iNaturalist citizen science community during City Nature Challenge: new computational approach for analysis of user activity
Authors:
Liubov Tupikina,
Frank Schlosser,
Vadim Voskresenskii,
Katharina Kloppenborg,
Florence Lopez,
Albrecht Mariz,
Anna Mogilevskaja,
Muki Haklay,
Bastian Greshake Tzovaras
Abstract:
Analysing patterns of engagement among citizen science participants can provide important insights into the organisation and practice of individual citizen science projects. In particular, methods from statistics and network science can be used to understand different types of user behaviour and user interactions to help the further implementation and organization of community efforts. Using publi…
▽ More
Analysing patterns of engagement among citizen science participants can provide important insights into the organisation and practice of individual citizen science projects. In particular, methods from statistics and network science can be used to understand different types of user behaviour and user interactions to help the further implementation and organization of community efforts. Using publicly available data from the iNaturalist community and their yearly City Nature Challenges (CNC) from 2017-2020 as an example; we showcase computational methods to explore the spatio-temporal evolution of this citizen science community that typically interacts in a hybrid offline-online way. In particular, we investigate the user types present in the community along with their interactions, finding significant differences in usage-behavior on both the level of engagement and the types of community tasks/roles and how they interact with the network of contributors. We expect that these computational analysis strategies will be useful to gain further understanding of other citizen science communities and projects.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
Revisiting Citizen Science Through the Lens of Hybrid Intelligence
Authors:
Janet Rafner,
Miroslav Gajdacz,
Gitte Kragh,
Arthur Hjorth,
Anna Gander,
Blanka Palfi,
Aleks Berditchevskaia,
François Grey,
Kobi Gal,
Avi Segal,
Mike Walmsley,
Josh Aaron Miller,
Dominik Dellerman,
Muki Haklay,
Pietro Michelucci,
Jacob Sherson
Abstract:
Artificial Intelligence (AI) can augment and sometimes even replace human cognition. Inspired by efforts to value human agency alongside productivity, we discuss the benefits of solving Citizen Science (CS) tasks with Hybrid Intelligence (HI), a synergetic mixture of human and artificial intelligence. Currently there is no clear framework or methodology on how to create such an effective mixture.…
▽ More
Artificial Intelligence (AI) can augment and sometimes even replace human cognition. Inspired by efforts to value human agency alongside productivity, we discuss the benefits of solving Citizen Science (CS) tasks with Hybrid Intelligence (HI), a synergetic mixture of human and artificial intelligence. Currently there is no clear framework or methodology on how to create such an effective mixture. Due to the unique participant-centered set of values and the abundance of tasks drawing upon both human common sense and complex 21st century skills, we believe that the field of CS offers an invaluable testbed for the development of HI and human-centered AI of the 21st century, while benefiting CS as well. In order to investigate this potential, we first relate CS to adjacent computational disciplines. Then, we demonstrate that CS projects can be grouped according to their potential for HI-enhancement by examining two key dimensions: the level of digitization and the amount of knowledge or experience required for participation. Finally, we propose a framework for types of human-AI interaction in CS based on established criteria of HI. This "HI lens" provides the CS community with an overview of several ways to utilize the combination of AI and human intelligence in their projects. It also allows the AI community to gain ideas on how developing AI in CS projects can further their own field.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
