-
State-wise Economic Viability of Long-Duration Energy Storage Systems in the United States
Authors:
Alexandre Moreira,
Patricia Silva,
Miguel Heleno,
Andre Marcato
Abstract:
Long-duration energy storage (LDES) assets can be fundamental resources for the next-generation power systems. However, LDES technologies are still immature and their future technology costs remain highly uncertain. In this context, we perform in this paper an extensive study to estimate the maximum LDES technology costs (which we define as viability costs) under which LDES systems would be econom…
▽ More
Long-duration energy storage (LDES) assets can be fundamental resources for the next-generation power systems. However, LDES technologies are still immature and their future technology costs remain highly uncertain. In this context, we perform in this paper an extensive study to estimate the maximum LDES technology costs (which we define as viability costs) under which LDES systems would be economically viable in each state of the contiguous U.S. according to their characteristics. Our results indicate that only 4 states (out of 48) would be able to remove firm conventional generation supported by LDES systems without increasing their total system costs under the current US-DOE cost target of 1,100 US$/kW for multi-day LDES. In addition, we find that states with the highest LDES viability costs have in general low participation of thermal generation, a high share of wind generation, and higher thermal-related fixed operation and maintenance (FO&M) costs.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
Selecting Critical Scenarios of DER Adoption in Distribution Grids Using Bayesian Optimization
Authors:
Olivier Mulkin,
Miguel Heleno,
Mike Ludkovski
Abstract:
We develop a new methodology to select scenarios of DER adoption most critical for distribution grids. Anticipating risks of future voltage and line flow violations due to additional PV adopters is central for utility investment planning but continues to rely on deterministic or ad hoc scenario selection. We propose a highly efficient search framework based on multi-objective Bayesian Optimization…
▽ More
We develop a new methodology to select scenarios of DER adoption most critical for distribution grids. Anticipating risks of future voltage and line flow violations due to additional PV adopters is central for utility investment planning but continues to rely on deterministic or ad hoc scenario selection. We propose a highly efficient search framework based on multi-objective Bayesian Optimization. We treat underlying grid stress metrics as computationally expensive black-box functions, approximated via Gaussian Process surrogates and design an acquisition function based on probability of scenarios being Pareto-critical across a collection of line- and bus-based violation objectives. Our approach provides a statistical guarantee and offers an order of magnitude speed-up relative to a conservative exhaustive search. Case studies on realistic feeders with 200-400 buses demonstrate the effectiveness and accuracy of our approach.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
A Modeling Framework for Equitable Deployment of Energy Storage in Disadvantaged Communities
Authors:
Miguel Heleno,
Paul Lesur,
Alexandre Moreira
Abstract:
This paper provides an analytical framework to incorporate the deployment of behind-the-meter energy storage coupled with rooftop solar, and their associated revenue streams, in the context of equitable energy policy interventions. We propose an extension to the Justice40 optimization model by adding storage and incorporating more realistic solar compensation mechanisms, such as net-billing, which…
▽ More
This paper provides an analytical framework to incorporate the deployment of behind-the-meter energy storage coupled with rooftop solar, and their associated revenue streams, in the context of equitable energy policy interventions. We propose an extension to the Justice40 optimization model by adding storage and incorporating more realistic solar compensation mechanisms, such as net-billing, which allows for temporal revenue differentiation and the economic viability of behind-the-meter energy storage devices. The extended model includes household-level PV plus storage co-deployment alongside existing interventions, such as weatherization, rooftop PV only, community solar, and community wind. From a modeling perspective, we propose a novel approximation method to represent storage operations and revenue streams without expanding the temporal dimension of model, thus maintaining its computational efficiency. The proposed model is validated using a case study in Wayne County, Michigan, involving 3,651 energy insecure households.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Decision-Dependent Uncertainty-Aware Distribution System Planning Under Wildfire Risk
Authors:
Felipe Piancó,
Alexandre Moreira,
Bruno Fanzeres,
Ruiwei Jiang,
Chaoyue Zhao,
Miguel Heleno
Abstract:
The interaction between power systems and wildfires can be dangerous and costly. Damaged structures, load shedding, and high operational costs are potential consequences when the grid is unprepared. In fact, the operation of distribution grids can be liable for the outbreak of wildfires when extreme weather conditions arise. Within this context, investment planning should consider the impact of op…
▽ More
The interaction between power systems and wildfires can be dangerous and costly. Damaged structures, load shedding, and high operational costs are potential consequences when the grid is unprepared. In fact, the operation of distribution grids can be liable for the outbreak of wildfires when extreme weather conditions arise. Within this context, investment planning should consider the impact of operational actions on the uncertainty related to wildfires that can directly affect line failure likelihood. Neglecting this can compromise the cost-benefit evaluation in planning system investments for wildfire risk. In this paper, we propose a decision-dependent uncertainty (DDU) aware methodology that provides the optimal portfolio of investments for distribution systems while considering that high power-flow levels through line segments in high-threat areas can ignite wildfires and, therefore, increase the probability of line failures. The methodology identifies the best combination of system upgrades (installation of new lines, hardening existing lines, and placement of switching devices) to provide the necessary leeway to operate the distribution system under wildfire-prone conditions. Our case study demonstrates that by modeling the DDU relationship between power flow prescriptions and line failures, investment decisions are more accurate and better prepare the grid infrastructure to deal with wildfire risk.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2024; v1 submitted 7 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Netload Range Cost Curves for a Transmission-Aware Distribution System Planning under DER Growth Uncertainty
Authors:
Samuel Cordova,
Alexandre Moreira,
Miguel Heleno
Abstract:
In the face of a substantial and uncertain growth of behind-the-meter Distributed Energy Resources (DERs), utilities and regulators are currently in the search for new network planning strategies for facilitating an efficient Transmission & Distribution (T&D) coordination. In this context, here we propose a novel distribution system planning methodology to facilitate coordinated planning exercises…
▽ More
In the face of a substantial and uncertain growth of behind-the-meter Distributed Energy Resources (DERs), utilities and regulators are currently in the search for new network planning strategies for facilitating an efficient Transmission & Distribution (T&D) coordination. In this context, here we propose a novel distribution system planning methodology to facilitate coordinated planning exercises with transmission system planners through the management of long-term DER growth uncertainty and its impact on the substation netload. The proposed approach is based on the design of a transmission-aware distribution planning model embedding DER growth uncertainty, which is used to determine a "menu" of secure distribution network upgrade options with different associated costs and peak netload guarantees observed from the transmission-side, referred here as Netload Range Cost Curves (NRCCs). NRCCs can provide a practical approach for coordinating T&D planning exercises, as these curves can be integrated into existing transmission planning workflows, and specify a direct incentive for distribution planners to evaluate peak netload reduction alternatives in their planning process. We perform computational experiments based on a realistic distribution network that demonstrate the benefits and applicability of our proposed planning approach.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Assessing Costs of Community Solar Integration via Optimal Distribution Grid Expansion
Authors:
Miguel Heleno,
Alan Valenzuela,
Alexandre Moreira,
Juan Pablo Carvallo
Abstract:
This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of distribution grid upgrades costs necessary to integrate Community Solar (CS) projects. The innovative methodology proposed for this quantification is based on incremental least-cost expansion of the distribution system, encompassing both traditional and non-traditional grid upgrade strategies. Realistic infrastructure investment costs are obtained us…
▽ More
This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of distribution grid upgrades costs necessary to integrate Community Solar (CS) projects. The innovative methodology proposed for this quantification is based on incremental least-cost expansion of the distribution system, encompassing both traditional and non-traditional grid upgrade strategies. Realistic infrastructure investment costs are obtained using a dataset of over 2,500 feeders, including various loading scenarios, and compared with empirical costs of integrating real CS projects. The results are then used to evaluate costs and deferrals from the consumers' and project developers' perspectives, assess the nature of the infrastructure upgrades and explore the potential benefits of a strategic siting of CS projects. This analysis is summarized in a set of regulatory and policy recommendations to support planning and valuation aspects related to CS.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Boundary Technology Costs for Economic Viability of Long-Duration Energy Storage Systems
Authors:
Patricia Silva,
Alexandre Moreira,
Miguel Heleno,
Andre Luis Marcato
Abstract:
The urgent need for decarbonization in the energy sector has led to an increased emphasis on the integration of renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar, into power grids. While these resources offer significant environmental benefits, they also introduce challenges related to intermittency and variability. Long-duration energy storage (LDES) technologies have emerged as a very promising s…
▽ More
The urgent need for decarbonization in the energy sector has led to an increased emphasis on the integration of renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar, into power grids. While these resources offer significant environmental benefits, they also introduce challenges related to intermittency and variability. Long-duration energy storage (LDES) technologies have emerged as a very promising solution to address these challenges by storing excess energy during periods of high generation and delivering it when demand is high or renewable resources are scarce for a sustained amount of time. This paper introduces a novel methodology for estimating the boundary technology cost of LDES systems for economic viability in decarbonized energy systems. Our methodology is applied to estimate the boundary costs in 2050 for the state of California to achieve full retirement of gas power plants. California's ambitious decarbonization goals and transition to a renewable energy-based power system present an ideal context for examining the role of LDES. The results also offer insights into the needed capacity expansion planning and the operational contribution of LDES in the California's energy landscape, taking into account the unique energy demand profiles and renewable resource availability of the region. Our findings are intended to provide complementary information to guide decision-makers, energy planners, and any other stakeholders in making informed choices about LDES investment in the context of a decarbonized energy future.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Energy Justice and Equity: A Review of Definitions, Measures, and Practice in Policy, Planning, and Operations
Authors:
Weihang Ren,
Yongpei Guan,
Feng Qiu,
Todd Levin,
Miguel Heleno
Abstract:
Energy justice, at the intersection of energy and societal ethics, studies the origins, quantification, and resolution of persistent and potential inequities within the energy sector, serving as a foundational pillar for societal harmony. In this review, we overview the historical and modern definitions of energy equity and frameworks of energy justice. We highlight the tools adopted to measure eq…
▽ More
Energy justice, at the intersection of energy and societal ethics, studies the origins, quantification, and resolution of persistent and potential inequities within the energy sector, serving as a foundational pillar for societal harmony. In this review, we overview the historical and modern definitions of energy equity and frameworks of energy justice. We highlight the tools adopted to measure equity in the energy context, unveiling multifaceted inequities that permeate global energy landscapes. We discuss the limitations of prevalent metrics such as the Gini coefficient and Generalized Entropy Indices in the evaluation of energy justice concerns. Finally, we analyze publications that examined current practices and proposed improving methods towards a more equitable energy market for the society from policy, planning, and operation perspectives.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2024; v1 submitted 21 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Distribution System Operation Amidst Wildfire-Prone Climate Conditions Under Decision-Dependent Line Availability Uncertainty
Authors:
Alexandre Moreira,
Felipe Pianco,
Bruno Fanzeres,
Alexandre Street,
Ruiwei Jiang,
Chaoyue Zhao,
Miguel Heleno
Abstract:
Wildfires can severely damage electricity grids leading to long periods of power interruption. Climate change will exacerbate this threat by increasing the frequency of dry climate conditions. Under these climate conditions, human-related actions that initiate wildfires should be avoided, including those induced by power systems operation. In this paper, we propose a novel optimization model that…
▽ More
Wildfires can severely damage electricity grids leading to long periods of power interruption. Climate change will exacerbate this threat by increasing the frequency of dry climate conditions. Under these climate conditions, human-related actions that initiate wildfires should be avoided, including those induced by power systems operation. In this paper, we propose a novel optimization model that is capable of determining appropriate network topology changes (via switching actions) to alleviate the levels of power flows through vulnerable parts of the grid so as to decrease the probability of wildfire ignition. Within this framework, the proposed model captures the relationship between failure probabilities and line-flow decisions by explicitly considering the former as a function of the latter. The resulting formulation is a two-stage model with endogenous decision-dependent probabilities, where the first stage determines the optimal switching actions and the second stage evaluates the worst-case expected operation cost. We propose an exact iterative method to deal with this intricate problem and the methodology is illustrated with a 54-bus and a 138-bus distribution system.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Evaluating Distribution System Reliability with Hyperstructures Graph Convolutional Nets
Authors:
Yuzhou Chen,
Tian Jiang,
Miguel Heleno,
Alexandre Moreira,
Yulia R. Gel
Abstract:
Nowadays, it is broadly recognized in the power system community that to meet the ever expanding energy sector's needs, it is no longer possible to rely solely on physics-based models and that reliable, timely and sustainable operation of energy systems is impossible without systematic integration of artificial intelligence (AI) tools. Nevertheless, the adoption of AI in power systems is still lim…
▽ More
Nowadays, it is broadly recognized in the power system community that to meet the ever expanding energy sector's needs, it is no longer possible to rely solely on physics-based models and that reliable, timely and sustainable operation of energy systems is impossible without systematic integration of artificial intelligence (AI) tools. Nevertheless, the adoption of AI in power systems is still limited, while integration of AI particularly into distribution grid investment planning is still an uncharted territory. We make the first step forward to bridge this gap by showing how graph convolutional networks coupled with the hyperstructures representation learning framework can be employed for accurate, reliable, and computationally efficient distribution grid planning with resilience objectives. We further propose a Hyperstructures Graph Convolutional Neural Networks (Hyper-GCNNs) to capture hidden higher order representations of distribution networks with attention mechanism. Our numerical experiments show that the proposed Hyper-GCNNs approach yields substantial gains in computational efficiency compared to the prevailing methodology in distribution grid planning and also noticeably outperforms seven state-of-the-art models from deep learning (DL) community.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
A Scalable Approach to Large Scale Risk-Averse Distribution Grid Expansion Planning
Authors:
Alexandre Moreira,
Miguel Heleno,
Alan Valenzuela,
Joseph H. Eto,
Jaime Ortega,
Cristina Botero
Abstract:
Distribution grid reliability and resilience has become a major topic of concern for utilities and their regulators. In particular, with the increase in severity of extreme events, utilities are considering major investments in distribution grid assets to mitigate the damage of highly impactful outages. Communicating the overall economic and risk-mitigation benefits of these investments to regulat…
▽ More
Distribution grid reliability and resilience has become a major topic of concern for utilities and their regulators. In particular, with the increase in severity of extreme events, utilities are considering major investments in distribution grid assets to mitigate the damage of highly impactful outages. Communicating the overall economic and risk-mitigation benefits of these investments to regulators is an important element of the approval process. Today, industry reliability and resilience planning practices are based largely on methods that do not take explicit account of risk. This paper proposes a practical method for identifying optimal combinations of investments in new line segments and storage devices while considering the balance between the risk associated with high impact low probability events and the reliability related to routine failures. We show that this method can be scaled to address large scale networks and demonstrate its benefits using a Target Feeder from the Commonwealth Edison Reliability Program.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Self-consumption for energy communities in Spain: a regional analysis under the new legal framework
Authors:
Cristobal Gallego-Castillo,
Miguel Heleno,
Marta Victoria
Abstract:
European climate polices acknowledge the role that energy communities can play in the energy transition. Self-consumption installations shared among those living in the same building are a good example of such energy communities. In this work, we perform a regional analysis of optimal self-consumption installations under the new legal framework recently passed in Spain. Results show that the optim…
▽ More
European climate polices acknowledge the role that energy communities can play in the energy transition. Self-consumption installations shared among those living in the same building are a good example of such energy communities. In this work, we perform a regional analysis of optimal self-consumption installations under the new legal framework recently passed in Spain. Results show that the optimal sizing of the installation leads to economic savings for self-consumers in all the territory, for both options with and without remuneration for energy surplus. A sensitivity analysis on technology costs revealed that batteries still require noticeably cost reductions to be cost-effective in a behind the meter self-consumption environment. In addition, solar compensation mechanisms make batteries less attractive in a scenario of low PV costs, since feeding PV surplus into the grid, yet less efficient, becomes more cost-effective. An improvement for the current energy surplus remuneration policy was proposed and analysed. It consists in the inclusion of the economic value of the avoided power losses in the remuneration.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2021; v1 submitted 11 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Bottom-up energy supply optimization of a national building stock
Authors:
Leander Kotzur,
Peter Markewitz,
Martin Robinius,
Gonçalo Cardoso,
Peter Stenzel,
Miguel Heleno,
Detlef Stolten
Abstract:
The installation and operation distributed energy resources (DER) and the electrification of the heat supply significantly changes the interaction of the residential building stock with the grid infrastructure. Evaluating the mass deployment of DER at the national level would require analyzing millions of individual buildings, entailing significant computational burden. To overcome this, this work…
▽ More
The installation and operation distributed energy resources (DER) and the electrification of the heat supply significantly changes the interaction of the residential building stock with the grid infrastructure. Evaluating the mass deployment of DER at the national level would require analyzing millions of individual buildings, entailing significant computational burden. To overcome this, this work proposes a novel bottom-up model that consists of an aggregation algorithm to create a spatially distributed set of typical residential buildings from census data. Each typical building is then optimized with a Mixed-Integer Linear Program to derive its cost optimal technology adoption and operation, determining its changing grid load in future scenarios. The model is validated for Germany, with 200 typical buildings considered to sufficiently represent the diversity of the residential building stock. In a future scenario for 2050, photovoltaic and heat pumps are predicted to be the most economically and ecologically robust supply solutions for the different building types. Nevertheless, their electricity generation and demand temporally do not match, resulting in a doubling of the peak electricity grid load in the rural areas during the winter. The urban areas can compensate this with efficient co-generation units, which are not cost-efficient in the rural areas.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.