-
Robust a posteriori estimation of probit-lognormal seismic fragility curves via sequential design of experiments and constrained reference prior
Authors:
Antoine Van Biesbroeck,
Clément Gauchy,
Cyril Feau,
Josselin Garnier
Abstract:
Seismic fragility curves express the probability of failure of a mechanical equipment conditional to an intensity measure derived from a seismic signal. Although based on a strong assumption, the probit-lognormal model is very popular among practitioners for estimating such curves, judging by its abundant use in the literature. However, as this model is likely to lead to biased estimates, its use…
▽ More
Seismic fragility curves express the probability of failure of a mechanical equipment conditional to an intensity measure derived from a seismic signal. Although based on a strong assumption, the probit-lognormal model is very popular among practitioners for estimating such curves, judging by its abundant use in the literature. However, as this model is likely to lead to biased estimates, its use should be limited to cases for which only few data are available. In practice, this involves having to resort to binary data which indicate the state of the structure when it has been subjected to a seismic loading, namely failure or non-failure. The question then arises of the choice of data that must be used to obtain an optimal estimate, that is to say the most precise possible with the minimum of data. To answer this question, we propose a methodology for design of experiments in a Bayesian framework based on the reference prior theory. This theory aims to define a so-called objective prior that favors data learning, which is slighty constrained in this work in order tackle the problems of likelihood degeneracy that are ubiquitous with small data sets. The novelty of our work is then twofold. First, we rigorously present the problem of likelihood degeneracy which hampers frequentist approaches such as the maximum likelihood estimation. Then, we propose our strategy inherited from the reference prior theory to build the data set. This strategy aims to maximize the impact of the data on the posterior distribution of the fragility curve. Our method is applied to a case study of the nuclear industry. The results demonstrate its ability to efficiently and robustly estimate the fragility curve, and to avoid degeneracy even with a limited number of experiments. Additionally, we demonstrate that the estimates quickly reach the model bias induced by the probit-lognormal modeling.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
Reference prior for Bayesian estimation of seismic fragility curves
Authors:
Antoine Van Biesbroeck,
Clement Gauchy,
Cyril Feau,
Josselin Garnier
Abstract:
One of the key elements of probabilistic seismic risk assessment studies is the fragility curve, which represents the conditional probability of failure of a mechanical structure for a given scalar measure derived from seismic ground motion. For many structures of interest, estimating these curves is a daunting task because of the limited amount of data available; data which is only binary in our…
▽ More
One of the key elements of probabilistic seismic risk assessment studies is the fragility curve, which represents the conditional probability of failure of a mechanical structure for a given scalar measure derived from seismic ground motion. For many structures of interest, estimating these curves is a daunting task because of the limited amount of data available; data which is only binary in our framework, i.e., only describing the structure as being in a failure or non-failure state. A large number of methods described in the literature tackle this challenging framework through parametric log-normal models. Bayesian approaches, on the other hand, allow model parameters to be learned more efficiently. However, the impact of the choice of the prior distribution on the posterior distribution cannot be readily neglected and, consequently, neither can its impact on any resulting estimation. This paper proposes a comprehensive study of this parametric Bayesian estimation problem for limited and binary data. Using the reference prior theory as a cornerstone, this study develops an objective approach to choosing the prior. This approach leads to the Jeffreys prior, which is derived for this problem for the first time. The posterior distribution is proven to be proper with the Jeffreys prior but improper with some traditional priors found in the literature. With the Jeffreys prior, the posterior distribution is also shown to vanish at the boundaries of the parameters' domain, which means that sampling the posterior distribution of the parameters does not result in anomalously small or large values. Therefore, the use of the Jeffreys prior does not result in degenerate fragility curves such as unit-step functions, and leads to more robust credibility intervals. The numerical results obtained from different case studies-including an industrial example-illustrate the theoretical predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2024; v1 submitted 14 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Uncertainty quantification and global sensitivity analysis of seismic fragility curves using kriging
Authors:
Clement Gauchy,
Cyril Feau,
Josselin Garnier
Abstract:
Seismic fragility curves have been introduced as key components of Seismic Probabilistic Risk Assessment studies. They express the probability of failure of mechanical structures conditional to a seismic intensity measure and must take into account the inherent uncertainties in such studies, the so-called epistemic uncertainties (i.e. coming from the uncertainty on the mechanical parameters of the…
▽ More
Seismic fragility curves have been introduced as key components of Seismic Probabilistic Risk Assessment studies. They express the probability of failure of mechanical structures conditional to a seismic intensity measure and must take into account the inherent uncertainties in such studies, the so-called epistemic uncertainties (i.e. coming from the uncertainty on the mechanical parameters of the structure) and the aleatory uncertainties (i.e. coming from the randomness of the seismic ground motions). For simulation-based approaches we propose a methodology to build and calibrate a Gaussian process surrogate model to estimate a family of non-parametric seismic fragility curves for a mechanical structure by propagating both the surrogate model uncertainty and the epistemic ones. Gaussian processes have indeed the main advantage to propose both a predictor and an assessment of the uncertainty of its predictions. In addition, we extend this methodology to sensitivity analysis. Global sensitivity indices such as aggregated Sobol indices and kernel-based indices are proposed to know how the uncertainty on the seismic fragility curves is apportioned according to each uncertain mechanical parameter. This comprehensive Uncertainty Quantification framework is finally applied to an industrial test case consisting in a part of a piping system of a Pressurized Water Reactor.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Importance sampling based active learning for parametric seismic fragility curve estimation
Authors:
Clement Gauchy,
Cyril Feau,
Josselin Garnier
Abstract:
The key elements of seismic probabilistic risk assessment studies are the fragility curves which express the probabilities of failure of structures conditional to a seismic intensity measure. A multitude of procedures is currently available to estimate these curves. For modeling-based approaches which may involve complex and expensive numerical models, the main challenge is to optimize the calls t…
▽ More
The key elements of seismic probabilistic risk assessment studies are the fragility curves which express the probabilities of failure of structures conditional to a seismic intensity measure. A multitude of procedures is currently available to estimate these curves. For modeling-based approaches which may involve complex and expensive numerical models, the main challenge is to optimize the calls to the numerical codes to reduce the estimation costs. Adaptive techniques can be used for this purpose, but in doing so, taking into account the uncertainties of the estimates (via confidence intervals or ellipsoids related to the size of the samples used) is an arduous task because the samples are no longer independent and possibly not identically distributed. The main contribution of this work is to deal with this question in a mathematical and rigorous way. To this end, we propose and implement an active learning methodology based on adaptive importance sampling for parametric estimations of fragility curves. We prove some theoretical properties (consistency and asymptotic normality) for the estimator of interest. Moreover, we give a convergence criterion in order to use asymptotic confidence ellipsoids. Finally, the performances of the methodology are evaluated on analytical and industrial test cases of increasing complexity.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2022; v1 submitted 9 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Efficient Seismic fragility curve estimation by Active Learning on Support Vector Machines
Authors:
Rémi Sainct,
Cyril Feau,
Jean-Marc Martinez,
Josselin Garnier
Abstract:
Fragility curves which express the failure probability of a structure, or critical components, as function of a loading intensity measure are nowadays widely used (i) in Seismic Probabilistic Risk Assessment studies, (ii) to evaluate impact of construction details on the structural performance of installations under seismic excitations or under other loading sources such as wind. To avoid the use…
▽ More
Fragility curves which express the failure probability of a structure, or critical components, as function of a loading intensity measure are nowadays widely used (i) in Seismic Probabilistic Risk Assessment studies, (ii) to evaluate impact of construction details on the structural performance of installations under seismic excitations or under other loading sources such as wind. To avoid the use of parametric models such as lognormal model to estimate fragility curves from a reduced number of numerical calculations, a methodology based on Support Vector Machines coupled with an active learning algorithm is proposed in this paper. In practice, input excitation is reduced to some relevant parameters and, given these parameters, SVMs are used for a binary classification of the structural responses relative to a limit threshold of exceedance. Since the output is not only binary, this is a score, a probabilistic interpretation of the output is exploited to estimate very efficiently fragility curves as score functions or as functions of classical seismic intensity measures.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
