-
Applying a star formation model calibrated on high-resolution interstellar medium simulations to cosmological simulations of galaxy formation
Authors:
Jan D. Burger,
Volker Springel,
Eve C. Ostriker,
Chang-Goo Kim,
Sarah M. R. Jeffreson,
Matthew C. Smith,
Rüdiger Pakmor,
Sultan Hassan,
Drummond Fielding,
Lars Hernquist,
Greg L. Bryan,
Rachel S. Somerville,
Jake S. Bennett,
Rainer Weinberger
Abstract:
Modern high-resolution simulations of the interstellar medium (ISM) have shown that key factors in governing star formation are the competing influences of radiative dissipation, pressure support driven by stellar feedback, and the relentless pull of gravity. Cosmological simulations of galaxy formation, such as IllustrisTNG or ASTRID, are however not able to resolve this physics in detail and the…
▽ More
Modern high-resolution simulations of the interstellar medium (ISM) have shown that key factors in governing star formation are the competing influences of radiative dissipation, pressure support driven by stellar feedback, and the relentless pull of gravity. Cosmological simulations of galaxy formation, such as IllustrisTNG or ASTRID, are however not able to resolve this physics in detail and therefore need to rely on approximate treatments. These have often taken the form of empirical subgrid models of the ISM expressed in terms of an effective equation of state (EOS) that relates the mean ISM pressure to the mean gas density. Here we seek to improve these heuristic models by directly fitting their key ingredients to results of the high-resolution TIGRESS simulations, which have shown that the dynamical equilibrium of the ISM can be understood in terms of a pressure-regulated, feedback modulated (PRFM) model for star formation. Here we explore a simple subgrid model that draws on the PRFM concept but uses only local quantities. It accurately reproduces PRFM for pure gas disks, while it predicts slightly less star formation than PRFM in the presence of an additional thin stellar disk. We compare the properties of this model with the older Springel and Hernquist and TNG prescriptions, and apply all three to isolated simulations of disk galaxies as well as to a set of high-resolution zoom-in simulations carried out with a novel 'multi-zoom' technique that we introduce in this study. The softer EOS implied by TIGRESS produces substantially thinner disk galaxies, which has important ramifications for disk stability and galaxy morphology. The total stellar mass of galaxies is however hardly modified at low redshift, reflecting the dominating influence of large-scale gaseous inflows and outflows to galaxies, which are not sensitive to the EOS itself
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2025;
originally announced February 2025.
-
Towards Implementation of the Pressure-Regulated, Feedback-Modulated Model of Star Formation in Cosmological Simulations: Methods and Application to TNG
Authors:
Sultan Hassan,
Eve C. Ostriker,
Chang-Goo Kim,
Greg L. Bryan,
Jan D. Burger,
Drummond B. Fielding,
John C. Forbes,
Shy Genel,
Lars Hernquist,
Sarah M. R. Jeffreson,
Bhawna Motwani,
Matthew C. Smith,
Rachel S. Somerville,
Ulrich P. Steinwandel,
Romain Teyssier
Abstract:
Traditional star formation subgrid models implemented in cosmological galaxy formation simulations, such as that of Springel & Hernquist (2003, hereafter SH03), employ adjustable parameters to satisfy constraints measured in the local Universe. In recent years, however, theory and spatially-resolved simulations of the turbulent, multiphase, star-forming ISM have begun to produce new first-principl…
▽ More
Traditional star formation subgrid models implemented in cosmological galaxy formation simulations, such as that of Springel & Hernquist (2003, hereafter SH03), employ adjustable parameters to satisfy constraints measured in the local Universe. In recent years, however, theory and spatially-resolved simulations of the turbulent, multiphase, star-forming ISM have begun to produce new first-principles models, which when fully developed can replace traditional subgrid prescriptions. This approach has advantages of being physically motivated and predictive rather than empirically tuned, and allowing for varying environmental conditions rather than being tied to local Universe conditions. As a prototype of this new approach, by combining calibrations from the TIGRESS numerical framework with the Pressure-Regulated Feedback-Modulated (PRFM) theory, simple formulae can be obtained for both the gas depletion time and an effective equation of state. Considering galaxies in TNG50, we compare the "native" simulation outputs with post-processed predictions from PRFM. At TNG50 resolution, the total midplane pressure is nearly equal to the total ISM weight, indicating that galaxies in TNG50 are close to satisfying vertical equilibrium. The measured gas scale height is also close to theoretical equilibrium predictions. The slopes of the effective equations of states are similar, but with effective velocity dispersion normalization from SH03 slightly larger than that from current TIGRESS simulations. Because of this and the decrease in PRFM feedback yield at high pressure, the PRFM model predicts shorter gas depletion times than the SH03 model at high densities and redshift. Our results represent a first step towards implementing new, numerically calibrated subgrid algorithms in cosmological galaxy formation simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Kinematic signatures of impulsive supernova feedback in dwarf galaxies
Authors:
Jan D. Burger,
Jesús Zavala,
Laura V. Sales,
Mark Vogelsberger,
Federico Marinacci,
Paul Torrey
Abstract:
Impulsive supernova feedback and non-standard dark matter models, such as self-interacting dark matter (SIDM), are the two main contenders for the role of the dominant core formation mechanism at the dwarf galaxy scale. Here we show that the impulsive supernova cycles that follow episodes of bursty star formation leave distinct features in the distribution function of stars: groups of stars with s…
▽ More
Impulsive supernova feedback and non-standard dark matter models, such as self-interacting dark matter (SIDM), are the two main contenders for the role of the dominant core formation mechanism at the dwarf galaxy scale. Here we show that the impulsive supernova cycles that follow episodes of bursty star formation leave distinct features in the distribution function of stars: groups of stars with similar ages and metallicities develop overdense shells in phase space. If cores are formed through supernova feedback, we predict the presence of such features in star-forming dwarf galaxies with cored host halos. Their systematic absence would favor alternative dark matter models, such as SIDM, as the dominant core formation mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Real and counterfeit cores: how feedback expands halos and disrupts tracers of inner gravitational potential in dwarf galaxies
Authors:
Ethan D. Jahn,
Laura V. Sales,
Federico Marinacci,
Mark Vogelsberger,
Paul Torrey,
Jia Qi,
Aaron Smith,
Hui Li,
Rahul Kannan,
Jan D. Burger,
Jesús Zavala
Abstract:
The tension between the diverging density profiles in Lambda Cold Dark Matter ($Λ$CDM) simulations and the constant-density inner regions of observed galaxies is a long-standing challenge known as the `core-cusp' problem. We demonstrate that the \texttt{SMUGGLE} galaxy formation model implemented in the \textsc{Arepo} moving mesh code forms constant-density cores in idealized dwarf galaxies of…
▽ More
The tension between the diverging density profiles in Lambda Cold Dark Matter ($Λ$CDM) simulations and the constant-density inner regions of observed galaxies is a long-standing challenge known as the `core-cusp' problem. We demonstrate that the \texttt{SMUGGLE} galaxy formation model implemented in the \textsc{Arepo} moving mesh code forms constant-density cores in idealized dwarf galaxies of $M_\star \approx 8 \times 10^7$ M$_{\odot}$ with initially cuspy dark matter halos of $M_{200} \approx 10^{10}$ M$_{\odot}$. Identical initial conditions run with the Springel and Hernquist (2003; SH03) feedback model preserve cuspiness. Literature on the subject has pointed to the low density threshold for star formation, $ρ_\text{th}$, in SH03-like models as an obstacle to baryon-induced core formation. Using a \texttt{SMUGGLE} run with equal $ρ_\text{th}$ to SH03, we demonstrate that core formation can proceed at low density thresholds, indicating that $ρ_\text{th}$ is insufficient on its own to determine whether a galaxy develops a core. We suggest that the ability to resolve a multiphase interstellar medium at sufficiently high densities is a more reliable indicator of core formation than any individual model parameter. In \texttt{SMUGGLE}, core formation is accompanied by large degrees of non-circular motion, with gas rotational velocity profiles that consistently fall below the circular velocity $v_\text{circ} = \sqrt{GM/R}$ out to $\sim 2$ kpc. This may artificially mimic larger core sizes when derived from observable quantities compared to the size measured from the dark matter distribution ($\sim 0.5$ kpc), highlighting the need for careful modeling in the inner regions of dwarfs to infer the true distribution of dark matter.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Degeneracies Between Self-interacting Dark Matter and Supernova Feedback as cusp-core transformation mechanisms
Authors:
Jan D. Burger,
Jesús Zavala,
Laura V. Sales,
Mark Vogelsberger,
Federico Marinacci,
Paul Torrey
Abstract:
We present a suite of 16 high-resolution hydrodynamic simulations of an isolated dwarf galaxy (gaseous and stellar disk plus a stellar bulge) within an initially cuspy dark matter (DM) halo, including self-interactions between the DM particles (SIDM); as well as stochastic star formation and subsequent supernova feedback (SNF), implemented using the stellar feedback model SMUGGLE. The simulations…
▽ More
We present a suite of 16 high-resolution hydrodynamic simulations of an isolated dwarf galaxy (gaseous and stellar disk plus a stellar bulge) within an initially cuspy dark matter (DM) halo, including self-interactions between the DM particles (SIDM); as well as stochastic star formation and subsequent supernova feedback (SNF), implemented using the stellar feedback model SMUGGLE. The simulations start from identical initial conditions and we regulate the strength of SIDM and SNF by systematically varying the SIDM momentum transfer cross section and the gas density threshold for star formation. The DM halo forms a constant density core of similar size and shape for several combinations of those two parameters. Haloes with cores that are formed due to SIDM (adiabatic cusp-core transformation) have velocity dispersion profiles which are closer to isothermal than those of haloes with cores that are formed due to SNF in simulations with bursty star formation (impulsive cusp-core transformation). Impulsive SNF can generate positive stellar age gradients and increase random motion in the gas at the centre of the galaxy. Simulated galaxies in haloes with cores that were formed adiabatically are spatially more extended, with stellar metallicity gradients that are shallower (at late times) than those of galaxies in other simulations. Such observable properties of the gas and the stars, which indicate either an adiabatic or an impulsive evolution of the gravitational potential, may be used to determine whether observed cores in DM haloes are formed through self-interactions between the DM particles or in response to impulsive SNF.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2022; v1 submitted 16 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
SN-driven mechanism of cusp-core transformation: an appraisal
Authors:
Jan D. Burger,
Jesús Zavala
Abstract:
We present and test an effective model for N -body simulations that aims at mimicking the impact of supernova (SN) feedback on the dark matter (DM) distribution of isolated halos hosting dwarf galaxies. Although the model is physically decoupled from the cosmological history of both the DM halo and the dwarf galaxy, it allows us to study the impact of different macroscopic parameters such as galax…
▽ More
We present and test an effective model for N -body simulations that aims at mimicking the impact of supernova (SN) feedback on the dark matter (DM) distribution of isolated halos hosting dwarf galaxies. Although the model is physically decoupled from the cosmological history of both the DM halo and the dwarf galaxy, it allows us to study the impact of different macroscopic parameters such as galaxy concentration, feedback energy and energy injection time in the process of SN-driven core formation in a physically clear way. Using our effective model in a suite of N-body simulations of an isolated halo with different SN feedback parameters, we find that whether or not a DM core forms is determined by the total amount of SN feedback energy that is transferred to the DM particles. At a fixed injected energy, the amount of transferred energy is bigger - and the size of the DM core is larger - the faster the energy injection occurs and the more compact the dwarf galaxy is. Analyzing the orbital evolution of kinematic tracers, we demonstrate that a core forms through SN feedback only if the energy injection is impulsive relative to the dynamical timescale of particles in the inner halo. However, there is no fundamental link between the total amount of injected energy and the injection rate. Consequently, the presence of signatures of impulsive changes of the gravitational potential is not a sufficient condition for dwarf-size halos to have cored density profiles.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2021; v1 submitted 1 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Conservation of radial actions in time-dependent spherical potentials
Authors:
Jan D. Burger,
Jorge Peñarrubia,
Jesús Zavala
Abstract:
In slowly evolving spherical potentials, $Φ(r,t)$, radial actions are typically assumed to remain constant. Here, we construct dynamical invariants that allow us to derive the evolution of radial actions in spherical central potentials with an arbitrary time dependence. We show that to linear order, radial actions oscillate around a constant value with an amplitude $ΔJ_r \propto \dotΦ/Φ\,P(E,L)$.…
▽ More
In slowly evolving spherical potentials, $Φ(r,t)$, radial actions are typically assumed to remain constant. Here, we construct dynamical invariants that allow us to derive the evolution of radial actions in spherical central potentials with an arbitrary time dependence. We show that to linear order, radial actions oscillate around a constant value with an amplitude $ΔJ_r \propto \dotΦ/Φ\,P(E,L)$. Using this result, we develop a diffusion theory that describes the evolution of the radial action distribution of ensembles of tracer particles orbiting in generic time-dependent spherical potentials. Tests against restricted $N$-body simulations in a varying Kepler potential indicate that our linear theory is accurate in regions of phase-space in which the diffusion coefficient $\tilde{D}(J_r) < 0.01\,J_r^2$. For illustration, we apply our theory to two astrophysical processes. We show that the median mass accretion rate of a Milky Way (MW) dark matter (DM) halo leads to slow global time-variation of the gravitational potential, in which the evolution of radial actions is linear (i.e. either adiabatic or diffusive) for $\sim 84$ per cent of the DM halo at redshift $z=0$. This fraction grows considerably with lookback time, suggesting that diffusion may be relevant to the modelling of several Gyr-old tidal streams in action-angle space. As a second application, we show that dynamical tracers in a self-interacting DM (SIDM) dwarf halo (with $σ/m_χ= 1\,{\rm cm^2g^{-1}}$) have invariant radial actions during the formation of a cored density profile.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2021; v1 submitted 1 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
The diverse dark matter density at sub-kiloparsec scales in Milky Way satellites:implications for the nature of dark matter
Authors:
Jesús Zavala,
Mark R. Lovell,
Mark Vogelsberger,
Jan D. Burger
Abstract:
Milky Way (MW) satellites reside within dark matter (DM) subhalos with a broad distribution of circular velocity profiles. This diversity is enhanced with the inclusion of ultra-faint satellites, which seemingly have very high DM densities, albeit with large systematic uncertainties. We argue that if confirmed, this large diversity in the MW satellite population poses a serious test for the struct…
▽ More
Milky Way (MW) satellites reside within dark matter (DM) subhalos with a broad distribution of circular velocity profiles. This diversity is enhanced with the inclusion of ultra-faint satellites, which seemingly have very high DM densities, albeit with large systematic uncertainties. We argue that if confirmed, this large diversity in the MW satellite population poses a serious test for the structure formation theory with possible implications for the DM nature. For the Cold Dark Matter model, the diversity might be a signature of the combined effects of subhalo tidal disruption by the MW disk and strong supernova feedback. For models with a dwarf-scale cutoff in the power spectrum, the diversity is a consequence of the lower abundance of dwarf-scale halos. This diversity is most challenging for Self-Interacting Dark Matter (SIDM) models with cross sections $σ/m_χ\gtrsim1~$cm$^2$g$^{-1}$ where subhalos have too low densities to explain the ultra-faint galaxies. We propose a novel solution to explain the diversity of MW satellites based on the gravothermal collapse of SIDM haloes. This solution requires a velocity-dependent cross section that predicts a bimodal distribution of cuspy dense (collapsed) subhaloes consistent with the ultra-faint satellites, and cored lower density subhaloes consistent with the brighter satellites.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2019; v1 submitted 22 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
The nature of core formation in dark matter haloes: adiabatic or impulsive?
Authors:
Jan D. Burger,
Jesús Zavala
Abstract:
It is well established that the central deficit of dark matter (DM) observed in many dwarf galaxies disagrees with the cuspy DM haloes predicted in the collision-less and cold DM (CDM) model. Plausible solutions to this problem are based on an effective energy deposition into the central halo with an origin that is either based on baryonic physics (e.g. supernova-driven gas blowouts; SNF) or on ne…
▽ More
It is well established that the central deficit of dark matter (DM) observed in many dwarf galaxies disagrees with the cuspy DM haloes predicted in the collision-less and cold DM (CDM) model. Plausible solutions to this problem are based on an effective energy deposition into the central halo with an origin that is either based on baryonic physics (e.g. supernova-driven gas blowouts; SNF) or on new DM physics (e.g. self-interacting DM, SIDM). We argue that the fundamental difference between the two is whether the process is impulsive or adiabatic, and explore novel ways to distinguishing them by looking at the response of stellar orbits. We perform idealised simulations of tracers embedded in a $1.48\times 10^{10}{\rm M}_{\odot}$ spherical halo, and model the creation of a $\sim1$kpc DM matter core in SIDM with $σ_T/m_χ = 2\,{\rm cm}^2{\rm g}^{-1}$ and through SNF by impulsively removing a mass equivalent to $\mathcal{O}(10\%)$ of the halo's potential energy. Choosing idealised initial orbital configurations for the tracers, we find that radial actions are conserved (changed) in the SIDM (impulsive) case. The adiabaticity of the SIDM case prevents tracers from changing their orbital family during core formation whereas SNF separates tracers of initially the same family to a variety of orbits. We show that these key features remain in a cosmological halo, albeit for a few dynamical timescales. The number density and velocity dispersion profile of a Plummer sphere with $r_{1/2} = 500$ pc change only marginally under adiabatic core formation, whereas SNF causes a substantial expansion of the sphere driving it out of Jeans equilibrium. Our results point towards promising ways of differentiating adiabatic from impulsive core formation.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2019; v1 submitted 23 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
How to Evaluate your Question Answering System Every Day and Still Get Real Work Done
Authors:
Eric Breck,
John D. Burger,
Lisa Ferro,
Lynette Hirschman,
David House,
Marc Light,
Inderjeet Mani
Abstract:
In this paper, we report on Qaviar, an experimental automated evaluation system for question answering applications. The goal of our research was to find an automatically calculated measure that correlates well with human judges' assessment of answer correctness in the context of question answering tasks. Qaviar judges the response by computing recall against the stemmed content words in the hum…
▽ More
In this paper, we report on Qaviar, an experimental automated evaluation system for question answering applications. The goal of our research was to find an automatically calculated measure that correlates well with human judges' assessment of answer correctness in the context of question answering tasks. Qaviar judges the response by computing recall against the stemmed content words in the human-generated answer key. It counts the answer correct if it exceeds agiven recall threshold. We determined that the answer correctness predicted by Qaviar agreed with the human 93% to 95% of the time. 41 question-answering systems were ranked by both Qaviar and human assessors, and these rankings correlated with a Kendall's Tau measure of 0.920, compared to a correlation of 0.956 between human assessors on the same data.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2000;
originally announced April 2000.
