-
A Reanalysis of the FDA's Benefit-Risk Assessment of Moderna's mRNA-1273 COVID Vaccine: For 18-25-Year-Old Males, Risks Exceeded Benefits Relative to Hospitalizations
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon,
Ram Duriseti,
H. Christian Gromoll,
Dyana K. Dalton,
Kevin Bardosh,
Allison E. Krug
Abstract:
The FDA conducted a benefit-risk assessment for Moderna's COVID vaccine mRNA-1273 prior to its full approval (announced 1/31/2022). The FDA focused its assessment on males of ages 18-64 years because the agency's risk analysis was limited to vaccine-attributable myocarditis/pericarditis (VAM/P) given the excess risk among males. The FDA analysis concluded that vaccine benefits clearly outweighed r…
▽ More
The FDA conducted a benefit-risk assessment for Moderna's COVID vaccine mRNA-1273 prior to its full approval (announced 1/31/2022). The FDA focused its assessment on males of ages 18-64 years because the agency's risk analysis was limited to vaccine-attributable myocarditis/pericarditis (VAM/P) given the excess risk among males. The FDA analysis concluded that vaccine benefits clearly outweighed risks, even for 18-25-year-old males (those at highest VAM/P risk). We reanalyze the FDA benefit-risk assessment using information available through the third week of January 2022 and focusing on 18-25-year-old males. We use the FDA's framework but extend its model by accounting for protection derived from prior COVID infection, finer age-stratification in COVID-hospitalization rates, and incidental hospitalizations (those of patients who test positive for COVID but are being treated for something else). We also use more realistic projections of Omicron-infection rates and more accurate rates of VAM/P. With hospitalizations as the principal endpoint of the analysis (those prevented by vaccination vs. those caused by VAM/P), we find a net harm: vaccine risks outweighed benefits for 18-25-year-old males, except in scenarios projecting implausibly high Omicron-infection prevalence. Comparing the projections of FDA's "most likely scenario" to ours, we find that the FDA's benefit-risk ratio, 43.33, is over 60 times more favorable than ours, 0.67. Our assessment suggests that mRNA-1273 vaccination of 18-25-year-old males generated between 16% and 63% more hospitalizations from vaccine-attributable myocarditis/pericarditis alone compared to COVID hospitalizations prevented (over a 5-month period of vaccine protection assumed by the FDA). The preceding assessment is based on assumptions drawn from data available before 1/22/22. Moreover, these assumptions are validated by subsequently available data.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Misleading assertions, unjustified assumptions, and additional limitations of a study by Patone et al., described in the article "Risk of Myocarditis After Sequential Doses of COVID-19 Vaccine and SARS-CoV-2 Infection by Age and Sex"
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon,
Spiro Pantazatos
Abstract:
We describe several shortcomings of a study by Patone et al, whose findings were recently published in the American Heart Association Journal Circulation, including the following:
* The study's principal conclusion, as initially stated, begins "Overall, the risk of myocarditis is greater after SARS-CoV-2 infection than after COVID-19 vaccination ...." However, Patone et al never attempt to asses…
▽ More
We describe several shortcomings of a study by Patone et al, whose findings were recently published in the American Heart Association Journal Circulation, including the following:
* The study's principal conclusion, as initially stated, begins "Overall, the risk of myocarditis is greater after SARS-CoV-2 infection than after COVID-19 vaccination ...." However, Patone et al never attempt to assess the incidence of myocarditis in their study population following SARS-CoV-2 infection. Rather, they make an untenable assumption that all infections occurring in their study population are associated with (reported) positive COVID-19 tests. Using publicly available data from the UK's ONS and NHS, we show that Patone et al's estimates, for the unvaccinated, of myocarditis incidence associated with infection are likely overestimated by a factor of at least 1.58.
* The method Patone et al use to compute the incidence of myocarditis among the unvaccinated after a positive COVID test may overestimate risk. The authors assume, without justification, that unvaccinated persons hospitalized during the study period with positive-test-associated myocarditis would later choose to vaccinate with the same probability as unvaccinated persons who have had a positive COVID test. We present a plausibility argument that suggests a possible further exaggeration of myocarditis risk post infection by a factor of 1.5.
* Patone et al fail to discuss important limitations of their study with respect to guiding public health recommendations. For instance, an insignificant number of cases contributing to the study's findings were Omicron-variant cases. Thus, the study's estimates of myocarditis risk following infection do not speak to the risk following Omicron infection, which is recognized to be milder than that of previous variants.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2023; v1 submitted 25 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Powers of posinormal Hilbert-space operators
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon,
C. S. Kubrusly,
Derek Thompson
Abstract:
A bounded linear operator $A$ on a Hilbert space $\mathcal{H}$ is posinormal if there exists a positive operator $P$ such that $AA^{*} = A^{*}PA$. We show that if $A$ is posinormal with closed range, then $A^n$ is posinormal and has closed range for all integers $n\ge 1$. Because the collection of posinormal operators includes all hyponormal operators, we obtain as a corollary that powers of close…
▽ More
A bounded linear operator $A$ on a Hilbert space $\mathcal{H}$ is posinormal if there exists a positive operator $P$ such that $AA^{*} = A^{*}PA$. We show that if $A$ is posinormal with closed range, then $A^n$ is posinormal and has closed range for all integers $n\ge 1$. Because the collection of posinormal operators includes all hyponormal operators, we obtain as a corollary that powers of closed-range hyponormal operators continue to have closed range. We also present a simple example of a closed-range operator $T: \mathcal{H}\to \mathcal{H}$ such that $T^2$ does not have closed range.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2022; v1 submitted 2 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Posinormal Composition Operators on $H^2$
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon,
Derek Thompson
Abstract:
A bounded linear operator $A$ on a Hilbert space is posinormal if there exists a positive operator $P$ such that $AA^{*} = A^{*}PA$. Posinormality of $A$ is equivalent to the inclusion of the range of $A$ in the range of its adjoint $A^*$. Every hyponormal operator is posinormal, as is every invertible operator. We characterize both the posinormal and coposinormal composition operators…
▽ More
A bounded linear operator $A$ on a Hilbert space is posinormal if there exists a positive operator $P$ such that $AA^{*} = A^{*}PA$. Posinormality of $A$ is equivalent to the inclusion of the range of $A$ in the range of its adjoint $A^*$. Every hyponormal operator is posinormal, as is every invertible operator. We characterize both the posinormal and coposinormal composition operators $C_\varphi$ on the Hardy space $H^2$ of the open unit disk $\mathbb{D}$ when $\varphi$ is a linear-fractional selfmap of $\mathbb{D}$. Our work reveals that there are composition operators that are both posinormal and coposinormal yet have powers that fail to be posinormal.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Spectra of Composition Operators with Symbols in S(2)
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon
Abstract:
Let H^2(D) denote the classical Hardy space of the open unit disk D in the complex plane. We obtain descriptions of both the spectrum and essential spectrum of composition operators on H^2(D) whose symbols belong to the class S(2) introduced by Kriete and Moorhouse [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 359, 2007]. Our work reveals new possibilities for the shapes of composition-operator spectra, settling a co…
▽ More
Let H^2(D) denote the classical Hardy space of the open unit disk D in the complex plane. We obtain descriptions of both the spectrum and essential spectrum of composition operators on H^2(D) whose symbols belong to the class S(2) introduced by Kriete and Moorhouse [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 359, 2007]. Our work reveals new possibilities for the shapes of composition-operator spectra, settling a conjecture of Cowen's [J. Operator Th. 9, 1983]. Our results depend on a number of lemmas, perhaps of independent interest, that provide spectral characterizations of sums of elements of a unital algebra over a field when certain pairwise products of the summands are zero.
△ Less
Submitted 1 January, 2015; v1 submitted 12 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
Invertible weighted composition operators
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon
Abstract:
Let X be a set of analytic functions on the open unit disk D, and let phi be an analytic function on D such that phi(D) is contained in D and f |-> f o phi takes X into itself. We present conditions on X ensuring that if f |-> f o phi is invertible on X, then phi is an automorphism of D, and we derive a similar result for mappings of the form f |-> psi.(f o phi), where psi is some analytic functio…
▽ More
Let X be a set of analytic functions on the open unit disk D, and let phi be an analytic function on D such that phi(D) is contained in D and f |-> f o phi takes X into itself. We present conditions on X ensuring that if f |-> f o phi is invertible on X, then phi is an automorphism of D, and we derive a similar result for mappings of the form f |-> psi.(f o phi), where psi is some analytic function on D. We obtain as corollaries of this purely function-theoretic work, new results concerning invertibility of composition operators and weighted composition operators on Banach spaces of analytic functions such as S^p and the weighted Hardy spaces H^2(beta).
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Normal weighted composition operators on the Hardy space
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon,
Sivaram K. Narayan
Abstract:
Let g be an analytic function on the open unit disc U such that g(U) is contained in U, and let h be an analytic function on U such that the weighted composition operator W_{h,g) defined by W_{h,g}f = h f(g) is bounded on the Hardy space H^2. We characterize those weighted composition operators on H^2 that are unitary, showing that in contrast to the unweighted case (h=1), every automorphism of…
▽ More
Let g be an analytic function on the open unit disc U such that g(U) is contained in U, and let h be an analytic function on U such that the weighted composition operator W_{h,g) defined by W_{h,g}f = h f(g) is bounded on the Hardy space H^2. We characterize those weighted composition operators on H^2 that are unitary, showing that in contrast to the unweighted case (h=1), every automorphism of U induces a unitary weighted composition operator. A conjugation argument, using these unitary operators, allows us to describe all normal weighted composition operators on H^2 for which the inducing map g fixes a point in U. This description shows both h and g must be linear fractional in order for W_{h,g} to be normal (assuming g fixes a point in U). In general, we show that if W_{h, g} is normal on H^2 and h is not the zero function, then g must be either univalent on U or constant. Descriptions of spectra are provided for the operator W_{h,g} when it is unitary or when it is normal and g fixes a point in U.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
Spectra of some composition operators and associated weighted composition operators
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon
Abstract:
We characterize the spectrum and essential spectrum of "essentially linear fractional" composition operators acting on the Hardy space H-two of the open unit disc U. When the symbols of these composition operators have Denjoy-Wolff point on the unit circle, the spectrum and essential spectrum coincide. Our work permits us to describe the spectrum and essential spectrum of certain associated weig…
▽ More
We characterize the spectrum and essential spectrum of "essentially linear fractional" composition operators acting on the Hardy space H-two of the open unit disc U. When the symbols of these composition operators have Denjoy-Wolff point on the unit circle, the spectrum and essential spectrum coincide. Our work permits us to describe the spectrum and essential spectrum of certain associated weighted composition operators on the Hardy space.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2009;
originally announced August 2009.
-
Overcoming a limitation of deterministic dense coding with a non-maximally entangled initial state
Authors:
P. S. Bourdon,
E. Gerjuoy
Abstract:
Under two-party deterministic dense-coding, Alice communicates (perfectly distinguishable) messages to Bob via a qudit from a pair of entangled qudits in pure state |Psi>. If |Psi> represents a maximally entangled state (i.e., each of its Schmidt coefficients is sqrt(1/d)), then Alice can convey to Bob one of d^2 distinct messages. If |Psi> is not maximally entangled, then Ji et al. [Phys. Rev.…
▽ More
Under two-party deterministic dense-coding, Alice communicates (perfectly distinguishable) messages to Bob via a qudit from a pair of entangled qudits in pure state |Psi>. If |Psi> represents a maximally entangled state (i.e., each of its Schmidt coefficients is sqrt(1/d)), then Alice can convey to Bob one of d^2 distinct messages. If |Psi> is not maximally entangled, then Ji et al. [Phys. Rev. A 73, 034307 (2006)] have shown that under the original deterministic dense-coding protocol, in which messages are encoded by unitary operations performed on Alice's qudit, it is impossible to encode d^2-1 messages. Encoding d^2-2 is possible; see, e.g., the numerical studies by Mozes et al. [Phys. Rev. A 71, 012311 (2005)]. Answering a question raised by Wu et al. [Phys. Rev. A 73, 042311 (2006)], we show that when |Psi> is not maximally entangled, the communications limit of d^2-2 messages persists even when the requirement that Alice encode by unitary operations on her qudit is weakened to allow encoding by more general quantum operators. We then describe a dense-coding protocol that can overcome this limitation with high probability, assuming the largest Schmidt coefficient of |Psi> is sufficiently close to sqrt(1/d). In this protocol, d^2-2 of the messages are encoded via unitary operations on Alice's qudit, and the final (d^2-1)-th message is encoded via a (non-trace-preserving) quantum operation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2010; v1 submitted 1 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
The augmented message-matrix approach to deterministic dense coding theory
Authors:
E. Gerjuoy,
H. T. Williams,
P. S. Bourdon
Abstract:
A method is presented for producing analytical results applicable to the standard two-party deterministic dense coding protocol, wherein communication of K perfectly distinguishable messages is attainable with the aid of K selected local unitary operations on one qudit from a pair of entangled qudits of equal dimension d in a pure state. The method utilizes the properties of a (d^2)x(d^2) unitar…
▽ More
A method is presented for producing analytical results applicable to the standard two-party deterministic dense coding protocol, wherein communication of K perfectly distinguishable messages is attainable with the aid of K selected local unitary operations on one qudit from a pair of entangled qudits of equal dimension d in a pure state. The method utilizes the properties of a (d^2)x(d^2) unitary matrix whose initial columns represent message states of the system used for communication, augmented by sufficiently many additional orthonormal column vectors so that the resulting matrix is unitary. Using the unitarity properties of this augmented message-matrix, we produce simple proofs of previously established results including (i) an upper bound on the value of the square of the largest Schmidt coefficient, given by d/K, and (ii) the impossibility of finding a pure state that can enable transmission of K=d^2-1 messages but not d^2. Additional results obtained using the method include proofs that when K=d+1 the upper bound on the square of the largest Schmidt coefficient (i) always reduces to at least (1/2)[1+sqrt{(d-2)/(d+2)}], and (ii) reduces to (d-1)/d in the special case that the identity and shift operators are two of the selected local unitaries.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2008;
originally announced September 2008.
-
Intertwining relations and extended eigenvalues for analytic Toeplitz operators
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon,
Joel H. Shapiro
Abstract:
We study the intertwining relations between analytic Toeplitz operators induced on the Hardy space H^2 by analytic functions bounded on the open unit disc. Our work centers on the connection between intertwining between the Toeplitz operators the image containment between their symbols, as well as on the nature of the intertwining operator. We use our results to study the "extended eigenvalues"…
▽ More
We study the intertwining relations between analytic Toeplitz operators induced on the Hardy space H^2 by analytic functions bounded on the open unit disc. Our work centers on the connection between intertwining between the Toeplitz operators the image containment between their symbols, as well as on the nature of the intertwining operator. We use our results to study the "extended eigenvalues" of analytic Toeplitz operators, i.e., the special case where the operator is intertwined with a scalar multiple of itself.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2009; v1 submitted 13 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Adjoints of rationally induced composition operators
Authors:
Paul S. Bourdon,
Joel H. Shapiro
Abstract:
We give an elementary proof of a formula recently obtained by Hammond, Moorhouse, and Robbins for the adjoint of a rationally induced composition operator on the Hardy space H^2. We discuss some variants and implications of this formula, and use it to provide a sufficient condition for a rationally induced composition operator adjoint to be a compact perturbation of a weighted composition operat…
▽ More
We give an elementary proof of a formula recently obtained by Hammond, Moorhouse, and Robbins for the adjoint of a rationally induced composition operator on the Hardy space H^2. We discuss some variants and implications of this formula, and use it to provide a sufficient condition for a rationally induced composition operator adjoint to be a compact perturbation of a weighted composition operator.
△ Less
Submitted 20 March, 2009; v1 submitted 11 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Deterministic dense coding and entanglement entropy
Authors:
P. S. Bourdon,
E. Gerjuoy,
J. P. McDonald,
H. T. Williams
Abstract:
We present an analytical study of the standard two-party deterministic dense-coding protocol, under which communication of perfectly distinguishable messages takes place via a qudit from a pair of non-maximally entangled qudits in pure state |S>. Our results include the following: (i) We prove that it is possible for a state |S> with lower entanglement entropy to support the sending of a greater…
▽ More
We present an analytical study of the standard two-party deterministic dense-coding protocol, under which communication of perfectly distinguishable messages takes place via a qudit from a pair of non-maximally entangled qudits in pure state |S>. Our results include the following: (i) We prove that it is possible for a state |S> with lower entanglement entropy to support the sending of a greater number of perfectly distinguishable messages than one with higher entanglement entropy, confirming a result suggested via numerical analysis in Mozes et al. [Phys. Rev. A 71 012311 (2005)]. (ii) By explicit construction of families of local unitary operators, we verify, for dimensions d = 3 and d=4, a conjecture of Mozes et al. about the minimum entanglement entropy that supports the sending of d + j messages, j = 2, ..., d-1; moreover, we show that the j=2 and j= d-1 cases of the conjecture are valid in all dimensions. (iii) Given that |S> allows the sending of K messages and has the square roof of c as its largest Schmidt coefficient, we show that the inequality c <= d/K, established by Wu et al. [ Phys. Rev. A 73, 042311 (2006)], must actually take the form c < d/K if K = d+1, while our constructions of local unitaries show that equality can be realized if K = d+2 or K = 2d-1.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2008; v1 submitted 4 September, 2007;
originally announced September 2007.
-
Sharp probability estimates for Shor's order-finding algorithm
Authors:
P. S. Bourdon,
H. T. Williams
Abstract:
Let N be a (large positive integer, let b > 1 be an integer relatively prime to N, and let r be the order of b modulo N. Finally, let QC be a quantum computer whose input register has the size specified in Shor's original description of his order-finding algorithm. We prove that when Shor's algorithm is implemented on QC, then the probability P of obtaining a (nontrivial) divisor of r exceeds 0.…
▽ More
Let N be a (large positive integer, let b > 1 be an integer relatively prime to N, and let r be the order of b modulo N. Finally, let QC be a quantum computer whose input register has the size specified in Shor's original description of his order-finding algorithm. We prove that when Shor's algorithm is implemented on QC, then the probability P of obtaining a (nontrivial) divisor of r exceeds 0.7 whenever N exceeds 2^{11}-1 and r exceeds 39, and we establish that 0.7736 is an asymptotic lower bound for P. When N is not a power of an odd prime, Gerjuoy has shown that P exceeds 90 percent for N and r sufficiently large. We give easily checked conditions on N and r for this 90 percent threshold to hold, and we establish an asymptotic lower bound for P of (2/Pi) Si(4Pi), about .9499, in this situation. More generally, for any nonnegative integer q, we show that when QC(q) is a quantum computer whose input register has q more qubits than does QC, and Shor's algorithm is run on QC(q), then an asymptotic lower bound on P is (2/Pi) Si(2^(q+2) Pi) (if N is not a power of an odd prime). Our arguments are elementary and our lower bounds on P are carefully justified.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2006; v1 submitted 21 July, 2006;
originally announced July 2006.
-
Unital quantum operators on the Bloch ball and Bloch region
Authors:
P. S. Bourdon,
H. T. Williams
Abstract:
For one qubit systems, we present a short, elementary argument characterizing unital quantum operators in terms of their action on Bloch vectors. We then show how our approach generalizes to multi-qubit systems, obtaining inequalities that govern when a ``diagonal'' superoperator on the Bloch region is a quantum operator. These inequalities are the n-qubit analogue of the Algoet-Fujiwara conditi…
▽ More
For one qubit systems, we present a short, elementary argument characterizing unital quantum operators in terms of their action on Bloch vectors. We then show how our approach generalizes to multi-qubit systems, obtaining inequalities that govern when a ``diagonal'' superoperator on the Bloch region is a quantum operator. These inequalities are the n-qubit analogue of the Algoet-Fujiwara conditions. Our work is facilitated by an analysis of operator-sum decompositions in which negative summands are allowed.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2003; v1 submitted 16 August, 2003;
originally announced August 2003.
