-
The uncertainty of magnetic fields in 3D non-local thermodynamic equilibrium inversions
Authors:
Jiri Stepan,
Tanausu del Pino Aleman,
Andres Vicente Arevalo
Abstract:
We describe our approach to solve the problem of ensuring the solenoidality of the magnetic field vector in three-dimensional (3D) inversions, as well as the estimation of the uncertainty in the inferred magnetic field. The solenoidality of the magnetic field vector is often disregarded in the inversion of spectropolarimetric data due to limitations in the traditional one-dimensional inversion tec…
▽ More
We describe our approach to solve the problem of ensuring the solenoidality of the magnetic field vector in three-dimensional (3D) inversions, as well as the estimation of the uncertainty in the inferred magnetic field. The solenoidality of the magnetic field vector is often disregarded in the inversion of spectropolarimetric data due to limitations in the traditional one-dimensional inversion techniques. We propose a method to ensure the solenoidal condition in 3D inversions based on our meshfree approach. The increase in dimensionality with respect to the 1D inversion techniques is such that some of the traditional methods to determine the uncertainties become unfeasible. We propose a method based on a Monte Carlo approach to determine the uncertainty of the magnetic field inference. Due to the physics of the problem, we can compute the uncertainty increasing the total required computational time by just a factor of about two. We also propose a metric to quantify the uncertainty to describe the degree of confidence of the magnetic field inference. Finally, we perform a numerical experiment to demonstrate the feasibility of both the method and the metric proposed to quantify the uncertainty.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2025; v1 submitted 14 May, 2025;
originally announced May 2025.
-
The He I 10830 A line: Radiative transfer and differential illumination effects
Authors:
Andres Vicente Arevalo,
Jiri Stepan,
Tanausu del Pino Aleman,
Maria Jesus Martinez Gonzalez
Abstract:
We study the formation of the Stokes profiles of the He I multiplet at 10830 A when relaxing two of the approximations that are often considered in the modeling of this multiplet, namely the lack of self-consistent radiation transfer and the assumption of equal illumination of the individual multiplet components. This He I multiplet is among the most important ones for the diagnostic of the outer…
▽ More
We study the formation of the Stokes profiles of the He I multiplet at 10830 A when relaxing two of the approximations that are often considered in the modeling of this multiplet, namely the lack of self-consistent radiation transfer and the assumption of equal illumination of the individual multiplet components. This He I multiplet is among the most important ones for the diagnostic of the outer solar atmosphere from spectropolarimetric observations, especially in prominences, filaments, and spicules. However, the goodness of these approximations is yet to be assessed, especially in situations where the optical thickness is of the order or larger than one, and radiation transfer has a significant impact in the local anisotropy and the ensuing spectral line polarization. This issue becomes particularly relevant in the ongoing development of new inversion tools which take into account multi-dimensional radiation transfer effects. To relax these approximations we generalize the multi-term equations for the atomic statistical equilibrium to allow for differential illumination of the multiplet components and implement them in a one-dimensional radiative transfer code. We find that, even for this simple geometry and relatively small optical thickness, both radiation transfer and differential illumination effects have a significant impact on the emergent polarization profiles. This should be taken into account in order to avoid potentially significant errors in the inference of the magnetic field vector.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2023; v1 submitted 30 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Accelerating non-LTE synthesis and inversions with graph networks
Authors:
A. Vicente Arévalo,
A. Asensio Ramos,
S. Esteban Pozuelo
Abstract:
The computational cost of fast non-LTE synthesis is one of the challenges that limits the development of 2D and 3D inversion codes. It also makes the interpretation of observations of lines formed in the chromosphere and transition region a slow and computationally costly process, which limits the inference of the physical properties on rather small fields of view. Having access to a fast way of c…
▽ More
The computational cost of fast non-LTE synthesis is one of the challenges that limits the development of 2D and 3D inversion codes. It also makes the interpretation of observations of lines formed in the chromosphere and transition region a slow and computationally costly process, which limits the inference of the physical properties on rather small fields of view. Having access to a fast way of computing the deviation from the LTE regime through the departure coefficients could largely alleviate this problem. We propose to build and train a graph network that quickly predicts the atomic level populations without solving the non-LTE problem. We find an optimal architecture for the graph network for predicting the departure coefficients of the levels of an atom from the physical conditions of a model atmosphere. A suitable dataset with a representative sample of potential model atmospheres is used for training. This dataset has been computed using existing non-LTE synthesis codes. The graph network has been integrated into existing synthesis and inversion codes for the particular case of \caii. We demonstrate orders of magnitude gain in computing speed. We analyze the generalization capabilities of the graph network and demonstrate that it produces good predicted departure coefficients for unseen models. We implement this approach in \hazel\ and show how the inversions nicely compare with those obtained with standard non-LTE inversion codes. Our approximate method opens up the possibility of extracting physical information from the chromosphere on large fields-of-view with time evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2022; v1 submitted 20 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
