High-resolution large-eddy simulation of indoor turbulence and its effect on airborne transmission of respiratory pathogens; model validation and infection probability analysis
Authors:
Mikko Auvinen,
Joel Kuula,
Tiia Grönholm,
Matthias Sühring,
Antti Hellsten
Abstract:
High-resolution large-eddy simulation (LES) is exploited to study indoor air turbulence and its effect on the dispersion of respiratory virus-laden aerosols and subsequent transmission risks. The methodology is applied to assess two dissimilar approaches to reduce transmission risks: a strategy to augment the indoor ventilation capacity with portable air purifiers and a strategy to utilize partiti…
▽ More
High-resolution large-eddy simulation (LES) is exploited to study indoor air turbulence and its effect on the dispersion of respiratory virus-laden aerosols and subsequent transmission risks. The methodology is applied to assess two dissimilar approaches to reduce transmission risks: a strategy to augment the indoor ventilation capacity with portable air purifiers and a strategy to utilize partitioning by exploiting portable space dividers. To substantiate the physical relevance of the LES model, a set of experimental aerosol concentration measurements are carried out, and their results are used for validating the LES model results. The obtained LES dispersion results are subjected to pathogen exposure and infection probability analysis. Wells-Riley probability model is extended to rely on realistic time- and space-dependent concentration fields to yield time- and space-dependent infection probability fields. The use of air purifiers leads to greater reduction in absolute risks compared to the analytical Wells-Riley model, which fails to predict the original risk level. However, the two models do agree on the relative risk reduction. The spatial partitioning strategy is demonstrated to have an undesirable effect when employed without other measures. The partitioning approach may yield positive results when employed together with targeted air purifier units. The LES-based results are examined in juxtaposition with the classical Wells-Riley model, which is shown to significantly underestimate the infection probability, highlighting the importance of employing accurate indoor turbulence modeling when evaluating different risk-reduction strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
Modelling aerosol transport and virus exposure with numerical simulations in relation to SARS-CoV-2 transmission by inhalation indoors
Authors:
Ville Vuorinen,
Mia Aarnio,
Mikko Alava,
Ville Alopaeus,
Nina Atanasova,
Mikko Auvinen,
Nallannan Balasubramanian,
Hadi Bordbar,
Panu Erästö,
Rafael Grande,
Nick Hayward,
Antti Hellsten,
Simo Hostikka,
Jyrki Hokkanen,
Ossi Kaario,
Aku Karvinen,
Ilkka Kivistö,
Marko Korhonen,
Risto Kosonen,
Janne Kuusela,
Sami Lestinen,
Erkki Laurila,
Heikki Nieminen,
Petteri Peltonen,
Juho Pokki
, et al. (5 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We provide research findings on the physics of aerosol dispersion relevant to the hypothesized aerosol transmission of SARS-CoV-2. We utilize physics-based modeling at different levels of complexity, and literature on coronaviruses, to investigate the possibility of airborne transmission. The previous literature, our 0D-3D simulations by various physics-based models, and theoretical calculations,…
▽ More
We provide research findings on the physics of aerosol dispersion relevant to the hypothesized aerosol transmission of SARS-CoV-2. We utilize physics-based modeling at different levels of complexity, and literature on coronaviruses, to investigate the possibility of airborne transmission. The previous literature, our 0D-3D simulations by various physics-based models, and theoretical calculations, indicate that the typical size range of speech and cough originated droplets (d < 20microns) allows lingering in the air for O(1h) so that they could be inhaled. Consistent with the previous literature, numerical evidence on the rapid drying process of even large droplets, up to sizes O(100microns), into droplet nuclei/aerosols is provided. Based on the literature and the public media sources, we provide evidence that the infected individuals could have been exposed to aerosols/droplet nuclei by inhaling them in significant numbers e.g. O(100). By 3D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations, we give examples on the transport and dilution of aerosols (d<20microns) over distances O(10m) in generic environments. We study susceptible and infected individuals in generic public places by Monte-Carlo modeling. The model accounts for the locally varying aerosol concentration levels which the susceptible accumulate via inhalation. The introduced concept, 'exposure time' to virus containing aerosols is proposed to complement the traditional 'safety distance' thinking. We show that the exposure time to inhale O(100) aerosols could range from O(1s) to O(1min) or even to O(1h) depending on the situation. The Monte Carlo analysis provides clear quantitative insight to the exposure time in different public indoor environments.
△ Less
Submitted 26 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
