-
Adaptive importance sampling based on fault tree analysis for piecewise deterministic Markov process
Authors:
Guillaume Chennetier,
Hassane Chraibi,
Anne Dutfoy,
Josselin Garnier
Abstract:
Piecewise deterministic Markov processes (PDMPs) can be used to model complex dynamical industrial systems. The counterpart of this modeling capability is their simulation cost, which makes reliability assessment untractable with standard Monte Carlo methods. A significant variance reduction can be obtained with an adaptive importance sampling (AIS) method based on a cross-entropy (CE) procedure.…
▽ More
Piecewise deterministic Markov processes (PDMPs) can be used to model complex dynamical industrial systems. The counterpart of this modeling capability is their simulation cost, which makes reliability assessment untractable with standard Monte Carlo methods. A significant variance reduction can be obtained with an adaptive importance sampling (AIS) method based on a cross-entropy (CE) procedure. The success of this method relies on the selection of a good family of approximations of the committor function of the PDMP. In this paper original families are proposed. They are well adapted to high-dimensional industrial systems. Their forms are based on reliability concepts related to fault tree analysis: minimal path sets and minimal cut sets. The proposed method is discussed in detail and applied to academic systems and to a realistic system from the nuclear industry.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2023; v1 submitted 17 September, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Numerical simulation of universal morphogenesis of fluid interface deformations driven by radiation pressure
Authors:
Hugo Chesneau,
Hamza Chraibi,
Nicolas Bertin,
Julien Petit,
Jean-Pierre Delville,
Etienne Brasselet,
Regis Wunenburger
Abstract:
We report on ab initio simulation of fluid interface deformations induced either by acoustic or optical radiation pressure. This is done by solving simultaneously the scalar wave propagation equation and the two-phase flow equations using the boundary element method. Using dimensional analysis, we show that interface deformation morphogenesis is universal, i.e. depends on the same dimensionless pa…
▽ More
We report on ab initio simulation of fluid interface deformations induced either by acoustic or optical radiation pressure. This is done by solving simultaneously the scalar wave propagation equation and the two-phase flow equations using the boundary element method. Using dimensional analysis, we show that interface deformation morphogenesis is universal, i.e. depends on the same dimensionless parameters in acoustics and electromagnetics. We numerically investigate a few selected phenomena -- in particular the shape of large deformations, the slenderness transition and its hysteresis -- and compare with existing and novel experimental observations. Qualitative agreement between the numerical simulations and experiments is found when the mutual interaction between wave propagation and wave-induced deformations is taken into account. Our results demonstrate the leading role of the radiation pressure in morphogenesis of fluid interface deformations and the importance of the propagation-deformation interplay .
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2022; v1 submitted 1 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Application of the interacting particle system method to piecewise deterministic Markov processes used in reliability
Authors:
H. Chraibi,
A. Dutfoy,
T. Galtier,
J. Garnier
Abstract:
Variance reduction methods are often needed for the reliability assessment of complex industrial systems, we focus on one variance reduction method in a given context, that is the interacting particle system method (IPS) used on piecewise deterministic Markov processes (PDMP) for reliability assessment . The PDMPs are a very large class of processes which benefit from high modeling capacities, the…
▽ More
Variance reduction methods are often needed for the reliability assessment of complex industrial systems, we focus on one variance reduction method in a given context, that is the interacting particle system method (IPS) used on piecewise deterministic Markov processes (PDMP) for reliability assessment . The PDMPs are a very large class of processes which benefit from high modeling capacities, they can model almost any Markovian phenomenon that does not include diffusion. In reliability assessment, the PDMPs modeling industrial systems generally involve low jump rates and jump kernels favoring one safe arrival, we call such model a "concentrated PDMP".
Used on such concentrated PDMPs, the IPS is inefficient and does not always provide a variance reduction. Indeed, the efficiency of the IPS method relies on simulating many different trajectories during its propagation steps, but unfortunately concentrated PDMPs are likely to generate the same deterministic trajectories over and over. We propose an adaptation of the IPS method called IPS+M that reduces this phenomenon. The IPS+M consists in modifying the propagation steps of the IPS, by conditioning the propagation to avoid generating the same trajectories multiple times. We prove that, compared to the IPS, the IPS+M method always provides an estimator with a lower variance. We also carry out a quick simulation study on a two-components system that confirms this result.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Optimal input potential functions in the interacting particle system method
Authors:
H. Chraibi,
A. Dutfoy,
T. Galtier,
J. Garnier
Abstract:
The assessment of the probability of a rare event with a naive Monte-Carlo method is computationally intensive, so faster estimation or variance reduction methods are needed. We focus on one of these methods which is the interacting particle system (IPS) method. The method is not intrusive in the sense that the random Markov system under consideration is simulated with its original distribution, b…
▽ More
The assessment of the probability of a rare event with a naive Monte-Carlo method is computationally intensive, so faster estimation or variance reduction methods are needed. We focus on one of these methods which is the interacting particle system (IPS) method. The method is not intrusive in the sense that the random Markov system under consideration is simulated with its original distribution, but selection steps are introduced that favor trajectories (particles) with high potential values. An unbiased estimator with reduced variance can then be proposed. The method requires to specify a set of potential functions. The choice of these functions is crucial, because it determines the magnitude of the variance reduction. So far, little information was available on how to choose the potential functions. This paper provides the expressions of the optimal potential functions minimizing the asymptotic variance of the estimator of the IPS method and it proposes recommendations for the practical design of the potential functions.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2020; v1 submitted 26 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Monte-Carlo acceleration: importance sampling and hybrid dynamic systems
Authors:
H. Chraibi,
A. Dutfoy,
T. Galtier,
J. Garnier
Abstract:
The reliability of a complex industrial system can rarely be assessed analytically. As system failure is often a rare event, crude Monte-Carlo methods are prohibitively expensive from a computational point of view. In order to reduce computation times, variance reduction methods such as importance sampling can be used. We propose an adaptation of this method for a class of multi-component dynamica…
▽ More
The reliability of a complex industrial system can rarely be assessed analytically. As system failure is often a rare event, crude Monte-Carlo methods are prohibitively expensive from a computational point of view. In order to reduce computation times, variance reduction methods such as importance sampling can be used. We propose an adaptation of this method for a class of multi-component dynamical systems. We address a system whose failure corresponds to a physical variable of the system (temperature, pressure, water level) entering a critical region. Such systems are common in hydraulic and nuclear industry. In these systems, the statuses of the components (on, off, or out-of-order) determine the dynamics of the physical variables, and is altered both by deterministic feedback mechanisms and random failures or repairs. In order to deal with this interplay between components status and physical variables we model trajectory using piecewise deterministic Markovian processes (PDMP). We show how to adapt the importance sampling method to PDMP, by introducing a reference measure on the trajectory space, and we present a biasing strategy for importance sampling. A simulation study compares our importance sampling method to the crude Monte-Carlo method for a three-component-system.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2019; v1 submitted 25 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
A Pragmatic Approach for Measuring Maintainability of DPRA Models
Authors:
Irina Rychkova,
Fabrice Boissier,
Hassane Chraibi,
Valentin Rychkov
Abstract:
Dynamic Probabilistic Risk Assessment (DPRA) is a powerful concept that is used to evaluate design and safety of complex industrial systems. A DPRA model uses a conceptual system representation as a formal basis for simulation and analysis. In this paper we consider an adaptive maintenance of DPRA models that consist in modifying and extending a simplified model to a real-size DPRA model. We propo…
▽ More
Dynamic Probabilistic Risk Assessment (DPRA) is a powerful concept that is used to evaluate design and safety of complex industrial systems. A DPRA model uses a conceptual system representation as a formal basis for simulation and analysis. In this paper we consider an adaptive maintenance of DPRA models that consist in modifying and extending a simplified model to a real-size DPRA model. We propose an approach for quantitative maintainability assessment of DPRA models created with an industrial modeling tool called PyCATSHOO. We review and adopt some metrics from conceptual modeling, software engineering and OO design for assessing maintainability of PyCATSHOO models. On the example of well-known "Heated Room" test case, we illustrate how the selected metrics can serve as early indicators of model modifiability and complexity. These indicators would allow experts to make better decisions early in the DPRA model development life cycle.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Visco-elastic drag forces and crossover from no-slip to slip boundary conditions for flow near air-water interfaces
Authors:
Abdelhamid Maali,
Rodolphe Boisgard,
Hamza Chraibi,
Zaicheng Zhang,
Hamid Kellay,
Alois Würger
Abstract:
The "free" water surface is generally prone to contamination with surface impurities be they surfactants, particles or other surface active agents. The presence of such impurities can modify flow boundary near such interfaces in a drastic manner. Here we show that vibrating a small sphere mounted on an AFM cantilever near a gas bubble immersed in water, is an excellent probe of surface contaminati…
▽ More
The "free" water surface is generally prone to contamination with surface impurities be they surfactants, particles or other surface active agents. The presence of such impurities can modify flow boundary near such interfaces in a drastic manner. Here we show that vibrating a small sphere mounted on an AFM cantilever near a gas bubble immersed in water, is an excellent probe of surface contamination. Both viscous and elastic forces are exerted by an air-water interface on the vibrating sphere even when very low doses of contaminants are present. The viscous drag forces show a cross-over from no-slip to slip boundary conditions while the elastic forces show a nontrivial variation as the vibration frequency changes. We provide a simple model to rationalize these results and propose a simple way of evaluating the concentration of such surface impurities.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Sedimentation of granular columns in the viscous and weakly inertial regimes
Authors:
Hamza Chraibi,
Yacine Amarouchene
Abstract:
We investigate the dynamics of granular columns of point particles that interact via long-range hydrodynamic interactions and fall under the action of gravity. We investigate the influence of inertia using the Green's function for the Oseen equation. The initial conditions (density and aspect ratio) are systematically varied. Our results suggest that universal self-similar laws may be sufficient t…
▽ More
We investigate the dynamics of granular columns of point particles that interact via long-range hydrodynamic interactions and fall under the action of gravity. We investigate the influence of inertia using the Green's function for the Oseen equation. The initial conditions (density and aspect ratio) are systematically varied. Our results suggest that universal self-similar laws may be sufficient to characterize the temporal and structural evolution of the granular columns. A characteristic time above which an instability is triggered (which may enable the formation of clusters) is also retrieved and discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Excitation of fountain and entrainment instabilities at the interface between two viscous fluids using a beam of laser light
Authors:
Hamza Chraibi,
Julien Petit,
Régis Wunenburger,
Jean-Pierre Delville
Abstract:
We report on two instabilities called viscous fountain and viscous entrainment triggered at the interface between two liquids by the action of bulk flows driven by a laser beam. These streaming flows are due to light scattering losses in turbid liquids, and can be directed either toward or forward the interface. We experimentally and numerically investigate these interface instabilities and show t…
▽ More
We report on two instabilities called viscous fountain and viscous entrainment triggered at the interface between two liquids by the action of bulk flows driven by a laser beam. These streaming flows are due to light scattering losses in turbid liquids, and can be directed either toward or forward the interface. We experimentally and numerically investigate these interface instabilities and show that the height and curvature of the interface deformation at the threshold and the jet radius after interface destabilization mainly depend on the waist of the laser beam. Analogies and differences between these two instabilities are characterized.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Universal morphologies of fluid interfaces deformed by the radiation pressure of acoustic or electromagnetic waves
Authors:
Nicolas Bertin,
Hamza Chraibi,
Régis Wunenburger,
Jean-Pierre Delville,
Etienne Brasselet
Abstract:
We unveil the generation of universal morphologies of fluid interfaces by radiation pressure whatever is the nature of the wave, acoustic or optical. Experimental observations reveal interface deformations endowed with step-like features that are shown to result from the interplay between the wave propagation and the shape of the interface. The results are supported by numerical simulations and a…
▽ More
We unveil the generation of universal morphologies of fluid interfaces by radiation pressure whatever is the nature of the wave, acoustic or optical. Experimental observations reveal interface deformations endowed with step-like features that are shown to result from the interplay between the wave propagation and the shape of the interface. The results are supported by numerical simulations and a quantitative interpretation based on the waveguiding properties of the field is provided.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Thermocapillary flows and interface deformations produced by localized laser heating in confined environment
Authors:
Hamza Chraibi,
Jean-Pierre Delville
Abstract:
The deformation of a fluid-fluid interface due to the thermocapillary stress induced by a continuous Gaussian laser wave is investigated analytically. We show that the direction of deformation of the liquid interface strongly depends on the viscosities and the thicknesses of the involved liquid layers. We first investigate the case of an interface separating two different liquid layers while a sec…
▽ More
The deformation of a fluid-fluid interface due to the thermocapillary stress induced by a continuous Gaussian laser wave is investigated analytically. We show that the direction of deformation of the liquid interface strongly depends on the viscosities and the thicknesses of the involved liquid layers. We first investigate the case of an interface separating two different liquid layers while a second part is dedicated to a thin film squeezed by two external layers of same liquid. These results are predictive for applications fields where localized thermocapillary stresses are used to produce flows or to deform interfaces in presence of confinement, such as optofluidics.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
Eddies and interface deformations induced by optical streaming
Authors:
Hamza Chraibi,
Régis Wunenburger,
Didier Lasseux,
Julien Petit,
Jean-Pierre Delville
Abstract:
We study flows and interface deformations produced by the scattering of a laser beam propagating through non-absorbing turbid fluids. Light scattering produces a force density resulting from the transfer of linear momentum from the laser to the scatterers. The flow induced in the direction of the beam propagation, called 'optical streaming', is also able to deform the interface separating the two…
▽ More
We study flows and interface deformations produced by the scattering of a laser beam propagating through non-absorbing turbid fluids. Light scattering produces a force density resulting from the transfer of linear momentum from the laser to the scatterers. The flow induced in the direction of the beam propagation, called 'optical streaming', is also able to deform the interface separating the two liquid phases and to produce wide humps. The viscous flow taking place in these two liquid layers is solved analytically, in one of the two liquid layers with a stream function formulation, as well as numerically in both fluids using a boundary integral element method. Quantitative comparisons are shown between the numerical and analytical flow patterns. Moreover, we present predictive simulations regarding the effects of the geometry, of the scattering strength and of the viscosities, on both the flow pattern and the deformation of the interface. Finally, theoretical arguments are put forth to explain the robustness of the emergence of secondary flows in a two-layer fluid system.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Optohydrodynamics of soft fluid interfaces : Optical and viscous nonlinear effects
Authors:
Hamza Chraibi,
Didier Lasseux,
Régis Wunenburger,
Eric Arquis,
Jean-Pierre Delville
Abstract:
Recent experimental developments showed that the use of the radiation pressure, induced by a continuous laser wave, to control fluid-fluid interface deformations at the microscale, represents a very promising alternative to electric or magnetic actuation. In this article, we solve numerically the dynamics and steady state of the fluid interface under the effects of buoyancy, capillarity, optical r…
▽ More
Recent experimental developments showed that the use of the radiation pressure, induced by a continuous laser wave, to control fluid-fluid interface deformations at the microscale, represents a very promising alternative to electric or magnetic actuation. In this article, we solve numerically the dynamics and steady state of the fluid interface under the effects of buoyancy, capillarity, optical radiation pressure and viscous stress. A precise quantitative validation is shown by comparison with experimental data. New results due to the nonlinear dependence of the optical pressure on the angle of incidence are presented, showing different morphologies of the deformed interface going from needle-like to finger-like shapes, depending on the refractive index contrast. In the transient regime, we show that the viscosity ratio influences the time taken for the deformation to reach steady state.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
-
Influence of wettability on liquid water transport in gas diffusion layer of proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFC)
Authors:
Hamza Chraibi,
L. Ceballos,
M. Prat,
Michel Quintard,
Alexandre Vabre
Abstract:
Water management is a key factor that limits PEFC's performance. We show how insights into this problem can be gained from pore-scale simulations of water invasion in a model fibrous medium. We explore the influence of contact angle on the water invasion pattern and water saturation at breakthrough and show that a dramatic change in the invasion pattern, from fractal to compact, occurs as the sy…
▽ More
Water management is a key factor that limits PEFC's performance. We show how insights into this problem can be gained from pore-scale simulations of water invasion in a model fibrous medium. We explore the influence of contact angle on the water invasion pattern and water saturation at breakthrough and show that a dramatic change in the invasion pattern, from fractal to compact, occurs as the system changes from hydrophobic to hydrophilic. Then, we explore the case of a system of mixed wettability, i.e. containing both hydrophilic and hydrophobic pores. The saturation at breakthrough is studied as a function of the fraction of hydrophilic pores. The results are discussed in relation with the water management problem, the optimal design of a GDL and the fuel cell performance degradation mechanisms. We outline how the study could be extended to 3D systems, notably from binarised images of GDLs obtained by X ray microtomography.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Stretching and squeezing of sessile dielectric drops by the optical radiation pressure
Authors:
Hamza Chraibi,
Didier Lasseux,
Eric Arquis,
Régis Wunenburger,
Jean-Pierre Delville
Abstract:
We study numerically the deformation of sessile dielectric drops immersed in a second fluid when submitted to the optical radiation pressure of a continuous Gaussian laser wave. Both drop stretching and drop squeezing are investigated at steady state where capillary effects balance the optical radiation pressure. A boundary integral method is implemented to solve the axisymmetric Stokes flow in…
▽ More
We study numerically the deformation of sessile dielectric drops immersed in a second fluid when submitted to the optical radiation pressure of a continuous Gaussian laser wave. Both drop stretching and drop squeezing are investigated at steady state where capillary effects balance the optical radiation pressure. A boundary integral method is implemented to solve the axisymmetric Stokes flow in the two fluids. In the stretching case, we find that the drop shape goes from prolate to near-conical for increasing optical radiation pressure whatever the drop to beam radius ratio and the refractive index contrast between the two fluids. The semi-angle of the cone at equilibrium decreases with the drop to beam radius ratio and is weakly influenced by the index contrast. Above a threshold value of the radiation pressure, these "optical cones" become unstable and a disruption is observed. Conversely, when optically squeezed, the drop shifts from an oblate to a concave shape leading to the formation of a stable "optical torus". These findings extend the electrohydrodynamics approach of drop deformation to the much less investigated "optical domain" and reveal the openings offered by laser waves to actively manipulate droplets at the micrometer scale.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Laser microfluidics: fluid actuation by light
Authors:
Jean-Pierre Delville,
Matthieu Robert De Saint-Vincent,
Robert D. Schroll,
Hamza Chraibi,
B. Issenmann,
Régis Wunenburger,
Didier Lasseux,
Wendy W Zhang,
Etienne Brasselet
Abstract:
The development of microfluidic devices is still hindered by the lack of robust fundamental building blocks that constitute any fluidic system. An attractive approach is optical actuation because light field interaction is contactless and dynamically reconfigurable, and solutions have been anticipated through the use of optical forces to manipulate microparticles in flows. Following the concept…
▽ More
The development of microfluidic devices is still hindered by the lack of robust fundamental building blocks that constitute any fluidic system. An attractive approach is optical actuation because light field interaction is contactless and dynamically reconfigurable, and solutions have been anticipated through the use of optical forces to manipulate microparticles in flows. Following the concept of an 'optical chip' advanced from the optical actuation of suspensions, we propose in this survey new routes to extend this concept to microfluidic two-phase flows. First, we investigate the destabilization of fluid interfaces by the optical radiation pressure and the formation of liquid jets. We analyze the droplet shedding from the jet tip and the continuous transport in laser-sustained liquid channels. In the second part, we investigate a dissipative light-flow interaction mechanism consisting in heating locally two immiscible fluids to produce thermocapillary stresses along their interface. This opto-capillary coupling is implemented in adequate microchannel geometries to manipulate two-phase flows and propose a contactless optical toolbox including valves, droplet sorters and switches, droplet dividers or droplet mergers. Finally, we discuss radiation pressure and opto-capillary effects in the context of the 'optical chip' where flows, channels and operating functions would all be performed optically on the same device.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Influence of contact angle on slow evaporation in two-dimensional porous media
Authors:
Hamza Chraibi,
M. Prat,
O. Chapuis
Abstract:
We study numerically the influence of contact angle on slow evaporation in two-dimensional model porous media. For sufficiently low contact angles, the drying pattern is fractal and can be predicted by a simple model combining the invasion percolation model with the computation of the diffusive transport in the gas phase. The overall drying time is minimum in this regime and is independent of co…
▽ More
We study numerically the influence of contact angle on slow evaporation in two-dimensional model porous media. For sufficiently low contact angles, the drying pattern is fractal and can be predicted by a simple model combining the invasion percolation model with the computation of the diffusive transport in the gas phase. The overall drying time is minimum in this regime and is independent of contact angle over a large range of contact angles up to the beginning of a transition zone. As the contact angle increases in the transition region, the cooperative smoothing mechanisms of the interface become important and the width of the liquid gas interface fingers that form during the evaporation process increases. The mean overall drying time increases in the transition region up to an upper bound which is reached at a critical contact angle Θ_c. The increase in the drying time in the transition region is explained in relation with the diffusional screening phenomenon associated with the Laplace equation governing the vapor transport in the gas phase. Above Θ_c the drying pattern is character- ized by a flat traveling front and the mean overall drying time becomes independent of the contact angle. Drying time fluctuations are studied and are found to be important below Θ_c, i.e., when the pattern is fractal. The fluctuations are of the same order of magnitude regardless of the value of contact angle in this range. The fluctuations are found to die out abruptly at Θ_c as the liquid gas interface becomes a flat front.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
-
Simulation of an optically induced asymmetric deformation of a liquid-liquid interface
Authors:
Hamza Chraibi,
Didier Lasseux,
Eric Arquis,
Régis Wunenburger,
Jean-Pierre Delville
Abstract:
Deformations of liquid interfaces by the optical radiation pressure of a focused laser wave were generally expected to display similar behavior, whatever the direction of propagation of the incident beam. Recent experiments showed that the invariance of interface deformations with respect to the direction of propagation of the incident wave is broken at high laser intensities. In the case of a b…
▽ More
Deformations of liquid interfaces by the optical radiation pressure of a focused laser wave were generally expected to display similar behavior, whatever the direction of propagation of the incident beam. Recent experiments showed that the invariance of interface deformations with respect to the direction of propagation of the incident wave is broken at high laser intensities. In the case of a beam propagating from the liquid of smaller refractive index to that of larger one, the interface remains stable, forming a nipple-like shape, while for the opposite direction of propagation, an instability occurs, leading to a long needle-like deformation emitting micro-droplets. While an analytical model successfully predicts the equilibrium shape of weakly deformed interface, very few work has been accomplished in the regime of large interface deformations. In this work, we use the Boundary Integral Element Method (BIEM) to compute the evolution of the shape of a fluid-fluid interface under the effect of a continuous laser wave, and we compare our numerical simulations to experimental data in the regime of large deformations for both upward and downward beam propagation. We confirm the invariance breakdown observed experimentally and find good agreement between predicted and experimental interface hump heights below the instability threshold.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2009;
originally announced March 2009.
