-
Robust wall modes and their interplay with bulk turbulence in confined rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection
Authors:
Xander M. de Wit,
Wouter J. M. Boot,
Matteo Madonia,
Andrés J. Aguirre Guzmán,
Rudie P. J. Kunnen
Abstract:
In confined rotating convection, a strong zonal flow can develop close to the side wall with a modal structure that precesses anti-cyclonically (counter to the applied rotation) along the side wall. It is surmised that this is a robust non-linear evolution of the wall modes observed before the onset of bulk convection. Here, we perform direct numerical simulations of cylindrically confined rotatin…
▽ More
In confined rotating convection, a strong zonal flow can develop close to the side wall with a modal structure that precesses anti-cyclonically (counter to the applied rotation) along the side wall. It is surmised that this is a robust non-linear evolution of the wall modes observed before the onset of bulk convection. Here, we perform direct numerical simulations of cylindrically confined rotating convection at high rotation rates and strong turbulent forcing. Through comparison with earlier work, we find a fit-parameter-free relation that links the angular drift frequency of the robust wall mode observed far into the turbulent regime with the critical wall mode frequency at onset, firmly substantiating the connection between the observed boundary zonal flow and the wall modes. Deviations from this relation at stronger turbulent forcing suggest early signs of the bulk turbulence starting to hamper the development of the wall mode. Furthermore, by studying the interactive flow between the robust wall mode and the bulk turbulence, we identify radial jets penetrating from the wall mode into the bulk. These jets induce a large scale multipolar vortex structure in the bulk turbulence, dependent on the wavenumber of the wall mode. In a narrow cylinder the entire bulk flow is dominated by a quadrupolar vortex driven by the radial jets, while in a wider cylinder the jets are found to have a finite penetration length and the vortices do not cover the entire bulk. We also identify the role of Reynolds stresses in the generation of zonal flows in the region near the sidewall.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2024; v1 submitted 1 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Reynolds number scaling and energy spectra in geostrophic convection
Authors:
Matteo Madonia,
Andrés J. Aguirre Guzmán,
Herman J. H. Clercx,
Rudie P. J. Kunnen
Abstract:
We report flow measurements in rotating Rayleigh--Bénard convection in the rotationally-constrained geostrophic regime. We apply stereoscopic particle image velocimetry to measure the three components of velocity in a horizontal cross-section of a water-filled cylindrical convection vessel. At a constant, small Ekman number $Ek=5\times 10^{-8}$ we vary the Rayleigh number $Ra$ between $10^{11}$ an…
▽ More
We report flow measurements in rotating Rayleigh--Bénard convection in the rotationally-constrained geostrophic regime. We apply stereoscopic particle image velocimetry to measure the three components of velocity in a horizontal cross-section of a water-filled cylindrical convection vessel. At a constant, small Ekman number $Ek=5\times 10^{-8}$ we vary the Rayleigh number $Ra$ between $10^{11}$ and $4\times 10^{12}$ to cover various subregimes observed in geostrophic convection. We also include one nonrotating experiment. The scaling of the velocity fluctuations (expressed as the Reynolds number $Re$) is compared to theoretical relations expressing balances of viscous--Archimedean--Coriolis (VAC) and Coriolis--inertial--Archimedean (CIA) forces. Based on our results we cannot decide which balance is most applicable here; both scaling relations match equally well. A comparison of the current data with several other literature datasets indicates a convergence towards diffusion-free scaling of velocity as $Ek$ decreases. However, the use of confined domains leads at lower $Ra$ to prominent convection in the wall mode near the sidewall. Kinetic energy spectra point at an overall flow organisation into a quadrupolar vortex filling the cross-section. This quadrupolar vortex is a quasi-two-dimensional feature as it only manifests in energy spectra based on the horizontal velocity components. At larger $Ra$ the spectra reveal the development of a scaling range with exponent close to $-5/3$, the classical exponent for inertial-range scaling in three-dimensional turbulence. The steeper $Re(Ra)$ scaling at low $Ek$ and development of a scaling range in the energy spectra are distinct indicators that a fully developed, diffusion-free turbulent flow state is approached, sketching clear perspectives for further investigation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Velocimetry in rapidly rotating convection: spatial correlations, flow structures and length scales
Authors:
Matteo Madonia,
Andrés J. Aguirre Guzmán,
Herman J. H. Clercx,
Rudie P. J. Kunnen
Abstract:
Rotating Rayleigh--Bénard convection is an oft-employed model system to evaluate the interplay of buoyant forcing and Coriolis forces due to rotation, an eminently relevant interaction of dynamical effects found in many geophysical and astrophysical flows. These flows display extreme values of the governing parameters: large Rayleigh numbers $Ra$, quantifying the strength of thermal forcing, and s…
▽ More
Rotating Rayleigh--Bénard convection is an oft-employed model system to evaluate the interplay of buoyant forcing and Coriolis forces due to rotation, an eminently relevant interaction of dynamical effects found in many geophysical and astrophysical flows. These flows display extreme values of the governing parameters: large Rayleigh numbers $Ra$, quantifying the strength of thermal forcing, and small Ekman numbers $E$, a parameter inversely proportional to the rotation rate. This leads to the dominant geostrophic balance of forces in the flow between pressure gradient and Coriolis force. The so-called geostrophic regime of rotating convection is difficult to study with laboratory experiments and numerical simulations given the requirements to attain simultaneously large $Ra$ values and small values of $E$. Here, we use flow measurements using stereoscopic particle image velocimetry in a large-scale rotating convection apparatus in a horizontal plane at mid-height to study the rich flow phenomenology of the geostrophic regime of rotating convection. We quantify the horizontal length scales of the flow using spatial correlations of vertical velocity and vertical vorticity, reproducing features of the convective Taylor columns and plumes flow states both part of the geostrophic regime. Additionally, we find in this horizontal plane an organisation into a quadrupolar vortex at higher Rayleigh numbers starting from the plumes state.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Discontinuous Transitions Towards Vortex Condensates in Buoyancy-Driven Rotating Turbulence
Authors:
Xander M. de Wit,
Andrés J. Aguirre Guzmán,
Herman J. H. Clercx,
Rudie P. J. Kunnen
Abstract:
Using direct numerical simulations of rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection, we explore the transitions between turbulent states from a 3D flow state towards a quasi-2D condensate known as the large-scale vortex (LSV). We vary the Rayleigh number $Ra$ as control parameter and study the system response (strength of the LSV) in terms of order parameters assessing the energetic content in the flow and…
▽ More
Using direct numerical simulations of rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection, we explore the transitions between turbulent states from a 3D flow state towards a quasi-2D condensate known as the large-scale vortex (LSV). We vary the Rayleigh number $Ra$ as control parameter and study the system response (strength of the LSV) in terms of order parameters assessing the energetic content in the flow and the upscale energy flux. By sensitively probing the boundaries of the region of existence of the LSV in parameter space, we find discontinuous transitions and we identify the presence of a hysteresis loop as well as memoryless abrupt growth dynamics. We show furthermore that the creation of the condensate state coincides with a discontinuous transition of the energy transport into the largest mode of the system.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2022; v1 submitted 2 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Frictional boundary layer effect on vortex condensation in rotating turbulent convection
Authors:
Andrés J. Aguirre Guzmán,
Matteo Madonia,
Jonathan S. Cheng,
Rodolfo Ostilla-Mónico,
Herman J. H. Clercx,
Rudie P. J. Kunnen
Abstract:
We perform direct numerical simulations of rotating Rayleigh--Bénard convection of fluids with low ($Pr=0.1$) and high ($Pr=5$) Prandtl numbers in a horizontally periodic layer with no-slip top and bottom boundaries. At both Prandtl numbers, we demonstrate the presence of an upscale transfer of kinetic energy that leads to the development of domain-filling vortical structures. Sufficiently strong…
▽ More
We perform direct numerical simulations of rotating Rayleigh--Bénard convection of fluids with low ($Pr=0.1$) and high ($Pr=5$) Prandtl numbers in a horizontally periodic layer with no-slip top and bottom boundaries. At both Prandtl numbers, we demonstrate the presence of an upscale transfer of kinetic energy that leads to the development of domain-filling vortical structures. Sufficiently strong buoyant forcing and rotation foster the quasi-two-dimensional turbulent state of the flow, despite the formation of plume-like vertical disturbances promoted by so-called Ekman pumping from the viscous boundary layer.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Turbulent rotating convection confined in a slender cylinder: the sidewall circulation
Authors:
Xander M. de Wit,
Andrés J. Aguirre Guzmán,
Matteo Madonia,
Jonathan S. Cheng,
Herman J. H. Clercx,
Rudie P. J. Kunnen
Abstract:
Recent studies of rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection at high rotation rates and strong thermal forcing have shown a significant discrepancy in total heat transport between experiments on a confined cylindrical domain on the one hand and simulations on a laterally unconfined periodic domain on the other. This paper addresses this discrepancy using direct numerical simulations on a cylindrical doma…
▽ More
Recent studies of rotating Rayleigh-Bénard convection at high rotation rates and strong thermal forcing have shown a significant discrepancy in total heat transport between experiments on a confined cylindrical domain on the one hand and simulations on a laterally unconfined periodic domain on the other. This paper addresses this discrepancy using direct numerical simulations on a cylindrical domain. An analysis of the flow field reveals a region of enhanced convection near the wall, the sidewall circulation. The sidewall circulation rotates slowly within the cylinder in anticyclonic direction. It has a convoluted structure, illustrated by mean flow fields in horizontal cross-sections of the flow where instantaneous snapshots are compensated for the orientation of the sidewall circulation before averaging. Through separate analysis of the sidewall region and the inner bulk flow, we find that for higher values of the thermal forcing the heat transport in the inner part of the cylindrical domain, outside the sidewall circulation region, coincides with the heat transport on the unconfined periodic domain. Thus the sidewall circulation accounts for the differences in heat transfer between the two considered domains, while in the bulk the turbulent heat flux is the same as that of a laterally unbounded periodic domain. Therefore, experiments, with their inherent confinement, can still provide turbulence akin to the unbounded domains of simulations, and at more extreme values of the governing parameters for thermal forcing and rotation. We also provide experimental evidence for the existence of the sidewall circulation that is in close agreement with the simulation results.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2020; v1 submitted 15 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Laboratory Exploration of Heat Transfer Regimes in Rapidly Rotating Turbulent Convection
Authors:
Jonathan S. Cheng,
Matteo Madonia,
Andrés J. Aguirre Guzmán,
Rudie P. J. Kunnen
Abstract:
We report heat transfer and temperature profile measurements in laboratory experiments of rapidly rotating convection in water under intense thermal forcing (Rayleigh number $Ra$ as high as $\sim 10^{13}$) and unprecedentedly strong rotational influence (Ekman numbers $E$ as low as $10^{-8}$). Measurements of the mid-height vertical temperature gradient connect quantitatively to predictions from n…
▽ More
We report heat transfer and temperature profile measurements in laboratory experiments of rapidly rotating convection in water under intense thermal forcing (Rayleigh number $Ra$ as high as $\sim 10^{13}$) and unprecedentedly strong rotational influence (Ekman numbers $E$ as low as $10^{-8}$). Measurements of the mid-height vertical temperature gradient connect quantitatively to predictions from numerical models of asymptotically rapidly rotating convection, separating various flow phenomenologies. Past the limit of validity of the asymptotically-reduced models, we find novel behaviors in a regime we refer to as rotationally-influenced turbulence, where rotation is important but not as dominant as in the known geostrophic turbulence regime. The temperature gradients collapse to a Rayleigh-number scaling as $Ra^{-0.2}$ in this new regime. It is bounded from above by a critical convective Rossby number $Ro^*=0.06$ independent of domain aspect ratio $Γ$, clearly distinguishing it from well-studied rotation-affected convection.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2020; v1 submitted 11 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
