Showing 1–50 of 140 results for author: Frenkel, D

Simulations of DNA-origami self-assembly reveal design-dependent nucleation barriers

Authors: Alexander Cumberworth, Daan Frenkel, Aleks Reinhardt

Abstract: Nucleation is the rate-determining step in the kinetics of many self-assembly processes. However, the importance of nucleation in the kinetics of DNA-origami self-assembly, which involves both the binding of staple strands and the folding of the scaffold strand, is unclear. Here, using Monte Carlo simulations of a lattice model of DNA origami, we find that some, but not all, designs can have a nuc… ▽ More Nucleation is the rate-determining step in the kinetics of many self-assembly processes. However, the importance of nucleation in the kinetics of DNA-origami self-assembly, which involves both the binding of staple strands and the folding of the scaffold strand, is unclear. Here, using Monte Carlo simulations of a lattice model of DNA origami, we find that some, but not all, designs can have a nucleation barrier and that this barrier disappears at lower temperatures, rationalizing the success of isothermal assembly. We show that the height of the nucleation barrier depends primarily on the coaxial stacking of staples that are adjacent on the same helix, a parameter that can be modified with staple design. Creating a nucleation barrier to DNA-origami assembly could be useful in optimizing assembly times and yields, while eliminating the barrier may allow for fast molecular sensors that can assemble/disassemble without hysteresis in response to changes in the environment. △ Less

Submitted 21 March, 2023; v1 submitted 5 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 28 pages, 17 figures, accepted in Nano Letters with improved text and figure accessibility

Journal ref: Nano Lett. 22, 6916 (2022)

Temperature Protocols to Guide Selective Self-Assembly of Competing Structures

Authors: Arunkumar Bupathy, Daan Frenkel, Srikanth Sastry

Abstract: Multi-component self-assembly mixtures offer the possibility of encoding multiple target structures with the same set of interacting components. Selective retrieval of one of the stored structures has been attempted by preparing an initial state that favours the assembly of the required target, through seeding, concentration patterning or specific choices of interaction strengths. This may not be… ▽ More Multi-component self-assembly mixtures offer the possibility of encoding multiple target structures with the same set of interacting components. Selective retrieval of one of the stored structures has been attempted by preparing an initial state that favours the assembly of the required target, through seeding, concentration patterning or specific choices of interaction strengths. This may not be possible in an experiment where on-the-fly reconfiguration of the building blocks to switch functionality may be required. In this paper, we explore principles of inverse design of a multi-component self-assembly mixture capable of encoding two competing structures that can be selected through simple temperature protocols. We design the target structures to realise the generic situation in which one of targets has the lower nucleation barrier while the other is globally more stable. We observe that to avoid the formation of spurious or chimeric aggregates, the number of neighbouring component pairs that occur in both structures should be minimal. Our design also requires the inclusion of components that are part only of one of the target structures, but we observe that to maximize the selectivity of retrieval, the component library itself should be maximally shared by the two targets. We demonstrate that temperature protocols can be designed which lead to the formation of either one of the target structures with high selectivity. We discuss the important role played by secondary aggregation products, which we term vestigial aggregates. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2021; originally announced October 2021.

Challenges in modelling diffusiophoretic transport

Authors: Simón Ramírez-Hinestrosa, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: The methodology to simulate transport phenomena in bulk systems is well-established. In contrast, there is no clear consensus about the choice of techniques to model cross-transport phenomena and phoretic transport, mainly because some of the hydrodynamic descriptions are incomplete from a thermodynamic point of view. In the present paper, we use a unified framework to describe diffusio-osmosis(ph… ▽ More The methodology to simulate transport phenomena in bulk systems is well-established. In contrast, there is no clear consensus about the choice of techniques to model cross-transport phenomena and phoretic transport, mainly because some of the hydrodynamic descriptions are incomplete from a thermodynamic point of view. In the present paper, we use a unified framework to describe diffusio-osmosis(phoresis), and we report non-equilibrium Molecular Dynamics (NEMD) on such systems. We explore different simulation methods to highlight some of the technical problems that arise in the calculations. For diffusiophoresis, we use two NEMD methods: boundary-driven and field-driven. Although the two methods should be equivalent in the limit of very weak gradients, we find that finite Peclet-number effects are much stronger in boundary-driven flows than in the case where we apply fictitious color forces. △ Less

Submitted 7 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Thermodynamics and kinetics of crystallisation in deeply supercooled Stillinger-Weber silicon

Authors: Yagyik Goswami, Vishwas V. Vasisht, Daan Frenkel, Pablo G. Debenedetti, Srikanth Sastry

Abstract: We study the kinetics of crystallization in deeply supercooled liquid silicon employing computer simulations and the Stillinger-Weber three body potential. The free energy barriers to crystallisation are computed using umbrella sampling Monte Carlo simulations, and for selected low temperature and zero pressure state points, using unconstrained molecular dynamics simulations to reconstruct the fre… ▽ More We study the kinetics of crystallization in deeply supercooled liquid silicon employing computer simulations and the Stillinger-Weber three body potential. The free energy barriers to crystallisation are computed using umbrella sampling Monte Carlo simulations, and for selected low temperature and zero pressure state points, using unconstrained molecular dynamics simulations to reconstruct the free energy from a mean first passage time formulation. We focus on state points that have been described in earlier work [Sastry and Angell, Nature Mater., 2, 739, 2003] as straddling a first order liquid-liquid phase transition (LLPT) between two metastable liquid states. It was argued subsequently [Ricci et al., Mol. Phys., 117, 3254, 2019] that the apparent phase transition is in fact due the loss of metastability of the liquid state with respect to the globally stable crystalline state. The presence or absence of a barrier to crystallization for these state points is therefore of importance to ascertain, with due attention to ambiguities that may arise from the choice of order parameters. We discuss our choice of order parameters and also our choice of methods to calculate the free energy at deep supercooling. We find a well-defined free energy barrier to crystallisation and demonstrate that both umbrella sampling and mean first passage time methods yield results that agree quantitatively. Our results thus provide strong evidence against the possibility that the liquids at state points close to the reported LLPT exhibit slow, spontaneous crystallisation, but they do not address the existence of a LLPT (or lack thereof). We also compute the free energy barriers to crystallisation at other state points over a broad range of temperatures and pressures, and discuss the effect of changes in the microscopic structure of the metastable liquid on the free energy barrier heights. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Estimation of the equilibrium free energy for glasses using the Jarzynski equality

Authors: H. A. Vinutha, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: The free energy of glasses cannot be estimated using thermodynamic integration, as glasses are intrinsically not in equilibrium. We present numerical simulations showing that, in contrast, plausible free-energy estimates of a Kob-Andersen glass can be obtained using the Jarzynski relation. Using the Jarzynski relation, we also compute the chemical potential difference of the two components of this… ▽ More The free energy of glasses cannot be estimated using thermodynamic integration, as glasses are intrinsically not in equilibrium. We present numerical simulations showing that, in contrast, plausible free-energy estimates of a Kob-Andersen glass can be obtained using the Jarzynski relation. Using the Jarzynski relation, we also compute the chemical potential difference of the two components of this system, and find that, in the glassy regime, the Jarzynski estimate matches well with the extrapolated value of the supercooled liquid. Our findings are of broader interest as they show that the Jarzynski method can be used under conditions where the thermodynamic integration approach, which is normally more accurate, breaks down completely. Systems where such an approach might be useful are gels and jammed, glassy structures formed by compression. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 4 pages, 2 figures

Heterogeneous versus homogeneous crystal nucleation in hard spheres

Authors: Jorge R. Espinosa, Carlos Vega, Chantal Valeriani, Daan Frenkel, Eduardo Sanz

Abstract: Hard-sphere model systems are well-suited in both experiment and simulations to investigate fundamental aspects of the crystallization of fluids. In experiments on colloidal models of hard-sphere fluids, the uid is unavoidably at contact with the walls of the sample cell, where heterogeneous crystallization may take place. In this work we use simulations to investigate the competition between homo… ▽ More Hard-sphere model systems are well-suited in both experiment and simulations to investigate fundamental aspects of the crystallization of fluids. In experiments on colloidal models of hard-sphere fluids, the uid is unavoidably at contact with the walls of the sample cell, where heterogeneous crystallization may take place. In this work we use simulations to investigate the competition between homogeneous and heterogeneous crystallization. We report simulations of wall-induced nucleation for different confining walls. Combining the results of these simulations with earlier studies of homogeneous allows us to asses the competition between homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation as a function of wall type, fluid density and the system size. On at walls, heterogeneous nucleation will typically overwhelm homogeneous nucleation. However, even for surfaces randomly coated with spheres with a diameter that was some three times larger than that of the fluid spheres - as has been used in some experiments - heterogeneous nucleation is likely to be dominant for volume fractions smaller than 0.535. Only for a disordered coating that has the same structure as the liquid holds promise did we find the nucleation was likely to occur in the bulk. Hence, such coatings might be used to suppress heterogeneous nucleation in experiments. Finally, we report the apparent homogeneous nucleation rate taking into account the formation of crystallites both in the bulk and at the walls. We find that the apparent overall nucleation rates coincides with those reported in "homogeneous nucleation" experiments. This suggests that heterogeneous nucleation at the walls could partly explain the large discrepancies found between experimental measurements and simulation estimates of the homogeneous nucleation rate. △ Less

Submitted 27 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Journal ref: Soft Matter, 15 (47), 9625-9631 (2019)

Reduced variance analysis of molecular dynamics simulations by linear combination of estimators

Authors: Samuel W. Coles, Etienne Mangaud, Daan Frenkel, Benjamin Rotenberg

Abstract: Building upon recent developments of force-based estimators with a reduced variance for the computation of densities, radial distribution functions or local transport properties from molecular simulations, we show that the variance can be further reduced by considering optimal linear combinations of such estimators. This control variates approach, well known in Statistics and already used in other… ▽ More Building upon recent developments of force-based estimators with a reduced variance for the computation of densities, radial distribution functions or local transport properties from molecular simulations, we show that the variance can be further reduced by considering optimal linear combinations of such estimators. This control variates approach, well known in Statistics and already used in other branches of computational Physics, has been comparatively much less exploited in molecular simulations. We illustrate this idea on the radial distribution function and the one-dimensional density of a bulk and confined Lennard-Jones fluid, where the optimal combination of estimators is determined for each distance or position, respectively. In addition to reducing the variance everywhere at virtually no additional cost, this approach cures an artefact of the initial force-based estimators, namely small but non-zero values of the quantities in regions where they should vanish. Beyond the examples considered here, the present work highlights more generally the underexplored potential of control variates to estimate observables from molecular simulations. △ Less

Submitted 22 April, 2021; v1 submitted 11 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 4 Pages and 2 Figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 154, 191101 (2021)

Computation of the chemical potential and solubility of amorphous solids

Authors: H. A. Vinutha, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Using a recently developed technique to estimate the equilibrium free energy of glassy materials, we explore if equilibrium simulation methods can be used to estimate the solubility of amorphous solids. As an illustration, we compute the chemical potentials of the constituent particles of a two-component Kob-Andersen model glass former. To compute the chemical potential for different components, w… ▽ More Using a recently developed technique to estimate the equilibrium free energy of glassy materials, we explore if equilibrium simulation methods can be used to estimate the solubility of amorphous solids. As an illustration, we compute the chemical potentials of the constituent particles of a two-component Kob-Andersen model glass former. To compute the chemical potential for different components, we combine the calculation of the overall free energy of the glass with a calculation of the chemical potential difference of the two components. We find that the standard method to compute chemical potential differences by thermodynamic integration yields not only a wide scatter in the chemical potential values but, more seriously, the average of the thermodynamic integration results is well above the extrapolated value for the supercooled liquid. However, we find that if we compute the difference of the chemical potential of the components with the the non-equilibrium free energy expression proposed by Jarzynski, we obtain a good match with the extrapolated value of the supercooled liquid. The extension of the Jarzynski method that we propose opens a potentially powerful route to compute free-energy related equilibrium properties of glasses. We find that the solubility estimate of amorphous materials obtained from direct coexistence simulations is only in fair agreement with the solubility prediction based on the chemical potential calculations of a hypothetical "well-equilibrated glass". In direct coexistence simulations, we find that, in qualitative agreement with experiments, the amorphous solubility decreases with time and attains a low solubility value. △ Less

Submitted 9 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 8 pages, 3 figures

Nano-Pump base on Exothermic Surface Reactions

Authors: Shaltiel Eloul, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We present simulations indicating that it should be possible to construct a switchable nano-scale fluid pump, driven by exothermic surface reactions. Such a pump could, for instance, be controlled electro-chemically. In our simulations we explore a simple illustration of such a pump. We argue that the simplicity of the pump design could make it attractive for micro/nano-fluidics applications. We present simulations indicating that it should be possible to construct a switchable nano-scale fluid pump, driven by exothermic surface reactions. Such a pump could, for instance, be controlled electro-chemically. In our simulations we explore a simple illustration of such a pump. We argue that the simplicity of the pump design could make it attractive for micro/nano-fluidics applications. △ Less

Submitted 29 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Numerical method for computing the free energy of glasses

Authors: H. A. Vinutha, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We propose a numerical technique to compute the equilibrium free energy of glasses that cannot be prepared quasi-reversibly. For such systems, standard techniques for estimating the free energy by extrapolation, cannot be used. Instead, we use a procedure that samples the equilibrium partition function of the basins of attraction of the different inherent structures (local potential energy minima)… ▽ More We propose a numerical technique to compute the equilibrium free energy of glasses that cannot be prepared quasi-reversibly. For such systems, standard techniques for estimating the free energy by extrapolation, cannot be used. Instead, we use a procedure that samples the equilibrium partition function of the basins of attraction of the different inherent structures (local potential energy minima) of the system. If all relevant inherent structures could be adequately sampled in the (supercooled) liquid phase, our approach would be rigorous. In any finite simulation, we will miss the lower-energy inherent structures that become dominant at very low temperatures. We find that our free energy estimates for a Kob-Andersen glass are lower than those obtained by very slow cooling, even at temperatures down to one third of the glass transition temperature. The current approach could be applied to compute the chemical potential of ultra-stable glassy materials, and should enable the estimation of their solubility. △ Less

Submitted 12 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 102, 063303 (2020)

Using Molecular Simulation to Compute Transport Coefficients of Molecular Gases

Authors: Xipeng Wang, Simón Ramírez-Hinestrosa, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: The existing kinetic theory of gases is based on an analytical approach that becomes intractable for all but the simplest molecules. Here we propose a simple numerical scheme to compute the transport properties of molecular gases in the limit of infinite dilution. The approach that we propose is approximate, but our results for the diffusivity $D$, the viscosity $η$ and the thermal conductivity… ▽ More The existing kinetic theory of gases is based on an analytical approach that becomes intractable for all but the simplest molecules. Here we propose a simple numerical scheme to compute the transport properties of molecular gases in the limit of infinite dilution. The approach that we propose is approximate, but our results for the diffusivity $D$, the viscosity $η$ and the thermal conductivity $λ$ of hard spheres, Lennard-Jones particles and rough hard spheres, agree well with the standard (lowest order) Chapman-Enskog results. We also present results for a Lennard-Jones-dimer model for nitrogen, for which no analytical results are available. In the case of poly-atomic molecules (we consider n-octane), our method remains simple and gives good predictions for the diffusivity and the viscosity. Computing the thermal conductivity of poly-atomic molecules requires an approximate treatment of their quantized internal modes. We show that a well-known approximation that relates $λ$ to $D$ and $η$, yields good results. We note that our approach should yield a lower limit to the exact value of $D$, $η$ and $λ$. Interestingly, the most sophisticated (higher-order) Chapman-Enskog results for rough hard spheres seem to violate this bound. △ Less

Submitted 22 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Computing the heat conductivity of fluids from density fluctuations

Authors: Bingqing Cheng, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations, in combination with the Green-Kubo (GK) method, have been extensively used to compute the thermal conductivity of liquids. However, the GK method relies on an ambiguous definition of the microscopic heat flux, which depends on how one chooses to distribute energies over atoms. This ambiguity makes it problematic to employ the GK method for systems with n… ▽ More Equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations, in combination with the Green-Kubo (GK) method, have been extensively used to compute the thermal conductivity of liquids. However, the GK method relies on an ambiguous definition of the microscopic heat flux, which depends on how one chooses to distribute energies over atoms. This ambiguity makes it problematic to employ the GK method for systems with non-pairwise interactions. In this work, we show that the hydrodynamic description of thermally driven density fluctuations can be used to obtain the thermal conductivity of a bulk fluid unambiguously, thereby bypassing the need to define the heat flux. We verify that, for a model fluid with only pairwise interactions, our method yields estimates of thermal conductivity consistent with the GK approach. We apply our approach to compute the thermal conductivity of a non-pairwise additive water model at supercritical conditions, and then of a liquid hydrogen system described by a machine-learning interatomic potential, at 33 GPa and 2000 K. △ Less

Submitted 15 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 130602 (2020)

Effect of the interaction strength and anisotropy on the diffusio-phoresis of spherical colloids

Authors: Jiachen Wei, Simón Ramírez-Hinestrosa, Jure Dobnikar, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Gradients in temperature, concentration or electrostatic potential cannot exert forces on a bulk fluid; they can, however, exert forces on a fluid in a microscopic boundary layer surrounding a (nano)colloidal solute, resulting in so-called phoretic flow. Here we present a simulation study of phoretic flow around a spherical colloid held fixed in a concentration gradient. We show that the resulting… ▽ More Gradients in temperature, concentration or electrostatic potential cannot exert forces on a bulk fluid; they can, however, exert forces on a fluid in a microscopic boundary layer surrounding a (nano)colloidal solute, resulting in so-called phoretic flow. Here we present a simulation study of phoretic flow around a spherical colloid held fixed in a concentration gradient. We show that the resulting flow velocity depends non-monotonically on the strength of the colloid-fluid interaction. The reason for this non-monotonic dependence is that solute particles are effectively trapped in a shell around the colloid and cannot contribute to diffusio-phoresis. We also observe that the flow depends sensitively on the anisotropy of solute-colloid interaction. △ Less

Submitted 22 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

'Rocket propulsion' of Janus micro-swimmers

Authors: Shaltiel Eloul, Wilson C K Poon, Oded Farago, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We report simulations of a spherical Janus particle undergoing exothermic surface reactions around one pole only. Our model excludes self-phoretic transport by design. Nevertheless, net motion occurs from direct momentum transfer between solvent and colloid, with speed scaling as the square root of the energy released during the reaction. We find that such propulsion is dominated by the system's s… ▽ More We report simulations of a spherical Janus particle undergoing exothermic surface reactions around one pole only. Our model excludes self-phoretic transport by design. Nevertheless, net motion occurs from direct momentum transfer between solvent and colloid, with speed scaling as the square root of the energy released during the reaction. We find that such propulsion is dominated by the system's short-time response, when neither the time dependence of the flow around the colloid nor the solvent compressibility can be ignored. Our simulations agree reasonably well with previous experiments. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 188001 (2020)

Information density, structure and entropy in equilibrium and non-equilibrium systems

Authors: Mengjie Zu, Arunkumar Bupathy, Daan Frenkel, Srikanth Sastry

Abstract: During a spontaneous change, a macroscopic physical system will evolve towards a macro-state with more realizations. This observation is at the basis of the Statistical Mechanical version of the Second Law of Thermodynamics, and it provides an interpretation of entropy in terms of probabilities. However, we cannot rely on the statistical-mechanical expressions for entropy in systems that are far f… ▽ More During a spontaneous change, a macroscopic physical system will evolve towards a macro-state with more realizations. This observation is at the basis of the Statistical Mechanical version of the Second Law of Thermodynamics, and it provides an interpretation of entropy in terms of probabilities. However, we cannot rely on the statistical-mechanical expressions for entropy in systems that are far from equilibrium. In this paper, we compare various extensions of the definition of entropy, which have been proposed for non-equilibrium systems. It has recently been proposed that measures of information density may serve to quantify entropy in both equilibrium and nonequilibrium systems. We propose a new "bit-wise" method to measure the information density for off lattice systems. This method does not rely on coarse-graining of the particle coordinates. We then compare different estimates of the system entropy, based on information density and on the structural properties of the system, and check if the various entropies are mutually consistent and, importantly, whether they can detect non-trivial ordering phenomena. We find that, except for simple (one-dimensional) cases, the different methods yield answers that are at best qualitatively similar, and often not even that, although in several cases, different entropy estimates do detect ordering phenomena qualitatively. Our entropy estimates based on bit-wise data compression contain no adjustable scaling factor, and show large quantitative differences with the thermodynamic entropy obtained from equilibrium simulations. Hence, our results suggest that, at present, there is not yet a single, structure-based entropy definition that has general validity for equilibrium and non equilibrium systems. △ Less

Submitted 9 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

The Lennard-Jones potential: when (not) to use it

Authors: Xipeng Wang, Simòn Ramírez-Hinestrosa, Jure Dobnikar, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: The Lennard-Jones 12-6 potential (LJ) is arguably the most widely used pair potential in Molecular Simulations. In fact, it is so popular that the question is rarely asked whether it is fit for purpose. In this paper, we argue that, whilst the LJ potential was designed for noble gases such as argon, it is often used for systems where it is not expected to be particularly realistic. Under those cir… ▽ More The Lennard-Jones 12-6 potential (LJ) is arguably the most widely used pair potential in Molecular Simulations. In fact, it is so popular that the question is rarely asked whether it is fit for purpose. In this paper, we argue that, whilst the LJ potential was designed for noble gases such as argon, it is often used for systems where it is not expected to be particularly realistic. Under those circumstances, the disadvantages of the LJ potential become relevant: most important among these is that in simulations the LJ potential is always modified such that it has a finite range. More seriously, there is by now a whole family of different potentials that are all called Lennard-Jones 12-6, and that are all different - and that may have very different macroscopic properties. In this paper, we consider alternatives to the LJ 12-6 potential that could be employed under conditions where the LJ potential is only used as a typical short-ranged potential with attraction. We construct a class of potentials that are, in many respects LJ-like but that are by construction finite ranged, vanishing quadratically at the cut-off distance, and that are designed to be computationally cheap. Below, we present this potential and report numerical data for its thermodynamic and transport properties, for the most important cases: cut-off distance rc=2 (LJ-like) and rc=1.2 (a typical colloidal potential). △ Less

Submitted 15 October, 2019; v1 submitted 13 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Studying polymer diffusiophoresis with Non-Equilibrium Molecular Dynamics

Authors: Simón Ramírez-Hinestrosa, Hiroaki Yoshida, Lydéric Bocquet, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We report a numerical study of the diffusiophoresis of short polymers using non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations. More precisely, we consider polymer chains in a fluid containing a solute which has a concentration gradient, and examine the variation of the induced diffusiophoretic velocity of the polymer chains as the interaction between the monomer and the solute is varied. We find that… ▽ More We report a numerical study of the diffusiophoresis of short polymers using non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations. More precisely, we consider polymer chains in a fluid containing a solute which has a concentration gradient, and examine the variation of the induced diffusiophoretic velocity of the polymer chains as the interaction between the monomer and the solute is varied. We find that there is a non-monotonic relation between the diffusiophoretic mobility and the strength of the monomer-solute interaction. In addition we find a weak dependence of the mobility on the length of the polymer chain, which shows clear difference from the diffusiophoresis of a solid particle. Interestingly, the hydrodynamic flow through the polymer is much less screened than for pressure driven flows. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2020; v1 submitted 13 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comparing Theory and Simulation for Thermo-osmosis

Authors: Karel Proesmans, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We report a numerical study of thermo-osmotic slip, i.e. the particle flux induced by a thermal gradient along a solid-fluid interface. To facilitate comparison with theory, we consider a model of an ideal but viscous gas. We compare three numerical routes to obtain the slip coefficient: 1. by using the Onsager reciprocity relations 2. by using the appropriate Green-Kubo relation 3. via the excess… ▽ More We report a numerical study of thermo-osmotic slip, i.e. the particle flux induced by a thermal gradient along a solid-fluid interface. To facilitate comparison with theory, we consider a model of an ideal but viscous gas. We compare three numerical routes to obtain the slip coefficient: 1. by using the Onsager reciprocity relations 2. by using the appropriate Green-Kubo relation 3. via the excess enthalpy. The numerical results are found to be mutually consistent, and to agree with the theoretical prediction based on the assumption that hydrodynamics and thermodynamics are locally valid. △ Less

Submitted 1 August, 2019; originally announced August 2019.

Lattice models and Monte Carlo methods for simulating DNA origami self-assembly

Authors: Alexander Cumberworth, Aleks Reinhardt, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: The optimal design of DNA origami systems that assemble rapidly and robustly is hampered by the lack of a model for self-assembly that is sufficiently detailed yet computationally tractable. Here, we propose a model for DNA origami that strikes a balance between these two criteria by representing these systems on a lattice at the level of binding domains. The free energy of hybridization between i… ▽ More The optimal design of DNA origami systems that assemble rapidly and robustly is hampered by the lack of a model for self-assembly that is sufficiently detailed yet computationally tractable. Here, we propose a model for DNA origami that strikes a balance between these two criteria by representing these systems on a lattice at the level of binding domains. The free energy of hybridization between individual binding domains is estimated with a nearest-neighbour model. Double helical segments are treated as rigid rods, but we allow flexibility at points where the backbone of one of the strands is interrupted, which provides a reasonably realistic representation of partially and fully assembled states. Particular attention is paid to the constraints imposed by the double helical twist, as they determine where strand crossovers between adjacent helices can occur. To improve the efficiency of sampling configuration space, we develop Monte Carlo methods for sampling scaffold conformations in near-assembled states, and we carry out simulations in the grand canonical ensemble, enabling us to avoid considering states with unbound staples. We demonstrate that our model can quickly sample assembled configurations of a small origami design previously studied with the oxDNA model, as well as a design with staples that span longer segments of the scaffold. The sampling ability of our method should allow for good statistics to be obtained when studying the assembly pathways, and is suited to investigating in particular the effects of design and assembly conditions on these pathways and their resulting final assembled structures. △ Less

Submitted 22 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 16 pages, 15 figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 149, 234905 (2018)

Theoretical prediction of thermal polarisation

Authors: Peter Wirnsberger, Christoph Dellago, Daan Frenkel, Aleks Reinhardt

Abstract: We present a mean-field theory to explain the thermo-orientation effect in an off-centre Stockmayer fluid. This effect is the underlying cause of thermally induced polarisation and thermally induced monopoles, which have recently been predicted theoretically. Unlike previous theories that are based either on phenomenological equations or on scaling arguments, our approach does not require any fitt… ▽ More We present a mean-field theory to explain the thermo-orientation effect in an off-centre Stockmayer fluid. This effect is the underlying cause of thermally induced polarisation and thermally induced monopoles, which have recently been predicted theoretically. Unlike previous theories that are based either on phenomenological equations or on scaling arguments, our approach does not require any fitting parameters. Given an equation of state and assuming local equilibrium, we construct an effective Hamiltonian for the computation of local Boltzmann averages. This simple theoretical treatment predicts molecular orientations that are in very good agreement with simulation results for the range of dipole strengths investigated. By decomposing the overall alignment into contributions from the temperature and density gradients, we shed further light on how the non-equilibrium result arises from the competition between the two gradients. △ Less

Submitted 1 June, 2018; v1 submitted 10 April, 2018; originally announced April 2018.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 226001 (2018)

Pressure Gradients Fail to Predict Diffusio-Osmosis

Authors: Yawei Liu, Raman Ganti, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We present numerical simulations of diffusio-osmotic flow, i.e. the fluid flow generated by a concentration gradient along a solid-fluid interface. In our study, we compare a number of distinct approaches that have been proposed for computing such flows and compare them with a reference calculation based on direct, non-equilibrium Molecular Dynamics simulations. As alternatives, we consider scheme… ▽ More We present numerical simulations of diffusio-osmotic flow, i.e. the fluid flow generated by a concentration gradient along a solid-fluid interface. In our study, we compare a number of distinct approaches that have been proposed for computing such flows and compare them with a reference calculation based on direct, non-equilibrium Molecular Dynamics simulations. As alternatives, we consider schemes that compute diffusio-osmotic flow from the gradient of the chemical potentials of the constituent species and from the gradient of the component of the stress tensor parallel to the interface. We find that the approach based on treating chemical potential gradients as external forces acting on various species agrees with the direct simulations, thereby supporting the approach of Marbach et al. (J Chem Phys 146, 194701 (2017)). In contrast, an approach based on computing the gradients of the microscopic pressure tensor does not reproduce the direct non-equilibrium results. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 7 Pages, 5 figures. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:1710.00355

Controlling cargo trafficking in multicomponent membranes

Authors: Tine Curk, Peter Wirnsberger, Jure Dobnikar, Daan Frenkel, Andela Saric

Abstract: Biological membranes typically contain a large number of different components dispersed in small concentrations in the main membrane phase, including proteins, sugars, and lipids of varying geometrical properties. Most of these components do not bind the cargo. Here, we show that such `inert' components can be crucial for precise control of cross-membrane trafficking. Using a statistical mechanics… ▽ More Biological membranes typically contain a large number of different components dispersed in small concentrations in the main membrane phase, including proteins, sugars, and lipids of varying geometrical properties. Most of these components do not bind the cargo. Here, we show that such `inert' components can be crucial for precise control of cross-membrane trafficking. Using a statistical mechanics model and molecular dynamics simulations, we demonstrate that the presence of inert membrane components of small isotropic curvatures dramatically influences cargo endocytosis, even if the total spontaneous curvature of such a membrane remains unchanged. Curved lipids, such as cholesterol, as well as asymmetrically included proteins and tethered sugars can hence all be actively participating in controlling membrane trafficking of nanoscopic cargo. We find that even a low-level expression of curved inert membrane components can determine the membrane selectivity towards the cargo size, and can be used to selectively target membranes of certain compositions. Our results suggest a robust and general way to control cargo trafficking by adjusting the membrane composition without needing to alter the concentration of receptors nor the average membrane curvature. This study indicates that cells can prepare for any trafficking event by incorporating curved inert components in either of the membrane leaflets. △ Less

Submitted 25 February, 2018; v1 submitted 29 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Hamiltonian transformation to compute Thermo-osmotic Forces

Authors: Raman Ganti, Yawei Liu, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: If a thermal gradient is applied along a fluid-solid interface, the fluid experiences a thermo-osmotic force. In steady state this force is balanced by the gradient of the shear stress. Surprisingly, there appears to be no unique microscopic expression that can be used for computing the magnitude of the thermo-osmotic force. Here we report how, by treating the mass $M$ of the fluid particles as… ▽ More If a thermal gradient is applied along a fluid-solid interface, the fluid experiences a thermo-osmotic force. In steady state this force is balanced by the gradient of the shear stress. Surprisingly, there appears to be no unique microscopic expression that can be used for computing the magnitude of the thermo-osmotic force. Here we report how, by treating the mass $M$ of the fluid particles as a tensor in the Hamiltonian, we can eliminate the balancing shear force in a non-equilibrium simulation and therefore compute the thermo-osmotic force at simple solid-fluid interfaces. We compare the non-equilibrium force measurement with estimates of the thermo-osmotic force based on computing gradients of the stress tensor. We find that the thermo-osmotic force as measured in our simulations cannot be derived from the most common microscopic definitions of the stress tensor. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 068002 (2018)

Microscopic Marangoni flows cannot be predicted on the basis of pressure gradients

Authors: Yawei Liu, Raman Ganti, Hugh G. A. Burton, Xianren Zhang, Wenchuan Wang, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: A concentration gradient along a fluid-fluid interface can cause flow. On a microscopic level, this so-called Marangoni effect can be viewed as being caused by a gradient in the pressures acting on the fluid elements, or as the chemical-potential gradients acting on the excess densities of different species at the interface. If the interfacial thickness can be ignored, all approaches should result… ▽ More A concentration gradient along a fluid-fluid interface can cause flow. On a microscopic level, this so-called Marangoni effect can be viewed as being caused by a gradient in the pressures acting on the fluid elements, or as the chemical-potential gradients acting on the excess densities of different species at the interface. If the interfacial thickness can be ignored, all approaches should result in the same flow profile away from the interface. However, on a more microscopic scale, the different expressions result in different flow profiles, only one of which can be correct. Here we compare the results of direct non-equilibrium Molecular Dynamics simulations with the flows that would be generated by pressure and chemical potential gradients. We find that the approach based on the chemical potential gradients agrees with the direct simulations, whereas the calculations based on the pressure gradients do not. △ Less

Submitted 1 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 5 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 224502 (2017)

A Unified Description of Colloidal Thermophoresis

Authors: Jerome Burelbach, Daan Frenkel, Ignacio Pagonabarraga, Erika Eiser

Abstract: We use the dynamic length and time scale separation in suspensions to formulate a general description of colloidal thermophoresis. Our approach allows an unambiguous definition of separate contributions to the colloidal flux and clarifies the physical mechanisms behind non-equilibrium motion of colloids. In particular, we derive an expression for the interfacial force density that drives single-pa… ▽ More We use the dynamic length and time scale separation in suspensions to formulate a general description of colloidal thermophoresis. Our approach allows an unambiguous definition of separate contributions to the colloidal flux and clarifies the physical mechanisms behind non-equilibrium motion of colloids. In particular, we derive an expression for the interfacial force density that drives single-particle thermophoresis in non-ideal fluids. The issuing relations for the transport coefficients explicitly show that interfacial thermophoresis has a hydrodynamic character that cannot be explained by a purely thermodynamic consideration. Our treatment generalises the results from other existing approaches, giving them a clear interpretation within the framework of non-equilibrium thermodynamics. △ Less

Submitted 16 December, 2017; v1 submitted 7 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Investigating the role of boundary bricks in DNA brick self-assembly

Authors: Hannah Wayment-Steele, Daan Frenkel, Aleks Reinhardt

Abstract: In the standard DNA brick set-up, distinct 32-nucleotide strands of single-stranded DNA are each designed to bind specifically to four other such molecules. Experimentally, it has been demonstrated that the overall yield is increased if certain bricks which occur on the outer faces of target structures are merged with adjacent bricks. However, it is not well understood by what mechanism such `boun… ▽ More In the standard DNA brick set-up, distinct 32-nucleotide strands of single-stranded DNA are each designed to bind specifically to four other such molecules. Experimentally, it has been demonstrated that the overall yield is increased if certain bricks which occur on the outer faces of target structures are merged with adjacent bricks. However, it is not well understood by what mechanism such `boundary bricks' increase the yield, as they likely influence both the nucleation process and the final stability of the target structure. Here, we use Monte Carlo simulations with a patchy particle model of DNA bricks to investigate the role of boundary bricks in the self-assembly of complex multicomponent target structures. We demonstrate that boundary bricks lower the free-energy barrier to nucleation and that boundary bricks on edges stabilize the final structure. However, boundary bricks are also more prone to aggregation, as they can stabilize partially assembled intermediates. We explore some design strategies that permit us to benefit from the stabilizing role of boundary bricks whilst minimizing their ability to hinder assembly; in particular, we show that maximizing the total number of boundary bricks is not an optimal strategy. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

Journal ref: Soft Matter 13, 1670-1680 (2017)

Phase transitions in biological systems with many components

Authors: William M. Jacobs, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Biological mixtures such as the cytosol may consist of thousands of distinct components. There is now a substantial body of evidence showing that, under physiological conditions, intracellular mixtures can phase separate into spatially distinct regions with differing compositions. In this paper we present numerical evidence indicating that such spontaneous compartmentalization exploits general fea… ▽ More Biological mixtures such as the cytosol may consist of thousands of distinct components. There is now a substantial body of evidence showing that, under physiological conditions, intracellular mixtures can phase separate into spatially distinct regions with differing compositions. In this paper we present numerical evidence indicating that such spontaneous compartmentalization exploits general features of the phase diagram of a multicomponent biomolecular mixture. In particular, we show that demixed domains are likely to segregate when the variance in the inter-molecular interaction strengths exceeds a well-defined threshold. Multiple distinct phases are likely to become stable under very similar conditions, which can then be tuned to achieve multiphase coexistence. As a result, only minor adjustments to the composition of the cytosol or the strengths of the inter-molecular interactions are needed to regulate the formation of different domains with specific compositions, implying that phase separation is a robust mechanism for creating spatial organization. We further predict that this functionality is only weakly affected by increasing the number of components in the system. Our model therefore suggests that, for purely physico-chemical reasons, biological mixtures are naturally poised to undergo a small number of demixing phase transitions. △ Less

Submitted 3 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Journal ref: Biophysical Journal 112:683-691 (2017)

Molecular Simulation of Thermo-osmotic slip

Authors: Raman Ganti, Yawei Liu, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Thermo-osmotic slip -- the flow induced by a thermal gradient along a surface -- is a well-known phenomenon, but curiously there is a lack of robust molecular-simulation techniques to predict its magnitude. Here, we compare three different molecular simulation techniques to compute the thermo-osmotic slip at a simple solid-fluid interface. Although we do not expect the different approaches to be i… ▽ More Thermo-osmotic slip -- the flow induced by a thermal gradient along a surface -- is a well-known phenomenon, but curiously there is a lack of robust molecular-simulation techniques to predict its magnitude. Here, we compare three different molecular simulation techniques to compute the thermo-osmotic slip at a simple solid-fluid interface. Although we do not expect the different approaches to be in perfect agreement, we find that the differences are barely significant for a range of different physical conditions, suggesting that practical molecular simulations of thermo-osmotic slip are feasible. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 038002 (2017)

Monte Carlo sampling for stochastic weight functions

Authors: Daan Frenkel, K. Julian Schrenk, Stefano Martiniani

Abstract: Conventional Monte Carlo simulations are stochastic in the sense that the acceptance of a trial move is decided by comparing a computed acceptance probability with a random number, uniformly distributed between 0 and 1. Here we consider the case that the weight determining the acceptance probability itself is fluctuating. This situation is common in many numerical studies. We show that it is possi… ▽ More Conventional Monte Carlo simulations are stochastic in the sense that the acceptance of a trial move is decided by comparing a computed acceptance probability with a random number, uniformly distributed between 0 and 1. Here we consider the case that the weight determining the acceptance probability itself is fluctuating. This situation is common in many numerical studies. We show that it is possible to construct a rigorous Monte Carlo algorithm that visits points in state space with a probability proportional to their average weight. The same approach has the potential to transform the methodology of a certain class of high-throughput experiments or the analysis of noisy datasets. △ Less

Submitted 19 December, 2016; originally announced December 2016.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114(27), 6924-6929 (2017)

Numerical Evidence for Thermally Induced Monopoles

Authors: Peter Wirnsberger, Domagoj Fijan, Roger Adam Lightwood, Anđela Šarić, Christoph Dellago, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Electrical charges are conserved. The same would be expected to hold for magnetic charges, yet magnetic monopoles have never been observed. It is therefore surprising that the laws of non-equilibrium thermodynamics, combined with Maxwell's equations, suggest that colloidal particles heated or cooled in certain polar or paramagnetic solvents may behave as if they carry an electrical/magnetic charge… ▽ More Electrical charges are conserved. The same would be expected to hold for magnetic charges, yet magnetic monopoles have never been observed. It is therefore surprising that the laws of non-equilibrium thermodynamics, combined with Maxwell's equations, suggest that colloidal particles heated or cooled in certain polar or paramagnetic solvents may behave as if they carry an electrical/magnetic charge [J. Phys. Chem. B $\textbf{120}$, 5987 (2016)]. Here we present numerical simulations that show that the field distribution around a pair of such heated/cooled colloidal particles agrees quantitatively with the theoretical predictions for a pair of oppositely charged electrical or magnetic monopoles. However, in other respects, the non-equilibrium colloids do not behave as monopoles: they cannot be moved by a homogeneous applied field. The numerical evidence for the monopole-like fields around heated/cooled colloids is crucial because the experimental and numerical determination of forces between such colloids would be complicated by the presence of other effects, such as thermophoresis. △ Less

Submitted 21 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Numerical test of the Edwards conjecture shows that all packings are equally probable at jamming

Authors: Stefano Martiniani, K. Julian Schrenk, Kabir Ramola, Bulbul Chakraborty, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: In the late 1980s, Sam Edwards proposed a possible statistical-mechanical framework to describe the properties of disordered granular materials. A key assumption underlying the theory was that all jammed packings are equally likely. In the intervening years it has never been possible to test this bold hypothesis directly. Here we present simulations that provide direct evidence that at the unjammi… ▽ More In the late 1980s, Sam Edwards proposed a possible statistical-mechanical framework to describe the properties of disordered granular materials. A key assumption underlying the theory was that all jammed packings are equally likely. In the intervening years it has never been possible to test this bold hypothesis directly. Here we present simulations that provide direct evidence that at the unjamming point, all packings of soft repulsive particles are equally likely, even though generically, jammed packings are not. Typically, jammed granular systems are observed precisely at the unjamming point since grains are not very compressible. Our results therefore support Edwards' original conjecture. We also present evidence that at unjamming the configurational entropy of the system is maximal. △ Less

Submitted 24 August, 2018; v1 submitted 20 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Journal ref: Nature Physics, 13(9), 848 (2017)

Kinetics of spontaneous filament nucleation via oligomers: insights from theory and simulation

Authors: Anđela Šarić, Thomas C. T. Michaels, Alessio Zaccone, Tuomas P. J. Knowles, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Nucleation processes are at the heart of a large number of phenomena, from cloud formation to protein crystallization. A recently emerging area where nucleation is highly relevant is the initiation of filamentous protein self-assembly, a process that has broad implications from medicine to nanotechnology. As such, spontaneous nucleation of protein fibrils has received much attention in recent year… ▽ More Nucleation processes are at the heart of a large number of phenomena, from cloud formation to protein crystallization. A recently emerging area where nucleation is highly relevant is the initiation of filamentous protein self-assembly, a process that has broad implications from medicine to nanotechnology. As such, spontaneous nucleation of protein fibrils has received much attention in recent years with many theoretical and experimental studies focussing on the underlying physical principles. In this paper we make a step forward in this direction and explore the early time behaviour of filamentous protein growth in the context of nucleation theory. We first provide an overview of the thermodynamics and kinetics of spontaneous nucleation of protein filaments in the presence of one relevant degree of freedom, namely the cluster size. In this case, we review how key kinetic observables, such as the reaction order of spontaneous nucleation, are directly related to the physical size of the critical nucleus. We then focus on the increasingly prominent case of filament nucleation that includes a conformational conversion of the nucleating building-block as an additional slow step in the nucleation process. Using computer simulations, we study the concentration dependence of the nucleation rate. We find that, under these circumstances, the reaction order of spontaneous nucleation with respect to the free monomer does no longer relate to the overall physical size of the nucleating aggregate but rather to the portion of the aggregate that actively participates in the conformational conversion. Our results thus provide a novel interpretation of the common kinetic descriptors of protein filament formation, including the reaction order of the nucleation step or the scaling exponent of lag times, and put into perspective current theoretical descriptions of protein aggregation. △ Less

Submitted 4 January, 2017; v1 submitted 7 October, 2016; originally announced October 2016.

Journal ref: The Journal of Chemical Physics The Journal of Chemical Physics J. Chem. Phys. 145, 211926 (2016)

Nanoparticle ordering in sandwiched polymer brushes

Authors: Tine Curk, Francisco J. Martinez-Veracoechea, Daan Frenkel, Jure Dobnikar

Abstract: The organization of nano-particles inside grafted polymer layers is governed by the interplay of polymer-induced entropic interactions and the action of externally applied fields. Earlier work had shown that strong external forces can drive the formation of colloidal structures in polymer brushes. Here we show that external fields are not essential to obtain such colloidal patterns: we report Mont… ▽ More The organization of nano-particles inside grafted polymer layers is governed by the interplay of polymer-induced entropic interactions and the action of externally applied fields. Earlier work had shown that strong external forces can drive the formation of colloidal structures in polymer brushes. Here we show that external fields are not essential to obtain such colloidal patterns: we report Monte Carlo and Molecular dynamics simulations that demonstrate that ordered structures can be achieved by compressing a `sandwich' of two grafted polymer layers, or by squeezing a coated nanotube, with nano-particles in between. We show that the pattern formation can be efficiently controlled by the applied pressure, while the characteristic length--scale, i.e. the typical width of the patterns, is sensitive to the length of the polymers. Based on the results of the simulations, we derive an approximate equation of state for nano-sandwiches. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2016; originally announced August 2016.

Comments: 18 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Nano Letters 14 (2014)

Design principles for super selectivity using multivalent interactions

Authors: Tine Curk, Jure Dobnikar, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Multivalent particles have the ability to form multiple bonds to a substrate. Hence, a multivalent interaction can be strong, even if the individual bonds are weak. However, much more interestingly, multivalency greatly increases the sensitivity of the particle-substrate interaction to external conditions, resulting in an ultra-sensitive and highly non-linear dependence of the binding strength on… ▽ More Multivalent particles have the ability to form multiple bonds to a substrate. Hence, a multivalent interaction can be strong, even if the individual bonds are weak. However, much more interestingly, multivalency greatly increases the sensitivity of the particle-substrate interaction to external conditions, resulting in an ultra-sensitive and highly non-linear dependence of the binding strength on parameters such as temperature, pH or receptor concentration. In this chapter we focus on super-selectivity: the high sensitivity of the strength of multivalent binding to the number of accessible binding sites on the target surface. For example, the docking of a multivalent particle on a cell-surface can be very sensitive (super-selective) to the concentration of the receptors to which the multiple ligands can bind. We present a theoretical analysis of systems of multivalent particles and describe the mechanism by which multivalency leads to super-selectivity. We introduce a simple analytical model that allows us to predict the overall strength of interactions based on physiochemical characteristics of multivalent binders. Finally, we formulate a set of simple design rules for multivalent interactions that yield optimal selectivity. △ Less

Submitted 3 April, 2017; v1 submitted 3 August, 2016; originally announced August 2016.

Comments: 30 pages 13 figures

DNA brick self-assembly with an off-lattice potential

Authors: Aleks Reinhardt, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We report Monte Carlo simulations of a simple off-lattice patchy-particle model for DNA `bricks'. We relate the parameters that characterise this model with the binding free energy of pairs of single-stranded DNA molecules. We verify that an off-lattice potential parameterised in this way reproduces much of the behaviour seen with a simpler lattice model we introduced previously, although the rela… ▽ More We report Monte Carlo simulations of a simple off-lattice patchy-particle model for DNA `bricks'. We relate the parameters that characterise this model with the binding free energy of pairs of single-stranded DNA molecules. We verify that an off-lattice potential parameterised in this way reproduces much of the behaviour seen with a simpler lattice model we introduced previously, although the relaxation of the geometric constraints leads to a more error-prone self-assembly pathway. We investigate the self-assembly process as a function of the strength of the non-specific interactions. We show that our off-lattice model for DNA bricks results in robust self-assembly into a variety of target structures. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2016; originally announced June 2016.

Journal ref: Soft Matter 12, 6253-6260 (2016)

Symplectic embeddings of four-dimensional ellipsoids into integral polydiscs

Authors: Daniel Cristofaro-Gardiner, David Frenkel, Felix Schlenk

Abstract: In previous work, the second author and Müller determined the function $c(a)$ giving the smallest dilate of the polydisc $P(1,1)$ into which the ellipsoid $E(1,a)$ symplectically embeds. We determine the function of two variables $c_b(a)$ giving the smallest dilate of the polydisc $P(1,b)$ into which the ellipsoid $E(1,a)$ symplectically embeds for all integers $b \geqslant 2$. It is known that… ▽ More In previous work, the second author and Müller determined the function $c(a)$ giving the smallest dilate of the polydisc $P(1,1)$ into which the ellipsoid $E(1,a)$ symplectically embeds. We determine the function of two variables $c_b(a)$ giving the smallest dilate of the polydisc $P(1,b)$ into which the ellipsoid $E(1,a)$ symplectically embeds for all integers $b \geqslant 2$. It is known that for fixed $b$, if $a$ is sufficiently large then all obstructions to the embedding problem vanish except for the volume obstruction. We find that there is another kind of change of structure that appears as one instead increases $b$: the number-theoretic "infinite Pell stairs" from the $b=1$ case almost completely disappears (only two steps remain), but in an appropriately rescaled limit, the function $c_b(a)$ converges as $b$ tends to infinity to a completely regular infinite staircase with steps all of the same height and width. △ Less

Submitted 21 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: 61 pages, 12 figures

Journal ref: Algebr. Geom. Topol. 17 (2017) 1189-1260

Switch-like surface binding of competing multivalent particles

Authors: Nicholas B. Tito, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Multivalent particles competing for binding on the same surface can exhibit switch-like behaviour, depending on the concentration of receptors on the surface. When the receptor concentration is low, energy dominates the free energy of binding, and particles having a small number of strongly-binding ligands preferentially bind to the surface. At higher receptor concentrations, multivalent effects b… ▽ More Multivalent particles competing for binding on the same surface can exhibit switch-like behaviour, depending on the concentration of receptors on the surface. When the receptor concentration is low, energy dominates the free energy of binding, and particles having a small number of strongly-binding ligands preferentially bind to the surface. At higher receptor concentrations, multivalent effects become significant, and entropy dominates the binding free energy; particles having many weakly-binding ligands preferentially bind to the surface. Between these two regimes there is a "switch-point", at which the surface binds the two species of particles equally strongly. We demonstrate that a simple theory can account for this switch-like behaviour and present numerical calculations that support the theoretical predictions. We argue that binding selectivity based on receptor density, rather than identity, may have practical applications. △ Less

Submitted 16 April, 2016; originally announced April 2016.

Comments: Main Article: 6 pages, 4 figures; Supporting Information: 7 pages, 6 figures

Structural analysis of high-dimensional basins of attraction

Authors: Stefano Martiniani, K. Julian Schrenk, Jacob D. Stevenson, David J. Wales, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We propose an efficient Monte Carlo method for the computation of the volumes of high-dimensional bodies with arbitrary shape. We start with a region of known volume within the interior of the manifold and then use the multistate Bennett acceptance-ratio method to compute the dimensionless free-energy difference between a series of equilibrium simulations performed within this object. The method p… ▽ More We propose an efficient Monte Carlo method for the computation of the volumes of high-dimensional bodies with arbitrary shape. We start with a region of known volume within the interior of the manifold and then use the multistate Bennett acceptance-ratio method to compute the dimensionless free-energy difference between a series of equilibrium simulations performed within this object. The method produces results that are in excellent agreement with thermodynamic integration, as well as a direct estimate of the associated statistical uncertainties. The histogram method also allows us to directly obtain an estimate of the interior radial probability density profile, thus yielding useful insight into the structural properties of such a high-dimensional body. We illustrate the method by analyzing the effect of structural disorder on the basins of attraction of mechanically stable packings of soft repulsive spheres. △ Less

Submitted 17 September, 2016; v1 submitted 31 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures, supplemental material

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 94, 031301 (2016)

Simple approach for calculating the binding free energy of a multivalent particle

Authors: Nicholas B. Tito, Stefano Angioletti-Uberti, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We present a simple yet accurate numerical approach to compute the free energy of binding of multivalent objects on a receptor-coated surface. The method correctly accounts for the fact that one ligand can bind to at most one receptor. The numerical approach is based on a saddle-point approximation to the computation of a complex residue. We compare our theory with the powerful Valence-Limited Int… ▽ More We present a simple yet accurate numerical approach to compute the free energy of binding of multivalent objects on a receptor-coated surface. The method correctly accounts for the fact that one ligand can bind to at most one receptor. The numerical approach is based on a saddle-point approximation to the computation of a complex residue. We compare our theory with the powerful Valence-Limited Interaction Theory (VLIT) (J. Chem. Phys. 137, 094108(2012), J. Chem. Phys. 138, 021102(2013)) and find excellent agreement in the regime where that theory is expected to work. However, the present approach even works for low receptor/ligand densities, where VLIT breaks down. △ Less

Submitted 14 March, 2016; originally announced March 2016.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures

Hot nano-particles in polar or paramagnetic liquids interact as monopoles

Authors: Daan Frenkel

Abstract: When neutral nano-particles are heated or cooled in a polar liquid, they will interact with each other as if they carry an electrostatic charge that is proportional to the temperature difference between the particle and the surrounding fluid. The same should hold for paramagnetic liquids, in which case the nano-particles should behave as magnetic monopoles. However, the analogy with electrostatics… ▽ More When neutral nano-particles are heated or cooled in a polar liquid, they will interact with each other as if they carry an electrostatic charge that is proportional to the temperature difference between the particle and the surrounding fluid. The same should hold for paramagnetic liquids, in which case the nano-particles should behave as magnetic monopoles. However, the analogy with electrostatics/magnetostatics is not complete: heated/cooled nano-particles do not move under the influence of an applied field. They should, however, interact as monopoles. △ Less

Submitted 30 March, 2016; v1 submitted 25 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Non-equilibrium simulations of thermally induced electric fields in water

Authors: Peter Wirnsberger, Domagoj Fijan, Anđela Šarić, Martin Neumann, Christoph Dellago, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Using non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations, it has been recently demonstrated that water molecules align in response to an imposed temperature gradient, resulting in an effective electric field. Here, we investigate how thermally induced fields depend on the underlying treatment of long-ranged interactions. For the short-ranged Wolf method and Ewald summation, we find the peak strength o… ▽ More Using non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations, it has been recently demonstrated that water molecules align in response to an imposed temperature gradient, resulting in an effective electric field. Here, we investigate how thermally induced fields depend on the underlying treatment of long-ranged interactions. For the short-ranged Wolf method and Ewald summation, we find the peak strength of the field to range between $2 \times 10^7$ and $5 \times 10^7~\text{V/m}$ for a temperature gradient of $5.2~\text{K/}\unicode{x212B}$. Our value for the Wolf method is therefore an order of magnitude lower than the literature value [J. Chem. Phys. 139, 014504 (2013) and 143, 036101 (2015)]. We show that this discrepancy can be traced back to the use of an incorrect kernel in the calculation of the electrostatic field. More seriously, we find that the Wolf method fails to predict correct molecular orientations, resulting in dipole densities with opposite sign to those computed using Ewald summation. By considering two different multipole expansions, we show that, for inhomogeneous polarisations, the quadrupole contribution can be significant and even outweigh the dipole contribution to the field. Finally, we propose a more accurate way of calculating the electrostatic potential and the field. In particular, we show that averaging the microscopic field analytically to obtain the macroscopic Maxwell field reduces the error bars by up to an order of magnitude. As a consequence, the simulation times required to reach a given statistical accuracy decrease by up to two orders of magnitude. △ Less

Submitted 8 August, 2016; v1 submitted 8 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.

Comments: 17 pages, 11 figures, link to supplementary material

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 144, 224102 (2016)

Theory and Simulation of DNA-Coated Colloids: a Guide for Rational Design

Authors: Stefano Angioletti-Uberti, Bortolo M. Mognetti, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: By exploiting the exquisite selectivity of DNA hybridization, DNA-Coated Colloids (DNACCs) can be made to self-assemble in a wide variety of structures. The beauty of this system stems largely from its exceptional versatility and from the fact that a proper choice of the grafted DNA sequences yields fine control over the colloidal interactions. Theory and simulations have an important role to play… ▽ More By exploiting the exquisite selectivity of DNA hybridization, DNA-Coated Colloids (DNACCs) can be made to self-assemble in a wide variety of structures. The beauty of this system stems largely from its exceptional versatility and from the fact that a proper choice of the grafted DNA sequences yields fine control over the colloidal interactions. Theory and simulations have an important role to play in the optimal design of self- assembling DNACCs. At present, the powerful model-based design tools are not widely used, because the theoretical literature is fragmented and the connection between different theories is often not evident. In this Perspective, we aim to discuss the similarities and differences between the different models that have been described in the literature, their underlying assumptions, their strengths and their weaknesses. Using the tools described in the present Review, it should be possible to move towards a more rational design of novel self-assembling structures of DNACCs and, more generally, of systems where ligand-receptors bonds are used to control interactions. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2016; originally announced January 2016.

Comments: Pre-refereed version (some small differences with final one, nothing major) Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2016

Consistent treatment of hydrophobicity in protein lattice models accounts for cold denaturation

Authors: Erik van Dijk, Patrick Varilly, Tuomas Knowles, Daan Frenkel, Sanne Abeln

Abstract: The hydrophobic effect stabilizes the native structure of proteins by minimizing the unfavourable interactions between hydrophobic residues and water through the formation of a hydrophobic core. Here we include the entropic and enthalpic contributions of the hydrophobic effect explicitly in an implicit solvent model. This allows us to capture two important effects: a length-scale dependence and a… ▽ More The hydrophobic effect stabilizes the native structure of proteins by minimizing the unfavourable interactions between hydrophobic residues and water through the formation of a hydrophobic core. Here we include the entropic and enthalpic contributions of the hydrophobic effect explicitly in an implicit solvent model. This allows us to capture two important effects: a length-scale dependence and a temperature dependence for the solvation of a hydrophobic particle. This consistent treatment of the hydrophobic effect explains cold denaturation and heat capacity measurements of solvated proteins. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2015; v1 submitted 20 November, 2015; originally announced November 2015.

Comments: Added and corrected references for design procedure in main text (p. 2) and in Supplemental Information (p. 8)

Evidence for non-ergodicity in quiescent states of periodically sheared suspensions

Authors: K. Julian Schrenk, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We present simulations of an equilibrium statistical-mechanics model that uniformly samples the space of quiescent states of a periodically sheared suspension. In our simulations, we compute the structural properties of this model as a function of density. We compare the results of our simulations with the structural data obtained in the corresponding non-equilibrium model of Corté et al. [Nat. Ph… ▽ More We present simulations of an equilibrium statistical-mechanics model that uniformly samples the space of quiescent states of a periodically sheared suspension. In our simulations, we compute the structural properties of this model as a function of density. We compare the results of our simulations with the structural data obtained in the corresponding non-equilibrium model of Corté et al. [Nat. Phys. 4, 420 (2008)]. We find that the structural properties of the non-equilibrium model are very different from those of the equilibrium model, even though the two models have exactly the same set of accessible states. This observation shows that the dynamical protocol does not sample all quiescent states with equal probability. In particular, we find that, whilst quiescent states prepared in a non-equilibrium protocol can be hyperuniform [see Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 110602 (2015), Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 148301 (2015), and Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 108301 (2015)], ergodic sampling never leads to hyperuniformity. In addition, we observe ordering phase transitions and a percolation transition in the equilibrium model that do not show up in the non-equilibrium model. Conversely, the quiescent-to-diffusive transition in the dynamical model does not correspond to a phase transition, nor a percolation transition, in the equilibrium model. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2015; v1 submitted 5 October, 2015; originally announced October 2015.

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 143, 241103 (2015)

Effects of co-ordination number on the nucleation behaviour in many-component self-assembly

Authors: Aleks Reinhardt, Chon Pan Ho, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We report canonical and grand-canonical lattice Monte Carlo simulations of the self-assembly of addressable structures comprising hundreds of distinct component types. The nucleation behaviour, in the form of free-energy barriers to nucleation, changes significantly as the co-ordination number of the building blocks is changed from 4 to 8 to 12. Unlike tetrahedral structures - which roughly corres… ▽ More We report canonical and grand-canonical lattice Monte Carlo simulations of the self-assembly of addressable structures comprising hundreds of distinct component types. The nucleation behaviour, in the form of free-energy barriers to nucleation, changes significantly as the co-ordination number of the building blocks is changed from 4 to 8 to 12. Unlike tetrahedral structures - which roughly correspond to DNA bricks that have been studied in experiment - the shapes of the free-energy barriers of higher co-ordination structures depend strongly on the supersaturation, and such structures require a very significant driving force for structure growth before nucleation becomes thermally accessible. Although growth at high supersaturation results in more defects during self-assembly, we show that high co-ordination number structures can still be assembled successfully in computer simulations and that they exhibit self-assembly behaviour analogous to DNA bricks. In particular, the self-assembly remains modular, enabling in principle a wide variety of nanostructures to be assembled, with a greater spatial resolution than is possible in low co-ordination structures. △ Less

Submitted 21 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: Faraday Discussions 2015

Journal ref: Faraday Discuss. 186, 215-228 (2016)

Turning intractable counting into sampling: computing the configurational entropy of three-dimensional jammed packings

Authors: Stefano Martiniani, K. Julian Schrenk, Jacob D. Stevenson, David J. Wales, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We report a numerical calculation of the total number of disordered jammed configurations $Ω$ of $N$ repulsive, three-dimensional spheres in a fixed volume $V$. To make these calculations tractable, we increase the computational efficiency of the approach of Xu et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 245502 (2011)) and Asenjo et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 098002 (2014)) and we extend the method to allow com… ▽ More We report a numerical calculation of the total number of disordered jammed configurations $Ω$ of $N$ repulsive, three-dimensional spheres in a fixed volume $V$. To make these calculations tractable, we increase the computational efficiency of the approach of Xu et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 245502 (2011)) and Asenjo et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 098002 (2014)) and we extend the method to allow computation of the configurational entropy as a function of pressure. The approach that we use computes the configurational entropy by sampling the absolute volume of basins of attraction of the stable packings in the potential energy landscape. We find a surprisingly strong correlation between the pressure of a configuration and the volume of its basin of attraction in the potential energy landscape. This relation is well described by a power law. Our methodology to compute the number of minima in the potential energy landscape should be applicable to a wide range of other enumeration problems in statistical physics, string theory, cosmology and machine learning, that aim to find the distribution of the extrema of a scalar cost function that depends on many degrees of freedom. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2016; v1 submitted 14 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: 18 pages, 7 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 93, 012906 (2016)

Oligomers of heat-shock proteins: Structures that don't imply function

Authors: William M. Jacobs, Tuomas P. J. Knowles, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: Most proteins must remain soluble in the cytosol in order to perform their biological functions. To protect against undesired protein aggregation, living cells maintain a population of molecular chaperones that ensure the solubility of the proteome. Here we report simulations of a lattice model of interacting proteins to understand how low concentrations of passive molecular chaperones, such as sm… ▽ More Most proteins must remain soluble in the cytosol in order to perform their biological functions. To protect against undesired protein aggregation, living cells maintain a population of molecular chaperones that ensure the solubility of the proteome. Here we report simulations of a lattice model of interacting proteins to understand how low concentrations of passive molecular chaperones, such as small heat-shock proteins, suppress thermodynamic instabilities in protein solutions. Given fixed concentrations of chaperones and client proteins, the solubility of the proteome can be increased by tuning the chaperone--client binding strength. Surprisingly, we find that the binding strength that optimizes solubility while preventing irreversible chaperone binding also promotes the formation of weakly bound chaperone oligomers, although the presence of these oligomers does not significantly affect the thermodynamic stability of the solution. Such oligomers are commonly observed in experiments on small heat-shock proteins, but their connection to the biological function of these chaperones has remained unclear. Our simulations suggest that this clustering may not have any essential biological function, but rather emerges as a natural side-effect of optimizing the thermodynamic stability of the proteome. △ Less

Submitted 12 February, 2016; v1 submitted 31 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Journal ref: PLoS Computational Biology 12(2): e1004756 (2016)

An enhanced version of the heat exchange algorithm with excellent energy conservation properties

Authors: P. Wirnsberger, D. Frenkel, C. Dellago

Abstract: We propose a new algorithm for non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations of thermal gradients. The algorithm is an extension of the heat exchange algorithm developed by Hafskjold and co-workers [Mol. Phys. 80, 1389 (1993); Mol. Phys. 81, 251 (1994)], in which a certain amount of heat is added to one region and removed from another by rescaling velocities appropriately. Since the amount of add… ▽ More We propose a new algorithm for non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations of thermal gradients. The algorithm is an extension of the heat exchange algorithm developed by Hafskjold and co-workers [Mol. Phys. 80, 1389 (1993); Mol. Phys. 81, 251 (1994)], in which a certain amount of heat is added to one region and removed from another by rescaling velocities appropriately. Since the amount of added and removed heat is the same and the dynamics between velocity rescaling steps is Hamiltonian, the heat exchange algorithm is expected to conserve the energy. However, it has been reported previously that the original version of the heat exchange algorithm exhibits a pronounced drift in the total energy, the exact cause of which remained hitherto unclear. Here, we show that the energy drift is due to the truncation error arising from the operator splitting and suggest an additional coordinate integration step as a remedy. The new algorithm retains all the advantages of the original one whilst exhibiting excellent energy conservation as illustrated for a Lennard-Jones liquid and SPC/E water. △ Less

Submitted 29 October, 2015; v1 submitted 25 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 8 pages, 6 figures

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 143, 124104 (2015)

Rational design of self-assembly pathways for complex multicomponent structures

Authors: William M. Jacobs, Aleks Reinhardt, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: The field of complex self-assembly is moving toward the design of multi-particle structures consisting of thousands of distinct building blocks. To exploit the potential benefits of structures with such `addressable complexity,' we need to understand the factors that optimize the yield and the kinetics of self-assembly. Here we use a simple theoretical method to explain the key features responsibl… ▽ More The field of complex self-assembly is moving toward the design of multi-particle structures consisting of thousands of distinct building blocks. To exploit the potential benefits of structures with such `addressable complexity,' we need to understand the factors that optimize the yield and the kinetics of self-assembly. Here we use a simple theoretical method to explain the key features responsible for the unexpected success of DNA-brick experiments, which are currently the only demonstration of reliable self-assembly with such a large number of components. Simulations confirm that our theory accurately predicts the narrow temperature window in which error-free assembly can occur. Even more strikingly, our theory predicts that correct assembly of the complete structure may require a time-dependent experimental protocol. Furthermore, we predict that low coordination numbers result in non-classical nucleation behavior, which we find to be essential for achieving optimal nucleation kinetics under mild growth conditions. We also show that, rather surprisingly, the use of heterogeneous bond energies improves the nucleation kinetics and in fact appears to be necessary for assembling certain intricate three-dimensional structures. This observation makes it possible to sculpt nucleation pathways by tuning the distribution of interaction strengths. These insights not only suggest how to improve the design of structures based on DNA bricks, but also point the way toward the creation of a much wider class of chemical or colloidal structures with addressable complexity. △ Less

Submitted 4 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: Accompanying code for computing free-energy landscapes of addressable structures can be found at https://github.com/wmjac/pygtsa

Journal ref: Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 112, 6313-6318 (2015)

Theoretical prediction of free-energy landscapes for complex self-assembly

Authors: William M. Jacobs, Aleks Reinhardt, Daan Frenkel

Abstract: We present a technique for calculating free-energy profiles for the nucleation of multicomponent structures that contain as many species as building blocks. We find that a key factor is the topology of the graph describing the connectivity of the target assembly. By considering the designed interactions separately from weaker, incidental interactions, our approach yields predictions for the equili… ▽ More We present a technique for calculating free-energy profiles for the nucleation of multicomponent structures that contain as many species as building blocks. We find that a key factor is the topology of the graph describing the connectivity of the target assembly. By considering the designed interactions separately from weaker, incidental interactions, our approach yields predictions for the equilibrium yield and nucleation barriers. These predictions are in good agreement with corresponding Monte Carlo simulations. We show that a few fundamental properties of the connectivity graph determine the most prominent features of the assembly thermodynamics. Surprisingly, we find that polydispersity in the strengths of the designed interactions stabilizes intermediate structures and can be used to sculpt the free-energy landscape for self-assembly. Finally, we demonstrate that weak incidental interactions can preclude assembly at equilibrium due to the combinatorial possibilities for incorrect association. △ Less

Submitted 9 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

Journal ref: J. Chem. Phys. 142, 021101 (2015)