Showing 1–15 of 15 results for author: Högås, M

Reassessing the Cepheid-based distance ladder: implications for the Hubble constant

Authors: Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: The Hubble constant ($H_0$) is a key parameter in cosmology, yet its precise value remains contentious due to discrepancies between early- and late-universe measurement methods, a problem known as the "Hubble tension." In this study, we revisit the Cepheid-based distance ladder calibration, focusing on two potential sources of bias in the period-luminosity relation (PLR): (1) the assumed prior for… ▽ More The Hubble constant ($H_0$) is a key parameter in cosmology, yet its precise value remains contentious due to discrepancies between early- and late-universe measurement methods, a problem known as the "Hubble tension." In this study, we revisit the Cepheid-based distance ladder calibration, focusing on two potential sources of bias in the period-luminosity relation (PLR): (1) the assumed prior for the residual parallax offset of the Milky Way (MW) Cepheids and (2) systematic differences between Cepheid periods in anchor galaxies versus supernova host galaxies. To address the latter, we adopt two different strategies alongside a renewed MW Cepheid calibration. The first strategy involves resampling anchor and host Cepheids from a common distribution of periods. This approach provides a conservative estimate of $H_0 = (72.18 \pm 1.76) \, \mathrm{km/s/Mpc}$, including the renewed MW analysis. The increased uncertainty reflects the reduced sample size -- about 700 Cepheids per resampling compared to 3200 in the original dataset. This method reduces the Hubble tension from $5.4 \, σ$ (as reported by the SH0ES collaboration with $H_0 = (73.17 \pm 0.86) \, \mathrm{km/s/Mpc}$) to $2.4 \, σ$. The second strategy allows the PLR slope to vary with the period, yielding $H_0 = (72.35 \pm 0.91) \, \mathrm{km/s/Mpc}$, including the renewed MW analysis, and the tension reduced to $4.4 \, σ$. A statistical comparison of the model with the single-linear PLR shows a significant preference for the broken PLR (p-value $< 0.001$). Both strategies consistently indicate a downward shift of approximately $-1 \, \mathrm{km/s/Mpc}$ in $H_0$. Our findings underscore the importance of careful consideration of Cepheid population characteristics for precise $H_0$ calibrations. △ Less

Submitted 6 March, 2025; v1 submitted 10 December, 2024; originally announced December 2024.

Comments: v2: Revised to match the published version: (1) Extended discussion of the impact of the assumed prior on the residual parallax offset, (2) Assessing the significance of the broken PLR, and (3) Introducing an alternative parallax correction based on ecliptic latitude. v3: Providing a detailed explanation of the SH0ES team's rationale for selecting their prior on the residual parallax offset

2D BAO vs 3D BAO: solving the Hubble tension with an alternative cosmological model

Authors: Sowmaydeep Dwivedi, Marcus Högås

Abstract: Ordinary 3D Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) data are model-dependent, requiring the assumption of a cosmological model to calculate comoving distances during data reduction. Throughout the present-day literature, the assumed model is $Λ$CDM. However, it has been pointed out in several recent works that this assumption can be inadequate when analyzing alternative cosmologies, potentially biasing… ▽ More Ordinary 3D Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO) data are model-dependent, requiring the assumption of a cosmological model to calculate comoving distances during data reduction. Throughout the present-day literature, the assumed model is $Λ$CDM. However, it has been pointed out in several recent works that this assumption can be inadequate when analyzing alternative cosmologies, potentially biasing the Hubble constant ($H_0$) low, thus contributing to the Hubble tension. To address this issue, 3D BAO data can be replaced with 2D BAO data, which is only weakly model-dependent. The impact of using 2D BAO data, in combination with alternative cosmological models beyond $Λ$CDM, has been explored for several phenomenological models, showing a promising reduction in the Hubble tension. In this work, we accommodate these models in the theoretically robust framework of bimetric gravity. This is a modified theory of gravity that exhibits a transition from a (possibly) negative cosmological constant in the early universe to a positive one in the late universe. By combining 2D BAO data with cosmic microwave background and type Ia supernovae data, we find that the inverse distance ladder in this theory yields a Hubble constant of $H_0 = (71.0 \pm 0.9) \, \mathrm{km/s/Mpc}$, consistent with the SH0ES local distance ladder measurement of $H_0 = (73.0 \pm 1.0) \, \mathrm{km/s/Mpc}$. Replacing 2D BAO with 3D BAO results in $H_0 = (68.6 \pm 0.5) \, \mathrm{km/s/Mpc}$ from the inverse distance ladder. Thus, the choice of BAO data significantly impacts the Hubble tension, with ordinary 3D BAO data exacerbating the tension, while 2D BAO data provides results consistent with the local distance ladder. △ Less

Submitted 31 October, 2024; v1 submitted 5 July, 2024; originally announced July 2024.

Comments: v3 according to the published version, including: corrected typos, improved introduction, added references, and a conclusions section

The Hubble tension and fifth forces: a cosmic screenplay

Authors: Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: Fifth forces are ubiquitous in modified theories of gravity. In this paper, we analyze their effect on the Cepheid-calibrated cosmic distance ladder, specifically with respect to the inferred value of the Hubble constant ($H_0$). We consider a variety of effective models where the strength, or amount of screening, of the fifth force is estimated using proxy fields related to the large-scale struct… ▽ More Fifth forces are ubiquitous in modified theories of gravity. In this paper, we analyze their effect on the Cepheid-calibrated cosmic distance ladder, specifically with respect to the inferred value of the Hubble constant ($H_0$). We consider a variety of effective models where the strength, or amount of screening, of the fifth force is estimated using proxy fields related to the large-scale structure of the Universe. For all models considered, the local distance ladder and the Planck value for $H_0$ agrees with a probability $\gtrsim 20 \, \%$, relieving the tension compared to the concordance model with data being excluded at $99 \, \%$ confidence. The alleviated discrepancy comes partially at the cost of an increased tension between distance estimates from Cepheids and the tip of the red-giant branch (TRGB). Demanding also that the consistency between Cepheid and TRGB distance estimates is not impaired, some fifth force models can still accommodate the data with a probability $\gtrsim 20 \, \%$. This provides incentive for more detailed investigations of fundamental theories on which the effective models are based, and their effect on the Hubble tension. △ Less

Submitted 4 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Comments: 10 pages, 9 figures. Comments are welcomme

Impact of symmetron screening on the Hubble tension: new constraints using cosmic distance ladder data

Authors: Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: Fifth forces are ubiquitous in modified theories of gravity. To be compatible with observations, such a force must be screened on solar-system scales but may still give a significant contribution on galactic scales. If this is the case, the fifth force can influence the calibration of the cosmic distance ladder, hence changing the inferred value of the Hubble constant $H_0$. In this paper, we anal… ▽ More Fifth forces are ubiquitous in modified theories of gravity. To be compatible with observations, such a force must be screened on solar-system scales but may still give a significant contribution on galactic scales. If this is the case, the fifth force can influence the calibration of the cosmic distance ladder, hence changing the inferred value of the Hubble constant $H_0$. In this paper, we analyze symmetron screening and show that it generally increases the Hubble tension. On the other hand, by doing a full statistical analysis, we show that cosmic distance ladder data are able to constrain the theory to a level competitive with solar-system tests -- currently the most constraining tests of the theory. For the standard coupling case, the constraint on the symmetron Compton wavelength is $λ_{\rm C} \lesssim 2.5 \, \mathrm{Mpc}$. Thus, distance ladder data constitutes a novel and powerful way of testing this, and similar, types of theories. △ Less

Submitted 11 September, 2023; v1 submitted 22 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 11 pages, 9 figures, v2 minor updates in accordance with the published version

A Cosmological Underdensity Does Not Solve the Hubble Tension

Authors: Sveva Castello, Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: A potential solution to the Hubble tension is the hypothesis that the Milky Way is located near the center of a matter underdensity. We model this scenario through the Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi formalism with the inclusion of a cosmological constant ($Λ$LTB) and consider a generalized Gaussian parametrization for the matter density profile. We constrain the underdensity and the background cosmology wi… ▽ More A potential solution to the Hubble tension is the hypothesis that the Milky Way is located near the center of a matter underdensity. We model this scenario through the Lemaître-Tolman-Bondi formalism with the inclusion of a cosmological constant ($Λ$LTB) and consider a generalized Gaussian parametrization for the matter density profile. We constrain the underdensity and the background cosmology with a combination of data sets: the Pantheon Sample of type Ia supernovae (both the full catalogue and a redshift-binned version of it), a collection of baryon acoustic oscillations data points and the distance priors extracted from the latest Planck data release. The analysis with the binned supernovae suggests a preference for a $-13 \%$ density drop with a size of approximately 300 Mpc, interestingly matching the prediction for the so-called KBC void already identified on the basis of independent analyses using galaxy distributions. The constraints obtained with the full Pantheon Sample are instead compatible with a homogeneous cosmology and we interpret this radically different result as a cautionary tale about the potential bias introduced by employing a binned supernova data set. We quantify the level of improvement on the Hubble tension by analyzing the constraints on the B-band absolute magnitude of the supernovae, which provides the calibration for the local measurements of $H_0$. Since no significant difference is observed with respect to an analogous fit performed with a standard $Λ$CDM cosmology, we conclude that the potential presence of a local underdensity does not resolve the tension and does not significantly degrade current supernova constraints on $H_0$. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2022; v1 submitted 8 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Comments: 24 pages, 5 figures; v2 slightly updated to match published version in JCAP

Journal ref: JCAP07(2022)003

Constraints on bimetric gravity from Big Bang nucleosynthesis

Authors: Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: Bimetric gravity is a ghost-free and observationally viable extension of general relativity, exhibiting both a massless and a massive graviton. The observed abundances of light elements can be used to constrain the expansion history of the Universe at the period of Big Bang nucleosynthesis. Applied to bimetric gravity, we readily obtain constraints on the theory parameters which are complementary… ▽ More Bimetric gravity is a ghost-free and observationally viable extension of general relativity, exhibiting both a massless and a massive graviton. The observed abundances of light elements can be used to constrain the expansion history of the Universe at the period of Big Bang nucleosynthesis. Applied to bimetric gravity, we readily obtain constraints on the theory parameters which are complementary to other observational probes. For example, the mixing angle between the two gravitons must satisfy $θ\lesssim 18^\circ$ in the graviton mass range $m_\mathrm{FP} \gtrsim 10^{-16} \, \mathrm{eV}/c^2$, representing a factor of two improvement compared with other cosmological probes. △ Less

Submitted 3 November, 2021; v1 submitted 16 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 5 pages, v2 minor updates in accordance with the published version. For a short (5 min) video summarizing the main result, see https://youtu.be/uqdbOZQ7k_k

Observational constraints on bimetric gravity

Authors: Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: Ghost-free bimetric gravity is a theory of two interacting spin-2 fields, one massless and one massive, in addition to the standard matter particles and fields, thereby generalizing Einstein's theory of general relativity. To parameterize the theory, we use five observables with specific physical interpretations. We present, for the first time, observational constraints on these parameters that: (… ▽ More Ghost-free bimetric gravity is a theory of two interacting spin-2 fields, one massless and one massive, in addition to the standard matter particles and fields, thereby generalizing Einstein's theory of general relativity. To parameterize the theory, we use five observables with specific physical interpretations. We present, for the first time, observational constraints on these parameters that: (i) apply to the full theory, (ii) are consistent with a working screening mechanism (i.e., restoring general relativity locally), (iii) exhibit a continuous, real-valued background cosmology (without the Higuchi ghost). For the cosmological constraints, we use data sets from the cosmic microwave background, baryon acoustic oscillations, and type Ia supernovae. Bimetric cosmology provides a good fit to data even for large values of the mixing angle between the massless and massive gravitons. Interestingly, the best-fit model is a self-accelerating solution where the accelerated expansion is due to the dynamical massive spin-2 field, without a cosmological constant. Due to the screening mechanism, the models are consistent with local tests of gravity such as solar system tests and gravitational lensing by galaxies. We also comment on the possibility of alleviating the Hubble tension with this theory. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2021; v1 submitted 21 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 20 pages, 15 figures + appendices. A short video summarizing the results can be found here: "https://youtu.be/u9nHGoP0iOU". Version 2, very slight modification according to the published version

Analytical constraints on bimetric gravity

Authors: Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: Ghost-free bimetric gravity is an extension of general relativity, featuring a massive spin-2 field coupled to gravity. We parameterize the theory with a set of observables having specific physical interpretations. For the background cosmology and the static, spherically symmetric solutions (for example approximating the gravitational potential of the solar system), there are four directions in th… ▽ More Ghost-free bimetric gravity is an extension of general relativity, featuring a massive spin-2 field coupled to gravity. We parameterize the theory with a set of observables having specific physical interpretations. For the background cosmology and the static, spherically symmetric solutions (for example approximating the gravitational potential of the solar system), there are four directions in the parameter space in which general relativity is approached. Requiring that there is a working screening mechanism and a nonsingular evolution of the Universe, we place analytical constraints on the parameter space which rule out many of the models studied in the literature. Cosmological solutions where the accelerated expansion of the Universe is explained by the dynamical interaction of the massive spin-2 field rather than by a cosmological constant, are still viable. △ Less

Submitted 10 May, 2021; v1 submitted 21 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: 24 pages, 12 figures + appendices. Version 2, slight modifications in accordance with the published version

On the stability of bimetric structure formation

Authors: Marcus Högås, Francesco Torsello, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: Bimetric gravity can reproduce the accelerated expansion of the Universe, without a cosmological constant. However, the stability of these solutions to linear perturbations has been questioned, suggesting exponential growth of structure in this approximation. We present a simple model of structure formation, for which an analytical solution is derived. The solution is well-behaved, showing that th… ▽ More Bimetric gravity can reproduce the accelerated expansion of the Universe, without a cosmological constant. However, the stability of these solutions to linear perturbations has been questioned, suggesting exponential growth of structure in this approximation. We present a simple model of structure formation, for which an analytical solution is derived. The solution is well-behaved, showing that there is no physical instability with respect to these perturbations. The model can yield a growth of structure exhibiting measurable differences from $Λ$CDM. △ Less

Submitted 29 April, 2020; v1 submitted 3 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: 15 pages, 7 figures. v2 slight updates in accordance with the published version

Journal ref: JCAP04(2020)046

Generalized Vaidya solutions in bimetric gravity

Authors: Marcus Högås, Mikica Kocic, Francesco Torsello, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: In general relativity, the endpoint of spherically symmetric gravitational collapse is a Schwarzschild--[(A)dS] black hole. In bimetric gravity, it has been speculated that a static end state must also be Schwarzschild--[(A)dS]. To this end, we present a set of exact solutions, including collapsing massless dust particles. For these, the speculation is confirmed. In general relativity, the endpoint of spherically symmetric gravitational collapse is a Schwarzschild--[(A)dS] black hole. In bimetric gravity, it has been speculated that a static end state must also be Schwarzschild--[(A)dS]. To this end, we present a set of exact solutions, including collapsing massless dust particles. For these, the speculation is confirmed. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2020; v1 submitted 23 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 15 pages, 2 figures. Updates in v2: changed title of the paper, added appendix on the Fierz-Pauli mass, removed all occurences of "bare cosmological constant" in the text and changed the comparison between bimetric gravity and GR accordingly, updated references, corrected typo in eq. (2.6b)

Spherical dust collapse in bimetric relativity: Bimetric polytropes

Authors: Mikica Kocic, Francesco Torsello, Marcus Högås, Edvard Mortsell

Abstract: We present a method for solving the constraint equations in the Hassan-Rosen bimetric theory to determine the initial data for the gravitational collapse of spherically symmetric dust. The setup leads to equations similar to those for a polytropic fluid in general relativity, here called a generalized Lane-Emden equation. Using a numerical code which solves the evolution equations in the standard… ▽ More We present a method for solving the constraint equations in the Hassan-Rosen bimetric theory to determine the initial data for the gravitational collapse of spherically symmetric dust. The setup leads to equations similar to those for a polytropic fluid in general relativity, here called a generalized Lane-Emden equation. Using a numerical code which solves the evolution equations in the standard 3+1 form, we also obtain a short term development of the initial data for these bimetric polytropes. The evolution highlights some important features of the bimetric theory such as the interwoven and oscillating null cones representing the essential nonbidiagonality in the dynamics of the two metrics. The simulations are in the strong-field regime and show that, at least at an early stage, the collapse of a dust cloud is similar to that in general relativity, and with no instabilities, albeit with small oscillations in the metric fields. △ Less

Submitted 18 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: 24 pages, 17 figures

Covariant BSSN formulation in bimetric relativity

Authors: Francesco Torsello, Mikica Kocic, Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell

Abstract: Numerical integration of the field equations in bimetric relativity is necessary to obtain solutions describing realistic systems. Thus, it is crucial to recast the equations as a well-posed problem. In general relativity, under certain assumptions, the covariant BSSN formulation is a strongly hyperbolic formulation of the Einstein equations, hence its Cauchy problem is well-posed. In this paper,… ▽ More Numerical integration of the field equations in bimetric relativity is necessary to obtain solutions describing realistic systems. Thus, it is crucial to recast the equations as a well-posed problem. In general relativity, under certain assumptions, the covariant BSSN formulation is a strongly hyperbolic formulation of the Einstein equations, hence its Cauchy problem is well-posed. In this paper, we establish the covariant BSSN formulation of the bimetric field equations. It shares many features with the corresponding formulation in general relativity, but there are a few fundamental differences between them. Some of these differences depend on the gauge choice and alter the hyperbolic structure of the system of partial differential equations compared to general relativity. Accordingly, the strong hyperbolicity of the system cannot be claimed yet, under the same assumptions as in general relativity. In the paper, we stress the differences compared with general relativity and state the main issues that should be tackled next, to draw a road map towards numerical bimetric relativity. △ Less

Submitted 6 March, 2020; v1 submitted 16 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Comments: It matches the published version and its corrigendum at https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6382/ab74f7. 14 pages plus appendices. The ancillary files contain the supplementary material and the paper in colors

Journal ref: 2020 Class. Quantum Grav. 37 025013

Spacetime symmetries and topology in bimetric relativity

Authors: Francesco Torsello, Mikica Kocic, Marcus Högås, Edvard Mortsell

Abstract: We explore spacetime symmetries and topologies of the two metric sectors in Hassan-Rosen bimetric theory. We show that, in vacuum, the two sectors can either share or have separate spacetime symmetries. If stress-energy tensors are present, a third case can arise, with different spacetime symmetries within the same sector. This raises the question of the best definition of spacetime symmetry in Ha… ▽ More We explore spacetime symmetries and topologies of the two metric sectors in Hassan-Rosen bimetric theory. We show that, in vacuum, the two sectors can either share or have separate spacetime symmetries. If stress-energy tensors are present, a third case can arise, with different spacetime symmetries within the same sector. This raises the question of the best definition of spacetime symmetry in Hassan-Rosen bimetric theory. We emphasize the possibility of imposing ansätze and looking for solutions having different Killing vector fields or different isometries in the two sectors, which has gained little attention so far. We also point out that the topology of spacetime imposes a constraint on possible metric combinations. △ Less

Submitted 19 April, 2018; v1 submitted 17 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 19 pages. It matches with the published version. Comments are welcome. Attached Mathematica notebook available in the ancillary files and at https://tinyurl.com/y9r7nuuh

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 084022 (2018)

On Birkhoff's theorem in ghost-free bimetric theory

Authors: Mikica Kocic, Marcus Högås, Francesco Torsello, Edvard Mortsell

Abstract: We consider the Hassan-Rosen bimetric field equations in vacuum when the two metrics share a single common null direction in a spherically symmetric configuration. By solving these equations, we obtain a class of exact solutions of the generalized Vaidya type parametrized by an arbitrary function. Besides not being asymptotically flat, the found solutions are nonstationary admitting only three glo… ▽ More We consider the Hassan-Rosen bimetric field equations in vacuum when the two metrics share a single common null direction in a spherically symmetric configuration. By solving these equations, we obtain a class of exact solutions of the generalized Vaidya type parametrized by an arbitrary function. Besides not being asymptotically flat, the found solutions are nonstationary admitting only three global spacelike Killing vector fields which are the generators of spatial rotations. Hence, these are spherically symmetric bimetric vacuum solutions with the minimal number of isometries. The absence of staticity formally disproves an analogue statement to Birkhoff's theorem in the ghost-free bimetric theory which would state that a spherically symmetric solution is necessarily static in empty space. △ Less

Submitted 25 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 27 pages, 3 figures

Algebraic Properties of Einstein Solutions in Ghost-Free Bimetric Theory

Authors: Mikica Kocic, Marcus Högås, Francesco Torsello, Edvard Mortsell

Abstract: A known fact is that an Einstein solution in one sector in ghost-free bimetric theory implies an Einstein solution in the other sector. Earlier studies have also shown that some classes of bimetric models necessitate proportional solutions between the sectors. Here we consider a general setup of the parameters in the theory as well as the general algebraic form of the potential. We show that, if o… ▽ More A known fact is that an Einstein solution in one sector in ghost-free bimetric theory implies an Einstein solution in the other sector. Earlier studies have also shown that some classes of bimetric models necessitate proportional solutions between the sectors. Here we consider a general setup of the parameters in the theory as well as the general algebraic form of the potential. We show that, if one sector has an Einstein solution, the solutions are either proportional or block proportional with at most two different eigenvalues in the square root governing metric interactions. △ Less

Submitted 2 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Comments: 6 pages