-
Chew, Goldberger & Low Equations: Eigensystem Analysis and Applications to One-Dimensional Test Problems
Authors:
Chetan Singh,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Anshu Yadav,
Harish Kumar,
Dinshaw S. Balsara
Abstract:
Chew, Goldberger & Low (CGL) equations describe one of the simplest plasma flow models that allow anisotropic pressure, i.e., pressure is modeled using a symmetric tensor described by two scalar pressure components, one parallel to the magnetic field, another perpendicular to the magnetic field. The system of equations is a non-conservative hyperbolic system. In this work, we analyze the eigensyst…
▽ More
Chew, Goldberger & Low (CGL) equations describe one of the simplest plasma flow models that allow anisotropic pressure, i.e., pressure is modeled using a symmetric tensor described by two scalar pressure components, one parallel to the magnetic field, another perpendicular to the magnetic field. The system of equations is a non-conservative hyperbolic system. In this work, we analyze the eigensystem of the CGL equations. We present the eigenvalues and the complete set of right eigenvectors. We also prove the linear degeneracy of some of the characteristic fields. Using the eigensystem for CGL equations, we propose HLL and HLLI Riemann solvers for the CGL system. Furthermore, we present the AFD-WENO schemes up to the seventh order in one dimension and demonstrate the performance of the schemes on several one-dimensional test cases.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2025;
originally announced April 2025.
-
Second order divergence constraint preserving schemes for two-fluid relativistic plasma flow equations
Authors:
Jaya Agnihotri,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Harish Kumar,
Praveen Chandrashekar,
Dinshaw S. Balsara
Abstract:
Two-fluid relativistic plasma flow equations combine the equations of relativistic hydrodynamics with Maxwell's equations for electromagnetic fields, which involve divergence constraints for the magnetic and electric fields. When developing numerical schemes for the model, the divergence constraints are ignored, or Maxwell's equations are reformulated as Perfectly Hyperbolic Maxwell's (PHM) equati…
▽ More
Two-fluid relativistic plasma flow equations combine the equations of relativistic hydrodynamics with Maxwell's equations for electromagnetic fields, which involve divergence constraints for the magnetic and electric fields. When developing numerical schemes for the model, the divergence constraints are ignored, or Maxwell's equations are reformulated as Perfectly Hyperbolic Maxwell's (PHM) equations by introducing additional equations for correction potentials. In the latter case, the divergence constraints are preserved only as the limiting case.
In this article, we present second-order numerical schemes that preserve the divergence constraint for electric and magnetic fields at the discrete level. The schemes are based on using a multidimensional Riemann solver at the vertices of the cells to define the numerical fluxes on the edges. The second-order accuracy is obtained by reconstructing the electromagnetic fields at the corners using a MinMod limiter. The discretization of Maxwell's equations can be combined with any consistent and stable discretization of the fluid parts. In particular, we consider entropy-stable schemes for the fluid part. The resulting schemes are second-order accurate, entropy stable, and preserve the divergence constraints of the electromagnetic fields. We use explicit and IMEX-based time discretizations. We then test these schemes using several one- and two-dimensional test cases. We also compare the divergence constraint errors of the proposed schemes with schemes having no divergence constraints treatment and schemes based on the PHM-based divergence cleaning.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2025;
originally announced March 2025.
-
An anisotropic plasma model of the heliospheric interface
Authors:
Vladimir Florinski,
Dinshaw S. Balsara,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Gary P. Zank,
Shishir Biswas,
Swati Sharma,
Sethupathy Subramanian
Abstract:
We present a pioneering model of the interaction between the solar wind and the surrounding interstellar medium that includes the possibility of different pressures in directions parallel and perpendicular to the magnetic field. The outer heliosheath region is characterized by a low rate of turbulent scattering that would permit development of pressure anisotropy. The effect is best seen on the in…
▽ More
We present a pioneering model of the interaction between the solar wind and the surrounding interstellar medium that includes the possibility of different pressures in directions parallel and perpendicular to the magnetic field. The outer heliosheath region is characterized by a low rate of turbulent scattering that would permit development of pressure anisotropy. The effect is best seen on the interstellar side of the heliopause, where a narrow region develops with an excessive perpendicular pressure resembling a plasma depletion layer typical of planetary magnetspheres. The magnitude of this effect for typical heliospheric conditions is relatively small owing to proton-proton collisions. We show, however, that if the circumstellar medium is warm and tenuous, a much broader anisotropic boundary layer can exist, with a dominant perpendicular pressure in the southern hemisphere and a dominant parallel pressure in the north.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2025; v1 submitted 29 October, 2024;
originally announced October 2024.
-
Second order divergence constraint preserving entropy stable finite difference schemes for ideal two-fluid plasma flow equations
Authors:
Jaya Agnihotri,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Harish Kumar,
Praveen Chandrashekhar,
Dinshaw S. Balsara
Abstract:
Two-fluid plasma flow equations describe the flow of ions and electrons with different densities, velocities, and pressures. We consider the ideal plasma flow i.e. we ignore viscous, resistive, and collision effects. The resulting system of equations has flux consisting of three independent components, one for ions, one for electrons, and a linear Maxwell's equation flux for the electromagnetic fi…
▽ More
Two-fluid plasma flow equations describe the flow of ions and electrons with different densities, velocities, and pressures. We consider the ideal plasma flow i.e. we ignore viscous, resistive, and collision effects. The resulting system of equations has flux consisting of three independent components, one for ions, one for electrons, and a linear Maxwell's equation flux for the electromagnetic fields. The coupling of these components is via source terms. In this article, we present {conservative} second-order finite difference schemes that ensure the consistent evolution of the divergence constraints on the electric and magnetic fields. The key idea is to design a numerical solver for Maxwell's equations using the multidimensional Riemann solver at the vertices, ensuring discrete divergence constraints; for the fluid parts, we use an entropy-stable discretization. The proposed schemes are co-located, second-order accurate, entropy stable, and ensure divergence-free evolution of the magnetic field. We use explicit and IMplicit-EXplicit (IMEX) schemes for time discretizations. To demonstrate the accuracy, stability, and divergence constraint-preserving ability of the proposed schemes, we present several test cases in one and two dimensions. We also compare the numerical results with those obtained from schemes with no divergence cleaning and those employing perfectly hyperbolic Maxwell (PHM) equations-based divergence cleaning methods for Maxwell's equations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2024;
originally announced September 2024.
-
Well-balanced high order finite difference WENO schemes for a first-order Z4 formulation of the Einstein field equations
Authors:
Dinshaw Balsara,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Olindo Zanotti,
Michael Dumbser
Abstract:
In this work we aim at developing a new class of high order accurate well-balanced finite difference (FD) Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (WENO) methods for numerical general relativity, which can be applied to any first-order reduction of the Einstein field equations, even if non-conservative terms are present. We choose the first-order non-conservative Z4 formulation of the Einstein equatio…
▽ More
In this work we aim at developing a new class of high order accurate well-balanced finite difference (FD) Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (WENO) methods for numerical general relativity, which can be applied to any first-order reduction of the Einstein field equations, even if non-conservative terms are present. We choose the first-order non-conservative Z4 formulation of the Einstein equations, which has a built-in cleaning procedure that accounts for the Einstein constraints and that has already shown its ability in keeping stationary solutions stable over long timescales. Upon the introduction of auxiliary variables, the vacuum Einstein equations in first order form constitute a ...
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2024; v1 submitted 8 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Entropy stable finite difference schemes for Chew, Goldberger & Low anisotropic plasma flow equations
Authors:
Chetan Singh,
Anshu Yadav,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Harish Kumar,
Dinshaw S. Balsara
Abstract:
In this article, we consider the Chew, Goldberger \& Low (CGL) plasma flow equations, which is a set of nonlinear, non-conservative hyperbolic PDEs modelling anisotropic plasma flows. These equations incorporate the double adiabatic approximation for the evolution of the pressure, making them very valuable for plasma physics, space physics and astrophysical applications. We first present the entro…
▽ More
In this article, we consider the Chew, Goldberger \& Low (CGL) plasma flow equations, which is a set of nonlinear, non-conservative hyperbolic PDEs modelling anisotropic plasma flows. These equations incorporate the double adiabatic approximation for the evolution of the pressure, making them very valuable for plasma physics, space physics and astrophysical applications. We first present the entropy analysis for the weak solutions. We then propose entropy-stable finite-difference schemes for the CGL equations. The key idea is to rewrite the CGL equations such that the non-conservative terms do not contribute to the entropy equations. The conservative part of the rewritten equations is very similar to the magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) equations. We then symmetrize the conservative part by following Godunov's symmetrization process for MHD. The resulting equations are then discretized by designing entropy conservative numerical flux and entropy diffusion operator based on the entropy scaled eigenvectors of the conservative part. We then prove the semi-discrete entropy stability of the schemes for CGL equations. The schemes are then tested using several test problems derived from the corresponding MHD test cases.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Going Beyond the MHD Approximation: Physics-Based Numerical Solution of the CGL Equations
Authors:
Deepak Bhoriya,
Dinshaw S. Balsara,
Vladimir Florinski,
Harish Kumar
Abstract:
We present a new numerical model for solving the Chew-Goldberger-Low system of equations describing a bi-Maxwellian plasma in a magnetic field. Heliospheric and geospace environments are often observed to be in an anisotropic state with distinctly different parallel and perpendicular pressure components. The CGL system represents the simplest leading order correction to the common isotropic MHD mo…
▽ More
We present a new numerical model for solving the Chew-Goldberger-Low system of equations describing a bi-Maxwellian plasma in a magnetic field. Heliospheric and geospace environments are often observed to be in an anisotropic state with distinctly different parallel and perpendicular pressure components. The CGL system represents the simplest leading order correction to the common isotropic MHD model that still allows to incorporate the latter's most desirable features. However, the CGL system presents several numerical challenges: the system is not in conservation form, the source terms are stiff, and unlike MHD it is prone to a loss of hyperbolicity if the parallel and perpendicular pressures become too different. The usual cure is to bring the parallel and perpendicular pressures closer to one another; but that has usually been done in an ad hoc manner. We present a physics-informed method of pressure relaxation based on the idea of pitch-angle scattering that keeps the numerical system hyperbolic and naturally leads to zero anisotropy in the limit of very large plasma beta. Numerical codes based on the CGL equations can, therefore, be made to function robustly for any magnetic field strength, including the limit where the magnetic field approaches zero. The capabilities of our new algorithm are demonstrated using several stringent test problems that provide a comparison of the CGL equations in the weakly and strongly collisional limits. This includes a test problem that mimics interaction of a shock with a magnetospheric environment in 2D.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Efficient Alternative Finite Difference WENO Schemes for Hyperbolic Systems with Non-Conservative Products
Authors:
Dinshaw S. Balsara,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Chi-Wang Shu,
Harish Kumar
Abstract:
Higher order finite difference Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (WENO) schemes for conservation laws represent a technology that has been reasonably consolidated. They are extremely popular because, when applied to multidimensional problems, they offer high order accuracy at a fraction of the cost of finite volume WENO or DG schemes. They come in two flavors. There is the classical finite diff…
▽ More
Higher order finite difference Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (WENO) schemes for conservation laws represent a technology that has been reasonably consolidated. They are extremely popular because, when applied to multidimensional problems, they offer high order accuracy at a fraction of the cost of finite volume WENO or DG schemes. They come in two flavors. There is the classical finite difference WENO (FD-WENO) method (Shu and Osher, J. Comput. Phys., 83 (1989) 32-78). However, in recent years there is also an alternative finite difference WENO (AFD-WENO) method which has recently been formalized into a very useful general-purpose algorithm for conservation laws (Balsara et al., Efficient Alternative Finite Difference WENO Schemes for Hyperbolic Conservation Laws, submitted to CAMC (2023)). However, the FD-WENO algorithm has only very recently been formulated for hyperbolic systems with non-conservative products (Balsara et al., Efficient Finite Difference WENO Scheme for Hyperbolic Systems with Non-Conservative Products, to appear CAMC (2023)). In this paper we show that there are substantial advantages in obtaining an AFD-WENO algorithm for hyperbolic systems with non-conservative products. Such an algorithm is documented in this paper. We present an AFD-WENO formulation in fluctuation form that is carefully engineered to retrieve the flux form when that is warranted and nevertheless extends to non-conservative products. The method is flexible because it allows any Riemann solver to be used. The formulation we arrive at is such that when non-conservative products are absent it reverts exactly to the formulation in the second citation above which is in exact flux conservation form. The ability to transition to a precise conservation form when non-conservative products are absent ensures, via the Lax-Wendroff theorem, that shock locations will be exactly ...
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Efficient Alternative Finite Difference WENO Schemes for Hyperbolic Conservation Laws
Authors:
Dinshaw S. Balsara,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Chi-Wang Shu,
Harish Kumar
Abstract:
Higher order finite difference Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (WENO) schemes for conservation laws are extremely popular because, for multidimensional problems, they offer high order accuracy at a fraction of the cost of finite volume WENO or DG schemes. Such schemes come in two formulations. The very popular classical finite difference WENO (FD-WENO) method (Shu and Osher, J. Comput. Phys.,…
▽ More
Higher order finite difference Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (WENO) schemes for conservation laws are extremely popular because, for multidimensional problems, they offer high order accuracy at a fraction of the cost of finite volume WENO or DG schemes. Such schemes come in two formulations. The very popular classical finite difference WENO (FD-WENO) method (Shu and Osher, J. Comput. Phys., 83 (1989) 32-78) relies two reconstruction steps applied to two split fluxes. However, the method cannot accommodate different types of Riemann solvers and cannot preserve free stream boundary conditions on curvilinear meshes. This limits its utility. The alternative finite difference WENO (AFD-WENO) method can overcome these deficiencies, however, much less work has been done on this method. The reasons are three-fold. First, it is difficult for the casual reader to understand the intricate logic that requires higher order derivatives of the fluxes to be evaluated at zone boundaries. The analytical methods for deriving the update equation for AFD-WENO schemes are somewhat recondite. To overcome that difficulty, we provide an easily accessible script that is based on a computer algebra system in Appendix A of this paper. Second, the method relies on interpolation rather than reconstruction, and WENO interpolation formulae have not been documented in the literature as thoroughly as WENO reconstruction formulae. In this paper, we explicitly provide all necessary WENO interpolation formulae that are needed for implementing AFD-WENO up to ninth order. The third reason is that AFD-WENO requires higher order derivatives of the fluxes to be available at zone boundaries. Since those derivatives are usually obtained by finite differencing the zone-centered fluxes, they become susceptible to a Gibbs phenomenon when the solution ...
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Entropy stable discontinuous Galerkin schemes for two-fluid relativistic plasma flow equations
Authors:
Deepak Bhoriya,
Biswarup Biswas,
Harish Kumar,
Praveen Chandrashekhar
Abstract:
This article proposes entropy stable discontinuous Galerkin schemes (DG) for two-fluid relativistic plasma flow equations. These equations couple the flow of relativistic fluids via electromagnetic quantities evolved using Maxwell's equations. The proposed schemes are based on the Gauss-Lobatto quadrature rule, which has the summation by parts (SBP) property. We exploit the structure of the equati…
▽ More
This article proposes entropy stable discontinuous Galerkin schemes (DG) for two-fluid relativistic plasma flow equations. These equations couple the flow of relativistic fluids via electromagnetic quantities evolved using Maxwell's equations. The proposed schemes are based on the Gauss-Lobatto quadrature rule, which has the summation by parts (SBP) property. We exploit the structure of the equations having the flux with three independent parts coupled via nonlinear source terms. We design entropy stable DG schemes for each flux part, coupled with the fact that the source terms do not affect entropy, resulting in an entropy stable scheme for the complete system. The proposed schemes are then tested on various test problems in one and two dimensions to demonstrate their accuracy and stability.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Entropy stable schemes for the shear shallow water model Equations
Authors:
Anshu Yadav,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Harish Kumar,
Praveen Chandrashekar
Abstract:
The shear shallow water model is an extension of the classical shallow water model to include the effects of vertical shear. It is a system of six non-linear hyperbolic PDE with non-conservative products. We develop a high-order entropy stable finite difference scheme for this model in one dimension and extend it to two dimensions on rectangular grids. The key idea is to rewrite the system so that…
▽ More
The shear shallow water model is an extension of the classical shallow water model to include the effects of vertical shear. It is a system of six non-linear hyperbolic PDE with non-conservative products. We develop a high-order entropy stable finite difference scheme for this model in one dimension and extend it to two dimensions on rectangular grids. The key idea is to rewrite the system so that non-conservative terms do not contribute to the entropy evolution. Then, we first develop an entropy conservative scheme for the conservative part, which is then extended to the complete system using the fact that the non-conservative terms do not contribute to the entropy production. The entropy dissipative scheme, which leads to an entropy inequality, is then obtained by carefully adding dissipative flux terms. The proposed schemes are then tested on several one and two-dimensional problems to demonstrate their stability and accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Efficient Finite Difference WENO Scheme for Hyperbolic Systems with Non-Conservative Products
Authors:
Dinshaw S. Balsara,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Chi-Wang Shu,
Harish Kumar
Abstract:
Higher order finite difference Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (WENO) schemes have been constructed for conservation laws. For multidimensional problems, they offer high order accuracy at a fraction of the cost of a finite volume WENO or DG scheme of comparable accuracy. This makes them quite attractive for several science and engineering applications. But, to the best of our knowledge, such…
▽ More
Higher order finite difference Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (WENO) schemes have been constructed for conservation laws. For multidimensional problems, they offer high order accuracy at a fraction of the cost of a finite volume WENO or DG scheme of comparable accuracy. This makes them quite attractive for several science and engineering applications. But, to the best of our knowledge, such schemes have not been extended to non-linear hyperbolic systems with non-conservative products. In this paper, we perform such an extension which improves the domain of applicability of such schemes. The extension is carried out by writing the scheme in fluctuation form. We use the HLLI Riemann solver of Dumbser and Balsara (2016) as a building block for carrying out this extension. Because of the use of an HLL building block, the resulting scheme has a proper supersonic limit. The use of anti-diffusive fluxes ensures that stationary discontinuities can be preserved by the scheme, thus expanding its domain of applicability. Our new finite difference WENO formulation uses the same WENO reconstruction that was used in classical versions, making it very easy for users to transition over to the present formulation.
For conservation laws, the new finite difference WENO is shown to perform as well as the classical version of finite difference WENO, with two major advantages:- 1) It can capture jumps in stationary linearly degenerate wave families exactly. 2) It only requires the reconstruction to be applied once. Several examples from hyperbolic PDE systems with non-conservative products are shown which indicate that the scheme works and achieves its design order of accuracy for smooth multidimensional flows. Stringent Riemann ... *Abstract truncated, see PDF*
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2023; v1 submitted 30 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Techniques, Tricks and Algorithms for Efficient GPU-Based Processing of Higher Order Hyperbolic PDEs
Authors:
Sethupathy Subramanian,
Dinshaw S. Balsara,
Deepak Bhoriya,
Harish Kumar
Abstract:
GPU computing is expected to play an integral part in all modern Exascale supercomputers. It is also expected that higher order Godunov schemes will make up about a significant fraction of the application mix on such supercomputers. It is, therefore, very important to prepare the community of users of higher order schemes for hyperbolic PDEs for this emerging opportunity. We focus on three broad a…
▽ More
GPU computing is expected to play an integral part in all modern Exascale supercomputers. It is also expected that higher order Godunov schemes will make up about a significant fraction of the application mix on such supercomputers. It is, therefore, very important to prepare the community of users of higher order schemes for hyperbolic PDEs for this emerging opportunity. We focus on three broad and high-impact areas where higher order Godunov schemes are used. The first area is computational fluid dynamics (CFD). The second is computational magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) which has an involution constraint that has to be mimetically preserved. The third is computational electrodynamics (CED) which has involution constraints and also extremely stiff source terms. Together, these three diverse uses of higher order Godunov methodology, cover many of the most important applications areas. In all three cases, we show that the optimal use of algorithms, techniques and tricks, along with the use of OpenACC, yields superlative speedups on GPUs! As a bonus, we find a most remarkable and desirable result: some higher order schemes, with their larger operations count per zone, show better speedup than lower order schemes on GPUs. In other words, the GPU is an optimal stratagem for overcoming the higher computational complexities of higher order schemes! Several avenues for future improvement have also been identified. A scalability study is presented for a real-world application using GPUs and comparable numbers of high-end multicore CPUs. It is found that GPUs offer a substantial performance benefit over comparable number of CPUs, especially when all the methods designed in this paper are used.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2023; v1 submitted 23 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
High-order finite-difference entropy stable schemes for two-fluid relativistic plasma flow equations
Authors:
Deepak Bhoriya,
Harish Kumar,
Praveen Chandrashekar
Abstract:
In this article, we propose high-order finite-difference entropy stable schemes for the two-fluid relativistic plasma flow equations. This is achieved by exploiting the structure of the equations, which consists of three independent flux components. The first two components describe the ion and electron flows, which are modeled using the relativistic hydrodynamics equation. The third component is…
▽ More
In this article, we propose high-order finite-difference entropy stable schemes for the two-fluid relativistic plasma flow equations. This is achieved by exploiting the structure of the equations, which consists of three independent flux components. The first two components describe the ion and electron flows, which are modeled using the relativistic hydrodynamics equation. The third component is Maxwell's equations, which are linear systems. The coupling of the ion and electron flows, and electromagnetic fields is via source terms only. Furthermore, we also show that the source terms do not affect the entropy evolution.
To design semi-discrete entropy stable schemes, we extend the RHD entropy stable schemes in Bhoriya et al. to three dimensions. This is then coupled with entropy stable discretization of the Maxwell's equations. Finally, we use SSP-RK schemes to discretize in time. We also propose ARK-IMEX schemes to treat the stiff source terms; the resulting nonlinear set of algebraic equations is local (at each discretization point). These equations are solved using the Newton's Method, which results in an efficient method. The proposed schemes are then tested using various test problems to demonstrate their stability, accuracy and efficiency.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2023; v1 submitted 16 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
