-
On the unique evolutionary mechanisms of massive quiescent galaxies in the epoch of reionisation
Authors:
Harry George Chittenden,
Karl Glazebrook,
Themiya Nanayakkara,
Lalitwadee Kawinwanichakij,
Claudia Lagos,
Lucas Kimmig,
Rhea-Silvia Remus
Abstract:
We investigate the evolutionary histories of a population of high mass, high redshift, quiescent galaxies in the cosmohydrodynamical simulation Thesan; studying the characteristic properties of their haloes and environments over the epoch of reionisation. Thesan employs a modified version of the Arepo moving-mesh code utilised in IllustrisTNG, whose explicit handling of ionising radiation couples…
▽ More
We investigate the evolutionary histories of a population of high mass, high redshift, quiescent galaxies in the cosmohydrodynamical simulation Thesan; studying the characteristic properties of their haloes and environments over the epoch of reionisation. Thesan employs a modified version of the Arepo moving-mesh code utilised in IllustrisTNG, whose explicit handling of ionising radiation couples haloes and galaxies with cosmic reionisation. This results in a regime of rapid growth and quenching, producing nine massive quiescent galaxies at $z = 5.5$, in a $95.5\text{cMpc}^3$ volume, with no counterpart in IllustrisTNG. We find that the rapid assembly of stellar mass is attributed to smooth accretion of mass onto their haloes in dense environments, particularly from massive neighbouring structures; while these galaxies exhibit fast-growing potential wells hosting massive central black holes. With insignificant merger activity, we find AGN feedback to be the primary source of quenching. We find megaparsec-scale densities and halo masses to continue growing after quenching, suggesting that massive quiescent galaxies will be found in some of the largest haloes and densest regions of space by observations. With an unprecedented plethora of massive quiescent galaxies found in JWST data, these reionisation simulations may provide the paradigm for the evolutionary histories of these galaxies, while constraining the relatively unknown physics of reionisation. Despite the rarity of simulated massive quiescent galaxies, their identification in Thesan enables identification of halo and environmental properties most conducive to their quenching, hopefully guiding future efforts into the study of analogous systems in deep observational surveys and large-volume N-body simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Encyclopedia Magneticum: Scaling Relations from Cosmic Dawn to Present Day
Authors:
Klaus Dolag,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Lucas M. Valenzuela,
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Benjamin Seidel,
Silvio Fortune,
Johannes Stoiber,
Anna Ivleva,
Tadziu Hoffmann,
Veronica Biffi,
Ilaria Marini,
Paola Popesso,
Stephan Vladutescu-Zopp
Abstract:
Galaxy and halo scaling relations, connecting a broad range of parameters, are well established from observations. The origin of many of these relations and their scatter is still a matter of debate. It remains a sizable challenge for models to simultaneously and self-consistently reproduce as many scaling relations as possible. We introduce the Magneticum Pathfinder hydrodynamical cosmological si…
▽ More
Galaxy and halo scaling relations, connecting a broad range of parameters, are well established from observations. The origin of many of these relations and their scatter is still a matter of debate. It remains a sizable challenge for models to simultaneously and self-consistently reproduce as many scaling relations as possible. We introduce the Magneticum Pathfinder hydrodynamical cosmological simulation suite, to date the suite that self-consistently covers the largest range in box volumes and resolutions. It is the only cosmological simulation suite that is tuned on the hot gas content of galaxy clusters instead of the stellar mass function. By assessing the successes and shortcomings of tuning to the hot gas component of galaxy clusters, we aim to further our understanding of the physical processes shaping the Universe. We analyze the importance of the hot and cold gas components for galaxy and structure evolution. We analyze 28 scaling relations, covering large-scale global parameters as well as internal properties for halos ranging from massive galaxy clusters down to galaxies, and show their predicted evolution from z=4 to z=0 in comparison with observations. These include the halo-to-stellar-mass and Kennicutt--Schmidt relations, the cosmic star formation rate density as well as the Fundamental Plane. Magneticum Pathfinder matches a remarkable number of the observed scaling relations from z=4 to z=0, including challenging relations like the number density of quiescent galaxies at cosmic dawn, the mass--size evolution, the mass--metallicity relation, the Magorrian relation, and the temperature--mass relation. We compile our data to allow for straightforward future comparisons. Galaxy properties and scaling relations arise naturally and the large scatter in observables at high redshift is crucial to distinguish the various galaxy formation models reproducing the z=0 relations.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Die Hard: The On-Off-Cycle of Galaxies on the Star Formation Main Sequence
Authors:
Silvio Fortuné,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Andreas Burkert,
Klaus Dolag
Abstract:
Our picture of galaxy evolution currently assumes that galaxies spend their life on the star formation main sequence until they may eventually be quenched. However, recent observations show indications that the full picture might be more complicated. We reveal how the star formation rates of galaxies evolve, possible causes and imprints of different evolution scenarios on galactic features. We fol…
▽ More
Our picture of galaxy evolution currently assumes that galaxies spend their life on the star formation main sequence until they may eventually be quenched. However, recent observations show indications that the full picture might be more complicated. We reveal how the star formation rates of galaxies evolve, possible causes and imprints of different evolution scenarios on galactic features. We follow the evolution of central galaxies in the highest-resolution box of the Magneticum Pathfinder cosmological hydrodynamical simulations and classify their evolution scenarios with respect to the star formation main sequence. We find that a major fraction of the galaxies undergoes long-term cycles of quenching and rejuvenation on Gyr timescales. This expands the framework of galaxy evolution from a secular evolution to a sequence of multiple active and passive phases. Only 14% of field galaxies on the star formation main sequence at z~0 actually evolved along the scaling relation, while the bulk of star forming galaxies in the local universe have undergone cycles of quenching and rejuvenation. In this work we describe the statistics of these galaxy evolution modes and how this impacts their stellar masses, ages and metallicities today. Galaxies with rejuvenation cycles can be distinguished well from main-sequence-evolved galaxies in their features at z~0. We further explore possible explanations and find that the geometry of gas accretion at the halo outskirts shows a strong correlation with the star formation rate evolution, while the density parameter as a tracer of environment shows no significant correlation. A derivation of star formation rates from gas accretion with simple assumptions only works reasonably well in the high-redshift universe where accreted gas gets quickly converted into stars.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Intra-Cluster Light as a Dynamical Clock for Galaxy Clusters: Insights from the MAGNETICUM, IllustrisTNG, Hydrangea and Horizon-AGN Simulations
Authors:
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Sarah Brough,
Klaus Dolag,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Yannick M. Bahé,
Garreth Martin,
Annalisa Pillepich,
Nina Hatch,
Mireia Montes,
Syeda Lammim Ahad,
Callum Bellhouse,
Harley J. Brown,
Amaël Ellien,
Jesse B. Golden-Marx,
Anthony H. Gonzalez,
Enrica Iodice,
Yolanda Jiménez-Teja,
Matthias Kluge,
Johan H. Knapen,
J. Christopher Mihos,
Rossella Ragusa,
Marilena Spavone
Abstract:
As the most massive nodes of the cosmic web, galaxy clusters represent the best probes of structure formation. Over time, they grow by accreting and disrupting satellite galaxies, adding those stars to the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) and the intra-cluster light (ICL). However, the formation pathways of different galaxy clusters can vary significantly. To inform upcoming large surveys, we aim to…
▽ More
As the most massive nodes of the cosmic web, galaxy clusters represent the best probes of structure formation. Over time, they grow by accreting and disrupting satellite galaxies, adding those stars to the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) and the intra-cluster light (ICL). However, the formation pathways of different galaxy clusters can vary significantly. To inform upcoming large surveys, we aim to identify observables that can distinguish galaxy cluster formation pathways. Using four different hydrodynamical simulations, Magneticum, TNG100 of IllustrisTNG, Horizon-AGN, and Hydrangea, we study how the fraction of stellar mass in the BCG and ICL ($f_{ICL+BCG}$) relates to the galaxy cluster mass assembly history. For all simulations, $f_{ICL+BCG}$ is the best tracer for the time at which the cluster has accumulated 50% of its mass ($z_{f}$), performing better than other typical dynamical tracers, such as the subhalo mass fraction, the halo mass, and the center shift. More relaxed clusters have higher $f_{ICL+BCG}$, in rare cases up to 90%, while dynamically active clusters have lower fractions, down to 20%, which we find to be independent of the exact implemented baryonic physics. We determine the average increase in $f_{ICL+BCG}$ from stripping and mergers to be between 3-4% per Gyr. $f_{ICL+BCG}$ is tightly traced by the stellar mass ratio between the BCG and both the second (M12) and fourth (M14) most massive cluster galaxy. The average galaxy cluster has assembled half of its halo mass by $z_{f}=0.67$ (about 6 Gyr ago), though individual histories vary significantly from $z_{f}=0.06$ to $z_{f}=1.77$ (0.8 to 10 Gyr ago). As all four cosmological simulations consistently find that $f_{ICL+BCG}$ is an excellent tracer of the cluster dynamical state, upcoming surveys can leverage measurements of $f_{ICL+BCG}$ to statistically quantify the assembly of the most massive structures.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Go with the Flow: The Self-Similar and Non-Linear Behaviour of Large-Scale In- and Outflows and the Impact of Accretion Shocks from Galaxies to Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
Benjamin A. Seidel,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Lucas M. Valenzuela,
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Klaus Dolag
Abstract:
From the scale-free nature of gravity, the structure in the universe is expected to be self-similar on large scales. However, this self-similarity will eventually break down due to small-scale gas physics such as star formation, AGN and stellar feedback as well as non-linear effects gaining importance relative to linear structure formation. In this work we investigate the large-scale matter flows…
▽ More
From the scale-free nature of gravity, the structure in the universe is expected to be self-similar on large scales. However, this self-similarity will eventually break down due to small-scale gas physics such as star formation, AGN and stellar feedback as well as non-linear effects gaining importance relative to linear structure formation. In this work we investigate the large-scale matter flows that connect collapsed structures to their cosmic environments specifically for their agreement with self-similarity in various properties. For this purpose we use the full power of the hydrodynamical cosmological simulation suite Magneticum Pathfinder to calculate the in- and outflow rates for haloes on a large range of masses and redshifts. We find a striking self-similarity across the whole mass range and cosmic epochs that only breaks in the outflowing regime due to the different outflow driving mechanisms for galaxies vs. galaxy clusters. Geometrical analysis of the patterns of in vs. outflow demonstrate how the inflows organize into anisotropic filaments driven by the tidal environment, while the outflows are isotropic due to their thermal nature. This also manifests in the thermal and chemical properties of the gas: While the inflowing gas is pristine and colder, encountering the accretion shocks and entering the influence region of AGN and stellar feedback heats the gas up into a diffuse, metal enriched and hot atmosphere. Overall the differences between outflowing and infalling gas are enhanced at the galaxy cluster scale compared to the galaxy scale due to the accretion shocks that reach out to large radii for these objects. An individual study of the gas motions in the outskirts of one of the most massive clusters in the simulations illustrates these results: Gas found in the outer hot atmosphere at z=0 falls in and is completely enriched early before being shock heated and expanding.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
The MAGPI Survey: the subtle role of environment and not-so-subtle impact of generations of stars on galaxy dynamics
Authors:
Caroline Foster,
Sabine Bellstedt,
Francesco DEugenio,
Adriano Poci,
Ryan Bagge,
Katherine Harborne,
Thomas Venville,
J. Trevor Mendel,
Claudia Del P. Lagos,
Emily Wisnioski,
Tania M. Barone,
Andrew J. Battisti,
Stefania Barsanti,
Sarah Brough,
Scott M. Croom,
Caro Derkenne,
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Anilkumar Mailvaganam,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Gauri Sharma,
Sarah M. Sweet,
Sabine Thater,
Lucas M. Valenzuela,
Jesse van de Sande,
Sam P. Vaughan
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The stellar age and mass of galaxies have been suggested as the primary determinants for the dynamical state of galaxies, with environment seemingly playing no or only a very minor role. We use a sample of 77 galaxies at intermediate redshift (z~0.3) in the Middle-Ages Galaxies Properties with Integral field spectroscopy (MAGPI) Survey to study the subtle impact of environment on galaxy dynamics.…
▽ More
The stellar age and mass of galaxies have been suggested as the primary determinants for the dynamical state of galaxies, with environment seemingly playing no or only a very minor role. We use a sample of 77 galaxies at intermediate redshift (z~0.3) in the Middle-Ages Galaxies Properties with Integral field spectroscopy (MAGPI) Survey to study the subtle impact of environment on galaxy dynamics. We use a combination of statistical techniques (simple and partial correlations and principal component analysis) to isolate the contribution of environment on galaxy dynamics, while explicitly accounting for known factors such as stellar age, star formation histories and stellar masses. We consider these dynamical parameters: high-order kinematics of the line-of-sight velocity distribution (parametrised by the Gauss-Hermite coefficients $h_3$ and $h_4$), kinematic asymmetries $V_{\rm asym}$ derived using kinemetry and the observational spin parameter proxy $λ_{R_e}$. Of these, the mean $h_4$ is the only parameter found to have a significant correlation with environment as parametrised by group dynamical mass. This correlation exists even after accounting for age and stellar mass trends. Finally, we confirm that variations in the spin parameter $λ_{R_e}$ are most strongly (anti-)correlated with age as seen in local studies, and show that this dependence is well-established by z~0.3.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
From Particles to Pixels: How many particles do I really need to construct stellar kinematic mock observational measurements?
Authors:
K. E. Harborne,
C. del P. Lagos,
S. M. Croom,
J. van de Sande,
A. Ludlow,
R. S. Remus,
L. C. Kimmig,
C. Power
Abstract:
This work considers the impact of resolution in the construction of mock observations of simulated galaxies. In particular, when building mock integral field spectroscopic observations from galaxy formation models in cosmological simulations, we investigate the possible systematics that may arise given the assumption that all galaxies above some stellar mass limit will provide unbiased and meaning…
▽ More
This work considers the impact of resolution in the construction of mock observations of simulated galaxies. In particular, when building mock integral field spectroscopic observations from galaxy formation models in cosmological simulations, we investigate the possible systematics that may arise given the assumption that all galaxies above some stellar mass limit will provide unbiased and meaningful observable stellar kinematics. We build a catalogue of N-body simulations to sample the range of stellar particle resolutions within the EAGLE Ref0050N0752 simulation box and examine how their observable kinematics vary relative to a higher-resolution N-body control. We use these models to compile a table of the minimum number of particles-per-pixel to reach a given uncertainty in the fitted line-of-sight velocity distribution parameters. Further, we introduce a Voronoi-binning module to the mock observation code, SimSpin, in order to meet these minimum numbers. Using EAGLE, we show the impact of this shot noise on the observed spin-ellipticity plane and the recovery of this space when observations are binned with increasing numbers of particles. In conclusion, we advise binning mock images to meet at least 200 particles-per-pixel to avoid systematically under-estimating the velocity dispersion along a given line-of-sight. We demonstrate that this is important for comparing galaxies extracted from the same simulation, as well as between simulations of varying mass resolution and observations of real galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2024;
originally announced November 2024.
-
The formation histories of massive and quiescent galaxies in the 3 < z < 4.5 Universe
Authors:
Themiya Nanayakkara,
Karl Glazebrook,
Corentin Schreiber,
Harry Chittenden,
Gabriel Brammer,
James Esdaile,
Colin Jacobs,
Glenn G. Kacprzak,
Lalitwadee Kawinwanichakij,
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Ivo Labbe,
Claudia Lagos,
Danilo Marchesini,
M. Martìnez-Marìn,
Z. Cemile Marsan,
Pascal A. Oesch,
Casey Papovich,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Kim-Vy H. Tran
Abstract:
We present the formation histories of 19 massive ($>3X10^{10}M_\odot$) quiescent (sSFR$<0.15Gyr^{-1}$) galaxy candidates at z~3.0-4.5 observed using JWST/NIRSpec. This completes the spectroscopic confirmation of the 24 K-selected quiescent galaxy sample from the ZFOURGE and 3DHST surveys (Schreiber et al. 2018a). Utilizing Prism $1-5μm$ spectroscopy, we confirm that all 12 sources that eluded conf…
▽ More
We present the formation histories of 19 massive ($>3X10^{10}M_\odot$) quiescent (sSFR$<0.15Gyr^{-1}$) galaxy candidates at z~3.0-4.5 observed using JWST/NIRSpec. This completes the spectroscopic confirmation of the 24 K-selected quiescent galaxy sample from the ZFOURGE and 3DHST surveys (Schreiber et al. 2018a). Utilizing Prism $1-5μm$ spectroscopy, we confirm that all 12 sources that eluded confirmation by ground-based spectroscopy lie at z>3, resulting in a spectroscopically confirmed number density of $\sim1.4X10^{-5}Mpc^{-3}$ between $z\sim3-4$. Rest-frame U-V vs V-J color selections show high effectiveness in identifying quiescent galaxies, with a purity of~90%. Our analysis shows that parametric star-formation histories (SFHs) from FAST++ and binned SFHs from Prospector on average yield consistent results, revealing diverse formation and quenching times. The oldest galaxy formed $~6X10^{10}M_\odot$ by $z\sim10$ and has been quiescent for over 1 Gyr at z~3.2. We detect two galaxies with ongoing star formation and six with active galactic nuclei (AGN). We demonstrate that the choice of stellar population models, stellar libraries, and nebular or AGN contributions does not significantly affect the derived average SFHs of the galaxies. We demonstrate that extending spectral fitting beyond the rest-frame optical regime reduces the inferred average star formation rates in the earliest time bins of the SFH reconstruction. The assumed SFH prior influences the star formation rate at early times, where spectral diagnostic power is limited. Simulated z~3 quiescent galaxies from IllustrisTNG, SHARK, and Magneticum broadly match the average SFHs of the observed sample but struggle to capture the full diversity, particularly at early stages. Our results emphasize the need for mechanisms that rapidly build stellar mass and quench star formation within the first billion years of the Universe.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2025; v1 submitted 2 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Characterising Tidal Features Around Galaxies in Cosmological Simulations
Authors:
Aman Khalid,
Sarah Brough,
Garreth Martin,
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Claudia Del P. Lagos,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Cristina Martinez-Lombilla
Abstract:
Tidal features provide signatures of recent mergers and offer a unique insight into the assembly history of galaxies. The Vera C. Rubin Observatory's Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) will enable an unprecedentedly large survey of tidal features around millions of galaxies. To decipher the contributions of mergers to galaxy evolution it will be necessary to compare the observed tidal features…
▽ More
Tidal features provide signatures of recent mergers and offer a unique insight into the assembly history of galaxies. The Vera C. Rubin Observatory's Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) will enable an unprecedentedly large survey of tidal features around millions of galaxies. To decipher the contributions of mergers to galaxy evolution it will be necessary to compare the observed tidal features with theoretical predictions. Therefore, we use cosmological hydrodynamical simulations NewHorizon, EAGLE, IllustrisTNG, and Magneticum to produce LSST-like mock images of $z\sim0$ galaxies ($z\sim0.2$ for NewHorizon) with $M_{\scriptstyle\star,\text{ 30 pkpc}}\geq10^{9.5}$ M$_{\scriptstyle\odot}$. We perform a visual classification to identify tidal features and classify their morphology. We find broadly good agreement between the simulations regarding their overall tidal feature fractions: $f_{\text{NewHorizon}}=0.40\pm0.06$, $f_{\text{EAGLE}}=0.37\pm0.01$, $f_{\text{TNG}}=0.32\pm0.01$ and $f_{\text{Magneticum}}=0.32\pm0.01$, and their specific tidal feature fractions. Furthermore, we find excellent agreement regarding the trends of tidal feature fraction with stellar and halo mass. All simulations agree in predicting that the majority of central galaxies of groups and clusters exhibit at least one tidal feature, while the satellite members rarely show such features. This agreement suggests that gravity is the primary driver of the occurrence of visually-identifiable tidal features in cosmological simulations, rather than subgrid physics or hydrodynamics. All predictions can be verified directly with LSST observations.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
The SRG/eROSITA All-Sky Survey: Dark Energy Survey Year 3 Weak Gravitational Lensing by eRASS1 selected Galaxy Clusters
Authors:
S. Grandis,
V. Ghirardini,
S. Bocquet,
C. Garrel,
J. J. Mohr,
A. Liu,
M. Kluge,
L. Kimmig,
T. H. Reiprich,
A. Alarcon,
A. Amon,
E. Artis,
Y. E. Bahar,
F. Balzer,
K. Bechtol,
M. R. Becker,
G. Bernstein,
E. Bulbul,
A. Campos,
A. Carnero Rosell,
M. Carrasco Kind,
R. Cawthon,
C. Chang,
R. Chen,
I. Chiu
, et al. (97 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Number counts of galaxy clusters across redshift are a powerful cosmological probe, if a precise and accurate reconstruction of the underlying mass distribution is performed -- a challenge called mass calibration. With the advent of wide and deep photometric surveys, weak gravitational lensing by clusters has become the method of choice to perform this measurement. We measure and validate the weak…
▽ More
Number counts of galaxy clusters across redshift are a powerful cosmological probe, if a precise and accurate reconstruction of the underlying mass distribution is performed -- a challenge called mass calibration. With the advent of wide and deep photometric surveys, weak gravitational lensing by clusters has become the method of choice to perform this measurement. We measure and validate the weak gravitational lensing (WL) signature in the shape of galaxies observed in the first 3 years of the DES Y3 caused by galaxy clusters selected in the first all-sky survey performed by SRG/eROSITA. These data are then used to determine the scaling between X-ray photon count rate of the clusters and their halo mass and redshift. We empirically determine the degree of cluster member contamination in our background source sample. The individual cluster shear profiles are then analysed with a Bayesian population model that self-consistently accounts for the lens sample selection and contamination, and includes marginalization over a host of instrumental and astrophysical systematics. To quantify the accuracy of the mass extraction of that model, we perform mass measurements on mock cluster catalogs with realistic synthetic shear profiles. This allows us to establish that hydro-dynamical modelling uncertainties at low lens redshifts ($z<0.6$) are the dominant systematic limitation. At high lens redshift the uncertainties of the sources' photometric redshift calibration dominate. With regard to the X-ray count rate to halo mass relation, we constrain all its parameters. This work sets the stage for a joint analysis with the number counts of eRASS1 clusters to constrain a host of cosmological parameters. We demonstrate that WL mass calibration of galaxy clusters can be performed successfully with source galaxies whose calibration was performed primarily for cosmic shear experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Preparing for low surface brightness science with the Vera C. Rubin Observatory: A Comparison of Observable and Simulated Intracluster Light Fractions
Authors:
Sarah Brough,
Syeda Lammim Ahad,
Yannick M. Bahe,
Amaël Ellien,
Anthony H. Gonzalez,
Yolanda Jiménez-Teja,
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Garreth Martin,
Cristina Martínez-Lombilla,
Mireia Montes,
Annalisa Pillepich,
Rossella Ragusa,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Chris A. Collins,
Johan H. Knapen,
J. Chris Mihos
Abstract:
Intracluster Light (ICL) provides an important record of the interactions galaxy clusters have undergone. However, we are limited in our understanding by our measurement methods. To address this we measure the fraction of cluster light that is held in the Brightest Cluster Galaxy and ICL (BCG+ICL fraction) and the ICL alone (ICL fraction) using observational methods (Surface Brightness Threshold-S…
▽ More
Intracluster Light (ICL) provides an important record of the interactions galaxy clusters have undergone. However, we are limited in our understanding by our measurement methods. To address this we measure the fraction of cluster light that is held in the Brightest Cluster Galaxy and ICL (BCG+ICL fraction) and the ICL alone (ICL fraction) using observational methods (Surface Brightness Threshold-SB, Non-Parametric Measure-NP, Composite Models-CM, Multi-Galaxy Fitting-MGF) and new approaches under development (Wavelet Decomposition-WD) applied to mock images of 61 galaxy clusters (14<log10 M_200c/M_solar <14.5) from four cosmological hydrodynamical simulations. We compare the BCG+ICL and ICL fractions from observational measures with those using simulated measures (aperture and kinematic separations). The ICL fractions measured by kinematic separation are significantly larger than observed fractions. We find the measurements are related and provide equations to estimate kinematic ICL fractions from observed fractions. The different observational techniques give consistent BCG+ICL and ICL fractions but are biased to underestimating the BCG+ICL and ICL fractions when compared with aperture simulation measures. Comparing the different methods and algorithms we find that the MGF algorithm is most consistent with the simulations, and CM and SB methods show the smallest projection effects for the BCG+ICL and ICL fractions respectively. The Ahad (CM), MGF and WD algorithms are best set up to process larger samples, however, the WD algorithm in its current form is susceptible to projection effects. We recommend that new algorithms using these methods are explored to analyse the massive samples that Rubin Observatory's Legacy Survey of Space and Time will provide.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Relight the Candle: What happens to High Redshift Massive Quenched Galaxies
Authors:
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Lucas C. Kimmig
Abstract:
A puzzling population of extremely massive quiescent galaxies at redshifts beyond z=3 has recently been revealed by JWST and ALMA, some of them with stellar ages that show their quenching times to be as high as z=6, while their stellar masses are already above 5e10Msun. These extremely massive yet quenched galaxies challenge our understanding of galaxy formation at the earliest stages. Using the h…
▽ More
A puzzling population of extremely massive quiescent galaxies at redshifts beyond z=3 has recently been revealed by JWST and ALMA, some of them with stellar ages that show their quenching times to be as high as z=6, while their stellar masses are already above 5e10Msun. These extremely massive yet quenched galaxies challenge our understanding of galaxy formation at the earliest stages. Using the hydrodynamical cosmological simulation suite Magneticum Pathfinder, we show that such massive quenched galaxies at high redshifts can be successfully reproduced with similar number densities as observed. The stellar masses, sizes, formation redshifts, and star formation histories of the simulated quenched galaxies match those determined with JWST. Following these quenched galaxies at z=3.4 forward in time, we find 20% to be accreted onto a more massive structure by z=2, and from the remaining 80% about 30% rejuvenate up to z=2, another 30% stay quenched, and the remaining 40% rejuvenated on a very low level of star formation. Stars formed through rejuvenation are mostly formed on the outer regions of the galaxies, not in the centres. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the massive quenched galaxies do not reside in the most massive nodes of the cosmic web, but rather live in side-nodes of approximately Milky-Way halo mass. Even at z=0, only about 10% end up in small-mass galaxy clusters, while most of the quenched galaxies at z=3.4 end up in group-mass halos, with about 20% actually not even reaching 1e13Msun in halo mass.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Blowing out the Candle: How to Quench Galaxies at High Redshift -- an Ensemble of Rapid Starbursts, AGN Feedback and Environment
Authors:
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Benjamin Seidel,
Lucas M. Valenzuela,
Klaus Dolag,
Andreas Burkert
Abstract:
Recent observations with JWST and ALMA have revealed extremely massive quiescent galaxies at redshifts of z=3 and higher, indicating both rapid onset and quenching of star formation. Using the cosmological simulation suite Magneticum Pathfinder we reproduce the observed number densities and stellar masses, with 36 quenched galaxies of stellar mass larger than 3e10Msun at z=3.42. We find that these…
▽ More
Recent observations with JWST and ALMA have revealed extremely massive quiescent galaxies at redshifts of z=3 and higher, indicating both rapid onset and quenching of star formation. Using the cosmological simulation suite Magneticum Pathfinder we reproduce the observed number densities and stellar masses, with 36 quenched galaxies of stellar mass larger than 3e10Msun at z=3.42. We find that these galaxies are quenched through a rapid burst of star-formation and subsequent AGN feedback caused by a particularly isotropic collapse of surrounding gas, occurring on timescales of around 200Myr or shorter. The resulting quenched galaxies host stellar components which are kinematically fast rotating and alpha-enhanced, while exhibiting a steeper metallicity and flatter age gradient compared to galaxies of similar stellar mass. The gas of the galaxies has been metal enriched and ejected. We find that quenched galaxies do not inhabit the densest nodes, but rather sit in local underdensities. We analyze observable metrics to predict future quenching at high redshifts, finding that on shorter timescales <500Myr the ratio M_bh/M_* is the best predictor, followed by the burstiness of the preceding star-formation, t50-t90 (time to go from 50% to 90% stellar mass). On longer timescales, >1Gyr, the environment becomes the strongest predictor, followed by t50-t90, indicating that at high redshifts the consumption of old and lack of new gas are more relevant for long-term prevention of star-formation than the presence of a massive AGN. We predict that relics of such high-z quenched galaxies should best be characterized by a strong alpha enhancement.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
On the Decline of Star Formation during the Evolution of Galaxies
Authors:
Adelheid Teklu,
Rolf-Peter Kudritzki,
Klaus Dolag,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Lucas Kimmig
Abstract:
Cosmological simulations predict that during the evolution of galaxies, the specific star formation rate continuously decreases. In a previous study we showed that generally this is not caused by the galaxies running out of cold gas but rather a decrease in the fraction of gas capable of forming stars. To investigate the origin of this behavior, we use disk galaxies selected from the cosmological…
▽ More
Cosmological simulations predict that during the evolution of galaxies, the specific star formation rate continuously decreases. In a previous study we showed that generally this is not caused by the galaxies running out of cold gas but rather a decrease in the fraction of gas capable of forming stars. To investigate the origin of this behavior, we use disk galaxies selected from the cosmological hydrodynamical simulation Magneticum Pathfinder and follow their evolution in time. We find that the mean density of the cold gas regions decreases with time. This is caused by the fact that during the evolution of the galaxies, the star-forming regions move to larger galactic radii, where the gas density is lower. This supports the idea of inside-out growth of disk galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The Hateful Eight: Connecting Massive Substructures in Galaxy Clusters like Abell 2744 to their Dynamical Assembly State using the Magneticum Simulations
Authors:
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Klaus Dolag,
Veronica Biffi
Abstract:
Substructures are known to be good tracers for the dynamical states and recent accretion histories of the most massive collapsed structures in the Universe, galaxy clusters. Observations find extremely massive substructures in some clusters, especially Abell 2744, which are potentially in tension with the $Λ$CDM paradigm since they are not found in simulations directly. However, the methods to mea…
▽ More
Substructures are known to be good tracers for the dynamical states and recent accretion histories of the most massive collapsed structures in the Universe, galaxy clusters. Observations find extremely massive substructures in some clusters, especially Abell 2744, which are potentially in tension with the $Λ$CDM paradigm since they are not found in simulations directly. However, the methods to measure substructure masses strongly differ between observations and simulations. Using the fully hydrodynamical cosmological simulation suite Magneticum Pathfinder we develop a method to measure substructure masses in projection from simulations, similar to the observational approach. We identify a simulated Abell 2744 counterpart that not only has eight substructures of similar mass fractions but also exhibits similar features in the hot gas component. This cluster formed only recently through a major merger together with at least 6 massive minor merger events since z=1, where prior the most massive component had a mass of less than $1\times10^{14}M_\odot$. We show that the mass fraction of all substructures and of the eighth substructure separately are excellent tracers for the dynamical state and assembly history for all galaxy cluster mass ranges, with high fractions indicating merger events within the last 2Gyr. Finally, we demonstrate that the differences between subhalo masses measured directly from simulations as bound and those measured in projection are due to methodology, with the latter generally 2-3 times larger than the former. We provide a predictor function to estimate projected substructure masses from SubFind masses for future comparison studies between simulations and observations.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Planes of Satellite Galaxies in the Magneticum Pathfinder Simulations
Authors:
Pascal U. Förster,
Rhea-Silvia Remus,
Klaus Dolag,
Lucas C. Kimmig,
Adelheid Teklu,
Lucas M. Valenzuela
Abstract:
Planes of satellites are observed around many galaxies. However, these observations are still considered a point of tension for the $Λ$CDM paradigm. We use the fully hydrodynamical cosmological $Λ$CDM state-of-the-art simulation Magneticum Pathfinder to investigate the existence of such planes over a large range of haloes, from Milky Way to galaxy cluster masses. To this end, we develop the Moment…
▽ More
Planes of satellites are observed around many galaxies. However, these observations are still considered a point of tension for the $Λ$CDM paradigm. We use the fully hydrodynamical cosmological $Λ$CDM state-of-the-art simulation Magneticum Pathfinder to investigate the existence of such planes over a large range of haloes, from Milky Way to galaxy cluster masses. To this end, we develop the Momentum in Thinnest Plane (MTP) method to identify planes and quantify the properties of their constituent satellites, considering both position and momentum. We find that thin planes ($20\%\cdot R_\mathrm{halo}$) containing at least $50\%$ of the total number of satellites can be found in almost all systems. In Milky Way mass-like systems, around 86\% of such planes are even aligned in momentum ($90\%$ of the total satellite momentum), where the fraction is smaller if more satellites are required to be inside the plane. We further find a mass dependency, with more massive systems exhibiting systematically thicker planes. This may point towards the change from continuous accretion of small objects along filaments and sheets for less massive haloes to the accretion of large objects (e.g., major mergers) dominating the growth of more massive haloes. There is no correlation between the existence of a plane and the main galaxy's morphology. Finally, we find a clear preference for the minor axes of the satellite planes and the host galaxy to be aligned, in agreement with recent observations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
