-
Sustainable Development Goal Target Interactions in the Philippines: A Two-Method Approach
Authors:
Vena Pearl Bongolan,
Spencer C. Soria,
Roselle Leah K. Rivera
Abstract:
In 2015, the United Nations adopted 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) with 169 targets for transformation toward a more sustainable future by 2030. This study seeks to evaluate and analyze SDG target interactions in the Philippines to resolve conflicting targets, and prioritize targets that reinforce others and have no conflicts. To evaluate all 14196 target interactions, two methods are emp…
▽ More
In 2015, the United Nations adopted 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) with 169 targets for transformation toward a more sustainable future by 2030. This study seeks to evaluate and analyze SDG target interactions in the Philippines to resolve conflicting targets, and prioritize targets that reinforce others and have no conflicts. To evaluate all 14196 target interactions, two methods are employed. First, experts with over five years of SDG-related experience evaluated interactions using a 7-point scale. Second, a non-parametric Spearman rank correlation is used on official indicator data with resulting coefficients serving as interaction scores. Interaction scores are then coded as synergies (interact positively), trade-offs (negatively) or non-classified (neutrally). Targets are also modelled as nodes and interactions as edges in graphs presented in sdginteractions.herokuapp.com. Results from the two methods were synthesized to formulate recommendations for concerned parties. This includes resolving negative intra-goal target interactions involving targets 3.1 'Reduce maternal mortality', 3.6 'Reduce road injuries and deaths', and 3.7 'Universal access to sexual and reproductive care, family planning, and education'. Ugly targets (at least one negative interaction) including target 3.6, 3.7, and 8.2 'Diversify, innovate, and upgrade for economic productivity' need to be resolved. Targets that reinforce their corresponding SDGs should be prioritized, including 1.1 'Eradicate extreme poverty', 4.2 'Equal access to quality pre-primary education', 6.2 'End open defecation and provide access to sanitation and hygiene', 8.1 'Sustainable economic growth', and 9.4 'Upgrade all industries and infrastructures for sustainability'. Beautiful targets (no negative interactions) should also be prioritized, including target 8.5 and 17.5 'Invest in least developed countries'.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2022; v1 submitted 22 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
SDG Target Interactions: The Philippine Analysis of Indivisible and Cancelling Targets
Authors:
Vena Pearl Bongolan,
Arian Allenson M. Valdez,
Roselle Leah K. Rivera
Abstract:
The United Nations developed the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), with 169 targets, to serve as a plan for solving the world's problems and achieving a more sustainable future. This is modeled as a graph with the targets as nodes, and with the interaction between targets as the edges of the graph. An exhaustive binary comparison is done to analyze the intra- and inter-goal target interacti…
▽ More
The United Nations developed the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), with 169 targets, to serve as a plan for solving the world's problems and achieving a more sustainable future. This is modeled as a graph with the targets as nodes, and with the interaction between targets as the edges of the graph. An exhaustive binary comparison is done to analyze the intra- and inter-goal target interactions, entailing over 14000 comparisons. The task is to assign a 'color' to an edge: positive (indivisible), zero (consistent) or negative (cancelling). This is done via a panel of experts who will evaluate the target interactions, through a web application that was developed for coloring the edges. This is an on-going study, and so far, of the 1256 edges colored, only 36 are cancelling (negative), or 2.86%; more than 97% are positive interactions. So far, the "most negative" interactions involve: "Climate Change"; "Life Below Water"; "Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions"; and "Decent Work and Economic Growth". Most useful for planning might be the 'graph of beautiful targets' feature, which shows target with non-negative interactions, and how they connect to each other. These are the targets that may be worked on simultaneously, and currently has more than 130 nodes. This study can help researchers analyze which targets enable or constrain each other, what mitigation can be done to avoid conflicts, and can be configured for sub-national or regional study. Web app at: http://sdg-interactions.herokuapp.com/
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2021; v1 submitted 12 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
COVID-19 Agent-Based Model with Multi-objective Optimization for Vaccine Distribution
Authors:
Jose Marie Antonio Minoza,
Vena Pearl Bongolan,
Joshua Frankie Rayo
Abstract:
Now that SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) vaccines are developed, it is very important to plan its distribution strategy. In this paper, we formulated a multi-objective linear programming model to optimize vaccine distribution and applied it to the agent-based version of our age-stratified and quarantine-modified SEIR with non-linear incidence rates (ASQ-SEIR-NLIR) compartmental model. Simulations were perfo…
▽ More
Now that SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) vaccines are developed, it is very important to plan its distribution strategy. In this paper, we formulated a multi-objective linear programming model to optimize vaccine distribution and applied it to the agent-based version of our age-stratified and quarantine-modified SEIR with non-linear incidence rates (ASQ-SEIR-NLIR) compartmental model. Simulations were performed using COVID-19 data from Quezon City and results were analyzed under various scenarios: (1) no vaccination, (2) base vaccination (prioritizing essential workers and vulnerable population), (3) prioritizing mobile workforce, (4) prioritizing elderly, and (5) prioritizing mobile workforce and elderly; in terms of (a) reducing infection rates and (b) reducing mortality incidence. After 10 simulations on distributing 500,000 vaccine courses, results show that prioritizing mobile workforce minimizes further infections by 24.14%, which is better than other scenarios. On the other hand, prioritizing the elderly yields the highest protection (439%) for the Quezon City population compared to other scenarios. This could be due to younger people, when contracted the disease, has higher chances of recovery than the elderly. Thus, this leads to reduction of mortality cases.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Stochastic dynamics of storm surge with stable noise
Authors:
Joshua Frankie Rayo,
Vena Pearl Boñgolan
Abstract:
The Advanced Circulation (ADCIRC) and Simulating Nearshore Waves (SWAN) coupled model is modified to include a stochastic term in the shallow water equations that represents random external forces from debris carried by surge and short-term local scale atmospheric fluctuations. We added $α$-stable noise, uncorrelated in space and time, in the forcing terms of the coupled model. Inputs to the model…
▽ More
The Advanced Circulation (ADCIRC) and Simulating Nearshore Waves (SWAN) coupled model is modified to include a stochastic term in the shallow water equations that represents random external forces from debris carried by surge and short-term local scale atmospheric fluctuations. We added $α$-stable noise, uncorrelated in space and time, in the forcing terms of the coupled model. Inputs to the model are unstructured computational mesh derived from topography and bathymetry, land cover classification, tidal potential constituents and atmospheric forcing. The model simulated surge height of around five meters rushing at four meters per second near Tacloban City downtown. Underestimation of simulated surge height is expected with use of bare earth model and absence of fluid sources on the governing equations, while overestimation of simulated peak height also occurs due to presence of concrete barriers that reduced surge height and inundation extent. The stochastic model is sensitive to random external forces during low tide and relatively higher fluid speed. Low tide happens when the fluid speed is maximum and water elevation is lowest, while higher fluid speed is brought by external forces like storm surge. However, the difference of stochastic solutions from the deterministic solution averages to zero and there is no significant improvement of the storm surge model in general when it comes to additive noise. This is an expected result since the noise used has zero mean. As $α$ goes to zero larger jumps occur more frequently so $σ$ needs to be as small as $10^{-8}$ for simulation stability.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Scenario and Sensitivity Analysis for Flooding Vulnerability using Genetic Algorithms
Authors:
Vena Pearl Boñgolan,
Oreste Terranova,
Edward Nataniel Apostol,
Joshua Kevin Cruz
Abstract:
We try to answer the question: "can we 'modify' our neighborhoods to make them less vulnerable to flooding?" We minimize flooding vulnerability for a city in the central plain of Luzon, by modeling the city as a biological organism with 'traits', and try to 'breed' a 'champion' city (with a low flooding vulnerability) via a genetic algorithm. The result is a description of the traits the barangays…
▽ More
We try to answer the question: "can we 'modify' our neighborhoods to make them less vulnerable to flooding?" We minimize flooding vulnerability for a city in the central plain of Luzon, by modeling the city as a biological organism with 'traits', and try to 'breed' a 'champion' city (with a low flooding vulnerability) via a genetic algorithm. The result is a description of the traits the barangays (neighborhoods) should have (the 'design' of the city). As far as we can tell, this kind of modeling has not been attempted before. The different components of flooding vulnerability were investigated, and each was given a weight, which allows us to express vulnerability as a weighted sum; this serves as the fitness function for the genetic algorithm. We also allowed non-linear interactions among related but independent components, viz, poverty and mortality rate, and literacy and radio/TV penetration. The two-table system we used to prioritize the components of vulnerability is prone to subjectivity, a common problem in analyses of vulnerability. Thus, a sensitivity analysis was done, which gave a design with a 24% decrease in vulnerability alongside a 14% percent decrease in cost, a significant improvement over this initial scenario analysis, where the proposed design had a 12% decrease in vulnerability with a one percent increase in cost.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Prioritizing the Components of Vulnerability in a Genetic Algorithms Minimization of Flood Risk
Authors:
Vena Pearl Boñgolan,
Karessa Alexandra O. Baritua,
Marie Junne Santos
Abstract:
We compare two prioritization schemes for the components of flooding vulnerability: urbanized area ration, literacy rate, mortality rate, poverty, radio/tv penetration, non-structural measures and structural measure. We prioritize the components, giving each a weight. We then express the vulnerability function as a weighted sum of its components. This weighted sum serves as the fitness function in…
▽ More
We compare two prioritization schemes for the components of flooding vulnerability: urbanized area ration, literacy rate, mortality rate, poverty, radio/tv penetration, non-structural measures and structural measure. We prioritize the components, giving each a weight. We then express the vulnerability function as a weighted sum of its components. This weighted sum serves as the fitness function in a genetic algorithm, which comes up with the optimal design for a flood-resistant city.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
A Probabilistic Approach to Risk Mapping for Mt. Etna
Authors:
Vena Pearl Bongolan,
Rocco Rongo,
Valeria Lupiano,
Donato D'Ambrosio,
William Spataro,
Giulio Iovine
Abstract:
We evaluate susceptibility to lava flows on Mt. Etna based on specially designed die-toss experiments using probabilities for type, time and place of activation from the volcano's 400-year recorded history and current studies on its known fractures and fissures. The types of activations were forcast using a table of probabilities for events, typed by duration and volume of ejecta. Lengths of time…
▽ More
We evaluate susceptibility to lava flows on Mt. Etna based on specially designed die-toss experiments using probabilities for type, time and place of activation from the volcano's 400-year recorded history and current studies on its known fractures and fissures. The types of activations were forcast using a table of probabilities for events, typed by duration and volume of ejecta. Lengths of time were represented by the number of activations to expect within a given time-frame, calculated assuming Poisson-distributed inter-arrival times for activations. Locations of future activations were forecast with a probability distribution function for activation probabilities. Most likely scenarios for risk and resulting topography were generated for Etna's next activation (average 7.76 years), the next 25, 50 and 100 years. Forecasts for areas most likely affected are in good agreement with previous risk studies made. Forecasts for risks of lava invasions, as well as future topographies might be a first. Threats to lifelines are also discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Metaheuristics in Flood Disaster Management and Risk Assessment
Authors:
Vena Pearl Bongolan,
Florencio C. Ballesteros, Jr.,
Joyce Anne M. Banting,
Aina Marie Q. Olaes,
Charlymagne R. Aquino
Abstract:
A conceptual area is divided into units or barangays, each was allowed to evolve under a physical constraint. A risk assessment method was then used to identify the flood risk in each community using the following risk factors: the area's urbanized area ratio, literacy rate, mortality rate, poverty incidence, radio/TV penetration, and state of structural and non-structural measures. Vulnerability…
▽ More
A conceptual area is divided into units or barangays, each was allowed to evolve under a physical constraint. A risk assessment method was then used to identify the flood risk in each community using the following risk factors: the area's urbanized area ratio, literacy rate, mortality rate, poverty incidence, radio/TV penetration, and state of structural and non-structural measures. Vulnerability is defined as a weighted-sum of these components. A penalty was imposed for reduced vulnerability. Optimization comparison was done with MatLab's Genetic Algorithms and Simulated Annealing; results showed 'extreme' solutions and realistic designs, for simulated annealing and genetic algorithm, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
