-
Physics of Solar Neutron Production: Questionable Detection of Neutrons from the 2007 December 31 Flare
Authors:
Gerald H. Share,
Ronald J. Murphy,
Allan J. Tylka,
Benz Kozlovsky,
James M. Ryan,
Chul Gwon
Abstract:
Spacecraft observations in the inner heliosphere offer the first opportunity to measure 1-10 MeV solar neutrons. We discuss the physics of low-energy neutron production in solar flares and show that, even at interacting-particle energies of 2 MeV/nucleon, neutrons with energies >10 MeV are produced. On the other hand, a significant fraction of 1-10 MeV neutrons result from interactions of >10 MeV/…
▽ More
Spacecraft observations in the inner heliosphere offer the first opportunity to measure 1-10 MeV solar neutrons. We discuss the physics of low-energy neutron production in solar flares and show that, even at interacting-particle energies of 2 MeV/nucleon, neutrons with energies >10 MeV are produced. On the other hand, a significant fraction of 1-10 MeV neutrons result from interactions of >10 MeV/nucleon ions in typical flare spectra. We calculate the escaping neutron spectra for mono-energetic and power-law particle spectra at the Sun for the location and observation angle of MESSENGER at the time of its reported detection of low-energy neutrons associated with the 2007 December 31 solar flare. We detail concerns about this questionable observation of solar neutrons: 1. the inferred number of accelerated protons at the Sun for this modest M2-class flare was 10X larger than any flare observed to date, 2. the onset and duration of the 'solar' neutron count rate was similar to that of the solar energetic particles (SEPs), and 3. the authors' argument that the SEPs were dominated by electrons and so could not have produced the neutron counts locally in the spacecraft. In contrast we argue that solar energetic protons and alpha particles, through local neutron production and accidental coincidences, were the source of most of the reported 'solar-neutron' counts.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2011; v1 submitted 14 July, 2010;
originally announced July 2010.
-
Delayed X- and Gamma-Ray Line Emission from Solar Flare Radioactivity
Authors:
V. Tatischeff,
B. Kozlovsky,
J. Kiener,
R. J. Murphy
Abstract:
We have studied the radioactive line emission expected from solar active regions after large flares, following the production of long-lived radioisotopes by nuclear interactions of flare-accelerated ions. This delayed X- and gamma-ray line emission can provide unique information on the accelerated particle composition and energy spectrum, as well as on mixing processes in the solar atmosphere. T…
▽ More
We have studied the radioactive line emission expected from solar active regions after large flares, following the production of long-lived radioisotopes by nuclear interactions of flare-accelerated ions. This delayed X- and gamma-ray line emission can provide unique information on the accelerated particle composition and energy spectrum, as well as on mixing processes in the solar atmosphere. Total cross sections for the formation of the main radioisotopes by proton, 3-He and alpha-particle reactions are evaluated from available data combined with nuclear reaction theory. Thick-target radioisotope yields are provided in tabular form, which can be used to predict fluxes of all of the major delayed lines at any time after a gamma-ray flare. The brightest delayed line for days after the flare is found to be the 511 keV positron-electron annihilation line resulting from the decay of several beta+ radioisotopes. After ~2 days however, the flux of the 511 keV line can become lower than that of the 846.8 keV line from the decay of 56-Co. Our study has revealed other delayed gamma-ray lines that appear to be promising for detection, e.g. at 1434 keV from the radioactivity of both the isomer and the ground state of 52-Mn, 1332 and 1792 keV from 60-Cu, and 931.1 keV from 55-Co. The strongest delayed X-ray line is found to be the Co Kalpha at 6.92 keV, which is produced from both the decay of the isomer of 58-Co by the conversion of a K-shell electron and the decay of 57-Ni by orbital electron capture. Prospects for observation of these lines with RHESSI or future space instruments are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2006;
originally announced April 2006.
-
Issues of LiBeB, Oxygen and Iron Evolution
Authors:
R. Ramaty,
R. E. Lingenfelter,
B. Kozlovsky
Abstract:
We discuss the highlights of our recent research, specifically the refractory vs. volatile interpretation of the rise of [O/Fe] with decreasing [Fe/H], and the issue of primary vs. secondary evolution of Be.
We discuss the highlights of our recent research, specifically the refractory vs. volatile interpretation of the rise of [O/Fe] with decreasing [Fe/H], and the issue of primary vs. secondary evolution of Be.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2001;
originally announced January 2001.
-
LiBeB, O and Fe Evolution: Refractory Element and Cosmic Ray Transport Delays
Authors:
R. Ramaty,
B. Kozlovsky,
R. E. Lingenfelter
Abstract:
Employing a Monte-Carlo based evolutionary code, we show that the delay of Fe deposition relative to O, due to the incorporation of supernova ejecta refractories in high velocity grains, can account for the rise of [O/Fe] with decreasing [Fe/H]. The predicted behavior of refractory Mg, Si, Ca and Ti, and volatile S, namely that the refractories should not show the rise, but that the behavior of…
▽ More
Employing a Monte-Carlo based evolutionary code, we show that the delay of Fe deposition relative to O, due to the incorporation of supernova ejecta refractories in high velocity grains, can account for the rise of [O/Fe] with decreasing [Fe/H]. The predicted behavior of refractory Mg, Si, Ca and Ti, and volatile S, namely that the refractories should not show the rise, but that the behavior of S should be similar to that of O, appears to be confirmed (Takeda et al. 2000, astro-ph/0007007). The delayed deposition of Be, due to cosmic ray transport in a relatively low density medium, leads to consistency of primary Be evolution as a function of both [Fe/H] and [O/H].
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2000;
originally announced July 2000.
-
Lithium-6 from Solar Flares
Authors:
R. Ramaty,
V. Tatischeff,
J. P. Thibaud,
B. Kozlovsky,
N. Mandzhavidze
Abstract:
By introducing a hitherto ignored Li-6 producing process, due to accelerated He-3 reactions with He-4, we show that accelerated particle interactions in solar flares produce much more Li-6 than Li-7. By normalizing our calculations to gamma-ray data we demonstrate that the Li-6 produced in solar flares, combined with photospheric Li-7, can account for the recently determined solar wind lithium i…
▽ More
By introducing a hitherto ignored Li-6 producing process, due to accelerated He-3 reactions with He-4, we show that accelerated particle interactions in solar flares produce much more Li-6 than Li-7. By normalizing our calculations to gamma-ray data we demonstrate that the Li-6 produced in solar flares, combined with photospheric Li-7, can account for the recently determined solar wind lithium isotopic ratio, obtained from measurements in lunar soil, provided that the bulk of the flare produced lithium is evacuated by the solar wind. Further research in this area could provide unique information on a variety of problems, including solar atmospheric transport and mixing, solar convection and the lithium depletion issue, and solar wind and solar particle acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2000;
originally announced March 2000.
-
LiBeB Evolution: Three Models
Authors:
R. Ramaty,
R. E. Lingenfelter,
B. Kozlovsky
Abstract:
We consider the three principal LiBeB evolutionary models, CRI in which the cosmic-ray source at all epochs of Galactic evolution is the average ISM, CRI+LECR in which metal enriched low energy cosmic rays (LECRs) are superimposed onto the CRI cosmic rays, and CRS in which the cosmic-ray source, accelerated in superbubbles, is constant, independent of the ISM metallicity. By considering the evol…
▽ More
We consider the three principal LiBeB evolutionary models, CRI in which the cosmic-ray source at all epochs of Galactic evolution is the average ISM, CRI+LECR in which metal enriched low energy cosmic rays (LECRs) are superimposed onto the CRI cosmic rays, and CRS in which the cosmic-ray source, accelerated in superbubbles, is constant, independent of the ISM metallicity. By considering the evolutionary trend of log(Be/H) vs. both [Fe/H] and [O/H], we demonstrate that the CRI model is energetically untenable. We present evolutionary trends for B-11/B-10 and B/Be which, combined with future precision measurements, could distinguish between the CRS and CRI+LECR models. We show that delayed LiBeB synthesis in the CRS model, due to the transport of the cosmic rays, could explain why log(Be/H) is steeper vs. [O/H] than vs. [Fe/H]. We also show that delayed deposition of Fe into star forming regions, due to its incorporation into high velocity dust, could provide an explanation for the possible rise of [O/Fe] with decreasing [Fe/H]. Observations of refractory and volatile alpha-elements could test this scenario. There seems to be a need for pregalactic or extragalactic Li-6 sources.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2000;
originally announced January 2000.
-
Light Element Evolution and Cosmic Ray Energetics
Authors:
R. Ramaty,
S. T. Scully,
R. E. Lingenfelter,
B. Kozlovsky
Abstract:
Using cosmic-ray energetics as a discriminator, we investigate evolutionary models of LiBeB. We employ a Monte Carlo code which incorporates the delayed mixing into the ISM both of the synthesized Fe, due to its incorporation into high velocity dust grains, and of the cosmic-ray produced LiBeB, due to the transport of the cosmic rays. We normalize the LiBeB production to the integral energy impa…
▽ More
Using cosmic-ray energetics as a discriminator, we investigate evolutionary models of LiBeB. We employ a Monte Carlo code which incorporates the delayed mixing into the ISM both of the synthesized Fe, due to its incorporation into high velocity dust grains, and of the cosmic-ray produced LiBeB, due to the transport of the cosmic rays. We normalize the LiBeB production to the integral energy imparted to cosmic rays per supernova. Models in which the cosmic rays are accelerated mainly out of the average ISM significantly under predict the measured Be abundance of the early Galaxy, the increase in [O/Fe] with decreasing [Fe/H] notwithstanding. We suggest that this increase could be due to the delayed mixing of the Fe. But, if the cosmic-ray metals are accelerated out of supernova ejecta enriched superbubbles, the measured Be abundances are consistent with a cosmic-ray acceleration efficiency that is in very good agreement with the current epoch data. We also find that neither the above cosmic-ray origin models nor a model employing low energy cosmic rays originating from the supernovae of only very massive progenitors can account for the $^6$Li data at values of [Fe/H] below $-$2.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 1999;
originally announced September 1999.
-
LiBeB and the Origin of Cosmic Rays
Authors:
Reuven Ramaty,
Richard Lingenfelter,
Benzion Kozlovsky
Abstract:
Be abundances at low metallicities have major implications on cosmic ray origin, requiring acceleration out of fresh supernova ejecta. The observed, essentially constant Be/Fe fixes the Be production per SNII, allowing the determination of the energy supplied to cosmic rays per SNII. The results rule out acceleration out of the metal-poor ISM, and favor Be production at all epochs of Galactic ev…
▽ More
Be abundances at low metallicities have major implications on cosmic ray origin, requiring acceleration out of fresh supernova ejecta. The observed, essentially constant Be/Fe fixes the Be production per SNII, allowing the determination of the energy supplied to cosmic rays per SNII. The results rule out acceleration out of the metal-poor ISM, and favor Be production at all epochs of Galactic evolution by cosmic rays having the same spectrum and source composition as those at the current epoch. Individual supernova acceleration of its own nucleosynthetic products and the collective acceleration by SN shocks of ejecta-enriched matter in the interiors of superbubbles have been proposed for such origin. A new Monte-Carlo based evolutionary code, into which the concept of Be and Fe production per supernova is explicitly built in, yields the supernova acceleration efficiency, 2% for the refractory metals and 12% for all the cosmic rays.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 1998;
originally announced September 1998.
-
X-Rays from Accelerated Ion Interactions
Authors:
V. Tatischeff,
R. Ramaty,
B. Kozlovsky
Abstract:
We have developed in detail the theory of X-ray line and continuum production due to atomic interactions of accelerated ions, incorporating in our calculations information from a broad range of laboratory measurements. We applied our calculations to the Orion region from which nuclear gamma-ray lines were observed with the COMPTEL instrument on CGRO. The accelerated particles which produce this…
▽ More
We have developed in detail the theory of X-ray line and continuum production due to atomic interactions of accelerated ions, incorporating in our calculations information from a broad range of laboratory measurements. We applied our calculations to the Orion region from which nuclear gamma-ray lines were observed with the COMPTEL instrument on CGRO. The accelerated particles which produce this gamma-ray emission via nuclear reactions also produce X-ray lines via atomic interactions. We predict strong line emission in the range from 0.5 to 1 keV, mainly due to de-excitations in fast O ions. While much of the diffuse X-ray emission observed with ROSAT from Orion could be due to accelerated ions, the current X-ray data do not provide unambiguous signatures for such an origin. If future observations with high spectral resolution would confirm the predicted X-rays, the combined analysis of the X-ray and gamma-ray data will set important constraints on the origin of the accelerated particles and their interaction model.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 1998;
originally announced April 1998.
-
Light Elements and Cosmic Rays in the Early Galaxy
Authors:
R. Ramaty,
B. Kozlovsky,
R. E. Lingenfelter
Abstract:
We derive constraints on the cosmic rays responsible for the Be and part of the B observed in stars formed in the early Galaxy: the cosmic rays cannot be accelerated from the ISM; their energy spectrum must be relatively hard (the bulk of the nuclear reactions should occur at $>$30 MeV/nucl); and only 10$^{49}$ erg/SNII in high metallicity, accelerated particle kinetic energy could suffice to pr…
▽ More
We derive constraints on the cosmic rays responsible for the Be and part of the B observed in stars formed in the early Galaxy: the cosmic rays cannot be accelerated from the ISM; their energy spectrum must be relatively hard (the bulk of the nuclear reactions should occur at $>$30 MeV/nucl); and only 10$^{49}$ erg/SNII in high metallicity, accelerated particle kinetic energy could suffice to produce the Be and B. The reverse SNII shock could accelerate the particles.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 1996;
originally announced October 1996.
-
LiBeB: High and low energy cosmic ray production and comparison with neutrino induced nucleosynthesis in SNII
Authors:
R. Ramaty,
H. Reeves,
R. E. Lingenfelter,
B. Kozlovsky
Abstract:
We present new calculations of LiBeB production by accelerated particles with various compositions and energy spectra ranging from low energies to relativistic energies, and various ambient medium metallicities ($Z/Z_\odot$). The observed, essentially constant, Be/Fe ratio as a function of $Z/Z_\odot$ can be best understood if the metallicity of the accelerated particles (high energy or low ener…
▽ More
We present new calculations of LiBeB production by accelerated particles with various compositions and energy spectra ranging from low energies to relativistic energies, and various ambient medium metallicities ($Z/Z_\odot$). The observed, essentially constant, Be/Fe ratio as a function of $Z/Z_\odot$ can be best understood if the metallicity of the accelerated particles (high energy or low energy) does not vary much with $Z/Z_\odot$. This could be achieved if the particles are accelerated directly from the ejecta of Type II supernovae (SNII) and not from the interstellar medium. Using the observed Be/Fe and the fact that most of the Fe at low $Z/Z_\odot$ is from SNII, we derive the energy content in accelerated particles per SNII (a few times 10$^{50}$ erg). We show that additional $^{11}$B production by neutrinos is consistent with the available data, allowing a neutrino yield from SNII less than or equal to the nominal published yields. We further show that the observed $^6$Li at low $Z/Z_\odot$ suggests that the accelerated particles responsible for the LiBeB at such $Z/Z_\odot$ are confined to low energies and have a relatively high He/O abundance.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 1996;
originally announced August 1996.
-
Gamma Ray Lines from the Orion Complex
Authors:
Reuven Ramaty,
Benzion Kozlovsky,
Richard E. Lingenfelter
Abstract:
We show that the 4.44 and 6.13 MeV line emission observed with COMPTEL from Orion is consistent with gamma ray spectra consisting of a mixture of narrow and broad lines or spectra containing only broad lines. We employed several accelerated particle compositions and showed that the current COMPTEL data in the 3--7 MeV region alone cannot distinguish between the various possibilities. However, th…
▽ More
We show that the 4.44 and 6.13 MeV line emission observed with COMPTEL from Orion is consistent with gamma ray spectra consisting of a mixture of narrow and broad lines or spectra containing only broad lines. We employed several accelerated particle compositions and showed that the current COMPTEL data in the 3--7 MeV region alone cannot distinguish between the various possibilities. However, the COMPTEL upper limits in the 1--3 MeV band favor a composition similar to that of the winds of Wolf-Rayet stars of spectral type WC. The power dissipated by the accelerated particles at Orion is about 4 $\times$ 10$^{38}$ erg s$^{-1}$. These particles are not expected to produce significant amounts of $^{26}$Al.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 1994;
originally announced November 1994.
