-
A market-based efficient matching mechanism for crowdsourced delivery systems with demand/supply elasticities
Authors:
Yuki Oyama,
Takashi Akamatsu
Abstract:
Crowdsourced delivery (CSD) is an emerging business model that leverages the underutilized or excess capacity of individual drivers to fulfill delivery tasks. This paper presents a general formulation of a larege-scale two-sided CSD matching problem, considering demand/supply elasticity, heterogeneous preferences of both shippers and drivers, and task-bundling. We propose a set of methodologies to…
▽ More
Crowdsourced delivery (CSD) is an emerging business model that leverages the underutilized or excess capacity of individual drivers to fulfill delivery tasks. This paper presents a general formulation of a larege-scale two-sided CSD matching problem, considering demand/supply elasticity, heterogeneous preferences of both shippers and drivers, and task-bundling. We propose a set of methodologies to solve this problem. First, we reveal that the fluid-particle decomposition approach of Akamatsu and Oyama (2024) can be extended to our general formulation. This approach decomposes the original large-scale matching problem into a fluidly-approximated task partition problem (master problem) and small-scale particle matching problems (sub-problems). We propose to introduce a truthful auction mechanism to sub-problems, which enables the observation of privately perceived costs for each shipper/driver. Furthermore, by finding a theoretical link between auction problems and parturbed utility theory, we succeed in accurately reflecting the information collected from auctions to the master problem. This reduces the master problem to a smooth convex optimization problem, theoretically guaranteeing the computational efficiency and solution accuracy of the fluid approximation. Second, we transform the master problem into a traffic assignment problem (TAP) based on a task-chain network. This transformation overcomes the difficulty in enumerating task bundles. Finally, we formulate the dual problem of the TAP, whose decision variable is only a price/reward pattern at market equilibrium, and develop an efficient accelerated gradient descent method. The numerical experiments clarify that our approach drastically reduces the computational cost of the matching problem (~700 times faster than a naive method) without sacrificing accuracy of the optimal solution (mostly within 0.5% errors).
△ Less
Submitted 29 December, 2024;
originally announced December 2024.
-
A fluid-particle decomposition approach to matching market design for crowdsourced delivery systems
Authors:
Takashi Akamatsu,
Yuki Oyama
Abstract:
This paper considers a crowdsourced delivery (CSD) system that effectively utilizes the existing trips to fulfill parcel delivery as a matching problem between CSD drivers and delivery tasks. This matching problem has two major challenges. First, it is a large-scale combinatorial optimization problem that is hard to solve in a reasonable computational time. Second, the evaluation of the objective…
▽ More
This paper considers a crowdsourced delivery (CSD) system that effectively utilizes the existing trips to fulfill parcel delivery as a matching problem between CSD drivers and delivery tasks. This matching problem has two major challenges. First, it is a large-scale combinatorial optimization problem that is hard to solve in a reasonable computational time. Second, the evaluation of the objective function for socially optimal matching contains the utility of drivers for performing the tasks, which is generally unobservable private information. To address these challenges, this paper proposes a hierarchical distribution mechanism of CSD tasks that decomposes the matching problem into the task partition (master problem) and individual task-driver matching within smaller groups of drivers (sub-problems). We incorporate an auction mechanism with truth-telling and efficiency into the sub-problems so that the drivers' perceived utilities are revealed through their bids. Furthermore, we formulate the master problem as a fluid model based on continuously approximated decision variables. By exploiting the random utility framework, we analytically represent the objective function of the problem using continuous variables, without explicitly knowing the drivers' utilities. The numerical experiment shows that the proposed approach solved large-scale matching problems at least 100 times faster than a naive LP solver and approximated the original objective value with errors of less than 1%.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
A Paradox of Telecommuting and Staggered Work Hours in the Bottleneck Model
Authors:
Takara Sakai,
Takashi Akamatsu,
Koki Satsukawa
Abstract:
We study the long- and short-term effects of telecommuting (TLC), staggered work hours (SWH), and their combined scheme on peak-period congestion and location patterns. In order to enable a unified comparison of the schemes' long- and short-term effects, we develop a novel equilibrium analysis approach that consistently synthesizes the long-term equilibrium (location and percentage of telecommutin…
▽ More
We study the long- and short-term effects of telecommuting (TLC), staggered work hours (SWH), and their combined scheme on peak-period congestion and location patterns. In order to enable a unified comparison of the schemes' long- and short-term effects, we develop a novel equilibrium analysis approach that consistently synthesizes the long-term equilibrium (location and percentage of telecommuting choice) and short-term equilibrium (preferred arrival time and departure time choice). By exploiting their special mathematical structures similar to optimal transport problems, we derive the closed-form solution to the long- and short-term equilibrium while explicitly considering their interaction. These closed-form solutions elucidate the discrepancies between the effects of each scheme and uncover a paradoxical finding: the introduction of SWH, in conjunction with TLC, may increase the total commuting costs compared to the scenario with only TLC, without yielding any improvement in worker utility.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2024; v1 submitted 15 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Weak Kantorovich difference and associated Ricci curvature of hypergraphs
Authors:
Tomoya Akamatsu
Abstract:
Ollivier and Lin--Lu--Yau established the theory of graph Ricci curvature (LLY curvature) via optimal transport on graphs. Ikeda--Kitabeppu--Takai--Uehara introduced a new distance called the Kantorovich difference on hypergraphs and generalized the LLY curvature to hypergraphs (IKTU curvature). As the LLY curvature can be represented by the graph Laplacian by Münch--Wojciechowski, Ikeda--Kitabepp…
▽ More
Ollivier and Lin--Lu--Yau established the theory of graph Ricci curvature (LLY curvature) via optimal transport on graphs. Ikeda--Kitabeppu--Takai--Uehara introduced a new distance called the Kantorovich difference on hypergraphs and generalized the LLY curvature to hypergraphs (IKTU curvature). As the LLY curvature can be represented by the graph Laplacian by Münch--Wojciechowski, Ikeda--Kitabeppu--Takai--Uehara conjectured that the IKTU curvature has a similar expression in terms of the hypergraph Laplacian. In this paper, we introduce a variant of the Kantorovich difference inspired by the above conjecture and study the Ricci curvature associated with this distance ($\mathsf{wIKTU}$ curvature). Moreover, for hypergraphs with a specific structure, we analyze a quantity $\mathcal{C}(x,y)$ at two distinct vertices $x,y$ defined by using the hypergraph Laplacian. If the resolvent operator converges uniformly to the identity, then $\mathcal{C}(x,y)$ coincides with the $\mathsf{wIKTU}$ curvature along $x,y$.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Global stability of day-to-day dynamics for schedule-based Markovian transit assignment with boarding queues
Authors:
Takashi Akamatsu,
Koki Satsukawa,
Yuki Oyama
Abstract:
Schedule-based transit assignment describes congestion in public transport services by modeling the interactions of passenger behavior in a time-space network built directly on a transit schedule. This study investigates the theoretical properties of scheduled-based Markovian transit assignment with boarding queues. When queues exist at a station, passenger boarding flows are loaded according to t…
▽ More
Schedule-based transit assignment describes congestion in public transport services by modeling the interactions of passenger behavior in a time-space network built directly on a transit schedule. This study investigates the theoretical properties of scheduled-based Markovian transit assignment with boarding queues. When queues exist at a station, passenger boarding flows are loaded according to the residual vehicle capacity, which depends on the flows of passengers already on board with priority. An equilibrium problem is formulated under this nonseparable link cost structure as well as explicit capacity constraints. The network generalized extreme value (NGEV) model, a general class of additive random utility models with closed-form expression, is used to describe the path choice behavior of passengers. A set of formulations for the equilibrium problem is presented, including variational inequality and fixed-point problems, from which the day-to-day dynamics of passenger flows and costs are derived. It is shown that Lyapunov functions associated with the dynamics can be obtained and guarantee the desirable solution properties of existence, uniqueness, and global stability of the equilibria. In terms of dealing with stochastic equilibrium with explicit capacity constraints and non-separable link cost functions, the present theoretical analysis is a generalization of the existing day-to-day dynamics in the context of general traffic assignment.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Queue replacement principle for corridor problems with heterogeneous commuters
Authors:
Takara Sakai,
Takashi Akamatsu,
Koki Satsukawa
Abstract:
This study investigates the theoretical properties of a departure time choice problem considering commuters' heterogeneity with respect to the value of schedule delay in corridor networks. Specifically, we develop an analytical method to solve the dynamic system optimal (DSO) and dynamic user equilibrium (DUE) problems. To derive the DSO solution, we first demonstrate the bottleneck-based decompos…
▽ More
This study investigates the theoretical properties of a departure time choice problem considering commuters' heterogeneity with respect to the value of schedule delay in corridor networks. Specifically, we develop an analytical method to solve the dynamic system optimal (DSO) and dynamic user equilibrium (DUE) problems. To derive the DSO solution, we first demonstrate the bottleneck-based decomposition property, i.e., the DSO problem can be decomposed into multiple single bottleneck problems. Subsequently, we obtain the analytical solution by applying the theory of optimal transport to each decomposed problem and derive optimal congestion prices to achieve the DSO state. To derive the DUE solution, we prove the queue replacement principle (QRP) that the time-varying optimal congestion prices are equal to the queueing delay in the DUE state at every bottleneck. This principle enables us to derive a closed-form DUE solution based on the DSO solution. Moreover, as an application of the QRP, we prove that the equilibrium solution under various policies (e.g., on-ramp metering, on-ramp pricing, and its partial implementation) can be obtained analytically. Finally, we compare these equilibria with the DSO state.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2024; v1 submitted 7 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Origin of power laws and their spatial fractal structure for city-size distributions
Authors:
Tomoya Mori,
Takashi Akamatsu,
Yuki Takayama,
Minoru Osawa
Abstract:
City-size distributions follow an approximate power law in various countries despite high volatility in relative city sizes over time. Our empirical evidence for the United States and Japan indicates that the scaling law stems from a spatial fractal structure owing to the coordination of industrial locations. While the locations of individual industries change considerably over time, there is a pe…
▽ More
City-size distributions follow an approximate power law in various countries despite high volatility in relative city sizes over time. Our empirical evidence for the United States and Japan indicates that the scaling law stems from a spatial fractal structure owing to the coordination of industrial locations. While the locations of individual industries change considerably over time, there is a persistent pattern in that more localized industries at a given time are found only in larger cities. The spatial organization of cities exhibits a hierarchical structure in which larger cities are spaced apart to serve as centers for surrounding smaller cities, generating a recursive pattern across different spatial scales. In our theoretical replication of the observed regularities, diversity in scale economy among industries induces diversity in their location pattern, which translates into diversity in city size via spatial coordination of industries and population. The city-size power law is a generic feature of Monte-Carlo samples of stationary states resulting from the spontaneous spatial fractal structure in the hypothetical economy. The identified regularities reveal constraints on feasible urban planning at each regional scale. The success or failure of place-based policies designed to take advantage of individual cities' characteristics should depend on their spatial relationships with other cities, subject to the nationwide spatial fractal structure.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2023; v1 submitted 12 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Non-existence of queues for system optimal departure patterns in tree networks
Authors:
Takara Sakai,
Koki Satsukawa,
Takashi Akamatsu
Abstract:
This study proves the non-existence of queues for a dynamic system optimal (DSO) departure pattern in a directed rooted tree network with a single destination. First, considering queueing conditions explicitly, we formulate the DSO problem as mathematical programming with complementarity constraints (MPCC) that minimizes the total system cost which consists of the schedule and queueing delay costs…
▽ More
This study proves the non-existence of queues for a dynamic system optimal (DSO) departure pattern in a directed rooted tree network with a single destination. First, considering queueing conditions explicitly, we formulate the DSO problem as mathematical programming with complementarity constraints (MPCC) that minimizes the total system cost which consists of the schedule and queueing delay costs. Next, for an arbitrary feasible solution to the MPCC, we prove the existence of another feasible solution where the departure flow pattern on every link is the same but no queue exists. This means that the queues can be eliminated without changing the total schedule delay cost. Queues are deadweight losses, and thus the non-existence theorem of queues in the DSO solution is established. Moreover, as an application of the non-existence theorem, we show that the MPCC can be transformed into a linear programming (LP) problem by eliminating the queueing conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Generalized von Mangoldt surfaces of revolution and asymmetric two-spheres of revolution with simple cut locus structure
Authors:
Minoru Tanaka,
Toyohiro Akamatsu,
Robert Sinclair,
Masaru Yamaguchi
Abstract:
It was known that if the Gaussian curvature function along each meridian on a surface of revolution $(R^2, dr^2+m(r)^2dθ^2)$ is decreasing, then the cut locus of each point of $θ^{-1}(0)$ is empty or a subarc of the opposite meridian $θ^{-1}(π).$ Such a surface is called a von Mangoldt's surface of revolution. A surface of revolution $(R^2, dr^2+m(r)^2dθ^2)$ is called a generalized von Mangoldt su…
▽ More
It was known that if the Gaussian curvature function along each meridian on a surface of revolution $(R^2, dr^2+m(r)^2dθ^2)$ is decreasing, then the cut locus of each point of $θ^{-1}(0)$ is empty or a subarc of the opposite meridian $θ^{-1}(π).$ Such a surface is called a von Mangoldt's surface of revolution. A surface of revolution $(R^2, dr^2+m(r)^2dθ^2)$ is called a generalized von Mangoldt surface of revolution if the cut locus of each point of $θ^{-1}(0)$ is empty or a subarc of the opposite meridian $θ^{-1}(π).$ For example, the surface of revolution $(R^2, dr^2+m_0(r)^2dθ^2),$ where $m_0(x):=x/(1+x^2),$ has the same cut locus structure as above and the cut locus of each point in $r^{-1}( (0, \infty ) )$ is nonempty. Note that the Gaussian curvature function is not decreasing along a meridian for this surface. In this article, we give sufficient conditions for a surface of revolution $(R^2, dr^2+m(r)^2dθ^2)$ to be a generalized von Mangoldt surface of revolution. Moreover, we prove that for any surface of revolution with finite total curvature $c,$ there exists a generalized von Mangoldt surface of revolution with the same total curvature $c$ such that the Gaussian curvature function along a meridian is not monotone on $[a,\infty)$ for any $a>0.$
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2022; v1 submitted 1 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
A new family of latitudinally corrugated two-spheres of revolution with simple cut locus
Authors:
Minoru Tanaka,
Toyohiro Akamatsu,
Robert Sinclair,
Masaru Yamaguchi
Abstract:
There are not so many kinds of surface of revolution whose cut locus structure have been determined, although the cut locus structures of very familiar surfaces of revolution (in Euclidean space) such as ellipsoids, 2-sheeted hyperboloids, paraboloids, and tori are now known.
Except for tori, the known cut locus structures are very simple, i.e., a single point or an arc. In this article, a new f…
▽ More
There are not so many kinds of surface of revolution whose cut locus structure have been determined, although the cut locus structures of very familiar surfaces of revolution (in Euclidean space) such as ellipsoids, 2-sheeted hyperboloids, paraboloids, and tori are now known.
Except for tori, the known cut locus structures are very simple, i.e., a single point or an arc. In this article, a new family {M_n}_n of 2-spheres of revolution with simple cut locus structure is introduced. This family is also new in the sense that the number of points on each meridian which assume a local minimum or maximum of the Gaussian curvature function on the meridian goes to infinity as n goes to infinity.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
A new transport distance and its associated Ricci curvature of hypergraphs
Authors:
Tomoya Akamatsu
Abstract:
The coarse Ricci curvature of graphs introduced by Ollivier as well as its modification by Lin-Lu-Yau have been studied from various aspects. In this paper, we propose a new transport distance appropriate for hypergraphs and study a generalization of Lin-Lu-Yau type curvature of hypergraphs. As an application, we derive a Bonnet-Myers type estimate for hypergraphs under a lower Ricci curvature bou…
▽ More
The coarse Ricci curvature of graphs introduced by Ollivier as well as its modification by Lin-Lu-Yau have been studied from various aspects. In this paper, we propose a new transport distance appropriate for hypergraphs and study a generalization of Lin-Lu-Yau type curvature of hypergraphs. As an application, we derive a Bonnet-Myers type estimate for hypergraphs under a lower Ricci curvature bound associated with our transport distance. We remark that our transport distance is new even for graphs and worthy of further study.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2022; v1 submitted 14 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Dynamic traffic assignment in a corridor network: Optimum versus Equilibrium
Authors:
Haoran Fu,
Takashi Akamatsu,
Koki Satsukawa,
Kentaro Wada
Abstract:
This study investigates dynamic system-optimal (DSO) and dynamic user equilibrium (DUE) traffic assignment of departure/arrival-time choices in a corridor network. The morning commute problems with a many-to-one pattern of origin-destination demand and the evening commute problems with a one-to-many pattern are considered. Specifically, a novel approach to derive closed-form solutions for both DSO…
▽ More
This study investigates dynamic system-optimal (DSO) and dynamic user equilibrium (DUE) traffic assignment of departure/arrival-time choices in a corridor network. The morning commute problems with a many-to-one pattern of origin-destination demand and the evening commute problems with a one-to-many pattern are considered. Specifically, a novel approach to derive closed-form solutions for both DSO and DUE problems is developed. We first derive a closed-form solution to the DSO problem based on the regularities of the cost and flow variables at an optimal state. By utilizing this solution, we prove that the queuing delay at a bottleneck in a DUE solution is equal to an optimal toll that eliminates the queue in a DSO solution under certain conditions of a schedule delay function. This enables us to derive a closed-form DUE solution by using the DSO solution. We also show the theoretical relationship between the DSO and DUE assignment. Numerical examples are provided to illustrate and verify the analytical results.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2021; v1 submitted 3 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Stochastic stability of agglomeration patterns in an urban retail model
Authors:
Minoru Osawa,
Takashi Akamatsu,
Yosuke Kogure
Abstract:
We consider a model of urban spatial structure proposed by Harris and Wilson (Environment and Planning A, 1978). The model consists of fast dynamics, which represent spatial interactions between locations by the entropy-maximizing principle, and slow dynamics, which represent the evolution of the spatial distribution of local factors that facilitate such spatial interactions. One known limitation…
▽ More
We consider a model of urban spatial structure proposed by Harris and Wilson (Environment and Planning A, 1978). The model consists of fast dynamics, which represent spatial interactions between locations by the entropy-maximizing principle, and slow dynamics, which represent the evolution of the spatial distribution of local factors that facilitate such spatial interactions. One known limitation of the Harris and Wilson model is that it can have multiple locally stable equilibria, leading to a dependence of predictions on the initial state. To overcome this, we employ equilibrium refinement by stochastic stability. We build on the fact that the model is a large-population potential game and that stochastically stable states in a potential game correspond to global potential maximizers. Unlike local stability under deterministic dynamics, the stochastic stability approach allows a unique and unambiguous prediction for urban spatial configurations. We show that, in the most likely spatial configuration, the number of retail agglomerations decreases either when shopping costs for consumers decrease or when the strength of agglomerative effects increases.
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
A new look at departure time choice equilibrium models with heterogeneous users
Authors:
Takashi Akamatsu,
Kentaro Wada,
Takamasa Iryo,
Shunsuke Hayashi
Abstract:
This paper presents a systematic approach for analyzing the departure-time choice equilibrium (DTCE) problem of a single bottleneck with heterogeneous commuters. The approach is based on the fact that the DTCE is equivalently represented as a linear programming problem with a special structure, which can be analytically solved by exploiting the theory of optimal transport combined with a decomposi…
▽ More
This paper presents a systematic approach for analyzing the departure-time choice equilibrium (DTCE) problem of a single bottleneck with heterogeneous commuters. The approach is based on the fact that the DTCE is equivalently represented as a linear programming problem with a special structure, which can be analytically solved by exploiting the theory of optimal transport combined with a decomposition technique. By applying the proposed approach to several types of models with heterogeneous commuters, it is shown that (i) the essential condition for emerging equilibrium "sorting patterns," which have been known in the literature, is that the schedule delay functions have the "Monge property," (ii) the equilibrium problems with the Monge property can be solved analytically, and (iii) the proposed approach can be applied to a more general problem with more than two types of heterogeneities.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2020; v1 submitted 23 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Markovian Traffic Equilibrium Assignment based on Network Generalized Extreme Value Model
Authors:
Yuki Oyama,
Yusuke Hara,
Takashi Akamatsu
Abstract:
This study establishes Markovian traffic equilibrium assignment based on the network generalized extreme value (NGEV) model, which we call NGEV equilibrium assignment. The use of the NGEV model for route choice modeling has recently been proposed, and it enables capturing the path correlation without explicit path enumeration. However, the theoretical properties of the model in traffic assignment…
▽ More
This study establishes Markovian traffic equilibrium assignment based on the network generalized extreme value (NGEV) model, which we call NGEV equilibrium assignment. The use of the NGEV model for route choice modeling has recently been proposed, and it enables capturing the path correlation without explicit path enumeration. However, the theoretical properties of the model in traffic assignment have yet to be investigated in the literature, which has limited the practical applicability of the NGEV model in the traffic assignment field. This study addresses the research gap by providing the theoretical developments necessary for the NGEV equilibrium assignment. We first show that the NGEV assignment can be formulated and solved under the same path algebra as the traditional Markovian traffic assignment models. Moreover, we present the equivalent optimization formulations to the NGEV equilibrium assignment. The formulations allow us to derive both primal and dual types of efficient solution algorithms. In particular, the dual algorithm is based on the accelerated gradient method that is for the first time applied in the traffic assignment. The numerical experiments showed the excellent convergence and complementary relationship of the proposed primal-dual algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2021; v1 submitted 4 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Spatial scale of agglomeration and dispersion: Number, spacing, and the spatial extent of cities
Authors:
Takashi Akamatsu,
Tomoya Mori,
Minoru Osawa,
Yuki Takayama
Abstract:
Cities have become fewer, bigger, and flatter in many countries. Better transport access has fostered the concentration of economic activities toward fewer, bigger cities, while each city has become more decentralized. We show that two types of dispersion forces against spatial agglomeration explain the dual evolution of cities. Dispersion forces within a city, such as those arising from the consu…
▽ More
Cities have become fewer, bigger, and flatter in many countries. Better transport access has fostered the concentration of economic activities toward fewer, bigger cities, while each city has become more decentralized. We show that two types of dispersion forces against spatial agglomeration explain the dual evolution of cities. Dispersion forces within a city, such as those arising from the consumption of limited land, affect only the city's residents. A decrease in transport costs reduces the relative benefits of agglomeration in a congested central location, making the population distribution in each city flatter and more spread out to achieve a balance between the costs and benefits of agglomeration. Dispersion forces that spill over beyond a city, such as market crowding, make locations near the city unattractive. Lower transport costs promote competition for a wider area around each city, leaving fewer cities with larger distances between them. A model's comparative static results, and thus its policy implications, depend on the type of dispersion forces it incorporates.
△ Less
Submitted 29 August, 2024; v1 submitted 10 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
