-
Industrialisation of spectral/hp element method for incompressible, transitional flow around Formula 1 geometries
Authors:
Parv Khurana,
Alexandra Liosi,
Spencer Sherwin,
Julien Hoessler,
Adam Swift,
Athanasios Chatzopoulos,
Francesco Bottone
Abstract:
This study applies the high-fidelity spectral/hp element method using the open-source Nektar++ framework to simulate the unsteady, transitional flow around complex 3D geometries representative of the Formula 1 industry. This study extends the work on a previously investigated industrial benchmark, the Imperial Front Wing (IFW), derived from the McLaren MP4-17D race car's front wing and endplate de…
▽ More
This study applies the high-fidelity spectral/hp element method using the open-source Nektar++ framework to simulate the unsteady, transitional flow around complex 3D geometries representative of the Formula 1 industry. This study extends the work on a previously investigated industrial benchmark, the Imperial Front Wing (IFW), derived from the McLaren MP4-17D race car's front wing and endplate design. A combined configuration of the IFW with a wheel in contact with a moving ground in a rolling state is considered, representing the first instance of such a configuration being simulated using higher-order methods. The rolling wheel combined with the IFW (IFW-W) provides the most realistic industrial configuration until now. The spectral/hp element method is applied to this test case to solve the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations, simulating the flow at a Reynolds number of $\mathbf{2.2 \times 10^5}$. Time-averaged results from the unsteady simulation are compared to experimental Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) data to assess the model's fidelity, offering insights into its reliability for accurately representing key flow characteristics. This research addresses the challenges and requisites associated with achieving diverse levels of flow resolution using the under-resolved DNS/implicit LES approach.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
A comparative study of explicit and implicit Large Eddy Simulations using a high-order discontinuous Galerkin solver: application to a Formula 1 front wing
Authors:
Gerasimos Ntoukas,
Gonzalo Rubio,
Oscar Marino,
Alexandra Liosi,
Francesco Bottone,
Julien Hoessler,
Esteban Ferrer
Abstract:
This paper explores two Large Eddy Simulation (LES) approaches within the framework of the high-order discontinuous Galerkin solver, Horses3D. The investigation focuses on an Inverted Multi-element Wing in Ground Effect (i.e. 2.5D Imperial Front Wing section) representing a Formula 1 front wing, and compares the strengths and limitations of the two LES methods. The explicit LES formulation relies…
▽ More
This paper explores two Large Eddy Simulation (LES) approaches within the framework of the high-order discontinuous Galerkin solver, Horses3D. The investigation focuses on an Inverted Multi-element Wing in Ground Effect (i.e. 2.5D Imperial Front Wing section) representing a Formula 1 front wing, and compares the strengths and limitations of the two LES methods. The explicit LES formulation relies on the Vreman model, that adapts to laminar, transitional and turbulent regimes. The numerical formulation uses nodal basis functions and Gauss points. The implicit LES formulation, does not require explicit turbulence modeling but relies in the discretization scheme. We use the Kennedy-Gruber entropy stable formulation to enhance stability in under resolved simulations, since we recover the continuous properties such as entropy conservation at a discrete level. This formulation employs Gauss-Lobatto points, which downgrades the accuracy of integration but allows for larger time steps in explicit time integration. We compare our results to Nektar++ [1] showing that both LES techniques provide results that agree well with the reference values. The implicit LES shows to better capture transition and allows for larger time steps at a similar cost per iteration. We conclude that this implicit LES formulation is very attractive for complex simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Statistical Review of Animal trials -- A Guideline
Authors:
Sophie K. Piper,
Dario Zocholl,
Ulf Toelch,
Robert Roehle,
Andrea Stroux,
Johanna Hößler,
Anne Kujawa,
Frank Konietschke
Abstract:
Examinations of any experiment involving living organisms require justifications of the need and moral defensibleness of the study. Statistical planning, design and sample size calculation of the experiment are no less important review criteria than general medical and ethical points to consider. Errors made in the statistical planning and data evaluation phase can have severe consequences on both…
▽ More
Examinations of any experiment involving living organisms require justifications of the need and moral defensibleness of the study. Statistical planning, design and sample size calculation of the experiment are no less important review criteria than general medical and ethical points to consider. Errors made in the statistical planning and data evaluation phase can have severe consequences on both results and conclusions. They might proliferate and thus impact future trials-an unintended outcome of fundamental research with profound ethical consequences. Therefore, any trial must be efficient in both a medical and statistical way in answering the questions of interests to be considered as approvable. Unified statistical standards are currently missing for animal review boards in Germany. In order to accompany, we developed a biometric form to be filled and handed in with the proposal at the local authority on animal welfare. It addresses relevant points to consider for biostatistical planning of animal experiments and can help both the applicants and the reviewers in overseeing the entire experiment(s) planned. Furthermore, the form might also aid in meeting the current standards set by the 3+3R's principle of animal experimentation Replacement, Reduction, Refinement as well as Robustness, Registration and Reporting. The form has already been in use by the local authority of animal welfare in Berlin, Germany. In addition, we provide reference to our user guide giving more detailed explanation and examples for each section of the biometric form. Unifying the set of biostatistical aspects will help both the applicants and the reviewers to equal standards and increase quality of preclinical research projects, also for translational, multicenter, or international studies.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2021; v1 submitted 29 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Spectral/hp element simulation of flow past a Formula One front wing: validation against experiments
Authors:
Filipe F. Buscariolo,
Julien Hoessler,
David Moxey,
Ayad Jassim,
Kevin Gouder,
Jeremy Basley,
Yushi Murai,
Gustavo R. S. Assi,
Spencer J. Sherwin
Abstract:
Emerging commercial and academic tools are regularly being applied to the design of road and race cars, but there currently are no well-established benchmark cases to study the aerodynamics of race car wings in ground effect. In this paper we propose a new test case, with a relatively complex geometry, supported by the availability of CAD model and experimental results. We refer to the test case a…
▽ More
Emerging commercial and academic tools are regularly being applied to the design of road and race cars, but there currently are no well-established benchmark cases to study the aerodynamics of race car wings in ground effect. In this paper we propose a new test case, with a relatively complex geometry, supported by the availability of CAD model and experimental results. We refer to the test case as the Imperial Front Wing, originally based on the front wing and endplate design of the McLaren 17D race car. A comparison of different resolutions of a high fidelity spectral/hp element simulation using under-resolved DNS/implicit LES approach with fourth and fifth polynomial order is presented. The results demonstrate good correlation to both the wall-bounded streaklines obtained by oil flow visualization and experimental PIV results, correctly predicting key characteristics of the time-averaged flow structures, namely intensity, contours and locations. This study highlights the resolution requirements in capturing salient flow features arising from this type of challenging geometry, providing an interesting test case for both traditional and emerging high-fidelity simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Implicit Large Eddy Simulation of a wingtip vortex at $Re_c = 1.2\cdot 10^6$
Authors:
Jean-Eloi W. Lombard,
David Moxey,
Julien F. A. Hoessler,
Sridar Dhandapani,
Mark J. Taylor,
Spencer J. Sherwin
Abstract:
In this article we present recent developments in numerical methods for performing a Large Eddy Simulation (LES) of the formation and evolution of a wingtip vortex. The development of these vortices in the near wake, in combination with the large Reynolds numbers present in these cases, make these types of test cases particularly challenging to investigate numerically. We first give an overview of…
▽ More
In this article we present recent developments in numerical methods for performing a Large Eddy Simulation (LES) of the formation and evolution of a wingtip vortex. The development of these vortices in the near wake, in combination with the large Reynolds numbers present in these cases, make these types of test cases particularly challenging to investigate numerically. We first give an overview of the Spectral Vanishing Viscosity--implicit LES (SVV-iLES) solver that is used to perform the simulations, and highlight techniques that have been adopted to solve various numerical issues that arise when studying such cases. To demonstrate the method's viability, we present results from numerical simulations of flow over a NACA 0012 profile wingtip at $Re_c = 1.2\cdot 10^6$ and compare them against experimental data, which is to date the highest Reynolds number achieved for a LES that has been correlated with experiments for this test case. Our model correlates favorably with experiment, both for the characteristic jetting in the primary vortex and pressure distribution on the wing surface. The proposed method is of general interest for the modeling of transitioning vortex dominated flows over complex geometries.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
