic particle pusher for high frequency waves (ion cyclotron frequency and beyond) and a guiding center pusher for low frequency waves have been implemented using cylindrical coordinates in a global toroidal geometry. The two integrators correctly capture the particle orbits and agree well with each other, conserving energy and canonical angular momentum. As a verification and application of this new capability, ion guiding center simulations have been carried out to study ion orbit losses at the edge of the DIII-D tokamak for single null magnetic separatrix discharges. The ion loss conditions are examined as a function of the pitch angle for cases without and with a radial electric field. The simulations show good agreement with past theoretical results and with experimentally observed feature in which high energy ions flow out along the ion drift orbits and then hit the divertor plates. A measure of the ion direct orbit loss fraction shows that the loss fraction increases with the ion energy for DIII-D in the initial velocity space. Finally, as a further verification of the capability of the new code, self-consistent simulations of zonal flows in the core region of the DIII-D tokamak were carried out. All DIII-D simulations were perfomed in the absence of turbulence.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2019; v1 submitted 13 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Nonlinear electromagnetic formulation for particle simulation of lower hybrid waves in toroidal geometry
Authors:
J. Bao,
Z. Lin,
A. Kuley,
Z. X. Wang
Abstract:
Electromagnetic particle simulation model has been formulated and verified for nonlinear processes of lower hybrid (LH) waves in fusion plasmas. Electron dynamics is described by the drift kinetic equation using either kinetic momentum or canonical momentum. Ion dynamics is treated as the fluid system or by the Vlasov equation. Compressible magnetic perturbation is retained to simulate both the fa…
▽ More
Electromagnetic particle simulation model has been formulated and verified for nonlinear processes of lower hybrid (LH) waves in fusion plasmas. Electron dynamics is described by the drift kinetic equation using either kinetic momentum or canonical momentum. Ion dynamics is treated as the fluid system or by the Vlasov equation. Compressible magnetic perturbation is retained to simulate both the fast and slow LH waves. Numerical properties are greatly improved by using electron continuity equation to enforce consistency between electrostatic potential and vector potential, and by using the importance sampling technique. The simulation model has been implemented in the gyrokinetic toroidal code (GTC), and verified for the dispersion relation and nonlinear particle trapping of the electromagnetic LH waves.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Particle simulation of lower hybrid waves in tokamak plasmas
Authors:
J. Bao,
Z. Lin,
A. Kuley,
Z. X. Wang,
Z. X. Lu
Abstract:
Global particle simulations of the lower hybrid waves have been carried out using fully kinetic ions and drift kinetic electrons with a realistic electron-to-ion mass ratio. The lower hybrid wave frequency, mode structure, and electron Landau damping from the electrostatic simulations agree very well with the analytic theory. Linear simulation of the propagation of a lower hybrid wave-packet in th…
▽ More
Global particle simulations of the lower hybrid waves have been carried out using fully kinetic ions and drift kinetic electrons with a realistic electron-to-ion mass ratio. The lower hybrid wave frequency, mode structure, and electron Landau damping from the electrostatic simulations agree very well with the analytic theory. Linear simulation of the propagation of a lower hybrid wave-packet in the toroidal geometry shows that the wave propagates faster in the high field side than the low field side, in agreement with a ray tracing calculation. Electromagnetic benchmarks of lower hybrid wave dispersion relation are also carried out. Electromagnetic mode conversion are observed in toroidal geometry, slow waves are launched at the plasma boundary and converts to fast waves at the mode conversion layer, which is consistent with linear theory.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.