-
The Role of Integration Cycles in Complex Langevin Simulations
Authors:
Michael W. Hansen,
Michael Mandl,
Erhard Seiler,
Dénes Sexty
Abstract:
Complex Langevin simulations are an attempt to solve the sign (or complex-action) problem encountered in various physical systems of interest. The method is based on a complexification of the underlying degrees of freedom and an evolution in an auxiliary time dimension. The complexification, however, does not come without drawbacks, the most severe of which is the infamous 'wrong convergence' prob…
▽ More
Complex Langevin simulations are an attempt to solve the sign (or complex-action) problem encountered in various physical systems of interest. The method is based on a complexification of the underlying degrees of freedom and an evolution in an auxiliary time dimension. The complexification, however, does not come without drawbacks, the most severe of which is the infamous 'wrong convergence' problem, stating that complex Langevin simulations sometimes fail to produce correct answers despite their apparent convergence. It has long been realized that wrong convergence may - in principle - be fixed by the introduction of a suitable kernel into the complex Langevin equation, such that the conventional correctness criteria are met. However, as we discuss in this work, complex Langevin results may - especially in the presence of a kernel - still be affected by unwanted so-called integration cycles of the theory spoiling them. Indeed, we confirm numerically that in the absence of boundary terms the complex Langevin results are given by a linear combination of such integration cycles, as put forward by Salcedo & Seiler. In particular, we shed light on the way different choices of kernel affect which integration cycles are being sampled in a simulation and how this knowledge can be used to ensure correct convergence in simple toy models.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2025; v1 submitted 22 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
Kernels and integration cycles in complex Langevin simulations
Authors:
Michael Mandl,
Michael W. Hansen,
Erhard Seiler,
Dénes Sexty
Abstract:
The method of complex Langevin simulations is a tool that can be used to tackle the complex-action problem encountered, for instance, in finite-density lattice quantum chromodynamics or real-time lattice field theories. The method is based on a stochastic evolution of the dynamical degrees of freedom via (complex) Langevin equations, which, however, sometimes converge to the wrong equilibrium dist…
▽ More
The method of complex Langevin simulations is a tool that can be used to tackle the complex-action problem encountered, for instance, in finite-density lattice quantum chromodynamics or real-time lattice field theories. The method is based on a stochastic evolution of the dynamical degrees of freedom via (complex) Langevin equations, which, however, sometimes converge to the wrong equilibrium distributions. While the convergence properties of the evolution can to some extent be assessed by studying so-called boundary terms, we demonstrate in this contribution that boundary terms on their own are not sufficient as a correctness criterion. Indeed, in their absence complex Langevin simulation results might still be spoiled by unwanted so-called integration cycles. In particular, we elaborate on how the introduction of a kernel into the complex Langevin equation can - in principle - be used to control which integration cycles are sampled in a simulation such that correct convergence is restored.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Testing dynamical stabilization of Complex Langevin simulations of QCD
Authors:
Michael W. Hansen,
Dénes Sexty
Abstract:
We study complex Langevin simulations of a toy model as well as QCD, supplemented with a dynamical stabilization (DS) term, which was proposed to regularize the complexified process at lower temperatures. We compare the results to reweghting from zero chemical potential to measure the bias that the inclusion of the stabilization term causes, depending on its strength. At high temperatures the stab…
▽ More
We study complex Langevin simulations of a toy model as well as QCD, supplemented with a dynamical stabilization (DS) term, which was proposed to regularize the complexified process at lower temperatures. We compare the results to reweghting from zero chemical potential to measure the bias that the inclusion of the stabilization term causes, depending on its strength. At high temperatures the stabilization term is not needed. At low temperatures (below deconfinement transition) the DS term has a beneficial stabilizing effect, but too strong DS term causes phase quenching on the system. We observed that the bias of the dynamical stabilization can be to a good accuracy removed by extrapolating to zero dynamical stabilization force using a sigmoid fit.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Complex Langevin boundary terms in full QCD
Authors:
Michael W. Hansen,
Dénes Sexty
Abstract:
Lattice simulations of non-zero density QCD introduce the so-called sign problem (complex or negative probabilities), which invalidates importance sampling methods. To circumvent this, we use the Complex Langevin Equation (CLE), to measure the boundary terms and then compare these results with the ones gotten from reweighting, confirming the expectations from previous studies. We also investigate…
▽ More
Lattice simulations of non-zero density QCD introduce the so-called sign problem (complex or negative probabilities), which invalidates importance sampling methods. To circumvent this, we use the Complex Langevin Equation (CLE), to measure the boundary terms and then compare these results with the ones gotten from reweighting, confirming the expectations from previous studies. We also investigate boundary terms in simulations using CLE with dynamic stabilization and compare this, to results calculated with reweighting.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2023; v1 submitted 22 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Complex Langevin boundary terms in lattice models
Authors:
Michael W. Hansen,
Erhard Seiler,
Dénes Sexty,
Ion-Olimipu Stamatescu
Abstract:
In complex Langevin simulations, the insufficient decay of the probability density near infinity leads to boundary terms that spoil the formal argument for correctness. We present a formulation of this term that is cheaply measurable in lattice models, and in principle allows also the direct estimation of the systematic error of the CL method. Results for a toy model, 3d XY model and HDQCD are pre…
▽ More
In complex Langevin simulations, the insufficient decay of the probability density near infinity leads to boundary terms that spoil the formal argument for correctness. We present a formulation of this term that is cheaply measurable in lattice models, and in principle allows also the direct estimation of the systematic error of the CL method. Results for a toy model, 3d XY model and HDQCD are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Inclusive rates from smeared spectral densities in the two-dimensional O(3) non-linear $σ$-model
Authors:
John Bulava,
Maxwell T. Hansen,
Michael W. Hansen,
Agostino Patella,
Nazario Tantalo
Abstract:
This work employs the spectral reconstruction approach of Ref. [1] to determine an inclusive rate in the $1+1$ dimensional O(3) non-linear $σ$-model, analogous to the QCD part of ${e}^+{e}^- \rightarrow \rm {hadrons}$. The Euclidean two-point correlation function of the conserved current $j$ is computed using Monte Carlo lattice field theory simulations for a variety of spacetime volumes and latti…
▽ More
This work employs the spectral reconstruction approach of Ref. [1] to determine an inclusive rate in the $1+1$ dimensional O(3) non-linear $σ$-model, analogous to the QCD part of ${e}^+{e}^- \rightarrow \rm {hadrons}$. The Euclidean two-point correlation function of the conserved current $j$ is computed using Monte Carlo lattice field theory simulations for a variety of spacetime volumes and lattice spacings. The spectral density of this correlator is related to the inclusive rate for $j \rightarrow {\rm X}$ in which all final states produced by the external current are summed. The ill-posed inverse problem of determining the spectral density from the correlation function is made tractable through the determination of smeared spectral densities in which the desired density is convolved with a set of known smearing kernels of finite width $ε$. The smooth energy dependence of the underlying spectral density enables a controlled $ε\to 0$ extrapolation in the inelastic region, yielding the real-time inclusive rate without reference to individual finite-volume energies or matrix elements. Systematic uncertainties due cutoff effects and residual finite-volume effects are estimated and taken into account in the final error budget. After taking the continuum limit, the results are consistent with the known analytic rate to within the combined statistical and systematic errors. Above energies where 20-particle states contribute, the overall precision is sufficient to discern the four-particle contribution to the spectral density.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Small-scale variations in the radiating surface of the GRB 011211 jet
Authors:
P. Jakobsson,
J. Hjorth,
E. Ramirez-Ruiz,
C. Kouveliotou,
K. Pedersen,
J. P. U. Fynbo,
J. Gorosabel,
D. Watson,
B. L. Jensen,
T. Grav,
M. W. Hansen,
R. Michelsen,
M. I. Andersen,
M. Weidinger,
H. Pedersen
Abstract:
We report the discovery of the afterglow of the X-ray rich, long-duration gamma-ray burst GRB 011211 and present evidence for oscillatory behaviour in its early optical light curve. The time-scale of the fluctuations, ~1 hour, is much smaller than the time of the observations, ~12 hours from the onset of the gamma-ray burst. The character and strength of the fluctuations are unprecedented and ar…
▽ More
We report the discovery of the afterglow of the X-ray rich, long-duration gamma-ray burst GRB 011211 and present evidence for oscillatory behaviour in its early optical light curve. The time-scale of the fluctuations, ~1 hour, is much smaller than the time of the observations, ~12 hours from the onset of the gamma-ray burst. The character and strength of the fluctuations are unprecedented and are inconsistent with causally connected variations in the emission of a symmetric, relativistic blast wave, i.e. flux variations which are produced uniformly throughout the shell surface are ruled out. Therefore, the wiggles are the result of spherically asymmetric density or energy variations. Additionally, there is evidence for fluctuations in the X-ray afterglow light curve. If real, the resulting difference in the observed time of the peaks of the short-term variations at X-ray and optical frequencies, would demonstrate that the energy content across the jet-emitting surface is not uniform.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2004;
originally announced January 2004.
-
The afterglow and the host galaxy of GRB 011211
Authors:
P. Jakobsson,
J. Hjorth,
J. P. U. Fynbo,
J. Gorosabel,
K. Pedersen,
I. Burud,
A. Levan,
C. Kouveliotou,
N. Tanvir,
A. Fruchter,
J. Rhoads,
T. Grav,
M. W. Hansen,
R. Michelsen,
M. I. Andersen,
B. L. Jensen,
H. Pedersen,
B. Thomsen,
M. Weidinger,
S. G. Bhargavi,
R. Cowsik,
S. B. Pandey
Abstract:
We present optical, near-infrared, and X-ray observations of the optical afterglow (OA) of the X-ray rich, long-duration gamma-ray burst GRB 011211. Hubble Space Telescope (HST) data obtained 14, 26, 32, and 59 days after the burst, show the host galaxy to have a morphology that is fairly typical of blue galaxies at high redshift. We measure its magnitude to be R = 24.95 +/- 0.11. We detect a br…
▽ More
We present optical, near-infrared, and X-ray observations of the optical afterglow (OA) of the X-ray rich, long-duration gamma-ray burst GRB 011211. Hubble Space Telescope (HST) data obtained 14, 26, 32, and 59 days after the burst, show the host galaxy to have a morphology that is fairly typical of blue galaxies at high redshift. We measure its magnitude to be R = 24.95 +/- 0.11. We detect a break in the OA R-band light curve which is naturally accounted for by a collimated outflow geometry. By fitting a broken power-law to the data we find a best fit with a break 1.56 +/- 0.02 days after the burst, a pre-break slope of alpha_1 = -0.95 +/- 0.02, and a post-break slope of alpha_2 = -2.11 +/- 0.07. The UV-optical spectral energy distribution (SED) around 14 hours after the burst is best fit with a power-law with index beta = -0.56 +/- 0.19 reddened by an SMC-like extinction law with a modest A_V = 0.08 +/- 0.08 mag. By comparison, from the XMM-Newton X-ray data at around the same time, we find a decay index of alpha_X = -1.62 +/- 0.36 and a spectral index of beta_X = -1.21 +0.10/-0.15. Interpolating between the UV-optical and X-ray implies that the cooling frequency is located close to ~10^16 Hz in the observer frame at the time of the observations. We argue, using the various temporal and spectral indices above, that the most likely afterglow model is that of a jet expanding into an external environment that has a constant mean density rather than a wind-fed density structure. We estimate the electron energy index for this burst to be p ~ 2.3.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2003;
originally announced July 2003.
