-
Determining sensor geometry and gain in a wearable MEG system
Authors:
Ryan M. Hill,
Gonzalo Reina Rivero,
Ashley J. Tyler,
Holly Schofield,
Cody Doyle,
James Osborne,
David Bobela,
Lukas Rier,
Joseph Gibson,
Zoe Tanner,
Elena Boto,
Richard Bowtell,
Matthew J. Brookes,
Vishal Shah,
Niall Holmes
Abstract:
Optically pumped magnetometers (OPMs) are compact and lightweight sensors that can measure magnetic fields generated by current flow in neuronal assemblies in the brain. Such sensors enable construction of magnetoencephalography (MEG) instrumentation, with significant advantages over conventional MEG devices including adaptability to head size, enhanced movement tolerance, lower complexity and imp…
▽ More
Optically pumped magnetometers (OPMs) are compact and lightweight sensors that can measure magnetic fields generated by current flow in neuronal assemblies in the brain. Such sensors enable construction of magnetoencephalography (MEG) instrumentation, with significant advantages over conventional MEG devices including adaptability to head size, enhanced movement tolerance, lower complexity and improved data quality. However, realising the potential of OPMs depends on our ability to perform system calibration, which means finding sensor locations, orientations, and the relationship between the sensor output and magnetic field (termed sensor gain). Such calibration is complex in OPMMEG since, for example, OPM placement can change from subject to subject (unlike in conventional MEG where sensor locations or orientations are fixed). Here, we present two methods for calibration, both based on generating well-characterised magnetic fields across a sensor array. Our first device (the HALO) is a head mounted system that generates dipole like fields from a set of coils. Our second (the matrix coil (MC)) generates fields using coils embedded in the walls of a magnetically shielded room. Our results show that both methods offer an accurate means to calibrate an OPM array (e.g. sensor locations within 2 mm of the ground truth) and that the calibrations produced by the two methods agree strongly with each other. When applied to data from human MEG experiments, both methods offer improved signal to noise ratio after beamforming suggesting that they give calibration parameters closer to the ground truth than factory settings and presumed physical sensor coordinates and orientations. Both techniques are practical and easy to integrate into real world MEG applications. This advances the field significantly closer to the routine use of OPMs for MEG recording.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Designing optimal loop, saddle, and ellipse-based magnetic coils by spherical harmonic mapping
Authors:
Peter James Hobson,
Noah Louis Hardwicke,
Alister Davis,
Thomas Smith,
Chris Morley,
Michael Packer,
Niall Holmes,
Max Alain Weil,
Matthew Brookes,
Richard Bowtell,
Mark Fromhold
Abstract:
Adaptable, low-cost, coils designed by carefully selecting the arrangements and geometries of simple primitive units are used to generate magnetic fields for diverse applications. These extend from magnetic resonance and fundamental physics experiments to active shielding of quantum devices including magnetometers, interferometers, clocks, and computers. However, finding optimal arrangements and g…
▽ More
Adaptable, low-cost, coils designed by carefully selecting the arrangements and geometries of simple primitive units are used to generate magnetic fields for diverse applications. These extend from magnetic resonance and fundamental physics experiments to active shielding of quantum devices including magnetometers, interferometers, clocks, and computers. However, finding optimal arrangements and geometries of multiple primitive structures is time-intensive and it is challenging to account for additional constraints, e.g. optical access, during the design process. Here, we demonstrate a general method to find these optimal arrangements. We encode specific symmetries into sets of loops, saddles, and cylindrical ellipses and then solve exactly for the magnetic field harmonics generated by each set. By combining these analytic solutions using computer algebra, we can use numerical techniques to efficiently map the landscape of parameters and geometries which the coils must satisfy. Sets of solutions may be found which generate desired target fields accurately while accounting for complexity and size restrictions. We demonstrate this approach by employing simple configurations of loops, saddles, and cylindrical ellipses to design target linear field gradients and compare their performance with designs obtained using conventional methods. A case study is presented where three optimized arrangements of loops, designed to generate a uniform axial field, a linear axial field gradient, and a quadratic axial field gradient, respectively, are hand-wound around a low-cost, 3D-printed coil former. These coils are used to null the background in a typical laboratory environment, reducing the magnitude of the axial field along the central half of the former's axis from $\left(7.8\pm0.3\right)$ $μ$T (mean $\pm$ st. dev.) to $\left(0.11\pm0.04\right)$ $μ$T.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2023; v1 submitted 30 April, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Benchtop magnetic shielding for benchmarking atomic magnetometers
Authors:
P. J. Hobson,
N. Holmes,
P. Patel,
J. Chalmers,
B. Styles,
C. Morley,
A. Davis,
M. Packer,
T. X. Smith,
S. Raudonyte,
D. Holmes,
R. Harrison,
D. Woolger,
D. Sims,
M. J. Brookes,
R. W. Bowtell,
T. M. Fromhold
Abstract:
Here, a benchtop hybrid magnetic shield containing four mumetal cylinders and nine internal flexible printed circuit boards is designed, constructed, tested, and operated. The shield is designed specifically as a test-bed for building and operating ultra-sensitive quantum magnetometers. The geometry and spacing of the mumetal cylinders are optimized to maximize shielding efficiency while maintaini…
▽ More
Here, a benchtop hybrid magnetic shield containing four mumetal cylinders and nine internal flexible printed circuit boards is designed, constructed, tested, and operated. The shield is designed specifically as a test-bed for building and operating ultra-sensitive quantum magnetometers. The geometry and spacing of the mumetal cylinders are optimized to maximize shielding efficiency while maintaining Johnson noise $<15$ fT/$\sqrt{}$Hz. Experimental measurements at the shield's center show passive shielding efficiency of $\left(1.0\pm0.1\right){\times}10^6$ for a $0.2$ Hz oscillating field applied along the shield's axis. The nine flexible printed circuit boards generate three uniform fields, which all deviate from perfect uniformity by ${\leq}0.5$% along $50$% of the inner shield axis, and five linear field gradients and one second-order gradient, which all deviate by ${\leq}4$% from perfect linearity and curvature, respectively, over measured target regions. Together, the target field amplitudes are adjusted to minimize the remnant static field along $40$% of the inner shield axis, as mapped using an atomic magnetometer. In this region, the active null reduces the norm of the magnitudes of the three uniform fields and six gradients by factors of $19.5$ and $19.8$, respectively, thereby reducing the total static field from $1.68$ nT to $0.23$ nT.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2023; v1 submitted 27 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Bespoke magnetic field design for a magnetically shielded cold atom interferometer
Authors:
P. J. Hobson,
J. Vovrosh,
B. Stray,
M. Packer,
J. Winch,
N. Holmes,
F. Hayati,
K. McGovern,
R. Bowtell,
M. J. Brookes,
K. Bongs,
T. M. Fromhold,
M. Holynski
Abstract:
Quantum sensors based on cold atoms are being developed which produce measurements of unprecedented accuracy. Due to shifts in atomic energy levels, quantum sensors often have stringent requirements on their internal magnetic field environment. Typically, background magnetic fields are attenuated using high permeability magnetic shielding, with the cancelling of residual and introduction of quanti…
▽ More
Quantum sensors based on cold atoms are being developed which produce measurements of unprecedented accuracy. Due to shifts in atomic energy levels, quantum sensors often have stringent requirements on their internal magnetic field environment. Typically, background magnetic fields are attenuated using high permeability magnetic shielding, with the cancelling of residual and introduction of quantisation fields implemented with coils inside the shield. The high permeability shield, however, distorts all magnetic fields, including those generated inside the sensor. Here, we demonstrate a solution by designing multiple coils overlaid on a 3D-printed former to generate three uniform and three constant linear gradient magnetic fields inside the capped cylindrical magnetic shield of a cold atom interferometer. The fields are characterised in-situ and match their desired forms to high accuracy. For example, the uniform transverse field, $B_x$, deviates by less than $0.2$% over more than $40$% of the length of the shield. We also map the field directly using the cold atoms and investigate the potential of the coil system to reduce bias from the quadratic Zeeman effect. This coil design technology enables targeted field compensation over large spatial volumes and has the potential to reduce systematic shifts and noise in numerous cold atom systems.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2022; v1 submitted 9 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Magnetic Field Design in a Cylindrical High-Permeability Shield: The Combination of Simple Building Blocks and a Genetic Algorithm
Authors:
M. Packer,
P. J. Hobson,
A. Davis,
N. Holmes,
J. Leggett,
P. Glover,
N. L. Hardwicke,
M. J. Brookes,
R. Bowtell,
T. M. Fromhold
Abstract:
Magnetically-sensitive experiments and newly-developed quantum technologies with integrated high-permeability magnetic shields require increasing control of their magnetic field environment and reductions in size, weight, power and cost. However, magnetic fields generated by active components are distorted by high-permeability magnetic shielding, particularly when they are close to the shield's su…
▽ More
Magnetically-sensitive experiments and newly-developed quantum technologies with integrated high-permeability magnetic shields require increasing control of their magnetic field environment and reductions in size, weight, power and cost. However, magnetic fields generated by active components are distorted by high-permeability magnetic shielding, particularly when they are close to the shield's surface. Here, we present an efficient design methodology for creating desired static magnetic field profiles by using discrete coils electromagnetically-coupled to a cylindrical passive magnetic shield. We utilize a modified Green's function solution that accounts for the interior boundary conditions on a closed finite-length high-permeability cylindrical magnetic shield, and determine simplified expressions when a cylindrical coil approaches the interior surface of the shield. We use an analytic formulation of simple discrete building blocks to provide a complete discrete coil basis to generate any physically-attainable magnetic field inside the shield. We then use a genetic algorithm to find optimized discrete coil structures composed of this basis. We use our methodology to generate an improved linear axial gradient field, $\mathrm{d}B_z/\mathrm{d}z$, and transverse bias field, $B_x$. These optimized structures increase, by a factor of seven and three compared to the standard configurations, the volume in which the desired and achieved fields agree within $1\%$ accuracy, respectively. This coil design method can be used to optimize active--passive magnetic field shaping systems that are compact and simple to manufacture, enabling accurate magnetic field control in spatially-confined experiments at low cost.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2022; v1 submitted 7 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Planar Coil Optimization in a Magnetically Shielded Cylinder
Authors:
M. Packer,
P. J. Hobson,
N. Holmes,
J. Leggett,
P. Glover,
M. J. Brookes,
R. Bowtell,
T. M. Fromhold
Abstract:
Hybrid magnetic shields with both active field generating components and high-permeability magnetic shielding are increasingly needed for a variety of technologies and experiments that require precision-controlled magnetic field environments. However, the fields generated by the active components interact with the passive magnetic shield, distorting the desired field profiles. Consequently, optimi…
▽ More
Hybrid magnetic shields with both active field generating components and high-permeability magnetic shielding are increasingly needed for a variety of technologies and experiments that require precision-controlled magnetic field environments. However, the fields generated by the active components interact with the passive magnetic shield, distorting the desired field profiles. Consequently, optimization of the active components needed to generate user-specified target fields must include coupling to the high-permeability passive components. Here, we consider the optimization of planar active systems, on which an arbitrary static current flows, coupled to a closed high-permeability cylindrical shield. We modify the Green's function for the magnetic vector potential to match boundary conditions on the shield's interior surface, enabling us to construct an inverse optimization problem to design planar coils that generate user-specified magnetic fields inside high-permeability shields. We validate our methodology by designing two bi-planar hybrid active--passive systems, which generate a constant transverse field, $\mathbf{B}=\mathbf{\hat{x}}$, and a linear field gradient, $\mathbf{B}=(-x~\mathbf{\hat{x}}-y~\mathbf{\hat{y}}+2z~\mathbf{\hat{z}})$, respectively. For both systems, the inverse-optimized magnetic field profiles agree well with forward numerical simulations. Our design methodology is accurate and flexible, facilitating the miniaturization of high-performance hybrid magnetic field generating technologies with strict design constraints and spatial limitations.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2021; v1 submitted 4 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Optimal Inverse Design of Magnetic Field Profiles in a Magnetically Shielded Cylinder
Authors:
M. Packer,
P. J. Hobson,
N. Holmes,
J. Leggett,
P. Glover,
M. J. Brookes,
R. Bowtell,
T. M. Fromhold
Abstract:
Magnetic shields that use both active and passive components to enable the generation of a tailored low-field environment are required for many applications in science, engineering, and medical imaging. Until now, accurate field nulling, or field generation, has only been possible over a small fraction of the overall volume of the shield. This is due to the interaction between the active field-gen…
▽ More
Magnetic shields that use both active and passive components to enable the generation of a tailored low-field environment are required for many applications in science, engineering, and medical imaging. Until now, accurate field nulling, or field generation, has only been possible over a small fraction of the overall volume of the shield. This is due to the interaction between the active field-generating components and the surrounding high-permeability passive shielding material. In this paper, we formulate the interaction between an arbitrary static current flow on a cylinder and an exterior closed high-permeability cylinder. We modify the Green's function for the magnetic vector potential and match boundary conditions on the shield's interior surface to calculate the total magnetic field generated by the system. We cast this formulation into an inverse optimization problem to design active--passive magnetic field shaping systems that accurately generate any physical static magnetic field in the interior of a closed cylindrical passive shield. We illustrate this method by designing hybrid systems that generate a range of magnetic field profiles to high accuracy over large interior volumes, and simulate them in real-world shields whose passive components have finite permeability, thickness, and axial entry holes. Our optimization procedure can be adapted to design active--passive magnetic field shaping systems that accurately generate any physical user-specified static magnetic field in the interior of a closed cylindrical shield of any length, enabling the development and miniaturization of systems that require accurate magnetic shielding and control.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2020; v1 submitted 4 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
