-
Andromeda's Parachute: Time Delays and Hubble Constant
Authors:
Vyacheslav N. Shalyapin,
Luis J. Goicoechea,
Karianne Dyrland,
Håkon Dahle
Abstract:
The gravitational lens system PS J0147+4630 (Andromeda's Parachute) consists of four quasar images ABCD and a lensing galaxy. We obtained $r$-band light curves of ABCD in the 2017$-$2022 period from monitoring with two 2-m class telescopes. Applying state-of-the-art curve shifting algorithms to these light curves led to measurements of time delays between images, and the three independent delays r…
▽ More
The gravitational lens system PS J0147+4630 (Andromeda's Parachute) consists of four quasar images ABCD and a lensing galaxy. We obtained $r$-band light curves of ABCD in the 2017$-$2022 period from monitoring with two 2-m class telescopes. Applying state-of-the-art curve shifting algorithms to these light curves led to measurements of time delays between images, and the three independent delays relative to image D are accurate enough to be used in cosmological studies (uncertainty of about 4%): $Δt_{\rm{AD}}$ = $-$170.5 $\pm$ 7.0, $Δt_{\rm{BD}}$ = $-$170.4 $\pm$ 6.0, and $Δt_{\rm{CD}}$ = $-$177.0 $\pm$ 6.5 d, where image D is trailing all the other images. Our finely sampled light curves and some additional fluxes in the years 2010$-$2013 also demonstrated the presence of significant microlensing variations. From the measured delays relative to image D and typical values of the external convergence, recent lens mass models yielded a Hubble constant that is in clear disagreement with currently accepted values around 70 km s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$. We discuss how to account for a standard value of the Hubble constant without invoking the presence of an extraordinary high external convergence.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Does the evaluation stand up to evaluation? A first-principle approach to the evaluation of classifiers
Authors:
K. Dyrland,
A. S. Lundervold,
P. G. L. Porta Mana
Abstract:
How can one meaningfully make a measurement, if the meter does not conform to any standard and its scale expands or shrinks depending on what is measured? In the present work it is argued that current evaluation practices for machine-learning classifiers are affected by this kind of problem, leading to negative consequences when classifiers are put to real use; consequences that could have been av…
▽ More
How can one meaningfully make a measurement, if the meter does not conform to any standard and its scale expands or shrinks depending on what is measured? In the present work it is argued that current evaluation practices for machine-learning classifiers are affected by this kind of problem, leading to negative consequences when classifiers are put to real use; consequences that could have been avoided. It is proposed that evaluation be grounded on Decision Theory, and the implications of such foundation are explored. The main result is that every evaluation metric must be a linear combination of confusion-matrix elements, with coefficients - "utilities" - that depend on the specific classification problem. For binary classification, the space of such possible metrics is effectively two-dimensional. It is shown that popular metrics such as precision, balanced accuracy, Matthews Correlation Coefficient, Fowlkes-Mallows index, F1-measure, and Area Under the Curve are never optimal: they always give rise to an in-principle avoidable fraction of incorrect evaluations. This fraction is even larger than would be caused by the use of a decision-theoretic metric with moderately wrong coefficients.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Don't guess what's true: choose what's optimal. A probability transducer for machine-learning classifiers
Authors:
K. Dyrland,
A. S. Lundervold,
P. G. L. Porta Mana
Abstract:
In fields such as medicine and drug discovery, the ultimate goal of a classification is not to guess a class, but to choose the optimal course of action among a set of possible ones, usually not in one-one correspondence with the set of classes. This decision-theoretic problem requires sensible probabilities for the classes. Probabilities conditional on the features are computationally almost impo…
▽ More
In fields such as medicine and drug discovery, the ultimate goal of a classification is not to guess a class, but to choose the optimal course of action among a set of possible ones, usually not in one-one correspondence with the set of classes. This decision-theoretic problem requires sensible probabilities for the classes. Probabilities conditional on the features are computationally almost impossible to find in many important cases. The main idea of the present work is to calculate probabilities conditional not on the features, but on the trained classifier's output. This calculation is cheap, needs to be made only once, and provides an output-to-probability "transducer" that can be applied to all future outputs of the classifier. In conjunction with problem-dependent utilities, the probabilities of the transducer allow us to find the optimal choice among the classes or among a set of more general decisions, by means of expected-utility maximization. This idea is demonstrated in a simplified drug-discovery problem with a highly imbalanced dataset. The transducer and utility maximization together always lead to improved results, sometimes close to theoretical maximum, for all sets of problem-dependent utilities. The one-time-only calculation of the transducer also provides, automatically: (i) a quantification of the uncertainty about the transducer itself; (ii) the expected utility of the augmented algorithm (including its uncertainty), which can be used for algorithm selection; (iii) the possibility of using the algorithm in a "generative mode", useful if the training dataset is biased.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Revisiting Andromeda's Parachute
Authors:
Vyacheslav N. Shalyapin,
Luis J. Goicoechea,
Karianne Dyrland,
Hakon Dahle
Abstract:
The gravitational lens system PS J0147+4630 (Andromeda's Parachute) consists of four quasar images ABCD and a lensing galaxy. We obtained $r$-band light curves of ABCD in the 2017$-$2021 period from a monitoring with two 2-m class telescopes. These curves and state-of-the-art curve-shifting algorithms led to three independent time delays relative to image A, one of which is accurate enough (uncert…
▽ More
The gravitational lens system PS J0147+4630 (Andromeda's Parachute) consists of four quasar images ABCD and a lensing galaxy. We obtained $r$-band light curves of ABCD in the 2017$-$2021 period from a monitoring with two 2-m class telescopes. These curves and state-of-the-art curve-shifting algorithms led to three independent time delays relative to image A, one of which is accurate enough (uncertainty of about 4%) to be used in cosmological studies. Our finely sampled light curves and some additional fluxes in the years 2010$-$2013 also demonstrated the presence of significant microlensing variations. This paper also focused on new near-IR spectra of ABCD in 2018$-$2019 that were derived from archive data of two 10-m class telescopes. We analysed the spectral region including the MgII, H$β$, [OIII], and H$α$ emission lines (0.9$-$2.4 $μ$m), measuring image flux ratios and a reliable quasar redshift of 2.357 $\pm$ 0.002, and finding evidence of an outflow in the H$α$ emission. In addition, we updated the lens mass model of the system and estimated a quasar black-hole logarithmic mass ${\log \left[ M_{\rm{BH}}/\rm{M_{\odot}} \right]}$ = 9.34 $\pm$ 0.30.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2023; v1 submitted 18 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Dynamical Modeling of the CIV Broad Line Region of the $z=2.805$ Multiply Imaged Quasar SDSS J2222+2745
Authors:
Peter R. Williams,
Tommaso Treu,
Håkon Dahle,
Stefano Valenti,
Louis Abramson,
Aaron J. Barth,
Brendon J. Brewer,
Karianne Dyrland,
Michael Gladders,
Keith Horne,
Keren Sharon
Abstract:
We present CIV BLR modeling results for the multiply imaged $z=2.805$ quasar SDSS J2222+2745. Using data covering a 5.3 year baseline after accounting for gravitational time delays, we find models that can reproduce the observed emission-line spectra and integrated CIV fluctuations. The models suggest a thick disk BLR that is inclined by $\sim$40 degrees to the observer's line of sight and with a…
▽ More
We present CIV BLR modeling results for the multiply imaged $z=2.805$ quasar SDSS J2222+2745. Using data covering a 5.3 year baseline after accounting for gravitational time delays, we find models that can reproduce the observed emission-line spectra and integrated CIV fluctuations. The models suggest a thick disk BLR that is inclined by $\sim$40 degrees to the observer's line of sight and with a emissivity weighted median radius of $r_{\rm median} = 33.0^{+2.4}_{-2.1}$ light days. The kinematics are dominated by near-circular Keplerian motion with the remainder inflowing. The rest-frame lag one would measure from the models is $τ_{\rm median} = 36.4^{+1.8}_{-1.8}$ days, which is consistent with measurements based on cross-correlation. We show a possible geometry and transfer function based on the model fits and find that the model-produced velocity-resolved lags are consistent with those from cross-correlation. We measure a black hole mass of $\log_{10}(M_{\rm BH}/M_\odot) = 8.31^{+0.07}_{-0.06}$, which requires a scale factor of $\log_{10}(f_{{\rm mean},σ}) = 0.20^{+0.09}_{-0.07}$.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
