-
Exact coherent structures and shadowing in turbulent Taylor-Couette flow
Authors:
Michael C. Krygier,
Joshua L. Pughe-Sanford,
Roman O. Grigoriev
Abstract:
We investigate a theoretical framework for modeling fluid turbulence based on the formalism of exact coherent structures (ECSs). Although highly promising, existing evidence for the role of ECSs in turbulent flows is largely circumstantial and comes primarily from idealized numerical simulations. In particular, it remains unclear whether three-dimensional turbulent flows in experiment shadow any E…
▽ More
We investigate a theoretical framework for modeling fluid turbulence based on the formalism of exact coherent structures (ECSs). Although highly promising, existing evidence for the role of ECSs in turbulent flows is largely circumstantial and comes primarily from idealized numerical simulations. In particular, it remains unclear whether three-dimensional turbulent flows in experiment shadow any ECSs. In order to conclusively answer this question, a hierarchy of ECSs should be computed on a domain and with boundary conditions exactly matching experiment. The present study makes the first step in this direction by investigating a small-aspect-ratio Taylor-Couette flow with naturally periodic boundary condition in the azimuthal direction. We describe the structure of the chaotic set underlying turbulent flow driven by counter-rotating cylinders and present direct numerical evidence for shadowing of a collection of unstable relative periodic orbits and a traveling wave, setting the stage for further experimental tests of the framework.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Quantifying the unknown impact of segmentation uncertainty on image-based simulations
Authors:
Michael C. Krygier,
Tyler LaBonte,
Carianne Martinez,
Chance Norris,
Krish Sharma,
Lincoln N. Collins,
Partha P. Mukherjee,
Scott A. Roberts
Abstract:
Image-based simulation, the use of 3D images to calculate physical quantities, fundamentally relies on image segmentation to create the computational geometry. However, this process introduces image segmentation uncertainty because there is a variety of different segmentation tools (both manual and machine-learning-based) that will each produce a unique and valid segmentation. First, we demonstrat…
▽ More
Image-based simulation, the use of 3D images to calculate physical quantities, fundamentally relies on image segmentation to create the computational geometry. However, this process introduces image segmentation uncertainty because there is a variety of different segmentation tools (both manual and machine-learning-based) that will each produce a unique and valid segmentation. First, we demonstrate that these variations propagate into the physics simulations, compromising the resulting physics quantities. Second, we propose a general framework for rapidly quantifying segmentation uncertainty. Through the creation and sampling of segmentation uncertainty probability maps, we systematically and objectively create uncertainty distributions of the physics quantities. We show that physics quantity uncertainty distributions can follow a Normal distribution, but, in more complicated physics simulations, the resulting uncertainty distribution can be both nonintuitive and surprisingly nontrivial. We also establish that simply bounding the uncertainty can fail in situations that are sensitive to image segmentation. While our work does not eliminate segmentation uncertainty, it makes visible the previously unrecognized range of uncertainty currently plaguing image-based simulation, enabling more credible simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2021; v1 submitted 17 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
A novel subcritical transition to turbulence in Taylor-Couette flow with counter-rotating cylinders
Authors:
Christopher J. Crowley,
Michael C. Krygier,
Daniel Borrero-Echeverry,
Roman O. Grigoriev,
Michael F. Schatz
Abstract:
The transition to turbulence in Taylor-Couette flow often occurs via a sequence of supercritical bifurcations to progressively more complex, yet stable, flows. We describe a subcritical laminar-turbulent transition in the counter-rotating regime mediated by an unstable intermediate state in a system with an axial aspect ratio of $Γ=5.26$ and a radius ratio of $η=0.905$. In this regime, flow visual…
▽ More
The transition to turbulence in Taylor-Couette flow often occurs via a sequence of supercritical bifurcations to progressively more complex, yet stable, flows. We describe a subcritical laminar-turbulent transition in the counter-rotating regime mediated by an unstable intermediate state in a system with an axial aspect ratio of $Γ=5.26$ and a radius ratio of $η=0.905$. In this regime, flow visualization experiments and numerical simulations indicate the intermediate state corresponds to an aperiodic flow featuring interpenetrating spirals. Furthermore, the reverse transition out of turbulence leads first to the same intermediate state, which is now stable, before returning to an azimuthally-symmetric laminar flow. Time-resolved tomographic particle image velocimetry is used to characterize the experimental flows; these measurements compare favorably to direct numerical simulations with axial boundary conditions matching those of the experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
