-
Large Scale Power Spectrum from Peculiar Velocities Via Likelihood Analysis
Authors:
S. Zaroubi,
A. Dekel,
Y. Hoffman,
T. Kolatt
Abstract:
The power spectrum (PS) of {\it mass} density fluctuations, independent of ``biasing", is estimated from the Mark3 Catalog of Peculiar Velocities of galaxies using Bayesian statistics. A parametric model is assumed for the PS, and the free parameters are determined by maximizing the posterior probability of the model given the data. The method has been tested using detailed mock catalogs. We use…
▽ More
The power spectrum (PS) of {\it mass} density fluctuations, independent of ``biasing", is estimated from the Mark3 Catalog of Peculiar Velocities of galaxies using Bayesian statistics. A parametric model is assumed for the PS, and the free parameters are determined by maximizing the posterior probability of the model given the data. The method has been tested using detailed mock catalogs. We use generalized CDM models with and without COBE normalization.
The robust result for all the models tested is $P(k) Ω^{1.2} = (4.1 \pm 0.7)x10^3 (Mpc h^{-1})^3$ at $k=0.1 h Mpc^{-1}$, with the peak constrained to the range $0.03 < k < 0.06 h Mpc^{-1}$. It is consistent with a direct computation of the PS (Kolatt \& Dekel 1996). When compared to galaxy-density surveys, the implied values for $β$ ($\equiv Ω^{0.6}/b$) are of order unity to within 25\%.
A $Γ$-shape model, free of COBE normalization, is constrained by the velocity data to $Γ=0.5\pm 0.15$ and $σ_8 Ω^{0.6}=0.85\pm 0.1$. Within the family of COBE-normalized CDM models, the best tilted model ($Ω=1$, $n \approx 0.84 h_{50}^{-0.65}$) and the best open model ($n=1$, $Ω\approx 0.75 h_{50}^{-1.0}$) are more likely than the best $Λ$ model ($n=1$, $Λ=1-Ω$, $Ω\approx 0.70 h_{50}^{-1.2}$). The most likely CDM model with $Ω\leq 1$ is found to be of $Ω=1$, $h\approx 0.75$, and a {\it tilted} spectrum of $n= 0.8\pm 0.02$ with tensor fluctuations.The tightest constraint for the tilted-$Λ$ models is of the sort $Ωh_{50}^{1.2} n^ν= 0.7 \pm 0.08$, with $ν=3.8$ and $1.85$ with and without tensor fluctuations respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 1996;
originally announced March 1996.
-
The Wiener-Filtered COBE DMR Data and Predictions for the Tenerife Experiment
Authors:
Emory F. Bunn,
Yehuda Hoffman,
Joseph Silk
Abstract:
We apply a Wiener filter to the two-year COBE DMR data. The resulting sky map has significantly reduced noise levels compared to the raw data: the most prominent hot and cold spots are significant at the 4-sigma level. Furthermore, the entire covariance matrix of the errors in the filtered sky map is known, and it is therefore possible to make constrained realizations of the microwave sky with t…
▽ More
We apply a Wiener filter to the two-year COBE DMR data. The resulting sky map has significantly reduced noise levels compared to the raw data: the most prominent hot and cold spots are significant at the 4-sigma level. Furthermore, the entire covariance matrix of the errors in the filtered sky map is known, and it is therefore possible to make constrained realizations of the microwave sky with the correct a posteriori probability distribution. The filtered DMR sky map is used to make predictions for the Tenerife experiment. Two prominent features are predicted in a region of the sky not yet analyzed by the Tenerife group. The presence of these features is a robust prediction of the standard cosmological paradigm; if these features are not observed, some of our fundamental assumptions must be incorrect.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 1995;
originally announced September 1995.
-
Non-linear Reconstruction of the Large Scale Structure
Authors:
V. Bistolas,
Y. Hoffman
Abstract:
The linear algorithm of the the full non-linear large scale structure of Gaussian random fields is extended here to to perform non-linear CRs. The procedure consists of: (1) Using linear CR of low resolution data to construct a high resolution realization of the underlying field, as if the linear theory is valid; (2) Taking the linear CR backwards in time, by the linear theory, to set initial co…
▽ More
The linear algorithm of the the full non-linear large scale structure of Gaussian random fields is extended here to to perform non-linear CRs. The procedure consists of: (1) Using linear CR of low resolution data to construct a high resolution realization of the underlying field, as if the linear theory is valid; (2) Taking the linear CR backwards in time, by the linear theory, to set initial conditions for an N-body simulation; (3) Forwarding the field in time by an N-body code. An intermediate step might be introduced to `linearize' the low resolution data.
The non-linear CR can be applied to any observational data set that is linearly related to the underlying field. Here it is applied to the IRAS 1.2Jy catalog using 843 data points within a sphere of $6000 Km/s$, to reconstruct the full non-linear large scale structure of our `local' universe.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 1995; v1 submitted 22 July, 1995;
originally announced July 1995.
-
Secondary Infall: Theory {\it Versus} Simulations
Authors:
Saleem Zaroubi,
Avi Naim,
Yehuda Hoffman
Abstract:
The applicability of the highly idealized secondary infall model to `realistic' initial conditions is investigated. The collapse of proto-halos seeded by $3σ$ density perturbations to an Einstein--de Sitter universe is studied here for a variety of scale-free power spectra with spectral indices ranging from $n=1$ to $-2$. Initial conditions are set by the constrained realization algorithm and th…
▽ More
The applicability of the highly idealized secondary infall model to `realistic' initial conditions is investigated. The collapse of proto-halos seeded by $3σ$ density perturbations to an Einstein--de Sitter universe is studied here for a variety of scale-free power spectra with spectral indices ranging from $n=1$ to $-2$. Initial conditions are set by the constrained realization algorithm and the dynamical evolution is calculated both analytically and numerically. The analytic calculation is based on the simple secondary infall model where spherical symmetry is assumed. A full numerical simulation is performed by a Tree N-body code where no symmetry is assumed. A hybrid calculation has been performed by using a monopole term code, where no symmetry is imposed on the particles but the force is approximated by the monopole term only. The main purpose of using such code is to suppress off-center mergers. In all cases studied here the rotation curves calculated by the two numerical codes are in agreement over most of the mass of the halos, excluding the very inner region, and these are compared with the analytically calculated ones. The main result obtained here, reinforces the foundings of many N-body experements, is that the collapse proceeds 'gently' and not {\it via} violent relaxation. There is a strong correlation of the final energy of individual particles with the initial one. In particular we find a preservation of the ranking of particles according to their binding energy. In cases where the analytic model predicts non-increasing rotation curves its predictions are confirmed by the simulations. Otherwise, sensitive dependence on initial conditions is found and the analytic model fails completely.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 1995;
originally announced July 1995.
-
Wiener Reconstruction of The Large Scale Structure
Authors:
S. Zaroubi,
Y. Hoffman,
K. B. Fisher,
O. Lahav
Abstract:
The formalism of Wiener filtering is developed here for the purpose of reconstructing the large scale structure of the universe from noisy, sparse and incomplete data. The method is based on a linear minimum variance solution, given data and an assumed \prior model which specifies the covariance matrix of the field to be reconstructed. While earlier applications of the Wiener filter have focused…
▽ More
The formalism of Wiener filtering is developed here for the purpose of reconstructing the large scale structure of the universe from noisy, sparse and incomplete data. The method is based on a linear minimum variance solution, given data and an assumed \prior model which specifies the covariance matrix of the field to be reconstructed. While earlier applications of the Wiener filter have focused on estimation, namely suppressing the noise in the measured quantities, we extend the method here to perform both prediction and dynamical reconstruction. The Wiener filter is used to predict the values of unmeasured quantities, such as the density field in un-sampled regions of space, or to deconvolve blurred data. The method is developed, within the context of linear gravitational instability theory, to perform dynamical reconstruction of one field which is dynamically related to some other observed field. This is the case, for example, in the reconstruction of the real space galaxy distribution from its redshift distribution When the field to be reconstructed is a Gaussian random field, such as the primordial perturbation field predicted by the canonical model of cosmology, the Wiener filter can be pushed to its fullest potential. In such a case the Wiener estimator coincides with the Bayesian estimator designed to maximize the {\it posterior} probability. The Wiener filter can be also derived by assuming a quadratic regularization function, in analogy with the `Maximum Entropy' method. The mean field obtained by the minimal variance solution can be supplemented with constrained realizations of the Gaussian field to
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 1994;
originally announced October 1994.
-
Wiener Reconstruction of Density, Velocity, and Potential Fields from All-Sky Galaxy Redshift Surveys
Authors:
Karl Fisher,
Ofer Lahav,
Yehuda Hoffman,
Donald Lynden-Bell,
Saleem Zaroubi
Abstract:
We present a new method for recovering the cosmological density, velocity, and potential fields from all-sky redshift catalogues. The method is based on an expansion of the fields in orthogonal radial (Bessel) and angular (spherical harmonic) functions. In this coordinate system, peculiar velocities introduce a coupling of the radial harmonics describing the density field in redshift space but l…
▽ More
We present a new method for recovering the cosmological density, velocity, and potential fields from all-sky redshift catalogues. The method is based on an expansion of the fields in orthogonal radial (Bessel) and angular (spherical harmonic) functions. In this coordinate system, peculiar velocities introduce a coupling of the radial harmonics describing the density field in redshift space but leave the angular modes unaffected. In the harmonic transform space, this radial coupling is described by a distortion matrix which can be computed analytically within the context of linear theory; the redshift space harmonics can then be converted to their real space values by inversion of this matrix. Statistical noise is mitigated by regularizing the matrix inversion with a Wiener filter. The method yields a minimum variance estimate of the density field in real space. In this coordinate system, the minimum variance harmonics of the peculiar velocity and potential fields are related to those of the density field by simple linear transformations. Tests of the method with simulations of a CDM universe and comparison with previously proposed methods demonstrate it to be a very promising new reconstruction method for the local density and velocity field. A first application to the 1.2 Jy IRAS redshift survey is presented.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 1994;
originally announced June 1994.
-
Wiener Filtering of the COBE DMR Data
Authors:
Emory F. Bunn,
Karl B. Fisher,
Yehuda Hoffman,
Ofer Lahav,
Joseph Silk,
Saleem Zaroubi
Abstract:
We derive an optimal linear filter to suppress the noise from the COBE DMR sky maps for a given power spectrum. We then apply the filter to the first-year DMR data, after removing pixels within $20^\circ$ of the Galactic plane from the data. The filtered data have uncertainties 12 times smaller than the noise level of the raw data. We use the formalism of constrained realizations of Gaussian ran…
▽ More
We derive an optimal linear filter to suppress the noise from the COBE DMR sky maps for a given power spectrum. We then apply the filter to the first-year DMR data, after removing pixels within $20^\circ$ of the Galactic plane from the data. The filtered data have uncertainties 12 times smaller than the noise level of the raw data. We use the formalism of constrained realizations of Gaussian random fields to assess the uncertainty in the filtered sky maps. In addition to improving the signal-to-noise ratio of the map as a whole, these techniques allow us to recover some information about the CMB anisotropy in the missing Galactic plane region. From these maps we are able to determine which hot and cold spots in the data are statistically significant, and which may have been produced by noise. In addition, the filtered maps can be used for comparison with other experiments on similar angular scales.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 1994;
originally announced April 1994.
-
Wiener Reconstruction of Galaxy Surveys in Spherical Harmonics
Authors:
O. Lahav,
K. B. Fisher,
Y. Hoffman,
C. A. Scharf,
S. Zaroubi
Abstract:
The analysis of whole-sky galaxy surveys commonly suffers from the problems of shot-noise and incomplete sky coverage (e.g. at the Zone of Avoidance). The orthogonal set of spherical harmonics is utilized here to expand the observed galaxy distribution. We show that in the framework of Bayesian statistics and Gaussian random fields the $4 π$ harmonics can be recovered and the shot-noise can be r…
▽ More
The analysis of whole-sky galaxy surveys commonly suffers from the problems of shot-noise and incomplete sky coverage (e.g. at the Zone of Avoidance). The orthogonal set of spherical harmonics is utilized here to expand the observed galaxy distribution. We show that in the framework of Bayesian statistics and Gaussian random fields the $4 π$ harmonics can be recovered and the shot-noise can be removed, giving the most probable picture of the underlying density field. The correction factor from observed to reconstructed harmonics turns out to be the well-known Wiener filter (the ratio of signal to signal+noise), which is also derived by requiring minimum variance. We apply the method to the projected 1.2 Jy IRAS survey. The reconstruction confirms the connectivity of the Supergalactic Plane across the Galactic Plane (at Galactic longitude $l \sim 135^o$ and $l \sim 315^o$) and the Puppis cluster behind the Galactic Plane ($ l \sim 240^o$). The method can be extended to 3-D in both real and redshift space, and applied to other cosmic phenomena such as the COBE Microwave Background maps.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 1993;
originally announced November 1993.
-
Reconstruction of the Large Scale Structure
Authors:
Y. Hoffman
Abstract:
The large scale structure of the universe is reconstructed by means of the Wiener filter and constrained realizations of Gaussian fields. The density field constructed from optically selected galaxies (Hudson \cite{Hudson}) has been sampled out to a distance of $80\hmpc$. This data set is used for the reconstruction of the underlying primordial perturbation field. A preliminary reconstruction an…
▽ More
The large scale structure of the universe is reconstructed by means of the Wiener filter and constrained realizations of Gaussian fields. The density field constructed from optically selected galaxies (Hudson \cite{Hudson}) has been sampled out to a distance of $80\hmpc$. This data set is used for the reconstruction of the underlying primordial perturbation field. A preliminary reconstruction analysis from the IRAS $1.9Jy$ density field is presented here for the sake of comparison. The perturbation field within a cube of $160\hmpc$ on the side, centered on the Local Group, and with Gaussian smoothing of length $10\hmpc$ is reconstructed, assuming the standard CDM model. In particular, the density field at the Zone of Avoidance is studied. A preliminary maximum likelihood analysis performed on Hudson's data shows that it is consistent with a tilted CDM with $n\sim -0.5\pm 0.3$ and $σ_8\sim 1.4\pm 0.15$
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 1993;
originally announced November 1993.
-
Clustering in Redshift Space: Linear Theory
Authors:
Saleem Zaroubi,
Yehuda Hoffman
Abstract:
The clustering in redshift space is studied here to first order within the framework of gravitational instability. The distortion introduced by the peculiar velocities of galaxies results in anisotropy in the galaxy distribution and mode-mode coupling when analyzed in Fourier space. An exact linear calculation of the full covariance matrix in both the real and Fourier space is presented here. Th…
▽ More
The clustering in redshift space is studied here to first order within the framework of gravitational instability. The distortion introduced by the peculiar velocities of galaxies results in anisotropy in the galaxy distribution and mode-mode coupling when analyzed in Fourier space. An exact linear calculation of the full covariance matrix in both the real and Fourier space is presented here. The explicit dependence on $\Omeg$ and the biasing parameter is calculated and its potential use as a probe of these parameters is analyzed. It is shown that Kaiser's formalism can be applied only to a data set that subtends a small solid angle on the sky, and therefore cannot be used in the case of all sky surveys. The covariance matrix in the real space is calculated explicitly for {\it CDM} model, where the behavior along and perpendicular to the line of sight is shown.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 1994; v1 submitted 3 November, 1993;
originally announced November 1993.
