-
A general relativistic hydrodynamic simulation code for studying advective, sub-Keplerian accretion flow onto black holes
Authors:
Sudip K Garain
Abstract:
In this paper, we describe a general relativistic hydrodynamics simulation code which is developed to simulate advective accretion flow onto black holes. We are particularly interested in the accretion simulations of sub-Keplerian matter in the close vicinity of black holes. Due to the presence of centrifugal barrier, a nearly free-falling sub-Keplerian accretion flow slows down close to a black h…
▽ More
In this paper, we describe a general relativistic hydrodynamics simulation code which is developed to simulate advective accretion flow onto black holes. We are particularly interested in the accretion simulations of sub-Keplerian matter in the close vicinity of black holes. Due to the presence of centrifugal barrier, a nearly free-falling sub-Keplerian accretion flow slows down close to a black hole and can even pass through shocks before accelerating again to the black hole. We design our simulation code using the high resolution shock capturing scheme so that such shock structures can be captured and analyzed for relevance. In this paper, we describe our implementation and validation of the code against a few known analytical and numerical results of sub-Keplerian matter accretion.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2025;
originally announced June 2025.
-
General Relativistic Hydrodynamic Simulations around Accreting Black Holes
Authors:
Sudip K Garain,
Pranayjit Dey
Abstract:
Strong gravity in the immediate vicinity of compact objects (e.g., black holes, neutron stars) necessitates inclusion of general relativistic effects. Traditionally, pseudo-Newtonian potential representation of gravity were favored to simulate the fluid motion in this region since that reduced the calculation complexity. However, with the advent of easily implementable, reliable numerical algorith…
▽ More
Strong gravity in the immediate vicinity of compact objects (e.g., black holes, neutron stars) necessitates inclusion of general relativistic effects. Traditionally, pseudo-Newtonian potential representation of gravity were favored to simulate the fluid motion in this region since that reduced the calculation complexity. However, with the advent of easily implementable, reliable numerical algorithms and computer hardware, more and more research groups are shifting towards the numerical solutions of general relativistic fluid dynamics equations. In this work, we report our progress on the development of such simulation tool and present results of sub-Keplerian accretion flow onto black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Three Dimensional Simulations of Advective, Sub-Keplerian Accretion Flow onto Non-rotating Black Holes
Authors:
Sudip K Garain,
Jinho Kim
Abstract:
We study the time evolution of sub-Keplerian transonic accretion flow onto a non-rotating black hole using a three-dimensional, inviscid hydrodynamics simulation code. Prior two-dimensional simulations show that centrifugal barrier in the accreting matter may temporarily halt the nearly free-falling matter and produce a stable, geometrically thick disk which may contain turbulent eddies. Our goal…
▽ More
We study the time evolution of sub-Keplerian transonic accretion flow onto a non-rotating black hole using a three-dimensional, inviscid hydrodynamics simulation code. Prior two-dimensional simulations show that centrifugal barrier in the accreting matter may temporarily halt the nearly free-falling matter and produce a stable, geometrically thick disk which may contain turbulent eddies. Our goal in this work is to investigate whether the disk develops any instability because of this turbulence when we dynamically activate all three dimensions. We find that the disk remains stable and axisymmetric even close to the central black hole. However, if we explicitly apply non-axisymmetric azimuthal perturbation, the axisymmetric structure of the disk is destroyed and instability is developed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Multidimensional Generalized Riemann Problem Solver for Maxwell's Equations
Authors:
Arijit Hazra,
Dinshaw S. Balsara,
Praveen Chandrashekar,
Sudip K. Garain
Abstract:
Approximate multidimensional Riemann solvers are essential building blocks in designing globally constraint-preserving finite volume time domain (FVTD) and discontinuous Galerkin time domain (DGTD) schemes for computational electrodynamics (CED). In those schemes, we can achieve high-order temporal accuracy with the help of Runge-Kutta or ADER time-stepping. This paper presents the design of a mul…
▽ More
Approximate multidimensional Riemann solvers are essential building blocks in designing globally constraint-preserving finite volume time domain (FVTD) and discontinuous Galerkin time domain (DGTD) schemes for computational electrodynamics (CED). In those schemes, we can achieve high-order temporal accuracy with the help of Runge-Kutta or ADER time-stepping. This paper presents the design of a multidimensional approximate Generalized Riemann Problem (GRP) solver for the first time. The multidimensional Riemann solver accepts as its inputs the four states surrounding an edge on a structured mesh, and its output consists of a resolved state and its associated fluxes. In contrast, the multidimensional GRP solver accepts as its inputs the four states and their gradients in all directions; its output consists of the resolved state and its corresponding fluxes and the gradients of the resolved state. The gradients can then be used to extend the solution in time. As a result, we achieve second-order temporal accuracy in a single step.
In this work, the formulation is optimized for linear hyperbolic systems with stiff, linear source terms because such a formulation will find maximal use in CED. Our formulation produces an overall constraint-preserving time-stepping strategy based on the GRP that is provably L-stable in the presence of stiff source terms. We present several stringent test problems, showing that the multidimensional GRP solver for CED meets its design accuracy and performs stably with optimal time steps. The test problems include cases with high conductivity, showing that the beneficial L-stability is indeed realized in practical applications.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2023; v1 submitted 16 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Effects of Magnetic Field Loops on the Dynamics of Advective Accretion Flows and Jets around a Schwarzschild Blackhole
Authors:
Sudip K. Garain,
Dinshaw S Balsara,
Sandip K Chakrabarti,
Jinho Kim
Abstract:
Magnetic fields advected along with low angular momentum accretion flows predominantly become toroidal due to the strong azimuthal velocity close to a black hole. We study self-consistently the movements of these flux tubes inside an advective disc and how they dynamically influence the flow. We find that the centrifugal barrier slows down the radial motion of the flux tubes. In this case, the lar…
▽ More
Magnetic fields advected along with low angular momentum accretion flows predominantly become toroidal due to the strong azimuthal velocity close to a black hole. We study self-consistently the movements of these flux tubes inside an advective disc and how they dynamically influence the flow. We find that the centrifugal barrier slows down the radial motion of the flux tubes. In this case, the large magnetic flux tubes with a significant drag force escape along the vertical axis due to buoyancy. Magnetic pressure rises close to the black hole and together with the centrifugal force, it combats gravity. The tug-of-war among these forces causes the centrifugal pressure supported shock to oscillate radially. We study the effects of successive injection of flux tubes and find how the flux tube could be trapped inside the disc in regions of highest entropy. Most interestingly, the shock wave remains at its average location and is not destroyed. We show that the toroidal field loops contribute significantly to collimate and accelerate the outflows from the centrifugal barrier and suggest this mechanism to be a way to collimate and accelerate jets.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Turbulent dynamo in a weakly ionized medium
Authors:
Siyao Xu,
Sudip K. Garain,
Dinshaw S. Balsara,
A. Lazarian
Abstract:
The small-scale turbulent dynamo is an important process contributing to the cosmic magnetization. In partially ionized astrophysical plasmas, the dynamo growth of magnetic energy strongly depends on the coupling state between ions and neutrals and the ion-neutral collisional damping effect. A new damping stage of turbulent dynamo in a weakly ionized medium was theoretically predicted by Xu \& Laz…
▽ More
The small-scale turbulent dynamo is an important process contributing to the cosmic magnetization. In partially ionized astrophysical plasmas, the dynamo growth of magnetic energy strongly depends on the coupling state between ions and neutrals and the ion-neutral collisional damping effect. A new damping stage of turbulent dynamo in a weakly ionized medium was theoretically predicted by Xu \& Lazarian (2016). By carrying out a 3D two-fluid dynamo simulation, here we for the first time numerically confirmed the physical conditions and the linear-in-time growth of magnetic field strength of the damping stage of dynamo. The dynamo-amplified magnetic field has a characteristic length as the damping scale, which increases with time and can reach the injection scale of turbulence after around eight largest eddy-turnover times given sufficiently low ionization fraction and weak initial magnetic field. Due to the weak coupling between ions and neutrals, most turbulent energy carried by neutrals cannot be converted to the magnetic energy, resulting in a relatively weak magnetic field at the end of dynamo. This result has important implications for the growth of magnetic fields in the partially ionized interstellar medium and shock acceleration of Galactic cosmic rays.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
General Relativistic Numerical Simulation of sub-Keplerian Transonic Accretion Flows onto Rotating Black Holes: Kerr Spacetime
Authors:
Jinho Kim,
Sudip K. Garain,
Sandip K. Chakrabarti,
Dinshaw S. Balsara
Abstract:
We study time evolution of sub-Keplerian transonic accretion flows onto black holes using a general relativistic numerical simulation code. We perform simulations around the black holes having non-zero rotation. We first compare one-dimensional simulation results with theoretical results and validate the performance of our code. Next, we present results of axisymmetric, two-dimensional simulation…
▽ More
We study time evolution of sub-Keplerian transonic accretion flows onto black holes using a general relativistic numerical simulation code. We perform simulations around the black holes having non-zero rotation. We first compare one-dimensional simulation results with theoretical results and validate the performance of our code. Next, we present results of axisymmetric, two-dimensional simulation of advective flows. In the literature, there is no solution which describes steady shock solutions in two dimensions. However, our simulations produce these centrifugal force supported steady shock waves even in presence of strong dragging of inertial frames. Since the post-shock region could be hot and upscatter photons through Comptonization, these shock would put imprints on the spectra. Thus, our solutions, which represent truly new results, could be useful to measure spins through radiation spectrum of accreting Kerr black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Images and Spectra of Time Dependent Two Component Advective Flow in Presence of Outflows
Authors:
Arka Chatterjee,
Sandip K. Chakrabarti,
Himadri Ghosh,
Sudip K. Garain
Abstract:
Two Component Advective Flow (TCAF) successfully explains the spectral and tem- poral properties of outbursting or persistent sources. Images of static TCAF with Compton cloud or CENtrifugal pressure supported Boundary Layer (CENBOL) due to gravitational bending of photons have been studied before. In this paper, we study time dependent images of advective flows around a Schwarzschild black hole w…
▽ More
Two Component Advective Flow (TCAF) successfully explains the spectral and tem- poral properties of outbursting or persistent sources. Images of static TCAF with Compton cloud or CENtrifugal pressure supported Boundary Layer (CENBOL) due to gravitational bending of photons have been studied before. In this paper, we study time dependent images of advective flows around a Schwarzschild black hole which include cooling effects due to Comptonization of soft photons from a Keplerian disks well as the self-consistently produced jets and outflows. We show the overall image of the disk-jet system after convolving with a typical beamwidth. A long exposure image with time dependent system need not show the black hole horizon conspicuously, un- less one is looking at a soft state with no jet or the system along the jet axis. Assuming these disk-jet configurations are relevant to radio emitting systems also, our results would be useful to look for event horizons in high accretion rate Supermassive Black Holes in Seyfert galaxies, RL Quasars.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2018; v1 submitted 28 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
General Relativistic Numerical Simulation of sub-Keplerian Transonic Accretion Flows onto Black Holes: Schwarzschild Spacetime
Authors:
Jinho Kim,
Sudip K. Garain,
Dinshaw S. Balsara,
Sandip K. Chakrabarti
Abstract:
We study time evolution of sub-Keplerian transonic accretion flows onto black holes using a general relativistic numerical simulation code. We perform simulations in Schwarzschild spacetime. We first compare one-dimensional simulation results with theoretical results and validate the performance of our code. Next, we present results of axisymmetric, two-dimensional simulation of advective flows. W…
▽ More
We study time evolution of sub-Keplerian transonic accretion flows onto black holes using a general relativistic numerical simulation code. We perform simulations in Schwarzschild spacetime. We first compare one-dimensional simulation results with theoretical results and validate the performance of our code. Next, we present results of axisymmetric, two-dimensional simulation of advective flows. We find that even in this case, for which no complete theoretical analysis is present in the literature, steady state shock formation is possible.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Segregation of a Keplerian disc and sub-Keplerian halo from a Transonic flow around a Black Hole by Viscosity and Cooling processes
Authors:
Kinsuk Giri,
Sudip K. Garain,
Sandip K. Chakrabarti
Abstract:
A black hole accretion is necessarily transonic. In presence of sufficiently high viscosity and cooling effects, a low-angular momentum transonic flow can become a standard Keplerian disc except close to the where hole where it must pass through the inner sonic point. However, if the viscosity is not high everywhere and cooling is not efficient everywhere, the flow cannot completely become a Keple…
▽ More
A black hole accretion is necessarily transonic. In presence of sufficiently high viscosity and cooling effects, a low-angular momentum transonic flow can become a standard Keplerian disc except close to the where hole where it must pass through the inner sonic point. However, if the viscosity is not high everywhere and cooling is not efficient everywhere, the flow cannot completely become a Keplerian disc. In this paper, we show results of rigorous numerical simulations of a transonic flow having vertically varying viscosity parameter (being highest on the equatorial plane) and optical depth dependent cooling processes to show that the flow indeed segregates into two distinct components as it approaches a black hole. The component on the equatorial plane has properties of a standard Keplerian disc, though the flow is not truncated at the inner- most stable circular orbit. This component extends till the horizon as a sub-Keplerian flow. This standard disc is found to be surrounded by a hot, low angular momentum component forming a centrifugal barrier dominated oscillating shock wave, consistent with the Chakrabarti-Titarchuk two component advective flow configuration.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Numerical Simulation Of Spectral And Timing Properties Of Galactic Black Holes
Authors:
Sudip Kumar Garain
Abstract:
A black hole accretion may have both the Keplerian and the sub-Keplerian components. We consider the most general accretion flow configuration, namely, two-component advective flow (TCAF) in which the Keplerian disk is immersed inside a low angular momentum, accreting sub-Keplerian halo component around a black hole. Low energy (soft) photons from the Keplerian component and hot electrons in the s…
▽ More
A black hole accretion may have both the Keplerian and the sub-Keplerian components. We consider the most general accretion flow configuration, namely, two-component advective flow (TCAF) in which the Keplerian disk is immersed inside a low angular momentum, accreting sub-Keplerian halo component around a black hole. Low energy (soft) photons from the Keplerian component and hot electrons in the sub-Keplerian component exchange their energy through Comptonization or inverse-Comptonization processes. In the sub-Keplerian component, a shock is generally formed due to the centrifugal force. The post-shock region is known as the CENtrifugal pressure dominated BOundary Layer (CENBOL). The spectral and the timing properties of TCAF have been extensively studied using mostly analytical and some time dependent numerical simulations since the model was proposed by Chakrabarti & Titarchuk in 1995. The findings are the key inputs of understanding several observed features of black hole candidates. In this thesis, using numerical simulation, we rigorously prove some of the conjectures of the TCAF model. In the work presented in this thesis, we have considered for the first time the presence of both the Keplerian and the sub-Keplerian flow in a single simulation. The Keplerian disk resides on the equatorial plane and is the standard disk from which low energy photons having multi-color blackbody spectrum is emitted. The hydrodynamics as well as the thermal properties of the sub-Keplerian halo are simulated using a finite difference code which uses the principle of total variation diminishing (TVD). The Comptonization between the photons and the hot electrons is simulated using a Monte Carlo code. These two codes are then coupled and the resulting localized heating and cooling are included in the coupled code. Using this code, we study the spectral and timing properties of the TCAF.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Numerical Simulation of Spectral and Timing Properties of a Two Component Advective Flow around a Black Hole
Authors:
Sudip K Garain,
Himadri Ghosh,
Sandip K Chakrabarti
Abstract:
We study the spectral and timing properties of a two component advective flow (TCAF) around a black hole by numerical simulation. Several cases have been simulated by varying the Keplerian disk rate and the resulting spectra and lightcurves have been produced for all the cases. The dependence of the spectral states and quasi-periodic oscillation (QPO) frequencies on the flow parameters is discusse…
▽ More
We study the spectral and timing properties of a two component advective flow (TCAF) around a black hole by numerical simulation. Several cases have been simulated by varying the Keplerian disk rate and the resulting spectra and lightcurves have been produced for all the cases. The dependence of the spectral states and quasi-periodic oscillation (QPO) frequencies on the flow parameters is discussed. We also find the earlier explanation of arising of QPOs as the resonance between infall time scale and cooling time scale remain valid even for Compton cooling.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Quasi Periodic Oscillations in a Radiative Transonic Flow: Results of a Coupled Monte Carlo-TVD Simulation
Authors:
Sudip K. Garain,
Himadri Ghosh,
Sandip K. Chakrabarti
Abstract:
Low and intermediate frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) in black hole candidates are believed to be due to oscillations of the Comptonizing regions in an accretion flow. Assuming that the general structure of an accretion disk is a Two Component Advective Flow (TCAF), we numerically simulate the light curves emitted from an accretion disk for different accretion rates and find how the QP…
▽ More
Low and intermediate frequency quasi-periodic oscillations (QPOs) in black hole candidates are believed to be due to oscillations of the Comptonizing regions in an accretion flow. Assuming that the general structure of an accretion disk is a Two Component Advective Flow (TCAF), we numerically simulate the light curves emitted from an accretion disk for different accretion rates and find how the QPO frequencies vary. We use a standard Keplerian disk residing at the equatorial plane as a source of soft photons. These soft photons, after suffering multiple scattering with the hot electrons of the low angular momentum, sub-Keplerian, flow emerge out as hard radiation. The hydrodynamic and thermal properties of the electron cloud is simulated using a Total Variation Diminishing (TVD) code. The TVD code is then coupled with a radiative transfer code which simulates the energy exchange between the electron and radiation using Monte Carlo technique. The resulting localized heating and cooling are included also. We find that the QPO frequency increases and the spectrum becomes softer as we increase the Keplerian disk rate. However, the spectrum becomes harder if we increase the sub-Keplerian accretion rate. We find that an earlier prediction that QPOs occur when the infall time scale roughly matches with the cooling time scale, originally obtained using a power-law cooling, remains valid even for Compton cooling. Our findings agree with the general observations of low frequency QPOs in black hole candidates.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Effects of Compton Cooling on outflows in a Two Component Accretion Flow around a Black Hole: Results of a Coupled Monte Carlo-TVD Simulation
Authors:
Sudip K. Garain,
Himadri Ghosh. Sandip K. Chakrabarti
Abstract:
The effect of cooling on the outflow rate from an accretion disk around a black hole is investigated using a coupled Monte Carlo Total Variation Diminishing code. A correlation between the spectral states and the outflow rates is found as a consequence.
The effect of cooling on the outflow rate from an accretion disk around a black hole is investigated using a coupled Monte Carlo Total Variation Diminishing code. A correlation between the spectral states and the outflow rates is found as a consequence.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Effects of Compton Cooling on Outflow in a Two Component Accretion Flow around a Black Hole: Results of a Coupled Monte Carlo-TVD Simulation
Authors:
Sudip K. Garain,
Himadri Ghosh,
Sandip K. Chakrabarti
Abstract:
We wish to investigate the effects of cooling of the Compton cloud on the outflow formation rate in an accretion disk around a black hole. We carry out a time dependent numerical simulation where both the hydrodynamics and the radiative transfer processes are coupled together. We consider a two-component accretion flow in which the Keplerian disk is immersed into an accreting low-angular momentum…
▽ More
We wish to investigate the effects of cooling of the Compton cloud on the outflow formation rate in an accretion disk around a black hole. We carry out a time dependent numerical simulation where both the hydrodynamics and the radiative transfer processes are coupled together. We consider a two-component accretion flow in which the Keplerian disk is immersed into an accreting low-angular momentum flow (halo) around a black hole. The soft photons which originate from the Keplerian disk are inverse-Comptonized by the electrons in the halo and the region between the centrifugal pressure supported shocks and the horizon. We run several cases by changing the rate of the Keplerian disk and see the effects on the shock location and properties of the outflow and the spectrum. We show that as a result of Comptonization of the Compton cloud, the cloud becomes cooler with the increase in the Keplerian disk rate. As the resultant thermal pressure is reduced, the post-shock region collapses and the outflow rate is also reduced. Since the hard radiation is produced from the post-shock region, and the spectral slope increases with the reduction of the electron temperature, the cooling produces softer spectrum. We thus find a direct correlation between the spectral states and the outflow rates of an accreting black hole.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Effects of Compton Cooling on the Hydrodynamic and the Spectral Properties of a Two Component Accretion Flow around a Black Hole
Authors:
Himadri Ghosh,
Sudip K. Garain,
Kinsuk Giri,
Sandip K. Chakrabarti
Abstract:
We carry out a time dependent numerical simulation where both the hydrodynamics and the radiative transfer are coupled together. We consider a two-component accretion flow in which the Keplerian disk is immersed inside an accreting low angular momentum flow (halo) around a black hole. The injected soft photons from the Keplerian disk are reprocessed by the electrons in the halo. We show that in pr…
▽ More
We carry out a time dependent numerical simulation where both the hydrodynamics and the radiative transfer are coupled together. We consider a two-component accretion flow in which the Keplerian disk is immersed inside an accreting low angular momentum flow (halo) around a black hole. The injected soft photons from the Keplerian disk are reprocessed by the electrons in the halo. We show that in presence of an axisymmetric soft-photon source, the spherically symmetric Bondi flow losses its symmetry and becomes axisymmetric. The low angular momentum flow was observed to slow down close to the axis and formed a centrifugal barrier which added new features into the spectrum. Using the Monte Carlo method, we generated the radiated spectra as functions of the accretion rates. We find that the transitions from a hard state to a soft state is determined by the mass accretion rates of the disk and the halo. We separate out the signature of the bulk motion Comptonization and discuss its significance. We study how the net spectrum is contributed by photons suffering different number of scatterings and spending different amounts of time inside the Compton cloud. We study the directional dependence of the emitted spectrum as well.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
Monte-Carlo Simulations of Thermal Comptonization Process in a Two Component Accretion Flow Around a Black Hole in presence of an Outflow
Authors:
Himadri Ghosh,
Sudip K. Garain,
Sandip K. Chakrabarti,
Philippe Laurent
Abstract:
A black hole accretion may have both the Keplerian and the sub-Keplerian component. In the so-called Chakrabarti-Titarchuk scenario, the Keplerian component supplies low energy (soft) photons while the sub-Keplerian component supplies hot electrons which exchange their energy with the soft photons through Comptonization or inverse Comptonization processes. In the sub-Keplerian component, a shock i…
▽ More
A black hole accretion may have both the Keplerian and the sub-Keplerian component. In the so-called Chakrabarti-Titarchuk scenario, the Keplerian component supplies low energy (soft) photons while the sub-Keplerian component supplies hot electrons which exchange their energy with the soft photons through Comptonization or inverse Comptonization processes. In the sub-Keplerian component, a shock is generally produced due to the centrifugal force. The postshock region is known as the CENtrifugal pressure-supported BOundary Layer (CENBOL). In this paper, we compute the effects of the thermal and the bulk motion Comptonization on the soft photons emitted from a Keplerian disk by the CENBOL, the preshock sub-Keplerian disk and the outflowing jet. We study the emerging spectrum when the converging inflow and the diverging outflow (generated from the CENBOL) are simultaneously present. From the strength of the shock, we calculate the percentage of matter being carried away by the outflow and determine how the emerging spectrum depends on the outflow rate. The preshock sub-Keplerian flow is also found to Comptonize the soft photons significantly. The interplay between the up-scattering and down-scattering effects determines the effective shape of the emerging spectrum. By simulating several cases with various inflow parameters, we conclude that whether the preshock flow, or the postshock CENBOL or the emerging jet is dominant in shaping the emerging spectrum depends strongly on the geometry of the flow and the strength of the shock in the sub-Keplerian flow.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
