-
MAD accretion and AGN jets -- an observational perspective
Authors:
Tuomas Savolainen,
Wara Chamani
Abstract:
One of the major open questions related to the production of jets by accreting black holes is: why do sources with similar accretion powers produce so vastly different jet powers? What conditions are required to make a powerful jet? If jets are powered by the Blandford-Zjanek mechanism, two further parameters control the jet power besides the black hole mass - black hole spin and the magnetic flux…
▽ More
One of the major open questions related to the production of jets by accreting black holes is: why do sources with similar accretion powers produce so vastly different jet powers? What conditions are required to make a powerful jet? If jets are powered by the Blandford-Zjanek mechanism, two further parameters control the jet power besides the black hole mass - black hole spin and the magnetic flux threading it. Since highly spinning black holes without jets appear to exist, the jet production efficiency may depend on whether the black hole managed to accrete high enough magnetic flux in the past. The highest-efficiency jets in this picture are launched from magnetically arrested disks (MADs). Here we discuss a method to test this hypothesis using VLBI core-shift measurements to estimate the jet magnetic flux.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
The polarisation behaviour of OJ 287 viewed through radio, millimetre and optical observations between 2015 and 2017
Authors:
J. Jormanainen,
T. Hovatta,
E. Lindfors,
A. Berdyugin,
W. Chamani,
V. Fallah Ramazani,
H. Jermak,
S. G. Jorstad,
A. Lähteenmäki,
C. McCall,
K. Nilsson,
P. Smith,
I. A. Steele,
J. Tammi,
M. Tornikoski,
F. Wierda
Abstract:
OJ 287 is a bright blazar with century-long observations, and one of the strongest candidates to host a supermassive black hole binary. Its polarisation behaviour between 2015 and 2017 (MJD 57300-58000) contains several interesting events that we re-contextualise in this study. We collected optical photometric and polarimetric data from several telescopes and obtained high-cadence light curves fro…
▽ More
OJ 287 is a bright blazar with century-long observations, and one of the strongest candidates to host a supermassive black hole binary. Its polarisation behaviour between 2015 and 2017 (MJD 57300-58000) contains several interesting events that we re-contextualise in this study. We collected optical photometric and polarimetric data from several telescopes and obtained high-cadence light curves from this period. In the radio band, we collected mm-wavelength polarisation data from the AMAPOLA program. We combined these with existing multifrequency polarimetric radio results and the results of very-long-baseline-interferometry imaging with the Global mm-VLBI Array at 86 GHz. In December 2015, an optical flare was seen according to the general relativistic binary black hole model. We suggest that the overall activity near the accretion disk and the jet base during this time may be connected to the onset of a new moving component K seen in the jet in March 2017. With the additional optical data, we find a fast polarisation angle rotation of 210 degrees coinciding with the December 2015 flare, hinting at a possible link between these events. Based on the 86-GHz images, we calculated a new speed of 0.12 mas/yr for K, which places it inside the core at the time of the 2015 flare. This speed also supports the scenario where the passage of K through the quasi-stationary feature S1 could have been the trigger for the very-high-energy gamma-ray flare of OJ 287 seen in February 2017. With the mm-polarisation data, we established that these bands follow the cm-band data but show a difference during the time of K passing through S1. This indicates that the mm-bands trace the substructures of the jet still unresolved in the cm-bands.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2025;
originally announced January 2025.
-
Interactions between the jet and disk wind in a nearby radio intermediate quasar III Zw 2
Authors:
Ailing Wang,
Tao An,
Shaoguang Guo,
Prashanth Mohan,
Wara Chamani,
Willem A. Baan,
Talvikki Hovatta,
Heino Falcke,
Tim J. Galvin,
Natasha Hurley-Walker,
Sumit Jaiswal,
Anne Lahteenmaki,
Baoqiang Lao,
Weijia Lv,
Merja Tornikoski,
Yingkang Zhang
Abstract:
Disk winds and jets are ubiquitous in active galactic nuclei (AGN), and how these two components interact remains an open question. We study the radio properties of a radio-intermediate quasar III Zw 2. We detect two jet knots J1 and J2 on parsec scales, which move at a mildly apparent superluminal speed of $1.35\,c$. Two $γ$-ray flares were detected in III Zw 2 in 2009--2010, corresponding to the…
▽ More
Disk winds and jets are ubiquitous in active galactic nuclei (AGN), and how these two components interact remains an open question. We study the radio properties of a radio-intermediate quasar III Zw 2. We detect two jet knots J1 and J2 on parsec scales, which move at a mildly apparent superluminal speed of $1.35\,c$. Two $γ$-ray flares were detected in III Zw 2 in 2009--2010, corresponding to the primary radio flare in late 2009 and the secondary radio flare in early 2010. The primary 2009 flare was found to be associated with the ejection of J2. The secondary 2010 flare occurred at a distance of $\sim$0.3 parsec from the central engine, probably resulting from the collision of the jet with the accretion disk wind. The variability characteristics of III Zw 2 (periodic radio flares, unstable periodicity, multiple quasi-periodic signals and possible harmonic relations between them) can be explained by the global instabilities of the accretion disk. These instabilities originating from the outer part of the warped disk propagate inwards and can lead to modulation of the accretion rate and consequent jet ejection. At the same time, the wobbling of the outer disk may also lead to oscillations of the boundary between the disk wind and the jet tunnel, resulting in changes in the jet-wind collision site. III Zw 2 is one of the few cases observed with jet-wind interactions, and the study in this paper is of general interest for gaining insight into the dynamic processes in the nuclear regions of AGN.
△ Less
Submitted 28 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Multi-messenger characterization of Mrk 501 during historically low X-ray and $γ$-ray activity
Authors:
MAGIC collaboration,
H. Abe,
S. Abe,
V. A. Acciari,
I. Agudo,
T. Aniello,
S. Ansoldi,
L. A. Antonelli,
A. Arbet Engels,
C. Arcaro,
M. Artero,
K. Asano,
D. Baack,
A. Babić,
A. Baquero,
U. Barres de Almeida,
J. A. Barrio,
I. Batković,
J. Baxter,
J. Becerra González,
W. Bednarek,
E. Bernardini,
M. Bernardos,
A. Berti,
J. Besenrieder
, et al. (300 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We study the broadband emission of Mrk 501 using multi-wavelength observations from 2017 to 2020 performed with a multitude of instruments, involving, among others, MAGIC, Fermi-LAT, NuSTAR, Swift, GASP-WEBT, and OVRO. Mrk 501 showed an extremely low broadband activity, which may help to unravel its baseline emission. Nonetheless, significant flux variations are detected at all wavebands, with the…
▽ More
We study the broadband emission of Mrk 501 using multi-wavelength observations from 2017 to 2020 performed with a multitude of instruments, involving, among others, MAGIC, Fermi-LAT, NuSTAR, Swift, GASP-WEBT, and OVRO. Mrk 501 showed an extremely low broadband activity, which may help to unravel its baseline emission. Nonetheless, significant flux variations are detected at all wavebands, with the highest occurring at X-rays and very-high-energy (VHE) $γ$-rays. A significant correlation ($>$3$σ$) between X-rays and VHE $γ$-rays is measured, supporting leptonic scenarios to explain the variable parts of the emission, also during low activity. This is further supported when we extend our data from 2008 to 2020, and identify, for the first time, significant correlations between Swift-XRT and Fermi-LAT. We additionally find correlations between high-energy $γ$-rays and radio, with the radio lagging by more than 100 days, placing the $γ$-ray emission zone upstream of the radio-bright regions in the jet. Furthermore, Mrk 501 showed a historically low activity in X-rays and VHE $γ$-rays from mid-2017 to mid-2019 with a stable VHE flux ($>$0.2 TeV) of 5% the emission of the Crab Nebula. The broadband spectral energy distribution (SED) of this 2-year-long low-state, the potential baseline emission of Mrk 501, can be characterized with one-zone leptonic models, and with (lepto)-hadronic models fulfilling neutrino flux constraints from IceCube. We explore the time evolution of the SED towards the low-state, revealing that the stable baseline emission may be ascribed to a standing shock, and the variable emission to an additional expanding or traveling shock.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2023; v1 submitted 5 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Time variability of the core-shift effect in the blazar 3C 454.3
Authors:
Wara Chamani,
Tuomas Savolainen,
Eduardo Ros,
Yuri Y. Kovalev,
Kaj Wiik,
Anne Lähteenmäki,
Merja Tornikoski,
Joni Tammi
Abstract:
Using VLBI to measure a so-called core shift effect is a common way of obtaining estimates of the jet magnetic field strength. The VLBI core is typically identified as the bright feature at the jet's base, and the position of the core changes with the observed frequency, $r_\mathrm{core} \propto ν^{-1/k_r}$. In this work, we investigated the time variability of the core-shift effect in the blazar…
▽ More
Using VLBI to measure a so-called core shift effect is a common way of obtaining estimates of the jet magnetic field strength. The VLBI core is typically identified as the bright feature at the jet's base, and the position of the core changes with the observed frequency, $r_\mathrm{core} \propto ν^{-1/k_r}$. In this work, we investigated the time variability of the core-shift effect in the blazar 3C 454.3. We employed self-referencing analysis of multi-frequency (5, 8, 15, 22-24, and 43 GHz) VLBA data covering 19 epochs from 2005 until 2010. We found significant core shift variability ranging from 0.27 to 0.86 mas between 5 and 43 GHz, confirming the core-shift variability phenomenon observed before. Time variability of the core-shift index ($k_r$) was found typically below one, with an average value of $0.85 \pm 0.08$ and a standard deviation of $0.30$. $k_r<1$ values were found during flaring and quiescent states and our results indicate that commonly assumed conical jet shape and equipartition conditions do not always hold simultaneously. Still, these conditions are often assumed when deriving magnetic field strengths from core shift measurements, leading to unreliable results if $k_r$ significantly deviates from unity. Therefore, it is important to verify that $k_r = 1$ holds before using core shift values and the equipartition assumption to derive physical parameters in the jets. When $k_r = 1$ epochs are selected in the case of 3C 454.3, the magnetic field estimates are indeed quite consistent, even though the core shift varies with time. Additionally, our estimations of the jet's magnetic flux in 3C 454.3 show that the source is indeed in the magnetically arrested disk state. Finally, we found a good correlation of the core position with the core flux density, $r_\mathrm{core}\propto S_\mathrm{core}^{0.7}$, which is consistent with increased particle density during the flares.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Testing the magnetic flux paradigm for AGN radio loudness with a radio intermediate quasar
Authors:
Wara Chamani,
Tuomas Savolainen,
Kazuhiro Hada,
Ming H. Xu
Abstract:
For understanding the diversity of jetted active galactic nuclei (AGN) and especially the puzzling wide range in their radio-loudness, it is important to understand what role the magnetic fields play in setting the power of relativistic jets in AGN. We have performed multi-frequency (4-24 GHz) VLBA phase-referencing observations of the radio-intermediate quasar III Zw 2 using three nearby calibrat…
▽ More
For understanding the diversity of jetted active galactic nuclei (AGN) and especially the puzzling wide range in their radio-loudness, it is important to understand what role the magnetic fields play in setting the power of relativistic jets in AGN. We have performed multi-frequency (4-24 GHz) VLBA phase-referencing observations of the radio-intermediate quasar III Zw 2 using three nearby calibrators as reference sources to estimate jet magnetic flux by measuring the core-shift effect. By combining the self-referencing core-shift of each calibrator with the phase-referencing core-shifts, we obtained an upper limit of 0.16 mas for the core-shift between 4 and 24 GHz in III Zw 2. By assuming equipartition between magnetic and particle energy densities and adopting the flux-freezing approximation, we further estimated the upper limit for both magnetic field strength and poloidal magnetic flux threading the black hole. We find that the upper limit to the measured magnetic flux is smaller by at least a factor of five compared to the value predicted by the magnetically arrested disk (MAD) model. An alternative way to derive the jet magnetic field strength from the turnover of the synchrotron spectrum leads to an even smaller upper limit. Hence, the central engine of III Zw 2 has not reached the MAD state, which could explain why it has failed to develop a powerful jet, even though the source harbours a fast-spinning black hole. However, it generates an intermittent jet, which is possibly triggered by small scale magnetic field fluctuations as predicted by the magnetic flux paradigm of Sikora & Begelman (2013). We propose here that combining black hole spin measurements with magnetic field measurements from the VLBI core-shift observations of AGN over a range of jet powers could provide a strong test for the dominant factor setting the jet power relative to the accretion power available.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Joint XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations of the reflection spectrum of III Zw 2
Authors:
Wara Chamani,
Karri Koljonen,
Tuomas Savolainen
Abstract:
Detecting and modelling the reprocessed hard X-ray emission component in the accretion flow, so-called reflection spectrum is a main tool to estimate black hole spins in a wide range of astrophysical black holes regardless of their mass or distance. In this work, we studied the X-ray spectra of the Seyfert I galaxy III Zw 2 using multi-epoch XMM-Newton, NuSTAR and Suzaku observations. The X-ray sp…
▽ More
Detecting and modelling the reprocessed hard X-ray emission component in the accretion flow, so-called reflection spectrum is a main tool to estimate black hole spins in a wide range of astrophysical black holes regardless of their mass or distance. In this work, we studied the X-ray spectra of the Seyfert I galaxy III Zw 2 using multi-epoch XMM-Newton, NuSTAR and Suzaku observations. The X-ray spectra exhibit a soft-excess below 1 keV and a prominent excess at the location of the broad Fe Kα line at 6.4 keV. To account for these spectral features, we have fitted the spectra with multiple models including an ionized partially covering absorber and an accretion disk reflection model. To fully resolve the reflection component, we analyzed jointly the XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations taken in 2017 and archival XMM-Newton data from 2000. Assuming the reflection scenario, the resulting model fits support a rapidly spinning black hole (a > 0.98) in this radio-intermediate source. The X-ray spectra in 2000 and 2017 are remarkably similar with the only difference in the reflection fraction, possibly due to a change in the geometry of the accretion flow. However, the Suzaku observation is markedly different, and we suggest this could be an effect of a jet contribution in the X-ray band, which is supported by the elevated radio flux during this observation.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Long term variability and correlation study of the blazar 3C 454.3 in radio, NIR and optical wavebands
Authors:
A. Sarkar,
V. R. Chitnis,
A. C. Gupta,
H. Gaur,
S. R. Patel,
P. J. Wiita,
A. E. Volvach,
M. Tornikoski,
W. Chamani,
S. Enestam,
A. Lähteenmäki,
J. Tammi,
R. J. C Vera,
L. N. Volvach
Abstract:
We performed a long-term optical (B, V, R bands), infra-red (J and K bands) and radio band (15, 22, 37 GHz band) study on the flat spectrum radio quasar, 3C 454.3, using the data collected over a period of more than 8 years (MJD 54500--57500). The temporal variability, spectral properties and inter-waveband correlations were studied by dividing the available data into smaller segments with more re…
▽ More
We performed a long-term optical (B, V, R bands), infra-red (J and K bands) and radio band (15, 22, 37 GHz band) study on the flat spectrum radio quasar, 3C 454.3, using the data collected over a period of more than 8 years (MJD 54500--57500). The temporal variability, spectral properties and inter-waveband correlations were studied by dividing the available data into smaller segments with more regular sampling. This helped us constrain the size and the relative locations of the emission regions for different wavebands. Spectral analysis of the source revealed the interplay between the accretion disk and jet emission. The source predominantly showed a redder-when-brighter trend, though we observed a bluer-when-brighter trend at high flux levels which could be signatures of particle acceleration and radiative cooling. Significant correlations with near-zero lag were seen between various optical/infra-red bands, indicating that these emission regions are co-spatial. Correlations with a time lag of about 10--100 days are seen between optical/infra-red and radio bands indicating these emissions arise from different regions. We also observe the DCF peak lag change from year to year. We try to explain these differences using a curved jet model where the different emission regions have different viewing angles resulting in a frequency dependent Doppler factor. This variable Doppler factor model explains the variability timescales and the variation in DCF peak lag between the radio and optical emissions in different segments. Lags of 6-180 days are seen between emissions in various radio bands, indicating a core-shift effect
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
X-ray, UV, and Radio Timing Observations of the Radio Galaxy 3C 120
Authors:
Alan P. Marscher,
Svetlana G. Jorstad,
Karen E. Williamson,
Anne Lähteenmäki,
Merja Tornikoski,
John M. Hunter,
Katya A. Leidig,
Muhammad Zain Mobeen,
Rafael J. C. Vera,
Wara Chamani
Abstract:
We report the results of monitoring of the radio galaxy 3C 120 with the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory, Very Long Baseline Array, and Metsähovi Radio Observatory. The UV-optical continuum spectrum and R-band polarization can be explained by a superposition of an inverted-spectrum source with a synchrotron component containing a disordered magnetic field. The UV-optical and X-ray light curves inclu…
▽ More
We report the results of monitoring of the radio galaxy 3C 120 with the Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory, Very Long Baseline Array, and Metsähovi Radio Observatory. The UV-optical continuum spectrum and R-band polarization can be explained by a superposition of an inverted-spectrum source with a synchrotron component containing a disordered magnetic field. The UV-optical and X-ray light curves include dips and flares, while several superluminal knots appear in the parsec-scale jet. The recovery time of the second dip was longer at UV-optical wavelengths, in conflict with a model in which the inner accretion disk (AD) is disrupted during a dip and then refilled from outer to inner radii. We favor an alternative scenario in which occasional polar alignments of the magnetic field in the disk and corona cause the flux dips and formation of shocks in the jet. Similar to observations of Seyfert galaxies, intra-band time lags of flux variations are longer than predicted by the standard AD model. This suggests that scattering or some other reprocessing occurs. The 37 GHz light curve is well correlated with the optical-UV variations, with a ~20-day delay. A radio flare in the jet occurred in a superluminal knot 0.14 milliarcseconds downstream of the 43 GHz "core," which places the site of the preceding X-ray/UV/optical flare within the core 0.5-1.3 pc from the black hole. The inverted UV-optical flare spectrum can be explained by a nearly mono-energetic electron distribution with energy similar to the minimum energy inferred in the TeV gamma-ray emitting regions of some BL Lacertae objects.
△ Less
Submitted 25 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Radio jets and gamma-ray emission in radio-silent narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxies
Authors:
A. Lähteenmäki,
E. Järvelä,
V. Ramakrishnan,
M. Tornikoski,
J. Tammi,
R. J. C. Vera,
W. Chamani
Abstract:
We have detected six narrow-line Seyfert 1 (NLS1) galaxies at 37 GHz that were previously classified as radio silent and two that were classified as radio quiet. These detections reveal the presumption that NLS1 galaxies labelled radio quiet or radio silent and hosted by spiral galaxies are unable to launch jets to be incorrect. The detections are a plausible indicator of the presence of a powerfu…
▽ More
We have detected six narrow-line Seyfert 1 (NLS1) galaxies at 37 GHz that were previously classified as radio silent and two that were classified as radio quiet. These detections reveal the presumption that NLS1 galaxies labelled radio quiet or radio silent and hosted by spiral galaxies are unable to launch jets to be incorrect. The detections are a plausible indicator of the presence of a powerful, most likely relativistic jet because this intensity of emission at 37 GHz cannot be explained by, for example, radiation from supernova remnants. Additionally, one of the detected NLS1 galaxies is a newly discovered source of gamma rays and three others are candidates for future detections.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Multiwavelength observations of the blazar BL Lacertae: a new fast TeV gamma-ray flare
Authors:
A. U. Abeysekara,
W. Benbow,
R. Bird,
T. Brantseg,
R. Brose,
M. Buchovecky,
J. H. Buckley,
V. Bugaev,
M. P. Connolly,
W. Cui,
M. K. Daniel,
A. Falcone,
Q. Feng,
J. P. Finley,
L. Fortson,
A. Furniss,
G. H. Gillanders,
I. Gunawardhana,
M. Hütten,
D. Hanna,
O. Hervet,
J. Holder,
G. Hughes,
T. B. Humensky,
C. A. Johnson
, et al. (52 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Combined with very-long-baseline interferometry measurements, the observations of fast TeV gamma-ray flares probe the structure and emission mechanism of blazar jets. However, only a handful of such flares have been detected to date, and only within the last few years have these flares been observed from lower-frequency-peaked BL~Lac objects and flat-spectrum radio quasars. We report on a fast TeV…
▽ More
Combined with very-long-baseline interferometry measurements, the observations of fast TeV gamma-ray flares probe the structure and emission mechanism of blazar jets. However, only a handful of such flares have been detected to date, and only within the last few years have these flares been observed from lower-frequency-peaked BL~Lac objects and flat-spectrum radio quasars. We report on a fast TeV gamma-ray flare from the blazar BL~Lacertae observed by VERITAS, with a rise time of $\sim$2.3~hr and a decay time of $\sim$36~min. The peak flux above 200 GeV is $(4.2 \pm 0.6) \times 10^{-6} \;\text{photon} \;\text{m}^{-2}\; \text{s}^{-1}$ measured with a 4-minute-binned light curve, corresponding to $\sim$180\% of the flux which is observed from the Crab Nebula above the same energy threshold. Variability contemporaneous with the TeV gamma-ray flare was observed in GeV gamma-ray, X-ray, and optical flux, as well as in optical and radio polarization. Additionally, a possible moving emission feature with superluminal apparent velocity was identified in VLBA observations at 43 GHz, potentially passing the radio core of the jet around the time of the gamma-ray flare. We discuss the constraints on the size, Lorentz factor, and location of the emitting region of the flare, and the interpretations with several theoretical models which invoke relativistic plasma passing stationary shocks.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Turbulent gas accretion between supermassive black holes and star-forming rings in the circumnuclear disk
Authors:
Wara Chamani,
Stephanie Doerschner,
Dominik R. G. Schleicher
Abstract:
While supermassive black holes are known to co-evolve with their host galaxy, the precise nature and origin of this co-evolution is not clear. We here explore the possible connection between star formation and black hole growth in the circumnuclear disk (CND) to probe this connection in the vicinity close to the black hole. We adopt here the circumnuclear disk model developed by Kawakatu & Wada (2…
▽ More
While supermassive black holes are known to co-evolve with their host galaxy, the precise nature and origin of this co-evolution is not clear. We here explore the possible connection between star formation and black hole growth in the circumnuclear disk (CND) to probe this connection in the vicinity close to the black hole. We adopt here the circumnuclear disk model developed by Kawakatu & Wada (2008) and Wutschik et al. (2013), and explore both the dependence on the star formation recipe as well as the role of the gravitational field, which can be dominated by the central black hole, the CND itself or the host galaxy. A specific emphasis is put on the turbulence regulated star formation model by Krumholz et al. (2005) to explore the impact of a realistic star formation recipe. It is shown that this model helps to introduce realistic fluctuations in the black hole and star formation rate, without overestimating them. Consistent with previous works, we show that the final black hole masses are rather insensitive to the masses of the initial seeds, even for seed masses of up to 10^6 M_sol. In addition, we apply our model to the formation of high-redshift quasars, as well as to the nearby system NGC 6951, where a tentative comparison is made in spite of the presence of a bar in the galaxy. We show that our model can reproduce the high black hole masses of the high-redshift quasars within a sufficiently short time, provided a high mass supply rate from the host galaxy. In addition, it reproduces several of the properties observed in NGC 6951. With respect to the latter system, our analysis suggests that supernova feedback may be important to create the observed fluctuations in the star formation history as a result of negative feedback effects.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
